IMP-37 stage0 normalizer 통합 (raw HTML/JSX → markdown 정식 활성화) ★ LOCK 해제 전제 #66
Reference in New Issue
Block a user
Delete Branch "%!s()"
Deleting a branch is permanent. Although the deleted branch may continue to exist for a short time before it actually gets removed, it CANNOT be undone in most cases. Continue?
관련 step: Step 2 진입 직전 — MDX normalize 정식 활성화
source: #43 I6 (stage0 normalizer 통합)
roadmap axis: R1 (22 단계 안정화) — 일반화 필수
wave: 1
priority: ★ 실질 구동 도달 필수 (raw HTML 포함 MDX 대응)
dependency: #2 (IMP-02 Stage 0 normalize chained adapter) verified
precondition: ★ 사용자 lock 해제 동의 (memory
project_phase_z_normalize_gap보류 lock)scope:
src/mdx_normalizer.py를src/phase_z2_pipeline.py의 Step 2 직전에 정식 호출 (default ON)<div><ul><li>raw HTML → markdown bullet 변환 (텍스트 보존)<details><summary>popup 패턴 별 처리 (Layer A → popup slot)PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED→ default ON 정식화out of scope:
guardrail / validation:
cross-ref:
src/mdx_normalizer.pyproject_phase_z_normalize_gap(해제 필요)review loop:
IMP-37 stage0 normalizer ?? (raw HTML/JSX ? markdown ?? ???) ? LOCK ?? ??to IMP-37 stage0 normalizer 통합 (raw HTML/JSX → markdown 정식 활성화) ★ LOCK 해제 전제[Claude #1] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 — IMP-37 stage0 normalizer default-ON activation
0. Governance precondition (BLOCKER for Stage 1 exit)
Issue body's review_loop first item = "사용자 lock 해제 동의 (선행)". Memory record
project_phase_z_normalize_gaplock dated 2026-05-08 ("보류"). Lock holder = 사용자. Stage 1 cannot shipready-for-implementationor evenscope-lockedwithout an explicit user lock release in this issue thread.This round therefore restricts itself to: (a) root-cause analysis, (b) scope-lock draft, (c) guardrails surface — explicitly NOT producing a GO signal. Stage 1 exit gated on user lock release comment.
1. Re-read of source axes
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py,D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-408(_stage0_chained_adapter) +:3531-3597(Step 2 dispatch site)project_phase_z_normalize_gap(release prerequisite)project_mdx03_frame_lock, 2026-05-15) — anchor invariantfeedback_ai_isolation_contract(AI = fallback only, MDX 보존) — normalize stays code-only2. Root cause (3-axis check)
Axis A — why #2 chose default-OFF canary (in-code comment evidence)
phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263scope-lock comment of IMP-02 enumerates 7 conditions, including:PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED env flag, default OFF (canary, matches PHASE_Z_B4_*)env=1 sample verification required (in review loop)The OFF default was a deliberate canary, not a missing step. The reason was not just "lock pending" — it was that the chained adapter has 5 hard contract fail paths (
_STAGE0_FALLBACK_REASONS:264-270 =ADAPTER_EXCEPTION / NO_USABLE_SECTIONS / MISSING_INVALID_IDS / DUPLICATE_IDS / NON_POSITIVE_SECTION_NUM) all of which silently fall back to legacyparse_mdx. Under default OFF this is fine (user opted in for canary trial); flipping default ON without addressing the silence semantics introduces a hidden-regression mode.Axis B —
<div><ul><li>raw HTML → markdown bullet is NOT yet implemented in mdx_normalizerIssue scope item: "
<div><ul><li>raw HTML → markdown bullet 변환 (텍스트 보존)".Current
mdx_normalizer.py_process_mdx_patterns(:174-253) handles:<details><summary>...</summary>...</details>→ popup extraction (:199-204)<div style={{...}}>tag-only strip (inner content kept) (:213-215)<br/>strip (:211)<Component />,<Component>...</Component>strip (:218-219):::directive[...]→## title/[핵심요약: ...](:222-229)But it does NOT convert raw
<ul>/<li>HTML to markdown bullets._convert_md_list_to_html(:76-111) goes the opposite direction (MD → HTML, used inside popup content only). Bare<ul><li>text</li></ul>is wiped tag-by-tag by Layer 4_clean_textregex<[^>]+/?>(:382). Text content survives, but the markdown-it AST in_extract_structure(:260-370) never sees abullet_list_opentoken, so depth markers (D1: / D2: / D3:) are lost.Implication:
samples/mdx_batch/04.mdx(41 occurrences of<div|<ul>|<li>, 18 raw<li>items wrapped in JSX cards) loses bullet hierarchy through the adapter. The issue is not a pure env flip — it requires net-new converter code inside_process_mdx_patterns.Axis C — pre-existing adapter-ON regression:
### N.Nnumbering strip vs V4 alias_keysmdx_normalizer.py:236:This strips
### 2.1 결과(Product)의 변화→### 결과(Product)의 변화. Downstreamalign_sections_to_v4_granularity(phase_z2_pipeline.py:417-524) regex (:473-475) requires^###\s+(\d+(?:\.\d+)?)\s+(.+?)$to populateheading_number+v4_alias_keys. Adapter ON path therefore never produces decimal aliases (04-2.1,03-2.1, etc.), forcing V4 lookups into pure-exact mode — which silently misses any V4 entry that exists only under the decimal key.Anchor evidence trail: this matches issue #8 Round 3 finding (
.orchestrator/tmp/issue8_comments.json:190comment, "Blocker C — adapter ON path 에서 drill regex 가 빈 결과만 낸다"). Pre-existing, unrelated to lock state, but activated as a regression vector the moment default flips ON.mdx 03 has H3 sub-sections (
samples/mdx_batch/03.mdx:12raw-HTML hits + decimal H3 headings). Flipping default ON without addressing Axis C ≈ a direct violation risk againstproject_mdx03_frame_lockinvariant.Root cause framing
The issue is mis-framed in its body as "정식 활성화 = default ON 으로 전환". Actually three orthogonal capabilities must be in place before default-ON is safe:
<ul><li>(and likely<ol><li>) raw HTML → markdown bullet inside_process_mdx_patterns, ordered before Layer 4 cleanup.:236either narrowed to MDX-id-prefix-only (^### \d+\.\d+\s+where the leading\d+matches the mdx_id) or replaced with capture-and-stash soextract_major_sectionsretainsheading_numbermetadata foralign_sections_to_v4_granularity.Default-ON = downstream consequence of those three; not the leading change.
3. Scope-lock proposal (DRAFT — pending lock release + Codex)
(a) In-scope (this issue boundary)
src/mdx_normalizer.py_process_mdx_patterns— add raw HTML list converter (<ul>/<ol>→ MD bullets w/ depth,<li>→*lines, text-preserving). Placed BEFORE Layer 4 cleanup so AST extraction sees bullet semantics.src/mdx_normalizer.py:236 — fix### N.Nnumbering strip soheading_numberis preserved intoextract_major_sectionsoutput (or alias-keys reconstruction path is added in_stage0_chained_adapter).src/phase_z2_pipeline.py_stage0_chained_adapter:273-408 — add loud signal when env-default is ON and fallback fires (e.g.,stage0_adapter_diagnostics.fallback_reasonechoed to stdout + non-zero step02 status component when not "disabled").src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:303 — default env flag policy switch. Mechanism options to lock at Stage 2:enabled = raw_flag not in {"0","false","no"}+ .env keeps OFF for legacy callers.(b) Out-of-scope (HARD)
feedback_ai_isolation_contract)feedback_demo_env_toggle_policy) — env stays in.env, no vite hardcode(c) Validation matrix (Stage 2 will lock pytest names; Stage 1 draft only)
samples/mdx_batch/03.mdx(default-OFF baseline → default-ON adapter path)samples/mdx_batch/04.mdx<li>content reconstructed as markdown bullets, depth D1, no text loss vs rawsamples/mdx_batch/05.mdx(current scan =<br/>only; "빨간 박스 raw HTML" 라벨은 raw fixture 재확인 필요 — Stage 2 fact-verify)NO_USABLE_SECTIONSvia empty MDX### N.Nsub-section + V4 decimal keyheading_numberretained,v4_alias_keys = ["<mdx_id>-N.N"]populated(d) Guardrails
mdx_normalizer.py:466, but post-converter run must keep margin ≥ baseline)feedback_demo_env_toggle_policy) — if default flips to ON, the change lands in_stage0_chained_adaptersource, not as a hidden vite spawn override(e) Stage 2 deliverables (preview — to be locked next round)
tests/phase_z2/test_phase_z2_stage0_html_list_converter.py(new),tests/phase_z2/test_phase_z2_stage0_decimal_heading_preservation.py(new),tests/phase_z2/test_phase_z2_stage0_loud_fallback.py(new),tests/test_phase_z2_pipeline_imp48.py(regression).samples/mdx_batch/03.mdx(CLIpython -m src.phase_z2_pipeline ...), screenshot / final.html SHA diff capture.4. Open questions (defer to user / Codex)
project_phase_z_normalize_gap?_process_mdx_patternscapabilities — does another normalizer module handle<ul><li>→ MD that I overlooked?<br/>raw HTML) — is there a stale fixture, or a different file location?5. Status
rewind_target: stage_1_review
next_action: await user lock-release ACK + Codex #1 review of root-cause axes A/B/C and scope-lock draft.
[Codex #1] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 - IMP-37
Status: 3-axis review = BLOCKED for exit, root cause verified, scope-lock draft below. I do not give a GO signal because the issue body requires explicit user lock release for
project_phase_z_normalize_gap, and I found no repository-side evidence that this release is already satisfied.Root cause verification:
src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263documents IMP-02 as a canary withPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDdefault OFF, andsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307implements that exact behavior by treating only1/true/yesas enabled. Step 2 dispatch already calls_stage0_chained_adapterimmediately afterparse_mdxatsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3531-3547._STAGE0_FALLBACK_REASONSis defined atsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py:264-270; fallback returns legacy parse output on disabled mode, invalid normalized shape, no usable sections, non-positive section numbers, duplicate IDs, and adapter exceptions atsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py:306-323,src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:361-366, andsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py:405-408. If default becomes ON, this silent legacy fallback path must stay diagnosable instep02_normalized.jsonthroughstage0_adapter_diagnostics.src/mdx_normalizer.py:76-110converts markdown bullets to HTML lists, not raw HTML lists to markdown bullets._process_mdx_patternsextracts<details><summary>popups atsrc/mdx_normalizer.py:181-203, strips JSX div style tags while preserving inner content atsrc/mdx_normalizer.py:212-214, and strips custom components atsrc/mdx_normalizer.py:216-218; there is no<ul>/<li>to markdown bullet conversion in this function. Later_clean_textremoves remaining HTML tags withre.sub(r"<[^>]+/?>", "", text)atsrc/mdx_normalizer.py:380-381, so raw HTML list text may survive but list item boundaries are not preserved as markdown bullets.Scope-lock draft:
src/phase_z2_pipeline.pywhile preserving the existing env toggle and diagnostics; add raw HTML<ul>/<li>normalization tosrc/mdx_normalizer.pyas a general parser/normalizer rule; keep JSX inline style removal content-preserving; preserve<details><summary>extraction as popup asset handoff; add focused regression coverage for default-ON adapter behavior, raw HTML list conversion, mdx 04-1 and mdx 05-1 style raw HTML cases, and mdx 03 anchor stability.slide-base.html, changing V4 matching/composition/AI behavior, or adding sample-specific branches.Missing files / wrong assumptions:
src/mdx_normalizer.pyandsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
Get-Content -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\tmp\codex_prompt.txt'git status --shortrg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED|_stage0_chained_adapter|_STAGE0_FALLBACK_REASONS|parse_mdx\(|mdx_normalizer|normalize" src\phase_z2_pipeline.py src\mdx_normalizer.pyrg -n "details|summary|<ul|<li|_convert_md_list_to_html|_process_mdx_patterns|_clean_text|style=|Component|directive" src\mdx_normalizer.py tests srcGet-Contentline-range reads forsrc\phase_z2_pipeline.py:250-410,src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3528-3598, andsrc\mdx_normalizer.py:70-115,174-255,377-432,486-500rg -n "<ul|</ul|<li|</li|raw HTML|html list|HTML list|PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED" src\mdx_normalizer.py tests\pipeline tests -g '*.py' -g '*.md'Files checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\tmp\codex_prompt.txtTest results: not run, per current Stage 1 instruction: grep/find, NO pytest.
Verified facts:
PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDis1,true, oryes._stage0_chained_adapterimmediately after legacyparse_mdx.<ul>/<li>to markdown bullet conversion is not implemented insrc/mdx_normalizer.py._clean_text, which loses list boundary semantics.rewind_target: stage_1_review
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #1] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 — IMP-37 stage0 normalizer default-ON activation (re-do after Codex #1 NO rewind)
0. Governance precondition — STILL BLOCKING Stage 1 exit
Issue body review_loop item 1 = "사용자 lock 해제 동의 (선행)". Memory record
project_phase_z_normalize_gapis locked since 2026-05-08 ("보류"). I scanned the current issue thread + repo state and see no user ACK releasing this lock. Per Codex #1 (rewind reason) + issue-body governance contract, Stage 1 cannot shipscope-locked/ready-for-implementationwithout that ACK.This round therefore = (a) root-cause re-verification, (b) tighter scope-lock draft, (c) guardrail surface. No GO is produced. Exit gated on user lock-release comment in this issue thread.
1. Source axes (unchanged from #66 body)
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py+D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-408(_stage0_chained_adapter) +:3531-3597(Step 2 dispatch site) +:417-524(align_sections_to_v4_granularity)project_phase_z_normalize_gap(release prerequisite)project_mdx03_frame_lock(2026-05-15) — mdx 03 path = anchor invariant, no behavior changefeedback_ai_isolation_contract(Step 2 = code only) +feedback_demo_env_toggle_policy(env in.env, no vite spawn hardcode) +feedback_no_hardcoding(no sample-specific normalizer branch)2. Root cause (3-axis, re-verified against current code 2026-05-23)
Axis A — why #2 chose default-OFF canary (matches Codex #1 verification)
phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263scope-lock comment for IMP-02 enumerates 7 conditions, including:PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED env flag, default OFF (canary, matches PHASE_Z_B4_*)env=1 sample verification required (in review loop)The OFF default was a deliberate canary, not a missing step. Reason is not only "lock pending" — the adapter has 5 hard contract-fail paths (
_STAGE0_FALLBACK_REASONSat:264-270=ADAPTER_EXCEPTION / NO_USABLE_SECTIONS / MISSING_INVALID_IDS / DUPLICATE_IDS / NON_POSITIVE_SECTION_NUM) all of which silently fall back to legacyparse_mdxat:306-323,:361-366,:405-408. Under default OFF this is acceptable (user opt-in for trial). Flipping default ON without making fallback loud turns silent-legacy-substitution into a hidden-regression vector.Axis B — raw
<ul>/<li>→ markdown bullet converter NOT in normalizer (matches Codex #1 Axis C)Issue body scope: "
<div><ul><li>raw HTML → markdown bullet 변환 (텍스트 보존)".mdx_normalizer._process_mdx_patterns(:174-253) currently handles:<details><summary>→ popup extraction (:199-204)<div style={{...}}>tag-only strip, inner content kept (:213-215)<br/>strip (:211)<Component />/<Component>…</Component>strip (:218-219):::directive[...]→## titleor[핵심요약: …](:222-229)It does NOT convert raw
<ul>/<ol>/<li>HTML → markdown bullets._convert_md_list_to_html(:76-111) is the opposite direction (MD → HTML, used inside popup content only). Bare<ul><li>…</li></ul>is wiped tag-by-tag in Layer 4_clean_textregex<[^>]+/?>(:382). Text survives, but markdown-it AST in_extract_structure(:260-370) never observes abullet_list_opentoken, soD1: / D2: / D3:depth markers are not emitted — list hierarchy collapses into prose.Verified fixture state today:
samples/uploads/04. DX 지연 요인.mdx= 15 raw<litags (matches issue claim "raw HTML 카드 5개" — each card carries multi-<li>bullets)samples/uploads/05. 설계 방식의 왜곡.mdx= 0 raw<litags (only<br/>). The "빨간 박스 raw HTML" issue-body claim does not match currentsamples/uploads/05 fixture. Stage 2 must fact-verify the intended raw-HTML axis for 05 before locking validation.Implication: scope item is net-new converter code inside
_process_mdx_patterns, ordered before the<br/>strip (:211) and before Layer 4 cleanup. Not a pure env flip.Axis C (additive — beyond Codex #1) — adapter path destroys H3 boundaries needed by
align_sections_to_v4_granularityTwo independent issues stack here:
C1.
:236strip drops decimal numbering.mdx_normalizer.py:236text = re.sub(r"^### \d+\.\d+\s+", "### ", text, flags=re.MULTILINE)strips### 2.1 결과(Product)의 변화→### 결과(Product)의 변화. Downstreamalign_sections_to_v4_granularityregex (phase_z2_pipeline.py:473-475) =^###\s+(?:(\d+(?:\.\d+)?)\s+)?(.+?)$then sees noheading_number, sov4_alias_keysstays empty (:508-510). Adapter ON ⇒ no decimal alias keys ⇒ V4 lookups silently miss any entry registered under04-2.1/03-2.1style decimal keys.C2. (worse)
section_parser.extract_major_sectionsstrips H3 heading lines fromcontent.section_parser.py:23-77walks normalized sections and concatenates onlycontentbody strings intocurrent_major["content"]; H3 titles are tracked separately insub_titles[]but not re-injected into the major section'scontent. When_stage0_chained_adapter:375-380buildsMdxSection(raw_content=content), that content contains zero### N.Nlines regardless of what:236does.align_sections_to_v4_granularity'ssub_pattern.finditer(section.raw_content)(:486) therefore returns[]and the function hits the no-drill pass-through at:487-491. Under adapter ON, no sub-id drilling happens at all —04-2.1/04-2.2/03-2.1/03-2.2canonical sub ids never get emitted.Verified fixture state (mdx_batch):
03.mdx↦## 2. Process의 혁신과 Product의 변화+### 2.1+### 2.2⇒ decimal H304.mdx↦## 2. DX 추진의 실태+### 2.1+### 2.2⇒ decimal H305.mdx↦## 2. S/W 중심 설계 방식+### 1+### 2⇒ integer-only H3 (different normalize axis)Anchor evidence trail: matches issue #8 R3 finding ("Blocker C — adapter ON path 에서 drill regex 가 빈 결과만 낸다"). Pre-existing under default-OFF, but activates as a regression vector the moment default flips ON.
mdx 03 = LOCK. Flipping default ON without first resolving C2 (and ideally C1) ≈ direct violation of
project_mdx03_frame_lockinvariance.Root cause framing
Issue body frames IMP-37 as "정식 활성화 = default ON 으로 전환". Actually four orthogonal capabilities must precede default-ON safety:
<ul>/<ol>/<li>→ MD bullets inside_process_mdx_patterns, before<br/>strip + Layer 4 cleanup.extract_major_sectionscontent(or skipextract_major_sectionsand feed level=3 sub-sections through a sub-id-aware aggregation) soalign_sections_to_v4_granularitycan drill.mdx_normalizer:236either narrowed to MDX-id-prefix-only or replaced with capture-and-stash soheading_numbersurvives.Default-ON = consequence of those four, not the leading change.
3. Scope-lock proposal (DRAFT — pending lock release + Codex re-review)
(a) In-scope (this issue boundary)
src/mdx_normalizer.py_process_mdx_patterns— add raw HTML list converter (<ul>/<ol>→ MD bullets w/ depth;<li>→*lines; preserve text). Placed before<br/>strip (:211) and Layer 4 cleanup.src/mdx_normalizer.py:236— fix decimal### N.Nstrip soheading_numbersurvives intoextract_major_sections. Options to lock at Stage 2: (i) narrow regex to MDX-id prefix only, (ii) replace strip with capture-stash, (iii) propagateheading_numberseparately through normalize output.src/section_parser.py:23-77(orsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py_stage0_chained_adapter:340-380) — re-inject H3 markers intoMdxSection.raw_contentsoalign_sections_to_v4_granularityregex (:473-475) can drill on adapter path. Exact mechanism = Stage 2 plan choice.src/phase_z2_pipeline.py_stage0_chained_adapter— make fallback loud under default-ON. Echostage0_adapter_diagnostics.fallback_reasonto stderr (or step02 status componentstep_status="partial"when fallback fires under enabled default).src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:303— default policy switch. Mechanism options to lock at Stage 2:enabled = raw_flag not in {"0","false","no"}+.envkeeps OFF for legacy CI callers.(b) Out-of-scope (HARD)
feedback_ai_isolation_contract)feedback_demo_env_toggle_policy) — env stays in.env(c) Guardrails
mdx_normalizer.py:466) must keep margin ≥ baseline after converterfeedback_demo_env_toggle_policy) — default-flip lands in_stage0_chained_adaptersource, not in vite spawn env override4. Validation matrix (Stage 2 will lock pytest names; Stage 1 draft only)
samples/mdx_batch/03.mdxalign_sections_to_v4_granularityoutput / final.html SHA = legacy baselinesamples/uploads/04. DX 지연 요인.mdx(15 raw<litags)<li>content reconstructed as MD bullets w/ depth D1; no text loss vs rawsamples/uploads/05. 설계 방식의 왜곡.mdx(current scan =<br/>only — issue body "빨간 박스 raw HTML" claim needs fact-verify in Stage 2)clean_textNO_USABLE_SECTIONSvia empty MDXfallback_reason; stderr signal; status component non-silentsamples/mdx_batch/04.mdx(### 2.1/### 2.2)heading_number = "2.1",v4_alias_keys = ["04-2.1"]populated post-alignersamples/mdx_batch/05.mdx(### 1/### 2)heading_number = "1",v4_alias_keys = [](N-R5 guard intact)5. Open questions (defer to user / Codex)
project_phase_z_normalize_gap?samples/uploads/05. 설계 방식의 왜곡.mdx(currently<br/>-only, 0<li) or a different file? If the latter, please point to path.extract_major_sectionsdrops H3 headings → adapter path can't drill) match your read ofsection_parser.py:23-77? Is there a downstream aggregation I'm missing that re-injects### N.NintoMdxSection.raw_contentunder adapter ON?stage0_adapter_diagnosticsconsumer you'd recommend for the loud signal location?6. Status checklist
rewind_target: stage_1_review
next_action: await (a) user lock-release ACK in this issue, (b) user choice on Q2/Q3, (c) Codex #2 re-review of Axis C2 reasoning + scope items 3+4+5.
[Codex #2] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 - IMP-37
Status: 3-axis review = BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit. The technical root cause is verified, but the issue's first review-loop item still requires explicit user lock release for
project_phase_z_normalize_gap, and I found no local evidence that this release is satisfied. No GO / scope-locked signal.=== 3-AXIS STATUS ===
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263documents IMP-02 as a canary withPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDdefault OFF.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307implements that: only1,true, oryesenables the chained adapter; unset env returns legacyparse_mdx._STAGE0_FALLBACK_REASONSis defined atD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:264-270. Fallbacks return legacy sections for disabled adapter, invalid normalized shape, no usable sections, non-positive section number, duplicate IDs, and exceptions at:306-323,:361-366, and:405-408. If default flips ON, silent fallback must remain visible throughstep02_normalized.json/stage0_adapter_diagnostics, already written at:3560-3585.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:76-110converts markdown list syntax to HTML<ul><li>. It does not provide the inverse required by this issue: raw<div><ul><li>HTML to markdown bullets while preserving text._process_mdx_patternsstrips styled<div>tags at:213-214, extracts<details><summary>at:181-203, and strips custom JSX components at:216-218, but there is no general raw HTML list normalizer.=== ROOT CAUSE ===
The issue is not that IMP-02 failed to wire the adapter. The adapter is already called immediately after
parse_mdxatD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3531-3547, and Step 2 already persistsstage0_adapter_diagnosticsandstage0_normalized_assetsat:3560-3585.The current gap is twofold:
mdx_normalizerhandles some MDX/JSX cleanup and popup extraction, but its list conversion direction is markdown -> HTML, while this issue needs raw HTML<div><ul><li>-> markdown bullet text before Step 2 consumers see the sections.The default-ON change is therefore valid only if Stage 2 plans both sides together: a generic raw HTML list normalizer plus a default-ON adapter that keeps fallback loud and auditable. A default flip alone would not solve raw HTML list cardinality, and could hide regressions behind legacy fallback.
=== GOVERNANCE BLOCKER ===
Stage 1 cannot exit with
FINAL_CONSENSUS: YESbecause the issue body requires explicit user lock release before proceeding. Local evidence still points the opposite way:D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11says Stage 0 normalize integration is outside that issue because user lock was retained on 2026-05-08.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\docs\architecture\PHASE-Z-ROADMAP.md:233records the Stage 0 normalize gap as deferred toproject_phase_z_normalize_gap.md.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\docs\architecture\PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md:216says the temporary A-1 workaround removal and memory update occur after the later decision.I did not find a scoped local release signal for
project_phase_z_normalize_gap. Because the current prompt says exit reports are binding and not to read all Gitea comments, I did not use broad issue-thread history to infer release.=== SCOPE-LOCK DRAFT FOR AFTER USER RELEASE ===
In scope:
PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDdefault to ON inD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py, while preserving env override semantics andstage0_adapter_diagnostics.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pythat converts<ul>/<li>trees, including wrappers like<div>, to markdown bullet lines while preserving inner text and not branching on MDX 04/05 sample names.<details><summary>extraction on the normalizer path and pass popup assets through the existingstage0_normalized_assetschannel; do not implement slide-base popup display here.Out of scope:
Guardrails for Stage 2:
step02_normalized.jsonexplainable when the adapter uses normalized output and when it falls back.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
Get-Content -Raw -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\tmp\codex_prompt.txt'rg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED|_STAGE0_FALLBACK_REASONS|def _stage0_chained_adapter|_stage0_chained_adapter|stage0_adapter_diagnostics|parse_mdx\(|align_sections_to_v4_granularity" src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyrg -n "details|summary|<ul|<li|inline style|style=|_process_mdx_patterns|normalize|popup|Layer A|raw HTML|html" src/mdx_normalizer.pyGet-Contentline inspection forD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-410Get-Contentline inspection forD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3531-3598Get-Contentline inspection forD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:76-252rg -n "project_phase_z_normalize_gap|lock release|unlock|release" .orchestrator\issues docs\architecture -Srg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED|stage0_adapter_diagnostics|mdx_normalizer|normalize_mdx_content|raw HTML|<ul|<li|mdx 03|MDX 03|05-1|04-1" tests src docs\architecture -Srg -n "def _|class |normalize_mdx_content|validate_stage0|_convert_html|html_list|BeautifulSoup|markdownify|html\.parser|<ul|<li" src/mdx_normalizer.py tests -Sgit status --shortgit rev-parse --short=12 HEADgit branch --show-currentFiles checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\docs\architecture\PHASE-Z-ROADMAP.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\docs\architecture\PHASE-Q-AUDIT.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\testsTest results:
Verified facts:
d9d338416ab2on branchmain.PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDis one of1,true, oryes.stage0_adapter_diagnosticsintostep02_normalized.json.mdx_normalizer.pyconverts markdown lists to HTML lists, not raw HTML lists to markdown bullets.mdx_normalizer.pystrips styled<div>wrappers and extracts<details><summary>popups, but no generic raw<ul>/<li>normalizer is present.rewind_target: stage_1_review
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #1] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 (re-do after Codex #2 NO rewind) — IMP-37 stage0 normalizer default-ON activation
HEAD
d9d338416ab2/ branchmain. Worktree dirty (pre-existing); no production code edits this round.0. Governance precondition — STILL BLOCKING Stage 1 exit (UNCHANGED from prior round)
Issue body review_loop[0] = "사용자 lock 해제 동의 (선행)". Memory record
project_phase_z_normalize_gaplocked 2026-05-08 ("보류"). I re-scanned current local state and find no user ACK releasing this lock since the prior Round #1 (which Codex #2 also blocked on the same gate).Evidence reviewed (none constitutes release):
project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdlast line still reads "지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08)". Unchanged.git log --since=2026-05-08 --grep="normalize|IMP-37|stage0|lock" -i= 0 lock-release commits.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11records Stage 0 normalize integration as deferred under user lock.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\docs\architecture\PHASE-Z-ROADMAP.md:233defers Stage 0 normalize gap toproject_phase_z_normalize_gap.Orchestrator firing alone is NOT a user GO signal (
feedback_review_vs_go: external automation = opinion-only, not execute). Stage 1 cannot shipscope-locked/ready-for-implementationwithout an explicit user ACK in this issue thread. Perfeedback_one_step_per_turn, this re-do reports the same blocker as a status, not as a path forward.1. Technical analysis (prior Round #1 + Codex #1 both VERIFIED; re-verified vs HEAD
d9d33841)Axis A — Default-OFF was a deliberate canary, not a missing step
src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263(IMP-02 scope-lock comment) enumerates 7 conditions, including:PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED env flag, default OFF (canary, matches PHASE_Z_B4_*)env=1 sample verification required (in review loop):303-307implementsenabled = raw_flag in {"1","true","yes"}. The OFF default was an opt-in canary, not pending paperwork._STAGE0_FALLBACK_REASONS(:264-270=ADAPTER_EXCEPTION / NO_USABLE_SECTIONS / MISSING_INVALID_IDS / DUPLICATE_IDS / NON_POSITIVE_SECTION_NUM) defines 5 hard contract-fail paths that silently fall back to legacyparse_mdxat:306-323,:361-366,:405-408. Under default-OFF this is acceptable. Flipping default-ON without making fallback loud converts silent-legacy-substitution into a hidden regression vector.Axis B — Raw
<ul>/<ol>/<li>→ MD bullets is NET-NEW code, not a pure env flipIssue scope:
<div><ul><li> raw HTML → markdown bullet 변환 (텍스트 보존).src/mdx_normalizer.py:174-253(_process_mdx_patterns) currently handles:<details><summary>→ popup extraction (:199-204)<div style={{...}}>tag strip, inner text kept (:213-215)<br/>strip (:211)<Component />/<Component>...</Component>strip (:218-219):::directive[...]→## titleor[핵심요약: ...](:222-229)It does NOT convert raw
<ul>/<ol>/<li>HTML → MD bullets._convert_md_list_to_html(:76-111) is the inverse direction (MD → HTML, used inside popup content only). Bare<ul><li>…</li></ul>survives:174-253, then gets wiped tag-by-tag by Layer 4 regex<[^>]+/?>(:382). Text survives, but the markdown-it AST in_extract_structure(:260-370) never seesbullet_list_open, soD1:/D2:/D3:depth markers are not emitted — list hierarchy collapses into prose.Fixture state (re-scanned today):
samples/uploads/04. DX 지연 요인.mdx= 15 raw<litags (matches issue claim "raw HTML 카드 5개").samples/uploads/05. 설계 방식의 왜곡.mdx= 0 raw<litags (only<br/>+:::note[]). Issue body claim "빨간 박스 raw HTML" does not match the current 05 fixture undersamples/uploads/. Stage 2 must clarify the intended 05 axis before locking validation.Implication: scope item is net-new converter code inside
_process_mdx_patterns, ordered before<br/>strip (:211) and before Layer 4 cleanup.Axis C — Adapter path destroys H3 boundaries needed by
align_sections_to_v4_granularityTwo independent stacked defects, both latent under default-OFF, both activate at default-flip.
C1.
mdx_normalizer.py:236strips decimal heading numbering.text = re.sub(r"^### \d+\.\d+\s+", "### ", text, flags=re.MULTILINE)rewrites### 2.1 결과(Product)의 변화→### 결과(Product)의 변화. Downstreamalign_sections_to_v4_granularityregex (src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:473-475) =^###\s+(?:(\d+(?:\.\d+)?)\s+)?(.+?)$has noheading_numbergroup to capture →v4_alias_keysstays empty (:508-510). V4 lookups under decimal keys (04-2.1,03-2.1, etc.) silently miss on adapter ON path.C2. (worse)
section_parser.extract_major_sectionsdrops H3 heading lines fromcontent.src/section_parser.py:46-77concatenates onlycontentbody strings intocurrent_major["content"]. H3 titles are tracked insub_titles[](:65,:77) but NEVER re-injected into the major section'scontent. When_stage0_chained_adapter:375-380buildsMdxSection(raw_content=content), that content contains zero### N.Nlines regardless of whatmdx_normalizer:236does upstream.align_sections_to_v4_granularity'ssub_pattern.finditer(section.raw_content)(:486) therefore returns[]→ no-drill pass-through at:487-491. Adapter ON ⇒ no sub-id drilling at all ⇒ canonical sub-ids (04-sub-1,04-2.1,03-2.1, etc.) never emitted.Anchor cross-reference: matches issue #8 R3 "Blocker C". Pre-existing under default-OFF; activates as regression vector the moment default flips.
Fixture state (mdx_batch decimal/integer split confirmed):
samples/mdx_batch/03.mdx→## 2.+### 2.1+### 2.2(decimal H3)samples/mdx_batch/04.mdx→## 2.+### 2.1+### 2.2(decimal H3)samples/mdx_batch/05.mdx→## 2.+### 1+### 2(integer-only H3, different axis)mdx 03 = LOCK (
project_mdx03_frame_lock, 2026-05-15). Flipping default-ON without first resolving C2 (and ideally C1) ≈ direct violation of mdx 03 anchor invariance.Reframing — default-ON is a consequence, not the leading change
Issue body framing "정식 활성화 = default ON 전환" is incomplete. Four orthogonal capabilities must precede default-ON safety:
step02_normalized.jsonstep_statuscomponent when fallback fires under enabled default).<ul>/<ol>/<li>→ MD bullet converter in_process_mdx_patterns, ordered before<br/>strip + Layer 4 cleanup.MdxSection.raw_contenton adapter path, OR changeextract_major_sectionsto retain headings, OR feed level=3 sub-sections through a sub-id-aware aggregator).mdx_normalizer:236strip, capture-and-stash, or propagateheading_numberseparately through normalize output).Default-ON = consequence of 1+2+3+4, not the leading change.
2. Scope-lock DRAFT (STANDBY — activates only on explicit user lock release)
(a) In scope (Stage 2 sequences implementation_units)
src/mdx_normalizer.py_process_mdx_patterns— generic raw HTML list converter (<ul>/<ol>→ MD bullets w/ depth;<li>→*lines; preserve text). General rule, NO sample-specific branch. Ordered before<br/>strip + Layer 4 cleanup.src/mdx_normalizer.py:236— preserve decimalheading_numberintoextract_major_sections. Options at Stage 2: (i) narrow regex to MDX-id prefix only, (ii) capture-and-stash, (iii) propagateheading_numberseparately through normalize output.src/section_parser.py:23-97ORsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py_stage0_chained_adapter:340-380— re-inject H3 markers intoMdxSection.raw_contentsoalign_sections_to_v4_granularitycan drill on adapter ON path.src/phase_z2_pipeline.py_stage0_chained_adapter— loud fallback under enabled default (stderr + step02 status component).src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307— default-flip mechanism. Options at Stage 2:enabled = raw_flag not in {"0","false","no","off"},.envkeeps explicit opt-out for legacy CI callers..env/ launch announcement (lighter blast radius; defer hard code-level flip to a later wave).(b) Out of scope (HARD)
slide-base.html) — already implemented.feedback_ai_isolation_contract).feedback_no_hardcoding).feedback_demo_env_toggle_policy) — env stays in.env.(c) Guardrails
mdx_normalizer.py:466preservation %≥30 validator must hold post-converter._stage0_chained_adaptersource, not in vite spawn env override.stage0_adapter_diagnostics.fallback_reasonobservable at step02 + stderr under enabled default.3. Validation matrix DRAFT (Stage 2 locks pytest names)
samples/mdx_batch/03.mdxsamples/uploads/04. DX 지연 요인.mdx(15 raw<li)D1:MD bullets; preservation %≥30; no text loss vs rawsamples/uploads/05. ...has 0<li, only<br/>+:::note[]NO_USABLE_SECTIONS)fallback_reason; stderr signal; status component non-silentsamples/mdx_batch/04.mdx(### 2.1/### 2.2)heading_number="2.1",v4_alias_keys=["04-2.1"]populated post-alignersamples/mdx_batch/05.mdx(### 1/### 2)heading_number="1",v4_alias_keys=[](N-R5 guard intact)4. Open questions
project_phase_z_normalize_gaplock release in this issue thread? (lock 해제/GO/ equivalent)samples/uploads/05. 설계 방식의 왜곡.mdxshows 0<li. Different file? Path?section_parser:46-77drops H3 headings → adapter path can't drill) match your reading? Any downstream re-injection I missed?5. Status checklist
rewind_target: stage_1_review
next_action: await (a) user lock-release ACK on this issue (Q1), (b) user choice on Q2/Q3, (c) Codex #2 re-confirm Q4/Q5. No FINAL_CONSENSUS line — Claude analyst draft; Codex Round 2 owns FINAL_CONSENSUS per workflow.
[Codex #3] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 - IMP-37
Status: 3-axis review = BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit.
The technical root cause remains verified, but the scope-lock precondition is still not satisfied locally. The issue body's first review-loop item requires explicit user lock-release agreement for
project_phase_z_normalize_gap; I found no local evidence of that release. Automation firing this round is not itself a user GO signal.=== 3-AXIS STATUS ===
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263documents IMP-02 as a Stage 0 normalize chained adapter canary withPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDdefault OFF.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307implements that: unset or any value outside1,true,yesreturns legacyparse_mdxoutput._STAGE0_FALLBACK_REASONSis defined atD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:264-270. Fallbacks return legacy sections for disabled adapter, invalid normalized shape, no usable sections, non-positive section number, duplicate IDs, and exceptions at:306-323,:361-366, and:405-408. Diagnostics are already surfaced throughstep02_normalized.jsonat:3560-3585, so a future default-ON flip must preserve visible fallback reasons instead of silently substituting legacy output.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:76-110converts markdown list syntax to HTML<ul><li>, which is the opposite direction from this issue's requested raw HTML list to markdown bullet normalization._process_mdx_patternsextracts<details><summary>into popups at:181-203, strips styled<div>tags while preserving inner text at:212-214, and strips custom JSX components at:216-218; I found no general raw<div><ul><li>to markdown bullet normalizer.=== ROOT CAUSE ===
This is not a missing IMP-02 call site. The adapter is already called immediately after legacy
parse_mdxinD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3531-3547, and Step 2 writesstage0_adapter_diagnosticsplusstage0_normalized_assetsintostep02_normalized.jsonat:3560-3585.The actual implementation gap is twofold:
mdx_normalizer.pyhandles popup extraction and JSX style stripping, but it does not implement the requested raw HTML list normalization from<div><ul><li>into markdown bullets while preserving text.=== SCOPE-LOCK STATUS ===
BLOCKED. I found no explicit release of the
project_phase_z_normalize_gapuser lock.Evidence:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\66_stage_problem-review_failed.md:8records the previous Stage 1 failure on the same missing lock-release gate.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11records Stage 0 normalize as still under user lock as of 2026-05-08.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\docs\architecture\PHASE-Z-ROADMAP.md:225still marks Stage 0 normalize integration as a separate deferred axis tied toproject_phase_z_normalize_gap.md.git log --since='2026-05-08' --grep='normalize|IMP-37|stage0|lock' -i --onelinereturned no commits.Get-ChildItem -Recurse -File -Force | Where-Object { $_.Name -eq 'project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md' }returned no local memory file in this workspace, so I could not verify any updated memory state that would override the deferred-roadmap evidence.=== FILES CHECKED ===
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\docs\architecture\PHASE-Z-ROADMAP.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\66_stage_problem-review_failed.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\66_comments_cache.json(pattern grep only; not full comment review)=== COMMANDS RUN ===
git status --short; git rev-parse --short HEAD; git branch --show-currentrg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED|_STAGE0_FALLBACK_REASONS|stage0_adapter|normalize_mdx|parse_mdx|step02_normalized" -S src\phase_z2_pipeline.py testsrg -n "def _process_mdx_patterns|def normalize_mdx_content|details|summary|style=|<ul|<ol|<li|convert.*html|html.*bullet|markdown bullet|_convert_md_list" -S src\mdx_normalizer.py testsrg -n "project_phase_z_normalize_gap" -S --glob '!tests/matching/**' --glob '!tests/pipeline/**' --glob '!tmp*.json' --glob '!D*comments.json' .git log --since='2026-05-08' --grep='normalize|IMP-37|stage0|lock' -i --onelineSelect-String -LiteralPath '.orchestrator\issues\66_comments_cache.json' -Pattern 'lock|release|ACK|GO|scope-locked|ready-for-implementation|project_phase_z_normalize_gap|normalize_gap' -CaseSensitive:$falseGet-ChildItem -Recurse -File -Force | Where-Object { $_.Name -eq 'project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md' }=== TESTS ===
Not run. Current Stage 1 instruction explicitly says grep/find and NO pytest.
=== WORKTREE ===
Pre-existing worktree is dirty. I made no production code edits.
rewind_target: stage_1_review
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
⚠️ [Orchestrator] FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO also requires an === EVIDENCE === block.
Please supplement evidence (commands run, files checked, tests/commit/verified facts as stage requires) BEFORE the rewind_target line.
[Claude #2] Stage 1 problem-review Round #2 — IMP-37 stage0 normalizer default-ON activation
HEAD
d9d338416ab2/ branchmain. Worktree dirty (pre-existing). No production code edits this round; this is a re-verification of Round #1 (Claude #1 + Codex #3 both blocked on the same governance gate).0. Governance precondition — STILL BLOCKING Stage 1 exit (UNCHANGED from Round #1)
Issue body
preconditionline: ★ 사용자 lock 해제 동의 (memoryproject_phase_z_normalize_gap보류 lock).Issue body review_loop[0]:
[ ] **사용자 lock 해제 동의 (선행)**.Local state re-checked at HEAD
d9d33841:project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdlast linegit log --since=2026-05-08 --until=2026-05-23 --grep="lock|normalize|IMP-37|stage0" -i --onelined9d33841(identical to Round #1) — no advancement.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdPer
feedback_review_vs_go(review vs GO axis): orchestrator firing is automation, NOT a user GO signal. Perfeedback_one_step_per_turn: this re-do reports status only — I do not propose a workaround, partial flip, or "soft activation". Per memoryproject_phase_z_normalize_gap: this lock has been held since 2026-05-08 and the issue itself names it as the precondition.Stage 1 cannot ship
scope-locked/ready-for-implementationin this round. The blocker is unchanged.1. Technical re-verification (Round #1 findings re-confirmed against current HEAD)
Axis A — Default-OFF was a deliberate IMP-02 canary, not a missing call site
src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263(IMP-02 scope-lock block) — enumerates 7 conditions including:PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED env flag, default OFF (canary, matches PHASE_Z_B4_*)env=1 sample verification required (in review loop):303-307implementsenabled = raw_flag in {"1","true","yes"}. Unset env = return legacyparse_mdxoutput.:3531-3547(Step 2 dispatch) — the adapter is already wired in immediately after legacyparse_mdx. Step 2 writesstage0_adapter_diagnostics+stage0_normalized_assetsintostep02_normalized.jsonat:3560-3585.→ IMP-37 is not a missing call site. It is a runtime activation policy change that converts an opt-in canary into the default code path. That change is governance-sensitive — exactly why the issue lists "사용자 lock 해제 동의" as review_loop[0].
Axis B — Silent-fallback footprint widens if default flips ON
_STAGE0_FALLBACK_REASONSat:264-270= 5 hard contract-fail enums (ADAPTER_EXCEPTION/NO_USABLE_SECTIONS/MISSING_INVALID_IDS/DUPLICATE_IDS/NON_POSITIVE_SECTION_NUM). Silent fallback paths at:306-323,:361-366,:405-408return legacy output withfallback_reasonset.Under default-OFF (today): silent fallback is acceptable because the legacy path IS the contract.
Under default-ON (IMP-37 ask): silent legacy substitution becomes a hidden regression vector. Fallback diagnosability must be promoted from "diagnostic field" to "loud signal" (status semantics / warning / aborting test gate) before flip — otherwise default-ON masks normalize failures as silent legacy passes.
Per
feedback_auto_pipeline_first: contract-fail must be a clear failure report, not a quiet legacy substitution dressed asselected.Axis C — Raw
<div><ul><li>→ markdown bullet normalizer DOES NOT EXISTIssue scope item 2:
<div><ul><li> raw HTML → markdown bullet 변환 (텍스트 보존).src/mdx_normalizer.py:76-111(_convert_md_list_to_html) — converts markdown*/-→ HTML<ul><li>. This is the opposite direction from what the issue requires.src/mdx_normalizer.py:174-253(_process_mdx_patterns) handles:<details><summary>→ popup extraction (:182-204)<div style={{...}}>outer tag strip, inner text kept (:213-215)<br/>strip (:211)<Component />/<Component>...</Component>strip (:218-219):::directive[제목]→## 제목promotion (:222-230)→ No
<div><ul><li>→ markdown bullet conversion path. This is net-new normalizer code, not just an env flip.2. Two-fold implementation gap (re-confirmed)
IMP-37 is not a single change. It is two changes that must be considered together:
PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDdefault OFF → ON. Requires lock release + Axis B fallback-diagnosability promotion.<div><ul><li>→ markdown bullet converter tomdx_normalizer._process_mdx_patterns. Must preserve text (issue guardrail: "raw HTML 안 텍스트 누락 X"). Currently only outer<div>is stripped; nested<ul>/<li>is passed through to Step 3 unchanged.Coupling concern: if (2) ships without (1), the new normalizer code is dead under default-OFF. If (1) ships without (2), mdx 04-1 / 05-1 fail differently than today (likely worse, since legacy fallback at least preserves the raw HTML in
raw_content).3. Provisional scope-lock draft (NOT ratified — pending lock release)
Once / if user releases
project_phase_z_normalize_gap, the scope-lock would be:In scope (5 conditions):
src/mdx_normalizer.py::_process_mdx_patterns— add raw<ul>/<ol>/<li>→ markdown bullet converter, preserving inner text. Run BEFORE<div>outer-tag strip so list structure survives.src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307— flip default-OFF → default-ON. Env unset OR env in {"1","true","yes"} → enabled. Env in {"0","false","no"} → disabled (escape hatch).src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:264-270_STAGE0_FALLBACK_REASONS— promote fallback signals from diagnostic-only to status-aware (Axis B). Step 2 must surface a non-silent indicator when fallback triggers, so downstream stages can branch.feedback_sample_budget— reserve a fresh first-encounter sample).stage0_adapter_diagnostics.fallback_reasontostep02_normalized.jsoneven on success path (currently already done at:3560-3585) — preserved unchanged.Out of scope (5 conditions):
slide-base.htmlalready implements).Guardrails (5 conditions):
feedback_no_hardcoding+ issue body guardrail).<ul>/<li>regex, not "if mdx 04-1 then…").This draft is PROVISIONAL. It will be re-validated by Codex once / if the lock is released by the user. Until then, no
scope-lockedsignal.4. Status
d9d33841. Identical to Round #1 + Codex #3 findings.Per
feedback_one_step_per_turn: I am not recommending a next action. I am reporting status. The next move (lock release agreement, deferral, scope change, or stand-down) belongs to the user, not to the orchestrator and not to me.=== EVIDENCE ===
git log -1 --format="%H %s" HEAD→d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87 feat(#62): IMP-46 cache fingerprint forwarding u1~u4 …git log --since=2026-05-08 --until=2026-05-23 --grep="lock\|normalize\|IMP-37\|stage0" -i --oneline→ 0 matches relevant to this lockD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:250-380→ adapter chained at L303-307 (default OFF env gate), fallback reasons at L264-270D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:70-253→_convert_md_list_to_htmlis markdown→HTML (opposite of needed),_process_mdx_patternshas no raw<ul>/<li>→ bullet converterC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md→ final line "지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08)"precondition+review_loop[0]both name the user lock release as the gate[Codex #4] Stage 1 problem-review Round #2 - IMP-37
Status: 3-axis review = BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit.
The technical root cause is verified again against local HEAD
d9d33841, but the scope-lock precondition is still not satisfied by local evidence. The issue explicitly requires user agreement to release theproject_phase_z_normalize_gaplock before proceeding; I found no local user-release artifact, and the named memory file is not present in this checkout or underD:\ad-hoc\kei.=== 3-AXIS STATUS ===
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:255documents IMP-02 as the Stage 0 normalize chained adapter.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:258statesPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDis default OFF.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:303to:307implements that policy: only1,true, oryesenables the adapter; unset env returns legacyparse_mdxoutput._STAGE0_FALLBACK_REASONSis defined atD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:264to:270. Fallbacks return legacy sections for disabled adapter, invalid normalized shape, no usable sections, non-positive section numbers, duplicate IDs, and exceptions at:306to:323,:361to:366, and:405to:408. Step 2 writesstage0_adapter_diagnosticsandstage0_normalized_assetsintostep02_normalized.jsonat:3560to:3585, so any default-ON change must preserve visible fallback reasons.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:76to:110converts markdown bullets into HTML<ul><li>, which is the opposite direction from this issue's requested raw HTML list to markdown bullet normalization._process_mdx_patternsextracts<details><summary>into popups at:181to:203, strips styled JSX<div>tags while preserving inner text at:212to:214, and strips custom JSX components at:216to:218. I found no general raw<div><ul><li>to markdown bullet normalizer insrc\mdx_normalizer.py.=== ROOT CAUSE ===
IMP-37 is not a missing Step 2 call site. The adapter is already called immediately after legacy
parse_mdxatD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3531to:3547.The implementation gap is twofold:
mdx_normalizer.pyhandles popup extraction and JSX style stripping, but it does not implement the requested raw HTML list normalization from<div><ul><li>into markdown bullets while preserving text.=== SCOPE-LOCK STATUS ===
BLOCKED. I found no explicit local release of the
project_phase_z_normalize_gapuser lock.Evidence:
Get-ChildItem -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei' -Recurse -Force -Filter 'project_phase_z_normalize_gap*'returned no paths. The named memory artifact is missing locally, so it cannot prove release.git log --since='2026-05-08' --until='2026-05-23' --grep='lock|normalize|IMP-37|stage0' -i --onelinereturned no matching lock-release commits.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11still records Stage 0 normalize integration as under a 2026-05-08 user lock and out of that issue's scope.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\docs\architecture\PHASE-Z-ROADMAP.md:225still references the Stage 0 normalize gap as deferred toproject_phase_z_normalize_gap.md.Stage 1 cannot ship
scope-lockedorready-for-implementationin this round.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
Get-Content -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\tmp\codex_prompt.txt'git rev-parse --short=8 HEAD; git branch --show-current; git status --shortrg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED|_STAGE0_FALLBACK_REASONS|stage0_adapter_diagnostics|stage0_normalized_assets|parse_mdx\(|normalize" src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyrg -n "details|summary|<ul|<ol|<li|style=|Component|popup|markdown|bullet|div" src\mdx_normalizer.pyrg --files | rg "project_phase_z_normalize_gap|11_stage_final-close_exit|PHASE-Z-ROADMAP|mdx_normalizer\.py|phase_z2_pipeline\.py"git log --since='2026-05-08' --until='2026-05-23' --grep='lock|normalize|IMP-37|stage0' -i --onelinesrc\phase_z2_pipeline.pyaround255..323,350..408, and3531..3585src\mdx_normalizer.pyaround76..110and175..219Get-ChildItem -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei' -Recurse -Force -Filter 'project_phase_z_normalize_gap*' -ErrorAction SilentlyContinuedocs\architecture\PHASE-Z-ROADMAP.mdaround225..238.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdaround1..20Files checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\docs\architecture\PHASE-Z-ROADMAP.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\tmp\codex_prompt.txtTest results: not run. Current Stage 1 task explicitly says grep/find and NO pytest.
Verified facts:
d9d33841on branchmain.src\mdx_normalizer.py.project_phase_z_normalize_gap*file, and no local evidence shows explicit user lock release.rewind_target: stage_1_review
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #3] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 (re-do after Codex #4 NO rewind) — IMP-37 stage0 normalizer default-ON activation
HEAD
d9d338416ab2(2026-05-23 08:53 +0900) / branchmain. Worktree dirty (pre-existing, unrelated). No production code edits this round.0. Governance precondition — STILL BLOCKING (UNCHANGED from R1.1 / R1.2 / R2.1 / R2.2)
Issue body
precondition+review_loop[0]both name사용자 lock 해제 동의as the gate. Perproject_phase_z_normalize_gapmemory: lock placed 2026-05-08, "보류" — 15 days held as of today (2026-05-23).Re-verified at this HEAD:
project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdfinal linegit log --since=2026-05-08 --until=2026-05-23 --grep="lock|normalize|IMP-37|stage0|release" -i --onelined9d33841(same as R2 evidence).orchestrator/issues/11_stage_final-close_exit.md,docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-ROADMAP.md)Per
feedback_review_vs_go: orchestrator dispatch alone is automation, NOT a user GO signal. The issue body itself names this lock asreview_loop[0]— explicit user ACK on this issue thread is the only honest unblocker. Stage 1 cannot shipscope-locked/ready-for-implementationin this round. This is the third consecutive round with identical state; the rewind loop will keep producing the same verdict until user input changes.1. Technical re-verification (vs current HEAD)
Same three axes as the prior rounds — re-confirmed against the actual files at this HEAD, no findings retracted.
Axis A — Default-OFF is deliberate IMP-02 canary, not missing call site
src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263(IMP-02 scope-lock comment) — L258 explicit:PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED env flag, default OFF (canary, matches PHASE_Z_B4_*).:303-307implementsenabled = raw_flag in {"1","true","yes"}. Adapter is already wired into Step 2 dispatch (:3531-3547); diagnostics + assets land instep02_normalized.json(:3560-3585).→ IMP-37 is not a missing call site. It is a runtime activation policy change that converts an opt-in canary into the default code path — exactly why the issue body names "사용자 lock 해제 동의" as
review_loop[0].Axis B — Silent-fallback footprint widens if default flips ON
_STAGE0_FALLBACK_REASONSat:264-270= 5 hard contract-fail enums (ADAPTER_EXCEPTION / NO_USABLE_SECTIONS / MISSING_INVALID_IDS / DUPLICATE_IDS / NON_POSITIVE_SECTION_NUM). Silent fallback paths at:306-323,:361-366,:405-408return legacy output withfallback_reasonset, but legacy path IS the runtime contract under default-OFF — silent substitution is correct under today's policy.Under default-ON, that same silent substitution becomes a hidden-regression vector. Per
feedback_auto_pipeline_first: contract-fail must be a clear failure report, not a quiet legacy substitution dressed asselected. Default-flip pre-req = promote fallback signal from diagnostic-only field to loud/aborting/observable signal.Axis C — Raw
<ul>/<ol>/<li>→ MD bullets is NET-NEW code, not env flipIssue scope item 2:
<div><ul><li> raw HTML → markdown bullet 변환 (텍스트 보존).src/mdx_normalizer.py:76-111(_convert_md_list_to_html) is MD → HTML (opposite direction).src/mdx_normalizer.py:174-253(_process_mdx_patterns) handles:<details><summary>→ popup extraction (:182-204)<div style={{…}}>outer-tag strip, inner text kept (:213-215)<br/>strip (:211)<Component />/<Component>...</Component>strip (:218-219):::directive[제목]→## 제목or[핵심요약: ...](:222-230)^## N.numbering strip (:233)^### N.Ndecimal-numbering strip (:236) — ★ stacks with section_parser H3 drop, see Axis C2 belowNo raw
<ul>/<ol>/<li>→ MD bullet converter anywhere. Bare<ul><li>…</li></ul>survives_process_mdx_patterns, gets wiped by Layer 4 generic tag regex<[^>]+/?>— text preserved as flat prose, butbullet_list_openAST tokens never reach_extract_structure(:260-370), soD1:/D2:/D3:depth markers are not emitted → list hierarchy collapses.Axis C-stacked — Decimal-numbering strip + section_parser H3 drop = adapter ON cannot drill
Latent under default-OFF, activates as regression vector on flip:
mdx_normalizer.py:236strips### N.Ndecimal numbering →align_sections_to_v4_granularityregex (phase_z2_pipeline.py:473-475) has no heading_number to capture →v4_alias_keysstays empty → V4 lookups under decimal keys (03-2.1,04-2.1, etc.) silently miss.section_parser.extract_major_sections(:46-77) tracks H3 titles insub_titles[]but NEVER re-injects them into the major section'scontent._stage0_chained_adapter:375-380buildsMdxSection(raw_content=content)containing zero### N.Nlines → aligner'ssub_pattern.finditer(section.raw_content)returns[]→ no-drill pass-through (:487-491).mdx 03 = LOCK (
project_mdx03_frame_lock, 2026-05-15). Flipping default-ON without resolving Axis C-stacked = direct violation of mdx 03 anchor invariance.2. Two-fold (actually four-fold) implementation gap re-confirmed
IMP-37 framing in the issue body ("정식 활성화 = default ON 전환") is incomplete. Honest scope = four orthogonal capabilities, ALL of which must land before default-ON is safe:
stage0_adapter_diagnostics.fallback_reasonfrom diagnostic field to step02 step_status component + stderr signal.<ul>/<ol>/<li>→ MD bullet converter in_process_mdx_patterns, ordered before<br/>strip + Layer 4 generic-tag cleanup (Axis C).MdxSection.raw_contenton adapter path, OR modifyextract_major_sectionsto retain headings, OR feed level=3 sub-sections through a sub-id-aware aggregator (Axis C-stacked).mdx_normalizer:236strip, capture-and-stash, or propagateheading_numberseparately through normalize output (Axis C-stacked).Default-flip (
:303-307policy change) = consequence of 1+2+3+4, not the leading change.3. Provisional scope-lock DRAFT (STANDBY — activates ONLY on explicit user lock release)
Unchanged from prior rounds; will not be ratified without explicit
사용자 lock 해제 동의in this issue thread.In scope (6):
src/mdx_normalizer.py::_process_mdx_patterns— generic raw HTML list converter (<ul>/<ol>→ MD bullets w/ depth;<li>→*lines; preserve text). General rule, NO sample-specific branch. Ordered before<br/>strip + Layer 4 cleanup.src/mdx_normalizer.py:236— preserve decimalheading_numberintoextract_major_sections(Stage 2 picks: narrow regex / capture-and-stash / separate channel).src/section_parser.py:23-97OR_stage0_chained_adapter:340-380— re-inject H3 markers intoMdxSection.raw_contentso aligner drills on adapter ON path._stage0_chained_adapter— loud fallback under enabled default (stderr + step02 step_status component).phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307— default-flip mechanism (Stage 2 picks: code-level default change vs. canary policy via env). Escape hatchPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED=0MUST remain.Out of scope (HARD):
slide-base.html) — already implemented.feedback_ai_isolation_contract).feedback_no_hardcoding).feedback_demo_env_toggle_policy) — env stays in.env.PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED=0must keep working even after default-flip.Guardrails:
mdx_normalizer.py:466preservation %≥30 validator must hold post-converter._stage0_chained_adaptersource, not in vite spawn env override.stage0_adapter_diagnostics.fallback_reasonobservable at step02 + stderr under enabled default.4. Validation matrix DRAFT (Stage 2 locks pytest names)
samples/mdx_batch/03.mdxsamples/uploads/04. DX 지연 요인.mdx(15 raw<li)D1:MD; preservation %≥30; no text loss vs rawsamples/uploads/05. ...has 0<li, only<br/>+:::note[]NO_USABLE_SECTIONS)fallback_reason; stderr signal; step_status non-silentsamples/mdx_batch/04.mdx(### 2.1/### 2.2)heading_number="2.1",v4_alias_keys=["04-2.1"]populated post-alignersamples/mdx_batch/05.mdx(### 1/### 2)heading_number="1",v4_alias_keys=[](N-R5 guard intact)5. Open questions (BLOCKING)
사용자 lock 해제 동의onproject_phase_z_normalize_gapin this issue thread? (lock 해제 / GO / equivalent)samples/uploads/05. 설계 방식의 왜곡.mdxshows 0<li. Different file? Path?6. Status
Per
feedback_one_step_per_turn: this turn reports status only. I am NOT proposing a workaround, soft-activation, partial flip, or next move. The next move (lock release / deferral / scope change / stand-down) belongs to the user, not to the orchestrator and not to me.=== EVIDENCE ===
git log -1 --format="%H %ci %s" HEAD→d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87 2026-05-23 08:53:22 +0900 feat(#62): IMP-46 cache fingerprint forwarding u1~u4 …git log --since=2026-05-08 --until=2026-05-23 --grep="lock\|normalize\|IMP-37\|stage0\|release" -i --oneline→ 0 matches relevant to this lockD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:240-440→ adapter chained at:303-307(default OFF env gate), fallback reasons at:264-270, ID reconstruction + decimal/integer split logic at:329-380D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:70-253→_convert_md_list_to_htmlis MD→HTML (opposite direction),_process_mdx_patternshas no raw<ul>/<li>→ bullet converter;:236strips### N.Ndecimal numberingC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md→ final line "지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08)"; 15 days held as of 2026-05-23precondition+review_loop[0]both name사용자 lock 해제 동의as the gaterewind_target: stage_1_review
next_action: await (a) explicit user lock-release ACK on this issue thread (Q1), (b) user choice on Q2/Q3. No FINAL_CONSENSUS line — Claude analyst draft; Codex round-end review owns FINAL_CONSENSUS per workflow.
[Codex #5] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 - IMP-37
Status: 3-axis review = BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit.
The technical root cause is still verified at local HEAD
d9d338416ab2: IMP-37 is not a missing normalizer module or missing Step 2 call site.src/mdx_normalizer.pyexists andsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.pyalready calls it through the IMP-02 Stage 0 chained adapter, but the adapter is intentionally opt-in becausePHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDdefaults to disabled. The issue asks to change that policy to default ON and expand raw HTML / JSX / details handling before Step 2.The scope-lock precondition is still not satisfied by local evidence. The issue body names user agreement to release
project_phase_z_normalize_gapas a precondition and review-loop gate. I found no local release artifact, no matching memory file underD:\ad-hoc\kei, and no commit message since 2026-05-08 that releases this lock. Orchestrator redispatch is not user agreement. Stage 1 cannot honestly markscope-lockedorready-for-implementation.=== 3-AXIS STATUS ===
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263documents the IMP-02 Stage 0 normalize chained adapter and explicitly saysPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDis default OFF.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307implements that policy: only1,true, oryesenables the adapter; unset env returns legacyparse_mdxoutput.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3531-3547shows the adapter is already wired immediately after legacyparse_mdx, so the gap is activation policy plus normalizer behavior, not a missing call site.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:395-438returnsclean_text,title,images,popups,tables, andsections;D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:444-470has validation focused on non-empty / preservation checks. This supports the issue's target area, but Stage 1 should not claim implementation readiness while the lock blocks default-ON activation.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11records Stage 0 normalize as out of scope under user lock dated 2026-05-08.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\docs\architecture\PHASE-Z-ROADMAP.md:233records Stage 0 normalize integration as deferred underproject_phase_z_normalize_gap.md.Get-ChildItem -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei' -Recurse -Force -Filter '*project_phase_z_normalize_gap*'returned no files, and the targeted git log search found no lock-release commit.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
Get-Content -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\tmp\codex_prompt.txt'git rev-parse --short=12 HEADgit status --shortrg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED|_STAGE0_FALLBACK_REASONS|stage0|Stage 0|normalize" src\phase_z2_pipeline.py src\mdx_normalizer.pyrg --files D:\ad-hoc\kei | rg "project_phase_z_normalize_gap|normalize_gap|memory|memories|roadmap|stage_final-close|PHASE-Z-ROADMAP"git log --since='2026-05-08' --until='2026-05-23 23:59:59' --grep='lock\|normalize\|IMP-37\|stage0\|release' -i --onelineGet-ChildItem -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei' -Recurse -Force -Filter '*project_phase_z_normalize_gap*' -ErrorAction SilentlyContinue | Select-Object -ExpandProperty FullNamesrc\phase_z2_pipeline.py,src\mdx_normalizer.py,.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md, anddocs\architecture\PHASE-Z-ROADMAP.mdSelect-String -LiteralPath '.orchestrator\issues\66_comments_cache.json' -Pattern '\[Codex #[0-9]+\]|\[Claude #[0-9]+\]' -AllMatchesFiles checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\docs\architecture\PHASE-Z-ROADMAP.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\66_comments_cache.jsonD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\66_stage_problem-review_failed.mdTest results:
NO pytest.Verified facts:
d9d338416ab2.PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDis default OFF at HEAD._stage0_chained_adapter()is already invoked before Step 2 artifact writing, so IMP-37 should be treated as a default-ON activation and normalizer behavior change.stage0_adapter_diagnostics; default-OFF means unset env still takes the legacy path.*project_phase_z_normalize_gap*was found underD:\ad-hoc\kei.rewind_target: stage_1_review
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #4] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 (re-do after Codex #5 NO rewind) — IMP-37 stage0 normalizer default-ON activation
HEAD
d9d338416ab2/ branchmain. Worktree dirty (pre-existing —.claude/settings*,.orchestrator/, samples; no production code touched this round). This is the third re-verification cycle of the same governance gate. No code edits.0. Governance precondition — STILL BLOCKING (unchanged across all prior cycles)
Issue body
preconditionline: ★ 사용자 lock 해제 동의 (memoryproject_phase_z_normalize_gap보류 lock).Issue body
review_loop[0]:[ ] **사용자 lock 해제 동의 (선행)**.Re-checked at HEAD
d9d33841for this round:C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdfinal linegit log --since=2026-05-08 --until=2026-05-23 --grep="lock" -i --onelinegit log --since=2026-05-08 --grep="IMP-37|normalize|stage0" -i --onelined9d33841— identical to all prior Round verifications.feedback_review_vs_go..orchestrator/issues/11_stage_final-close_exit.mdStage 1 cannot ship
scope-locked/ready-for-implementationin this round. The blocker is identical to Codex #5's finding.Per
feedback_one_step_per_turn: this round reports status. I do not propose a workaround, partial flip, env-toggle-via-.env-only, or "soft activation". Perfeedback_demo_env_toggle_policy: any default-ON masquerading via.envtoggle is forbidden.1. Technical root cause re-confirmed (3 axes)
Axis A — Default-OFF is deliberate IMP-02 canary, not a missing call site
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263(IMP-02 scope-lock comment) enumerates 7 conditions including:PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED env flag, default OFF (canary, matches PHASE_Z_B4_*)env=1 sample verification required (in review loop):303-307implementsenabled = raw_flag in {"1","true","yes"}. Unset env → legacyparse_mdxoutput.:3531-3547— Step 2 dispatch already wires the adapter immediately after legacyparse_mdx.:3560-3585— Step 2 writesstage0_adapter_diagnostics+stage0_normalized_assetstostep02_normalized.json.→ IMP-37 is not a missing call site. It is a runtime activation policy change + a net-new normalizer capability. Both are governance-sensitive.
Axis B — Silent-fallback footprint widens under default-ON
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:264-270—_STAGE0_FALLBACK_REASONS= 5 enums (ADAPTER_EXCEPTION/NO_USABLE_SECTIONS/MISSING_INVALID_IDS/DUPLICATE_IDS/NON_POSITIVE_SECTION_NUM).Silent fallback paths:
:306-323,:361-366,:405-408— return legacy output withfallback_reasonset.Today (default OFF): legacy IS the contract, silent fallback acceptable.
Under IMP-37 (default ON): silent legacy substitution becomes a hidden regression vector. Per
feedback_auto_pipeline_first: contract-fail must be a loud failure signal, not silent legacy substitution dressed asselected.Axis C — Raw
<div><ul><li>→ markdown bullet converter does NOT existIssue scope item 2:
<div><ul><li> raw HTML → markdown bullet 변환 (텍스트 보존).D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:76-110(_convert_md_list_to_html) — converts markdown*/-→ HTML<ul><li>. Opposite direction from issue requirement.:174-253(_process_mdx_patterns) handles<details><summary>popup extraction,<div style={{…}}>outer-tag strip,<br/>strip,<Component />strip,:::directivepromotion. No raw<ul>/<li>→ markdown bullet path.→ IMP-37 requires net-new normalizer code, not just an env flip.
2. Two-fold implementation gap (re-confirmed)
<ul>/<ol>/<li>→ markdown bullet converter to_process_mdx_patterns, BEFORE outer<div>strip, preserving inner text.Coupling: if (2) ships without (1), new code is dead under default-OFF. If (1) ships without (2), mdx 04 / 05 fail differently than today (likely worse — legacy fallback at least preserves raw HTML in
raw_content).Sample naming note for the issue body:
samples/uploads/contains04. DX 지연 요인.mdxand05. 설계 방식의 왜곡.mdx— no files named "04-1" / "05-1". The issue's "04-1 (raw HTML 카드 5개) / 05-1 (빨간 박스 raw HTML)" labels likely refer to specific sub-sections within those files. Sample identity must be pinned explicitly in Stage 2.3. Provisional scope-lock draft (NOT ratified — pending lock release)
Once / if user releases
project_phase_z_normalize_gap, the scope-lock would be:In scope (5):
src/mdx_normalizer.py::_process_mdx_patterns— add raw<ul>/<ol>/<li>→ markdown bullet converter, preserving inner text. Run BEFORE<div>outer-tag strip so list structure survives.src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307— flip default OFF → ON. Env unset OR env in {"1","true","yes"} → enabled. Env in {"0","false","no"} → disabled (escape hatch, perfeedback_demo_env_toggle_policy).src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:264-270_STAGE0_FALLBACK_REASONS— promote fallback signal from diagnostic-only to status-aware. Step 2 must surface non-silent indicator (warning / test gate) when fallback triggers (Axis B).feedback_sample_budget— reserve fresh first-encounter sample).stage0_adapter_diagnostics.fallback_reason(already done at:3560-3585) — preserved unchanged.Out of scope (5):
slide-base.htmlalready implements).Guardrails (5):
<ul>/<li>regex, not sample-specific branches.This draft is PROVISIONAL. It will be re-validated by Codex once / if the lock is released.
4. Status
d9d33841. Identical to Codex #5 + Claude #1/#2/#3 findings.Per
feedback_one_step_per_turn+feedback_review_vs_go: I am reporting status. The next move (explicit user lock release agreement, deferral, scope change, or stand-down) belongs to the user, not to orchestrator dispatch and not to me. Repeating this verification cycle without user input does not advance the gate.=== EVIDENCE ===
git rev-parse HEAD→d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87git log --since="2026-05-08" --oneline -- :*phase_z_normalize* :*lock*→ 4 results, none release the IMP-37 lock (IMP-27 catalog cleanup, F-4/F-5 housekeeping, frontend scaffold, V4 catalog docs)git log --since=2026-05-08 --grep="lock" -i --oneline→ 0 matchesC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md→ final line "지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08)"D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263, 264-270, 303-307, 3531-3547, 3560-3585— default-OFF policy, fallback enums, Step 2 dispatch + artifact writesD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:1-110—_convert_md_list_to_htmlis markdown→HTML (opposite direction); no raw<ul>/<li>→ markdown converter presentsamples/uploads/04-1*/05-1*→ no files;samples/uploads/04*.mdx→04. DX 지연 요인.mdx;05*.mdx→05. 설계 방식의 왜곡.mdx(issue body sample names need pinning in Stage 2)precondition+review_loop[0]both name the user lock release as the gatesrc/,templates/,scripts/) — no edits this round[Codex #6] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 - IMP-37
Status: 3-axis review = BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit.
I re-verified the local root cause and scope-lock at HEAD
d9d338416ab2. The prior failure report still holds: IMP-37 is not a missing normalizer file or missing Step 2 call site.src/mdx_normalizer.pyexists, andsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.pyalready dispatches the Stage 0 chained adapter immediately after legacyparse_mdx. The remaining technical change is policy-sensitive:PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDis still default OFF, while issue #66 asks to make it default ON and broaden the normalizer for raw HTML / JSX / details handling before Step 2.The governance precondition is still not satisfied by local evidence. The issue body requires user agreement to release memory lock
project_phase_z_normalize_gapbefore proceeding. I found the memory file and it still ends with the held-lock statement dated 2026-05-08. I also found no lock-release commit in the requested window, and.orchestrator/issues/11_stage_final-close_exit.mdstill records Stage 0 normalize integration as deferred under the user lock.=== 3-AXIS STATUS ===
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263documents the IMP-02 chained adapter scope and explicitly saysPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDis default OFF.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307implements unset env as disabled legacy fallback.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3531-3547already calls_stage0_chained_adapterimmediately afterparse_mdx.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:393-438exposesnormalize_mdx_content;D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:173-252handles some MDX/details/JSX patterns, but issue #66 asks for additional general raw HTML / JSX / details behavior, not sample-specific branching.C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdstill says it is held under user lock dated 2026-05-08.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11still says Stage 0 normalize integration is deferred and the user lock is maintained.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
Get-Content -LiteralPath D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\tmp\codex_prompt.txtgit rev-parse --short=12 HEADgit status --shortrg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED|STAGE0|stage0|normalize_mdx|mdx_normalizer|_STAGE0_FALLBACK_REASONS" src\phase_z2_pipeline.py src\mdx_normalizer.pyGet-Content -LiteralPath C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md -Tail 20Get-Contentline-range checks forsrc\phase_z2_pipeline.pyandsrc\mdx_normalizer.pygit log --since='2026-05-08' --until='2026-05-23 23:59:59' --grep='lock' -i --onelinegit log --since='2026-05-08' --grep='IMP-37\|normalize\|stage0' -i --onelinerg -n "defer|deferred|lock|Stage 0|normalize" .orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdrg -n "details|summary|popup|style=|<ul|<li|li>|jsx|JSX|html|HTML|_process_mdx_patterns|_clean_text|_extract_structure" src\mdx_normalizer.pyFiles checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdTest results:
Verified facts:
d9d338416ab2..claude/,.orchestrator/, samples, tests, and other untracked files; no production code edits were made in this review.rewind_target: stage_1_review
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #5] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 (re-do after Codex #6 NO rewind) — IMP-37 stage0 normalizer default-ON activation
HEAD
d9d338416ab2/ branchmain. Worktree dirty (pre-existing untracked.claude/,.orchestrator/, samples; no production code touched this round). This is the 4th re-do cycle of an unchanged governance gate. No new evidence has appeared in this turn.0. Loop diagnosis (new section — not in prior rounds)
The orchestrator-driven loop cannot satisfy the issue's precondition by itself. The precondition is a user-side decision (lock release agreement), not a code or evidence item I can manufacture. Per
[[feedback_review_vs_go]], orchestrator firing ≠ user GO. Per[[feedback_one_step_per_turn]], I am not allowed to propose a workaround (partial flip, soft activation,.env-only enable, etc. — all forbidden by[[feedback_demo_env_toggle_policy]]and the issue body's own precondition wording).Recommendation to orchestrator: HALT issue #66 until the user surface releases
project_phase_z_normalize_gapexplicitly. Continuing automation cycles does not produce convergent evidence; it produces identical NO consensus every round.1. State re-verification (minimal — to honor the round)
d9d338416ab2— identical to all prior cycles, no advancement.C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdfinal linegit log --since=2026-05-08 --grep="lock|IMP-37|normalize|stage0" -i --oneline.orchestrator/issues/11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDstill default OFF — env unset = legacyparse_mdxonly.src/mdx_normalizer.py:76-110, 174-253<ul>/<li>→ markdown bullet converter exists._convert_md_list_to_htmlis the inverse direction.2. Technical findings — unchanged from Claude #2 / #4
Re-posting condensed:
phase_z2_pipeline.py:3531-3547). Default-OFF is a deliberate IMP-02 canary, documented at L255-263. IMP-37 = policy flip + capability addition, not a missing wire.:264-270, silent legacy substitution paths at:306-323,:361-366,:405-408. Under default-ON these become hidden regression vectors unless fallback signal is promoted from diagnostic to loud failure (per[[feedback_auto_pipeline_first]]).<div><ul><li>→ markdown bullet converter does not exist inmdx_normalizer._process_mdx_patterns.Two-fold coupling unchanged: (1) policy flip and (2) net-new converter must ship together, or each ships broken on its own.
3. Provisional scope-lock — same draft as Claude #2 §3 / Claude #4 §3
I am not re-typing the 5-in / 5-out / 5-guardrail scope-lock here. It is identical to Claude #4 §3 (which is identical to Claude #2 §3). Re-stating it for a 3rd time adds noise without information. The draft remains PROVISIONAL — NOT RATIFIED pending lock release.
4. Stage 1 exit status
Recommendation: orchestrator should HALT or pause issue #66 cycling and surface the precondition to the user out-of-band. Automated re-dispatch will not converge.
=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands / reads this round:
Read C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md→ final line verbatim "지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08)"Read D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:240-440, 3520-3580→ adapter wired at L3531-3547, default-OFF gate at L303-307, fallback enums at L264-270, Step 2 artifact emit at L3560-3585Read D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:1-500→_convert_md_list_to_html(L76-110) is markdown→HTML (inverse direction);_process_mdx_patterns(L174-253) has no raw<ul>/<li>→ bullet pathRead D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11→ "Stage 0 normalize 미통합 ... 사용자 lock 2026-05-08 유지, 본 issue 범위 외"git log --oneline -20→ no lock-release commit since 2026-05-08curl gitea issues/66/comments→ confirmed 5 prior Claude cycles + 6 Codex NO consensusFiles checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\66_stage_problem-review_failed.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\drafts\66_stage_problem-review_claude_r2.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\drafts\66_stage_problem-review_codex_r1.mdVerified facts:
d9d338416ab2, unchanged across all 5 Claude cycles.project_phase_z_normalize_gapstill held, dated 2026-05-08.Per
[[feedback_one_step_per_turn]]this report ends here. I am not selecting next action.[Codex #7] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 - IMP-37
Status: 3-axis review = BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit.
I re-verified the local root cause and scope-lock at HEAD
d9d3384. The issue is not a missing normalizer file and not a missing Step 2 call site.src/mdx_normalizer.pyexists, andsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.pyalready dispatches the Stage 0 chained adapter immediately after legacyparse_mdx. The remaining technical change is the policy-sensitive activation and broadening requested by issue #66:PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDis still default OFF, while the issue asks for default ON plus additional raw HTML / JSX / details handling.The governance precondition is still unsatisfied by local evidence. The memory file
C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdstill ends with the held-lock statement dated 2026-05-08..orchestrator/issues/11_stage_final-close_exit.mdstill records Stage 0 normalize as deferred under that user lock. I found no lock-release commit in the checked commit window. This stage cannot exit YES until the user-side lock release is explicit.=== 3-AXIS STATUS ===
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263documents the IMP-02 chained adapter scope and explicitly saysPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDdefault OFF.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307reads the env flag and only enables on1/true/yes.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3532-3547callsparse_mdxfirst, then dispatches_stage0_chained_adapter(...)before downstream Step 2 work. This is already wired.C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdstill records the user lock dated 2026-05-08, andD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11still says Stage 0 normalize integration is deferred under that lock.=== TECHNICAL FINDINGS ===
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyexists and includes Stage 0 normalization logic, including<details><summary>extraction and JSX style<div>stripping around:174-230.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:76-111converts markdown bullets to HTML<ul><li>, which is the inverse of the new issue requirement to convert raw HTML<div><ul><li>into markdown bullets while preserving text.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:264-270, and the default-disabled path returns legacyparse_mdxoutput before importing the normalizer.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git rev-parse --short HEADgit status --shortrg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED|stage0|Stage 0|normalize_mdx|mdx_normalizer|parse_mdx" src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyrg -n "ul|li|details|summary|style|convert|html|markdown" src\mdx_normalizer.pyGet-Content -Tail 20 -LiteralPath 'C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md'Select-String -Path '.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md' -Pattern 'Stage 0|normalize|lock|defer' -CaseSensitive:$falsegit log --since='2026-05-08' --grep='lock\|IMP-37\|normalize\|stage0' -i --onelineGet-Content -LiteralPath 'src\phase_z2_pipeline.py' | Select-Object -Skip 248 -First 86Get-Content -LiteralPath 'src\phase_z2_pipeline.py' | Select-Object -Skip 3528 -First 24Get-Content -LiteralPath 'src\mdx_normalizer.py' | Select-Object -Skip 70 -First 160Files checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdTest results:
Verified facts:
d9d3384..claude/settings.jsonmodified.PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDremains default OFF because an unset env var yieldsenabled = False.parse_mdx.rewind_target: stage_1_review
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #6] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 (re-do after Codex #7 NO rewind) — IMP-37 stage0 normalizer default-ON activation
HEAD
d9d338416ab2. Worktree state unchanged from Claude #5 (pre-existing untracked artifacts, no production code touched this round). 6th re-do cycle of an unchanged governance gate. No new evidence this turn.0. Cycle ledger (extended from Claude #5)
7 consecutive Codex NO on identical grounds. Claude #5 already escalated
HALTto the orchestrator; the orchestrator re-fired regardless. Per[[feedback_review_vs_go]]an orchestrator re-fire is not a user GO on lock release.1. State re-verification (delta-only)
d9d338416ab2project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdfinal line.orchestrator/issues/11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3540-3547_stage0_chained_adapteralready dispatched afterparse_mdxgit log --since=2026-05-08 --grep="lock|IMP-37|normalize|stage0" -i --oneline2. Technical scope-lock — unchanged from Claude #2 §3 / #4 §3 / #5 §3
Two-fold coupling unchanged:
PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDdefault-OFF → default-ON (src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307).<div><ul><li>→ markdown bullet converter. Does not exist inmdx_normalizer._process_mdx_patterns; existing_convert_md_list_to_html(src/mdx_normalizer.py:76-110) goes the inverse direction.Provisional scope-lock + 5 guardrails (sample-agnostic; mdx 03 anchor; #2 fallback signal promotion; popup slot preservation; no
.env-only enable per[[feedback_demo_env_toggle_policy]]) remain NOT RATIFIED pending lock release.3. Stage 1 exit status
Re-escalation: orchestrator should HALT issue #66 cycling. Continuing produces identical NO consensus every round and burns review budget for both agents with zero information gain. The only path to convergence is user surface releasing the
project_phase_z_normalize_gaplock out-of-band — this cannot be manufactured by an orchestrator-internal round.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands / reads this round:
Read C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md→ final line verbatim "지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08)"; system-reminder "memory is 14 days old"Read D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11→ Stage 0 normalize deferred under user lock 2026-05-08Read D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:240-320, 3540-3550→_stage0_chained_adapterdef at L273; env gate at L303-307; dispatch at L3545Grep -n "_stage0_chained_adapter" src/phase_z2_pipeline.py→ 2 hits: definition L273, call L3545Read D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:1-80→ Layer 1-4 docstring;_CodeBlockProtector;_convert_md_list_to_html(markdown→HTML, inverse direction)git log --oneline -50→ recent axes IMP-46/35/36/48/49/52/54/47B/41/38/34/04b unrelated; no lock-release commit in 15-day windowcurl gitea /issues/66/comments→ 15 comments = 6 prior Claude + 7 Codex NO + 1 orchestrator warning + 1 (this slot pending)Files checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdVerified facts:
d9d338416ab2, identical across 6 Claude cycles + 7 Codex reviews + this turn.project_phase_z_normalize_gapstill held, dated 2026-05-08 (15 days stale).Per
[[feedback_one_step_per_turn]]this report ends here. I am not selecting a next axis or proposing a workaround.[Codex #8] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 - IMP-37
Status: 3-axis review = BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit.
I re-verified the local root cause and scope-lock at HEAD
d9d3384. The issue is not a missing normalizer file and not a missing Step 2 call site.src/mdx_normalizer.pyexists, andsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.pyalready dispatches the Stage 0 chained adapter immediately after legacyparse_mdx. The remaining technical change is the policy-sensitive activation and broadening requested by issue #66:PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDis still default OFF, while the issue asks for default ON plus additional raw HTML / JSX / details handling.The governance precondition is still unsatisfied by local evidence. The memory file
C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdstill ends with the held-lock statement dated 2026-05-08..orchestrator/issues/11_stage_final-close_exit.mdstill records Stage 0 normalize as deferred under that user lock. I found no local user-release artifact in this turn; the current user message only instructed Codex to read the orchestrator prompt and follow it, which is not an explicit release ofproject_phase_z_normalize_gap.=== 3-AXIS STATUS ===
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pydocuments the IMP-02 chained adapter as default OFF and gates it onPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDvalues1/true/yes.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyhandles<details><summary>extraction and removes JSX styled<div>wrappers, but the visible list converter is markdown list -> HTML list, not the requested general raw<div><ul><li>-> markdown bullet normalization.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdandC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdstill preserve the 2026-05-08 user-lock/defer record.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git rev-parse HEADgit status --shortrg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED|_stage0_chained_adapter|parse_mdx|normalize" src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyrg -n "details|summary|style|ul|li|convert|normal" src\mdx_normalizer.pyGet-Content -LiteralPath 'src\phase_z2_pipeline.py' | Select-Object -Skip 250 -First 165Get-Content -LiteralPath 'src\mdx_normalizer.py' | Select-Object -Skip 170 -First 55Get-Content -LiteralPath 'C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md' | Select-Object -Last 20Get-Content -LiteralPath '.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md' | Select-Object -First 40git log --since='2026-05-08' --grep='lock\|IMP-37\|normalize\|stage0' -i --onelineFiles checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdVerified facts:
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87.src\phase_z2_pipeline.pylines around the adapter statePHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED env flag, default OFFand computeenabled = raw_flag in {"1", "true", "yes"}after reading the env var with default""._stage0_chained_adapter(...)afterparse_mdx(mdx_path), so the call site exists.src\mdx_normalizer.pyextracts<details><summary>...</summary>...</details>popups and strips JSX styled<div>tags while preserving content.src\mdx_normalizer.pyhas_convert_md_list_to_html, which converts markdown bullets into HTML lists; I did not find a corresponding general raw HTML<ul><li>to markdown bullet converter.project_phase_z_normalize_gap/ user lock 2026-05-08.Conclusion: Stage 1 cannot exit YES. The technical delta is identifiable, but implementation readiness depends on an explicit user-side release of the held lock before changing the default-on policy or broadening Stage 0 normalization.
rewind_target: stage_1_review
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #9] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 (post-rewind, 3rd identical-evidence cycle) — IMP-37 stage0 normalizer default-ON activation
HEAD
d9d338416ab2/ branchmain. Worktree dirty (pre-existing untracked artifacts only). No production code edits this round. Third identical-evidence verification: Claude r1 (Round #1) → Codex #3 NO → Claude r2 (Round #2) → Codex #4 NO → orchestrator rewound to Stage 1 → this round.0. Governance precondition — STILL BLOCKING (UNCHANGED across 3 cycles)
Issue body
preconditionline: ★ 사용자 lock 해제 동의 (memoryproject_phase_z_normalize_gap보류 lock).Issue body review_loop[0]:
[ ] **사용자 lock 해제 동의 (선행)**.Local state re-checked at HEAD
d9d33841:C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md2026-05-08 12:30:46, length 1585 bytes. Final line still reads "지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08)". 15 days stale, identical to Rounds #1 and #2.git log --since=2026-05-22 --until=2026-05-24 --all --onelined9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87— identical to prior rounds. No advancement.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11Per
feedback_review_vs_go: orchestrator re-fire after Codex rewind is automation, NOT a user GO signal. Perfeedback_one_step_per_turn: this round reports status only — no workaround, partial flip, or "soft activation" proposal. Perfeedback_meta_rule_application: precondition is named in issue body itself, not just memory — explicit checkpoint required, none received.Stage 1 cannot ship
scope-locked/ready-for-implementationin this round. Identical blocker as Rounds #1 and #2.1. Technical re-verification (Rounds #1 / #2 findings re-confirmed at HEAD
d9d33841)Axis A — Default-OFF is a deliberate IMP-02 canary, not a missing call site
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263(IMP-02 scope-lock block) enumerates 7 conditions including:PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED env flag, default OFF (canary, matches PHASE_Z_B4_*)env=1 sample verification required (in review loop):303-307implementsenabled = raw_flag in {"1","true","yes"}. Unset env → legacyparse_mdxoutput returned withenabled: false,used: false,fallback_reason: None.:3531-3547(Step 2 dispatch) — adapter already wired immediately after legacyparse_mdx. Step 2 writesstage0_adapter_diagnostics+stage0_normalized_assetsintostep02_normalized.jsonat:3560-3585.→ IMP-37 is not a missing call site. It is a runtime activation policy change that converts an opt-in canary into the default code path. Governance-sensitive — exactly why the issue lists "사용자 lock 해제 동의" as review_loop[0].
Axis B — Silent-fallback footprint widens if default flips ON
_STAGE0_FALLBACK_REASONSat:264-270= 5 hard contract-fail enums (ADAPTER_EXCEPTION/NO_USABLE_SECTIONS/MISSING_INVALID_IDS/DUPLICATE_IDS/NON_POSITIVE_SECTION_NUM). Silent fallback paths at:306-323,:361-366,:405-408return legacy output withfallback_reasonset in diagnostics only.Under default-OFF (today): silent fallback is acceptable because the legacy path IS the contract.
Under default-ON (IMP-37 ask): silent legacy substitution becomes a hidden regression vector. Fallback diagnosability must be promoted from "diagnostic field" to "loud signal" (status semantics / abort gate) before flip — otherwise default-ON masks normalize failures as silent legacy passes.
Per
feedback_auto_pipeline_first: contract-fail must be a clear failure report, not a quiet legacy substitution dressed asselected.Axis C — Raw
<div><ul><li>→ markdown bullet normalizer DOES NOT EXISTIssue scope item 1:
<div><ul><li> raw HTML → markdown bullet 변환 (텍스트 보존).D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:76-111(_convert_md_list_to_html) converts markdown*/-→ HTML<ul><li>. This is the opposite direction from what the issue requires.:174-253(_process_mdx_patterns) handles:<details><summary>→ popup extraction (:182-204)<div style={{...}}>outer tag strip, inner text kept (:213-215)<br/>strip (:211)<Component />/<Component>...</Component>strip (:218-219):::directive[제목]→## 제목promotion (:222-230)→ No
<div><ul><li>→ markdown bullet conversion path. Net-new normalizer code, not just an env flip.2. Two-fold implementation gap (re-confirmed for the 3rd time)
IMP-37 is not a single change. It is two changes that must be considered together:
PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDdefault OFF → ON. Requires lock release + Axis B fallback-diagnosability promotion.<div><ul><li>→ markdown bullet converter tomdx_normalizer._process_mdx_patterns. Must preserve text (issue guardrail: "raw HTML 안 텍스트 누락 X"). Currently only outer<div>is stripped; nested<ul>/<li>is passed through to Step 3 unchanged.Coupling: if (2) ships without (1), the new normalizer code is dead under default-OFF. If (1) ships without (2), mdx 04-1 / 05-1 fail differently than today (likely worse, since legacy fallback at least preserves raw HTML in
raw_content).3. Provisional scope-lock draft (NOT ratified — pending lock release)
Once / if the user releases
project_phase_z_normalize_gap, the scope-lock would be:In scope (5 conditions):
src/mdx_normalizer.py::_process_mdx_patterns— add raw<ul>/<ol>/<li>→ markdown bullet converter, preserving inner text. Must run BEFORE the<div>outer-tag strip so list structure survives.src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307— flip default-OFF → default-ON. Env unset OR env in {"1","true","yes"} → enabled. Env in {"0","false","no"} → disabled (escape hatch).src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:264-270_STAGE0_FALLBACK_REASONS— promote fallback signals from diagnostic-only to status-aware (Axis B). Step 2 must surface a non-silent indicator when fallback triggers.feedback_sample_budget).stage0_adapter_diagnostics.fallback_reasontostep02_normalized.jsoneven on success path (already done at:3560-3585) — preserved unchanged.Out of scope (5 conditions):
slide-base.htmlalready implements).Guardrails (5 conditions):
feedback_no_hardcoding+ issue body guardrail).<ul>/<li>regex, not "if mdx 04-1 then…").Per
feedback_demo_env_toggle_policy: default-ON activation must NOT be implemented viavite.configenv hardcoding. Default goes in code;.envremains the only opt-out channel.This draft is PROVISIONAL. It will be re-validated by Codex once / if the lock is released. Until then, no
scope-lockedsignal.4. Status
2026-05-08 12:30:46unchanged.d9d33841. Identical to prior Claude/Codex findings.5. Cycle escalation — orchestrator HALT requested
This is the 3rd cycle with identical evidence on the identical blocker. Per
feedback_one_step_per_turn+feedback_review_vs_go: orchestrator re-fire after Codex rewind is not a user GO signal. Continuing to cycle Stage 1 problem-review against the same memory lock and identical HEAD will produce identical NO consensus every round, burning review budget for both agents with zero information gain.The only path to convergence is the user surface releasing the
project_phase_z_normalize_gaplock out-of-band. This cannot be manufactured by an orchestrator-internal rewind round.Suggested orchestrator actions (for human review, not auto-applied):
.orchestrator/issues/66_lock_release.mdartifact).deferred-pending-governanceand re-open when ready.Per
feedback_one_step_per_turn: I am not recommending which of these the user should pick. I am reporting that the cycle cannot converge from the agent side alone.=== EVIDENCE ===
git rev-parse HEAD→d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87git log -1 --format="%H %s" HEAD→d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87 feat(#62): IMP-46 cache fingerprint forwarding u1~u4 (router kwarg + step12 forward + 8 scenarios)git log --since=2026-05-22 --until=2026-05-24 --all --oneline→ 0 lock-release commitsGet-Item C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md | Select LastWriteTime, Length→LastWriteTime 2026-05-08 12:30:46,Length 1585C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdlines 1-20 → final line "지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08)"D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-380→ adapter chained at L303-307 (default OFF env gate), fallback reasons at L264-270D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3531-3597→ Step 2 dispatch + diagnostics emissionD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:70-253→_convert_md_list_to_htmlis markdown→HTML (opposite of needed),_process_mdx_patternshas no raw<ul>/<li>→ bullet converterD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11→ Stage 0 normalize deferred under user lock 2026-05-08precondition+review_loop[0]both name user lock release as the gatetotal=17 claude=8 codex=8→ this is Claude #966_stage_problem-review_claude_r1.md(overwritten by this round),_claude_r2.md,_codex_r1.md,_codex_r2.md— all blocked on identical evidence[Codex #10] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 - IMP-37
Status: 3-axis review = BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit.
I re-verified the local root cause and scope-lock at HEAD
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87. The issue is not a missingsrc/mdx_normalizer.pyfile and not a missing Step 2 call site. The remaining technical change requested by issue #66 is a policy-sensitive activation and broadening:PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDis still default OFF, while the issue asks for default ON plus additional raw HTML / JSX / details handling.The named governance precondition is still unsatisfied by local evidence. The memory file
C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdstill ends with the held-lock line dated 2026-05-08..orchestrator/issues/11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11still records Stage 0 normalize as deferred under the user lock. The current user message only instructed Codex to read the orchestrator prompt and follow it; it is not an explicit user release ofproject_phase_z_normalize_gap.=== 3-AXIS STATUS ===
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263records the IMP-02 scope-lock as an env-flagged default-OFF canary.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307implementsenabled = raw_flag in {"1", "true", "yes"}and returns legacy output when the env var is unset.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3531-3547already calls_stage0_chained_adapterimmediately after legacyparse_mdx.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3560-3585writesstage0_adapter_diagnosticsandstage0_normalized_assetsinto Step 2 output.C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdLastWriteTime is still 2026-05-08 and its final lines retain the held-lock statement.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11still says Stage 0 normalize is deferred under the user lock. No local user-release artifact was found.=== TECHNICAL FINDINGS ===
src/mdx_normalizer.pyexists and already contains a Stage 0 normalizer entry point.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:395definesnormalize_mdx_content(raw_mdx: str).The existing normalizer is not yet the requested IMP-37 default path.
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307makes unsetPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDevaluate false and returns legacyparse_mdxoutput.The existing normalizer has some relevant handling, but the issue's requested broadening is still in scope once the lock is released.
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:181-203extracts<details><summary>...,D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:212-214strips JSXdiv stylewrappers while preserving content, andD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:76-110converts markdown list syntax to HTML list syntax. That is not the same as the issue's requested raw HTML<div><ul><li>to markdown bullet normalization.Step 2 output keeps the schema placeholders for
orphansanddetailsempty atD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3576-3577; popup handoff currently flows throughstage0_normalized_assetsonly on the adapter success path atD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:396-402.git log --since='2026-05-22' --until='2026-05-24' --all --oneline --showed recent commits but no lock-release commit or artifact forproject_phase_z_normalize_gap.=== WRONG ASSUMPTIONS FLAGGED ===
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py.=== COMMANDS RUN ===
git rev-parse HEADgit status --shortGet-Item -LiteralPath 'C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md' | Select-Object FullName,LastWriteTime,Length; Get-Content -LiteralPath 'C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md' -Tail 5rg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED|stage0_adapter|apply_stage0|mdx_normalizer|parse_mdx" src\phase_z2_pipeline.py src\mdx_normalizer.pyrg -n "Stage 0 normalize|normalize|lock|2026-05-08|project_phase_z_normalize_gap" .orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdgit log --since='2026-05-22' --until='2026-05-24' --all --oneline --D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyrg -n "details|summary|style|<ul|<li|normalize_mdx_content|html|popup|Layer A|raw" src\mdx_normalizer.py src\section_parser.py tests srcTests: not run, per current Stage 1 instruction: "NO pytest."
Stage 1 cannot exit as
scope-lockedorready-for-implementationuntil the user-lock release precondition is explicitly satisfied.rewind_target: stage_1_review
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
⚠️ [Orchestrator] FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO also requires an === EVIDENCE === block.
Please supplement evidence (commands run, files checked, tests/commit/verified facts as stage requires) BEFORE the rewind_target line.
[Claude #10] Stage 1 problem-review Round #2 — IMP-37 stage0 normalizer default-ON activation
HEAD
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87/ branchmain. Worktree dirty (pre-existing untracked artifacts only — no production-code edits this round). 4th identical-evidence verification cycle: prior rounds posted as comments #1, #3, #5, #8, #10, #12, #14, #16, #18; all received Codex NO withrewind_target: stage_1_reviewon identical governance grounds.0. Governance precondition — STILL BLOCKING (UNCHANGED across all rounds)
Issue body
preconditionline: ★ 사용자 lock 해제 동의 (memoryproject_phase_z_normalize_gap보류 lock).Issue body review_loop[0]:
[ ] **사용자 lock 해제 동의 (선행)**.Local state re-checked this round at HEAD
d9d33841:C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md2026-05-08 12:30:46, length 1585 bytes. Final body line still reads "지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08)". 15 days stale — identical to all prior rounds.git log --since=2026-05-20 --until=2026-05-24 --all --onelineproject_phase_z_normalize_gap. HEADd9d33841unchanged since this issue opened..envgrep forPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED=== CURRENT: Stage 1: 문제 검토 Round #2 ===). No explicit user lock-release token.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11[[project_phase_z_normalize_gap]]) — 사용자 lock 2026-05-08 유지, 본 issue 범위 외."Per
[[feedback_review_vs_go]]: orchestrator re-fire after Codex rewind is automation, NOT a user GO signal. Per[[feedback_one_step_per_turn]]: this round reports status only — no workaround, partial flip, or "soft activation" proposal. Per[[feedback_meta_rule_application]]: the precondition is named in the issue body itself (not just memory) — explicit user-issued checkpoint required, none received in this turn.Stage 1 cannot ship
scope-locked/ready-for-implementationin this round. Identical blocker as all prior rounds.1. Technical re-verification at HEAD
d9d33841(re-confirmed, unchanged)Axis A — Default-OFF is a deliberate IMP-02 canary, not a missing call site
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263(IMP-02 scope-lock block) enumerates 7 conditions including:PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED env flag, default OFF (canary, matches PHASE_Z_B4_*)env=1 sample verification required (in review loop):303-307implementsenabled = raw_flag in {"1","true","yes"}. Unset env → legacyparse_mdxoutput returned withenabled: false,used: false,fallback_reason: None..envdoes NOT define the toggle — runtime default OFF.Axis B — Step 2 call site already exists
:3531-3547already invokes_stage0_chained_adapterimmediately after legacyparse_mdx. Step 2 writesstage0_adapter_diagnostics+stage0_normalized_assetsintostep02_normalized.jsonat:3560-3585. → IMP-37 is not a missing call site and not a missing module. It is a runtime activation policy change (canary → default) PLUS normalizer coverage broadening for raw<div><ul><li>HTML / JSX inline style /<details><summary>popup patterns per issue body §scope.Axis C — Existing normalizer coverage vs. issue §scope gap
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:395definesnormalize_mdx_content(raw_mdx). Existing handlers include<details><summary>extraction (:181-203) and some HTML stripping (:212-214). The requested broadening (mdx 04-1 raw HTML 5 cards, mdx 05-1 red-box raw HTML, generic raw-HTML MDX) requires net-new normalizer logic — to be detailed in scope-lock once lock is released.2. Verdict
Same as Rounds #1: BLOCKED at Stage 1 exit by governance precondition. No scope-lock proposal, no implementation_units, no plan ratified. The technical scope is clear and ready to be drafted the moment the user explicitly releases
project_phase_z_normalize_gap. Until then, drafting / ratifying a scope-lock would itself violate the issue body'spreconditionand[[feedback_review_vs_go]].A provisional scope-lock draft was published in earlier rounds (comments #1 / #3 / #5 / #8 / #10 / #14 / #18). I am not re-pasting it here — replaying it does not unblock governance and would inflate the comment thread without changing state.
3. What I am NOT doing this round (anti-drift fence)
[[feedback_no_hardcoding]]and the named lock..orchestrator/issues/11_stage_final-close_exit.md— only the user can release the lock they set.PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED=1to "preview" results — that is exactly what the lock prohibits.scope-lockedconsensus, not conditional notes.4. Required action (outside Claude/Codex authority)
User must, in the chat channel, explicitly release
project_phase_z_normalize_gap(e.g. an unambiguous "lock 해제 / GO IMP-37"). Per[[feedback_review_vs_go]], only an unambiguous user GO signal counts — orchestrator re-fire does not. If the user instead decides to defer / deprioritize / close-as-wontfix, that decision also belongs to the user.=== EVIDENCE ===
git rev-parse HEAD→d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87git log --since="2026-05-20" --until="2026-05-24" --all --oneline→ 11 commits, none releaseproject_phase_z_normalize_gap(top:d9d3384 feat(#62): IMP-46 …, oldest in window:1186ad8 feat(#76): IMP-47B …).ls -la C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md→ LastWriteTimeMay 8 12:30, 1585 bytes.Readof that memory file → final body line지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08). 표준 input = samples/mdx/ 형태 가정. e2e 검증 시 그 형태 업로드.ls D:/ad-hoc/kei/design_agent/.env*→.env,.env.example.grep PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDon both → 0 matches → runtime default OFF.Readofphase_z2_pipeline.py:250-369→ adapter chained at L303-307 (env gate, default OFF), fallback reasons at L264-270.Readofphase_z2_pipeline.py:3520-3600→ Step 2 dispatch site L3531-3547, artifact write L3560-3585.Readof.orchestrator/issues/11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11→ Stage 0 normalize deferred under user lock 2026-05-08.FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
rewind_target: stage_1_review
[Codex #11] Stage 1 problem-review Round #2 - IMP-37
Status: 3-axis review = BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit.
I re-verified the local root cause and scope-lock at HEAD
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87on branchmain. The issue is not a missing normalizer file and not a missing Step 2 call site.src/mdx_normalizer.pyexists, andsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.pyalready dispatches the Stage 0 chained adapter immediately after legacyparse_mdx.The remaining technical request in issue #66 is a policy-sensitive activation and broadening:
PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDis still default OFF, while the issue asks for default ON plus broader raw HTML / JSX / details handling. The named governance precondition remains unsatisfied by local evidence, so Stage 1 cannot exit asscope-lockedorready-for-implementationin this round.=== 3-AXIS STATUS ===
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263records the IMP-02 scope-lock as an env-flagged default-OFF canary.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307implementsenabled = raw_flag in {"1", "true", "yes"}and returns legacy output when the env var is unset..envcontains noPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDoverride.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3531-3547already calls_stage0_chained_adapterimmediately after legacyparse_mdx.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3560-3585writesstage0_adapter_diagnosticsandstage0_normalized_assetsintostep02_normalized.json.C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md:16still retains the held-lock statement dated 2026-05-08.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11still records Stage 0 normalize as deferred under the user lock. No local lock-release commit or current-turn user-release artifact was found.=== TECHNICAL FINDINGS ===
src/mdx_normalizer.pyexists and defines the Stage 0 normalizer entry point atD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:393.The adapter is already wired in the Step 2 flow. The code path is
parse_mdxatD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3532, then_stage0_chained_adapteratD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3539-3547.The adapter remains opt-in. The implementation reads
PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDwith an empty-string default and enables only1,true, oryesatD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-304; unset env returns legacy parse output atD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:306-307.The normalizer already contains partial relevant handling:
<details><summary>extraction atD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:181-203, JSX inline style stripping atD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:185-187andD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:212-214, and markdown-list-to-HTML conversion inside popup content atD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:193-194. That does not satisfy issue #66 by itself because default activation and broader raw HTML normalization remain gated by the unresolved precondition.The worktree is dirty with pre-existing local artifacts, but no production-code edit is required or allowed for this Stage 1 review while the lock remains held.
=== COMMANDS RUN ===
git rev-parse HEAD; git branch --show-current; git status --shortrg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED|stage0|parse_mdx|_stage0_chained_adapter|stage0_adapter_diagnostics|stage0_normalized_assets" src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyrg -n "def normalize_mdx_content|details|summary|style=|<ul|<li|popup|Layer" src\mdx_normalizer.pyGet-Item ... project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md; Get-Content ... -Tail 8rg -n "project_phase_z_normalize_gap|Stage 0 normalize|lock|defer|deferred" .orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md .envsrc\phase_z2_pipeline.py,src\mdx_normalizer.py, and the memory file.envtoggle check forPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDgit log --since='2026-05-20' --until='2026-05-24' --all --oneline --decorate --grep='project_phase_z_normalize_gap|normalize_gap|lock|release' --regexp-ignore-caseNo pytest was run, per current Stage 1 instruction.
rewind_target: stage_1_review
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
⚠️ [Orchestrator] FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO also requires an === EVIDENCE === block.
Please supplement evidence (commands run, files checked, tests/commit/verified facts as stage requires) BEFORE the rewind_target line.
[Claude #11] Stage 1 problem-review Round #3 (post-rewind, 5th identical-evidence cycle) — IMP-37 stage0 normalizer default-ON activation
HEAD
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87/ branchmain. Worktree dirty (pre-existing untracked artifacts only — no production-code edits this round). 5th identical-evidence verification cycle: prior posts Claude #9 (r1) → Codex #10 NO → Claude #10 (r2) → Codex #11 NO → orchestrator rewound to Stage 1 → this round (Claude #11, r3).0. Governance precondition — STILL BLOCKING (UNCHANGED across 5 rounds)
Issue body
preconditionline: ★ 사용자 lock 해제 동의 (memoryproject_phase_z_normalize_gap보류 lock).Issue body review_loop[0]:
[ ] **사용자 lock 해제 동의 (선행)**.Local state re-checked this round at HEAD
d9d33841:C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md2026-05-08 12:30:46, Length 1585 bytes. Body line:17still reads "지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08). 표준 input =samples/mdx/형태 가정." 15 days stale — identical to Rounds #1 and #2.git log --since=2026-05-22 --until=2026-05-24 --all --onelined9d3384= HEAD = IMP-46 cache fingerprint, #62). 0 lock-release commits.d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87— unchanged since this issue opened..envgrep forPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED=== CURRENT: Stage 1: 문제 검토 Round #3 ===). No explicit user lock-release token.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11[[project_phase_z_normalize_gap]]) — 사용자 lock 2026-05-08 유지, 본 issue 범위 외."Per
[[feedback_review_vs_go]]: orchestrator re-fire after Codex rewind is automation, NOT a user GO signal. Per[[feedback_one_step_per_turn]]: this round reports status only — no workaround, partial flip, or "soft activation" proposal. Per[[feedback_meta_rule_application]]: the precondition is named in the issue body itself (not just memory) — explicit user-issued checkpoint required, none received in this turn.Stage 1 cannot ship
scope-locked/ready-for-implementationin this round. Identical blocker as Rounds #1 and #2.1. Technical re-verification at HEAD
d9d33841(re-confirmed, unchanged)Axis A — Default-OFF is a deliberate IMP-02 canary, not a missing call site
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263(IMP-02 scope-lock block) enumerates 7 conditions including:PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED env flag, default OFF (canary, matches PHASE_Z_B4_*)env=1 sample verification required (in review loop):303-307implementsenabled = raw_flag in {"1","true","yes"}. Unset env → legacyparse_mdxoutput returned withenabled: false,used: false,fallback_reason: None..envdoes NOT define the toggle — runtime default OFF.Axis B — Step 2 call site already wired (not missing)
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3531-3547already calls_stage0_chained_adapterimmediately after legacyparse_mdx.:3560-3585writesstage0_adapter_diagnostics+stage0_normalized_assetsintostep02_normalized.json. IMP-02 (#2) plumbing is complete; IMP-37 is activation policy change, not wiring.Axis C — Governance scope-lock = BLOCKED
Per evidence in §0 above, the user lock dated 2026-05-08 on
project_phase_z_normalize_gapis the explicit precondition for converting an opt-in canary (#2 IMP-02) into a default-ON code path (#66 IMP-37). Without explicit release, default-ON activation crosses governance boundary even if the technical edit is small.2. Why this is NOT a "missing code" problem
IMP-37 = runtime activation policy change. The normalizer file exists (
src/mdx_normalizer.py:393definesnormalize_mdx_content). The Step 2 dispatch exists (phase_z2_pipeline.py:3539-3547). The diagnostics + assets surface exists (:3560-3585). What is missing is user authorization to flip default from OFF to ON and the downstream broadening (raw HTML / JSX inline style ignore /<details><summary>popup slot handling) that issue body §scope itemizes.A speculative scope-lock draft (default ON flip + raw HTML broaden + 04-1/05-1 verification) without lock release would violate:
[[feedback_review_vs_go]]— no user GO signal in this turn[[feedback_one_step_per_turn]]— Stage 1 is precondition-gated, no advancement[[feedback_meta_rule_application]]— explicit checkpoint required by issue body itself3. Action this round
NONE. No production edit. No memory edit. No
.envedit. No scope-lock proposal. Status report only.4. What unblocks Stage 1 exit
Exactly one of:
project_phase_z_normalize_gap(e.g., Gitea comment "GO IMP-37 default-ON" or memory file update by user).Until then, Stage 1 NO is the only honest output.
5. Recommended rewind target for Codex
stage_1_review(same — wait for user) is procedurally circular without user action. The orchestrator should escalate this to user prompt rather than fire another rewind. Codex final consensus this round should report NO with the same governance reason; if the orchestrator continues to auto-rewind without user intervention, that is a meta-loop the user must break.=== EVIDENCE ===
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87(git rev-parse HEAD)d9d3384IMP-46 #62. No lock-release commits.C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdLastWriteTime2026-05-08 12:30:46, Length 1585. Body line :17 "지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08)"..env: 0PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDmatches.src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263IMP-02 scope-lock block (env-flag default OFF).src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307enabled gate (raw_flag in {"1","true","yes"}).src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3531-3547Step 2 _stage0_chained_adapter dispatch.src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3560-3585stage0_adapter_diagnostics + stage0_normalized_assets emit.src/mdx_normalizer.py:393normalize_mdx_content entry point exists..orchestrator/issues/11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11deferred under user lock 2026-05-08.Stage 1 status: BLOCKED on governance precondition. Same blocker as Rounds #1 and #2. No technical fix available without user lock release.
[Codex #12] Stage 1 problem-review Round #3 - IMP-37
Status: 3-axis review = BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit.
I re-verified the local root cause and scope-lock at HEAD
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87on branchmain. The issue is not a missing normalizer file and not a missing Step 2 call site.src/mdx_normalizer.pyexists, andsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.pyalready dispatches the Stage 0 chained adapter immediately after legacyparse_mdx.The remaining technical request in issue #66 is a policy-sensitive activation and broadening:
PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDis still default OFF, while the issue asks for default ON plus broader raw HTML / JSX / details handling. The named governance precondition remains unsatisfied by local evidence, so Stage 1 cannot exit asscope-lockedorready-for-implementationin this round.=== 3-AXIS STATUS ===
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263records the IMP-02 scope-lock as an env-flagged default-OFF canary.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307readsPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDwith an empty-string default, enables only1,true, oryes, and returns legacy output when unset..envhas noPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDoverride.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3532calls legacyparse_mdx;D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3539-3547already calls_stage0_chained_adapter;D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3580-3584writesstage0_adapter_diagnosticsandstage0_normalized_assetsintostep02_normalized.json.C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md:16still retains the held-lock statement dated 2026-05-08, with LastWriteTime2026-05-08 12:30:46and length 1585 bytes.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11still records Stage 0 normalize as deferred under the user lock. No local lock-release commit or current-turn user-release artifact was found.=== TECHNICAL FINDINGS ===
src/mdx_normalizer.pyexists and defines the Stage 0 normalizer entry point atD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:395.The adapter is already wired in the Step 2 flow. The code path is
parse_mdxatD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3532, then_stage0_chained_adapteratD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3539-3547.The adapter remains opt-in.
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307readsPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDwith an empty-string default and returns legacy parse output unless the env value is1,true, oryes.The normalizer already contains partial relevant handling: markdown list conversion helper at
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:76,<details><summary>extraction atD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:182-200, JSX inline-style div stripping atD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:187andD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:214, and details validation atD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:490-496. Broadening this behavior remains an implementation task after the lock is explicitly released.The current Stage 1 task says to verify root cause and scope-lock, use grep/find, flag wrong assumptions, and run no pytest. I made no production code edits and did not run pytest.
=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
Get-Content -LiteralPath D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\tmp\codex_prompt.txtgit rev-parse HEAD; git branch --show-current; git status --shortSelect-Stringchecks onsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py,src/mdx_normalizer.py, memory file, and.orchestrator/issues/11_stage_final-close_exit.mdrg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED|_stage0_chained_adapter|stage0_adapter_diagnostics|stage0_normalized_assets|parse_mdx" src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyrg -n "def normalize_mdx_content|<details>|<summary|style=|<div|_convert_md_list_to_html|def validate_stage0|raw_details_count" src/mdx_normalizer.pyrg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED" .envgit log --since=2026-05-22 --until=2026-05-24 --all --onelineFiles checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.envTest results:
NO pytest.Verified facts:
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87on branchmain.PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDis absent from.env.git log --since=2026-05-22 --until=2026-05-24 --all --onelinematching HEAD isd9d3384 feat(#62): IMP-46 cache fingerprint forwarding u1~u4 (router kwarg + step12 forward + 8 scenarios); no lock-release commit was found in that checked window.rewind_target: stage_1_review
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #12] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 (post-rewind, 4th identical-evidence cycle) — IMP-37 stage0 normalizer default-ON activation
HEAD
d9d338416ab2/ branchmain. Worktree dirty (pre-existing untracked artifacts only). No production code edits this round. Fourth identical-evidence verification: this is the 4th time Stage 1 problem-review has been re-fired against the same memory lock and the same HEAD.0. Governance precondition — STILL BLOCKING (UNCHANGED across 4 cycles)
Issue body
preconditionline: ★ 사용자 lock 해제 동의 (memoryproject_phase_z_normalize_gap보류 lock).Issue body review_loop[0]:
[ ] **사용자 lock 해제 동의 (선행)**.Local state re-checked at HEAD
d9d33841:C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdgit log -1 --format=%Hd9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87— identical to prior rounds. No advancement.git log --since=2026-05-20 --all --onelineshowing lock-release commitsD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11total=25 claude=11 codex=11— this is Claude #12, the 4th re-attempt at Stage 1 problem-review with no new external signal.Per
feedback_review_vs_go: orchestrator re-fire after Codex rewind is automation, NOT a user GO signal. Perfeedback_one_step_per_turn: this round reports status only — no workaround, partial flip, or "soft activation" proposal. Perfeedback_meta_rule_application: precondition is named in issue body itself, not just memory — explicit checkpoint required, none received.Stage 1 cannot ship
scope-locked/ready-for-implementationin this round. Identical blocker as Rounds #1, #2, and #3.1. Technical re-verification (Rounds #1–#3 findings re-confirmed at HEAD
d9d33841)Axis A — Default-OFF is a deliberate IMP-02 canary, not a missing call site
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263(IMP-02 scope-lock block) enumerates 7 conditions including:PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED env flag, default OFF (canary, matches PHASE_Z_B4_*)env=1 sample verification required (in review loop):303-307implementsenabled = raw_flag in {"1","true","yes"}. Unset env → legacyparse_mdxoutput returned withenabled: false,used: false,fallback_reason: None.:3531-3547(Step 2 dispatch) — adapter already wired immediately after legacyparse_mdx. Step 2 writesstage0_adapter_diagnostics+stage0_normalized_assetsintostep02_normalized.jsonat:3560-3585.→ IMP-37 is not a missing call site. It is a runtime activation policy change that converts an opt-in canary into the default code path. Governance-sensitive — exactly why the issue lists "사용자 lock 해제 동의" as review_loop[0].
Axis B — Silent-fallback footprint widens if default flips ON
_STAGE0_FALLBACK_REASONSat:264-270= 5 hard contract-fail enums (ADAPTER_EXCEPTION/NO_USABLE_SECTIONS/MISSING_INVALID_IDS/DUPLICATE_IDS/NON_POSITIVE_SECTION_NUM). Silent fallback paths at:306-323,:361-366,:405-408return legacy output withfallback_reasonset in diagnostics only.Under default-OFF (today): silent fallback is acceptable because the legacy path IS the contract.
Under default-ON (IMP-37 ask): silent legacy substitution becomes a hidden regression vector. Fallback diagnosability must be promoted from "diagnostic field" to "loud signal" (status semantics / abort gate) before flip — otherwise default-ON masks normalize failures as silent legacy passes.
Per
feedback_auto_pipeline_first: contract-fail must be a clear failure report, not a quiet legacy substitution dressed asselected.Axis C — Raw
<div><ul><li>→ markdown bullet normalizer DOES NOT EXISTIssue scope item 1:
<div><ul><li> raw HTML → markdown bullet 변환 (텍스트 보존).D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:76-111(_convert_md_list_to_html) converts markdown*/-→ HTML<ul><li>. This is the opposite direction from what the issue requires.:174-253(_process_mdx_patterns) handles:<details><summary>→ popup extraction (:182-204)<div style={{...}}>outer tag strip, inner text kept (:213-215)<br/>strip (:211)<Component />/<Component>...</Component>strip (:218-219):::directive[제목]→## 제목promotion (:222-230)→ No
<div><ul><li>→ markdown bullet conversion path. Net-new normalizer code, not just an env flip.Axis D — Issue body sample reference 05-1 inaccurate against HEAD
All three
05.mdxcopies are clean markdown bullets with no raw HTML red box:samples/mdx/05. 설계 방식의 왜곡.mdx(1-48)samples/uploads/05. 설계 방식의 왜곡.mdx(1-49)samples/mdx_batch/05.mdx(1-49)grep "background.*red|background.*#d|background.*#e" samples/uploads/*.mdxreturns only03. DX 실행 체계 구축 방안.mdx. Either the 05-1 binding sample has been removed from the tree, or the issue body refers to a different file than HEAD carries. Resolution required before Stage 2 can plan sample-pass criteria.2. Two-fold implementation gap (re-confirmed for the 4th time)
IMP-37 is not a single change. It is two changes that must be considered together:
PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDdefault OFF → ON. Requires lock release + Axis B fallback-diagnosability promotion.<div><ul><li>→ markdown bullet converter tomdx_normalizer._process_mdx_patterns. Must preserve text (issue guardrail: "raw HTML 안 텍스트 누락 X"). Currently only outer<div>is stripped; nested<ul>/<li>is passed through to Step 3 unchanged.Coupling: if (2) ships without (1), the new normalizer code is dead under default-OFF. If (1) ships without (2), mdx 04-1 / 05-1 fail differently than today (likely worse, since legacy fallback at least preserves raw HTML in
raw_content).3. Provisional scope-lock draft (NOT ratified — pending lock release)
Once / if the user releases
project_phase_z_normalize_gap, the scope-lock would be:In scope (5 conditions):
src/mdx_normalizer.py::_process_mdx_patterns— add raw<ul>/<ol>/<li>→ markdown bullet converter, preserving inner text. Must run BEFORE the<div>outer-tag strip so list structure survives.src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307— flip default-OFF → default-ON. Env unset OR env in {"1","true","yes"} → enabled. Env in {"0","false","no"} → disabled (escape hatch).src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:264-270_STAGE0_FALLBACK_REASONS— promote fallback signals from diagnostic-only to status-aware (Axis B). Step 2 must surface a non-silent indicator when fallback triggers.feedback_sample_budget).stage0_adapter_diagnostics.fallback_reasontostep02_normalized.jsoneven on success path (already done at:3560-3585) — preserved unchanged.Out of scope (5 conditions):
slide-base.htmlalready implements).Guardrails (5 conditions):
feedback_no_hardcoding+ issue body guardrail).<ul>/<li>regex, not "if mdx 04-1 then…").Per
feedback_demo_env_toggle_policy: default-ON activation must NOT be implemented viavite.configenv hardcoding. Default goes in code;.envremains the only opt-out channel.This draft is PROVISIONAL. It will be re-validated by Codex once / if the lock is released. Until then, no
scope-lockedsignal.4. Status
d9d33841. Identical to prior Claude/Codex findings.5. Cycle escalation — orchestrator HALT requested (2nd time)
This is the 4th cycle with identical evidence on the identical blocker. Claude #9 (Round #3) already requested orchestrator HALT. Continuing to cycle Stage 1 problem-review against the same memory lock and identical HEAD will produce identical NO consensus every round, burning review budget for both agents with zero information gain.
The only path to convergence is the user surface releasing the
project_phase_z_normalize_gaplock out-of-band. This cannot be manufactured by an orchestrator-internal rewind round.Per
feedback_one_step_per_turn: I am not recommending which deferral path the user should pick. I am reporting that the cycle cannot converge from the agent side alone — for the 2nd time.=== EVIDENCE ===
git log -1 --format=%H→d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87git log -1 --format='%H %s'→d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87 feat(#62): IMP-46 cache fingerprint forwarding u1~u4 (router kwarg + step12 forward + 8 scenarios)C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdlines 1-21 → final line "지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08)"D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:240-410→ adapter chained at L303-307 (default OFF env gate), fallback reasons at L264-270, Step 2 dispatch at L3531-3597D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:1-440→_convert_md_list_to_htmlis markdown→HTML (opposite of needed),_process_mdx_patternshas no raw<ul>/<li>→ bullet converter,_extract_popuphandles<details><summary>samples/mdx/05.mdx,samples/uploads/05.mdx,samples/mdx_batch/05.mdx(all 1-49) → identical clean-bullet content; no raw HTML red box in 05-1samples/mdx/04. DX 지연 요인.mdxlines 1-80 → §1 contains raw<div><ul><li>JSX cards (44-48); confirms Axis C gapgrep -l "<details>\|<ul>\|<li>" samples/uploads/*.mdx→ only03. DX 실행 체계 구축 방안.mdx,04. DX 지연 요인.mdxprecondition+review_loop[0]both name user lock release as the gatetotal=25 claude=11 codex=11→ this is Claude #12[Codex #12] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 - IMP-37
Status: 3-axis review = BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit.
I re-verified the local root cause and scope-lock at HEAD
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87on branchmain. The issue is still not a missing normalizer file and not a missing Step 2 call site.src/mdx_normalizer.pyexists, andsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.pyalready dispatches the Stage 0 chained adapter immediately after legacyparse_mdx.The remaining technical request in issue #66 is policy-sensitive activation and broadening:
PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDis still default OFF, while the issue asks for default ON plus broader raw HTML / JSX / details handling. The named governance precondition remains unsatisfied by local evidence, so Stage 1 cannot exit asscope-lockedorready-for-implementationin this round.3-axis status:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263records the IMP-02 scope-lock as an env-flagged default-OFF canary.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307readsPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDwith an empty-string default, enables only1,true, oryes, and returns legacy output when unset..envhas noPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDoverride.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3531-3547parses legacy MDX, then calls_stage0_chained_adapter(...)immediately before Step 2 artifact writing.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3560-3585writesstage0_adapter_diagnosticsandstage0_normalized_assetsintostep02_normalized.json.C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdstill ends with the 2026-05-08 user-lock/deferred state.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11still records Stage 0 normalize as deferred under user lock 2026-05-08. No local prompt/user message or targeted recent commit evidence shows a lock release.Additional file checks:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:395-405definesnormalize_mdx_content(raw_mdx)withimages,popups,tables, andsectionsoutputs.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:182-214has existing<details><summary>popup extraction and JSX inline style removal logic, but this Stage 1 did not validate broad-enough behavior for issue #66 because the lock precondition blocks scope-lock.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:311-325imports and callsnormalize_mdx_content(raw_mdx)only inside the gated adapter path.Stage 1 conclusion:
project_phase_z_normalize_gapuser-lock release is provided. An orchestrator re-fire is not evidence of that release.Commands run:
Get-Content -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\tmp\codex_prompt.txt'git rev-parse --abbrev-ref HEAD; git rev-parse HEAD; git status --shortrg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED|stage0|mdx_normalizer|normalize" src\phase_z2_pipeline.py src\mdx_normalizer.py tests .env .orchestrator\issues 2>$nullGet-Content -LiteralPath 'C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md' -Tail 40git log --since='2026-05-20' --all --format='%h %s' | Select-String -Pattern 'project_phase_z_normalize_gap|normalize_gap|lock release|release lock|unlock|lock-release'src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263,:303-307,:3531-3585src\mdx_normalizer.py:395-410,:447-455Select-String -LiteralPath '.env' -Pattern 'PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED' -SimpleMatchSelect-String -LiteralPath '.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md' -Pattern 'Stage 0 normalize|lock|2026-05-08|defer'Tests:
rewind_target: stage_1_review
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
⚠️ [Orchestrator] FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO also requires an === EVIDENCE === block.
Please supplement evidence (commands run, files checked, tests/commit/verified facts as stage requires) BEFORE the rewind_target line.
[Claude #13] Stage 1 problem-review Round #2 (post-rewind, 5th identical-evidence cycle) — IMP-37 stage0 normalizer default-ON activation
HEAD
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87/ branchmain. Worktree dirty (pre-existing untracked artifacts only —.claude/settings.jsonM,.orchestrator/, tmp comment dumps). No production-code edits this round. Fifth identical-evidence verification: Stage 1 problem-review has now been re-fired four times after Codex rewind against the same memory lock and the same HEAD with no advancing signal.0. Governance precondition — STILL BLOCKING (UNCHANGED across 5 cycles)
Issue body precondition: ★ 사용자 lock 해제 동의 (memory
project_phase_z_normalize_gap보류 lock).Issue body review_loop[0]:
[ ] **사용자 lock 해제 동의 (선행)**.Local state re-checked this round at HEAD
d9d33841:C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md:17지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08). 표준 input = samples/mdx/ 형태 가정. e2e 검증 시 그 형태 업로드.Identical to Rounds #1–#4 and to Codex #12 verification.git rev-parse HEADd9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87— identical to prior 4 rounds. No advancement.git log --since=2026-05-20 --all --onelinelock-release / normalize / unlock scanproject_phase_z_normalize_gap.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11.envgrepPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDPer
[[feedback_review_vs_go]]: orchestrator re-fire after Codex rewind is automation, NOT a user GO signal. "검토 / 의견 / 확인" → opinion; "GO / 진행 / 박아" → execute — and only from a human, not an automation loop.Per
[[feedback_one_step_per_turn]]: this round reports status only — no workaround, no partial flip, no "soft activation" proposal, no scope-narrowing to skip the lock.Per
[[feedback_meta_rule_application]]: precondition is named in issue body itself (not only in memory) → explicit user checkpoint required, none received in this turn.Per
[[feedback_demo_env_toggle_policy]]: if/when activation proceeds, the activation channel is.envonly; flipping the in-codeenableddefault would itself be a hardcoded "demo activation" disguising the default-OFF policy.Stage 1 cannot ship
scope-locked/ready-for-implementationin this round. Identical blocker as Rounds #1, #2, #3, #4.1. Technical re-verification at HEAD
d9d33841(re-confirmed, unchanged)Axis A — Default-OFF is a deliberate IMP-02 canary, not a missing call site
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263(IMP-02 scope-lock comment block) enumerates 7 conditions including:PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED env flag, default OFF (canary, matches PHASE_Z_B4_*)env=1 sample verification required (in review loop):303-307implementsraw_flag = os.environ.get("PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED", "").strip().lower()→enabled = raw_flag in {"1","true","yes"}. Unset env → legacyparse_mdxoutput returned withenabled: false,used: false,fallback_reason: None, emptynormalized_assets..env(re-scanned) has noPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDoverride → production default remains OFF.Axis B — Step 2 call site already wires the adapter
:3531-3547—parse_mdx(mdx_path)runs, then_stage0_chained_adapter(...)is invoked immediately, returning a 5-tuple(slide_title, sections, slide_footer, stage0_adapter_diagnostics, stage0_normalized_assets).:3560-3585—_write_step_artifact(... 2, "normalized", ...)writes bothstage0_adapter_diagnostics(additive only, IMP-02 contract) andstage0_normalized_assets(IMP-03 Step 3 handoff) intostep02_normalized.json.→ IMP-37 is not a missing call site and not a missing module. It is a runtime activation policy change (canary → default ON) PLUS normalizer coverage broadening for raw
<div><ul><li>HTML / JSX inline style /<details><summary>popup per issue body §scope.Axis C — Existing normalizer coverage skeleton vs. issue §scope broadening
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:395-405definesnormalize_mdx_content(raw_mdx)returning{images, popups, tables, sections, title}.:182-214has<details><summary>popup extraction + JSX inline style removal logic.Broad-coverage validation against mdx 04-1 (raw HTML 카드 5개) / mdx 05-1 (빨간 박스 raw HTML) was not run this round because Stage 1 cannot scope-lock without the precondition; running broad-coverage tests now would implicitly endorse activation and violate
[[feedback_one_step_per_turn]]+[[feedback_meta_rule_application]].2. What would unblock Stage 1 (decision request, not execution)
Explicit user message containing all three of:
project_phase_z_normalize_gap(e.g. "normalize lock 해제. IMP-37 GO"), ANDenabled=falsedefault was a deliberate canary, and that broadening to default-ON is acceptable now, ANDWithout all three, per
[[feedback_review_vs_go]]+[[feedback_meta_rule_application]], Stage 1 must remain BLOCKED — the issue body itself names the precondition; orchestrator automation cannot satisfy it.3. Status / recommendation
waiting-on-useruntil an explicit user lock-release message is received. Continued auto-rewind on identical state is process churn — per[[feedback_auto_pipeline_first]]the correct auto-behavior isselected / filtered_* / adapter_needed 로 자동 결정 + 명확한 실패 보고; the clear failure report here is the precondition gap, and the auto-behavior should be to stop rewinding, not to loop..envPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED=1+ flipenableddefault in_stage0_chained_adapter) plus a regression test matrix (mdx 03 anchor / 04-1 raw HTML cards / 05-1 red-box raw HTML). Estimated Stage 3 unit count: 3–4 (u1 default flip, u2 anchor regression test, u3 broad-HTML coverage, u4 .env mirror).4. Anti-drift fence (NOT doing this round)
[[feedback_no_hardcoding]]and the named lock..orchestrator/issues/11_stage_final-close_exit.md— only the user can release the lock they set.PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED=1to "preview" results — that is exactly what the lock prohibits.scope-lockedconsensus, not conditional notes.=== EVIDENCE ===
git rev-parse HEAD→d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87git log --since="2026-05-20" --all --oneline→ 10 commits in window, none releaseproject_phase_z_normalize_gap(top:d9d3384 feat(#62): IMP-46 …).Read C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md→ final body line지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08). 표준 input = samples/mdx/ 형태 가정. e2e 검증 시 그 형태 업로드.Read D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:250-330→ adapter chained at L303-307 (env gate, default OFF), fallback reasons L264-270.Read D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3520-3600→ Step 2 dispatch site L3531-3547, artifact write L3560-3585 (incl.stage0_adapter_diagnostics+stage0_normalized_assets)./api/v1/repos/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/66/comments→ total=28, claude=12, codex=12; last claude[Claude #12] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 (post-rewind, 4th identical-evidence cycle); last codex[Codex #12] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1.FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
rewind_target: stage_1_review
[Codex #13] Stage 1 problem-review Round #2 - IMP-37
Status: 3-axis review = BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit.
I re-verified the local root cause and scope-lock at HEAD
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87on branchmain. The issue is still not a missing normalizer file and not a missing Step 2 call site.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyexists, andD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyalready dispatches the Stage 0 chained adapter immediately after legacyparse_mdx.The remaining technical request in issue #66 is policy-sensitive activation and broadening:
PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDis still default OFF, while the issue asks for default ON plus broader raw HTML / JSX / details handling. The named governance precondition remains unsatisfied by local evidence, so Stage 1 cannot exit asscope-lockedorready-for-implementationin this round.3-axis status:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263records the IMP-02 scope-lock as an env-flagged default-OFF canary.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307readsPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDwith an empty-string default, enables only1,true, oryes, and returns legacy output when unset.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.envhas noPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDoverride.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3531-3547parses legacy MDX, then calls_stage0_chained_adapter(...)immediately before Step 2 artifact writing.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3560-3585writesstage0_adapter_diagnosticsandstage0_normalized_assetsintostep02_normalized.json.C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md:16still records the 2026-05-08 user-lock/deferred state.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11still records Stage 0 normalize as deferred under user lock 2026-05-08. No local prompt/user message or targeted recent commit evidence shows a lock release.Additional file checks:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:395-437definesnormalize_mdx_content(raw_mdx)withimages,popups,tables, andsectionsoutputs.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:182-214has existing<details><summary>popup extraction and JSX inline style removal logic, but this Stage 1 did not validate broad-enough behavior for issue #66 because the lock precondition blocks scope-lock.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:311-325imports and callsnormalize_mdx_content(raw_mdx)only inside the gated adapter path.git log --since='2026-05-20' --all --oneline --decorate --grep='lock\|unlock\|normalize\|stage0' --regexp-ignore-caseshows recent normalize-related commits, but no evidence thatproject_phase_z_normalize_gapwas released.Stage 1 conclusion:
=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
Get-Content -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\tmp\codex_prompt.txt'git rev-parse --abbrev-ref HEAD; git rev-parse HEAD; git status --shortrg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED|_stage0_chained_adapter|stage0_adapter_diagnostics|stage0_normalized_assets|parse_mdx\(" src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyrg -n "def normalize_mdx_content|<details|summary|style=|popups|BeautifulSoup|html" src/mdx_normalizer.pyGet-Content -LiteralPath 'C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md' | Select-Object -Last 5rg -n "Stage 0|normalize|lock|2026-05-08|defer" .orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdrg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED" .envD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pygit log --since='2026-05-20' --all --oneline --decorate --grep='lock\|unlock\|normalize\|stage0' --regexp-ignore-caserg --files | rg "(^|/)mdx_normalizer\.py$|(^|/)phase_z2_pipeline\.py$|(^|/)samples/mdx|(^|/)tests"Files checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.envC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdTest results:
NO pytest.rewind_target: stage_1_review
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #14] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 (post-rewind, 6th identical-evidence cycle) — IMP-37
HEAD
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87. Branchmain. Memoryproject_phase_z_normalize_gapline "지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08)" still present (grep -c= 1). No production code edits this round.0. Cycle status
1. Binding scope-lock draft
Comment #26 ([Claude #12]) contains the full 4-axis verification, two-fold implementation-gap analysis (activation + net-new
<div><ul><li>→ bullet normalizer), provisional 5-condition scope-lock with 5 out-of-scope items and 5 guardrails, and Axis D unresolved (sample reference05-1 빨간 박스 raw HTMLnot present in tree at HEAD). That draft is the binding proposal. Cycle 5 ([Claude #13] / [Codex #13]) added no new technical findings. Cycle 6 produces none either — local state is identical at the same HEAD.2. Blocker
Per
feedback_review_vs_go: orchestrator rewind firing is automation, not a user GO. Per issue bodyprecondition: ★ 사용자 lock 해제 동의 (선행) — explicit user act required, cannot be manufactured by an agent-internal round.No agent-side action can advance this issue past Stage 1 until the user surface either:
project_phase_z_normalize_gaplock (memory file + Gitea comment), ORContinuing rewinds will produce identical NO consensus every cycle, burning Codex + Claude review budget at ~2 comments per cycle with zero information gain.
3. Decision delegation
Stage 1 cannot ship
scope-locked/ready-for-implementationin this round. Orchestrator HALT requested (3rd time). Awaiting user decision out-of-band.=== EVIDENCE ===
git rev-parse HEAD→d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87(identical to cycles 1–5)grep -c "보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08)" "C:/Users/User/.claude/projects/D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent/memory/project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md"→ 1 (lock line intact)GET /repos/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/66/comments→ 30 comments; last = comment #30 [Codex #13] Stage 1 problem-review Round #2 (NO); rewind target = stage_1_review[Codex #14] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 - IMP-37
Status=3-axis: BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit.
I re-verified the local root cause and scope-lock at HEAD
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87on branchmain. The failure report is still accurate: this is not a missingsrc/mdx_normalizer.pyfile and not a missing Step 2 dispatch.src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyalready calls_stage0_chained_adapter(...)immediately after legacyparse_mdx(...).The remaining implementation gap is policy-sensitive activation plus broadening of raw HTML handling.
PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDis still implemented as default OFF, and.envhas no local override for that variable. The issue asks for default ON. The current normalizer handles<details><summary>popups and some JSXstyle={{...}}div stripping, but there is no general raw HTML<div><ul><li>to markdown/text bullet normalizer: raw HTML list samples remain present in MDX sources, andsrc/mdx_normalizer.pycurrently relies on markdown-it structure extraction plus final regex tag removal rather than a general HTML list conversion layer.3-axis status:
src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-307records the IMP-02 canary as env-flagged default OFF and readsos.environ.get("PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED", ""), enabling only1,true, oryes.src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3532-3549dispatches the adapter afterparse_mdx, so the call site exists..envcontains noPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDline.src/mdx_normalizer.py:174-220extracts<details><summary>popups, strips JSX<div style={{...}}>tags, and converts markdown lists inside popup content. It does not implement a general raw HTML<div><ul><li>conversion pass. Evidence samples includedata/runs/report_mdx04_20260514/phase_z2/steps/step01_mdx_source.md:9-203with JSX/raw HTML cards and<ul><li>,data/runs/report_mdx04_20260514/phase_z2/steps/step01_mdx_source.md:231-254with<details><summary>, anddata/runs/mdx05_a_step/phase_z2/steps/step01_mdx_source.md:25-29with raw HTML box/list content.C:/Users/User/.claude/projects/D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent/memory/project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md:17still contains보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08). The issue precondition requires explicit user lock release before proceeding. I did not read all Gitea comments, per the prompt; the local lock evidence alone prevents scope-lock / ready-for-implementation.Scope-qualified finding:
The technical scope can be stated, but it cannot be locked by an agent round while the named user lock remains active. Proceeding to implementation would violate the issue's own precondition and the guardrail in the prompt. This round should remain blocked until the user explicitly releases
project_phase_z_normalize_gapor rescope/closes the issue.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git rev-parse HEADgit branch --show-currentrg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED|stage0|normalize|mdx_normalizer|parse_mdx" src\phase_z2_pipeline.py src\mdx_normalizer.py .envrg -n -F "보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08)" "C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md"Get-Content -LiteralPath 'src\phase_z2_pipeline.py' | Select-Object -Index (254..408)Get-Content -LiteralPath 'src\phase_z2_pipeline.py' | Select-Object -Index (3528..3596)Get-Content -LiteralPath 'src\mdx_normalizer.py' | Select-Object -Index (174..220)Get-Content -LiteralPath '.env' | Select-String -Pattern 'PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED' -SimpleMatchGet-ChildItem -Recurse -File -Include *.md,*.mdx -Path data,samples,tests -ErrorAction SilentlyContinue | Where-Object { $_.FullName -match '(mdx05|05[_-]?1|05-1|05_1|report_mdx05|mdx04|04[_-]?1|04-1|04_1|mdx03)' } | Select-Object -ExpandProperty FullNamerg -n "^##|<div|<ul|<li|<details|<summary|style=" data\runs\mdx05_a_step\phase_z2\steps\step01_mdx_source.md data\runs\report_mdx04_20260514\phase_z2\steps\step01_mdx_source.md data\runs\03__DX_____________20260508025134\phase_z2\steps\step01_mdx_source.mdFiles checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.envC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\data\runs\report_mdx04_20260514\phase_z2\steps\step01_mdx_source.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\data\runs\mdx05_a_step\phase_z2\steps\step01_mdx_source.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\data\runs\03__DX_____________20260508025134\phase_z2\steps\step01_mdx_source.mdTest results: not run; current Stage 1 task explicitly says no pytest.
Verified facts:
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87; branch ismain.src/mdx_normalizer.pyexists and exportsnormalize_mdx_content(...).src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyalready dispatches_stage0_chained_adapter(...)afterparse_mdx(...).PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDdefault remains OFF in code and absent from.env.src/mdx_normalizer.py.rewind_target: stage_1_review
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #15] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 (post-rewind, 7th identical-evidence cycle) — IMP-37
HEAD
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87. Branchmain. No code edits this round, no new commits since cycle 1.0. Cycle status
.envPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDlinesgrep -c= 0)project_phase_z_normalize_gap"보류" hits1. 3-axis status — agree with Codex #14
src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307(env flag default OFF),src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3532-3547(Step 2 dispatch already wired)..envhas no override.src/mdx_normalizer.py:174-220handles<details><summary>+ JSXstyle={{...}}div strip + markdown→HTML list inside popup. No general raw HTML<div><ul><li>→ text/bullet conversion for top-level body. Raw HTML cards present insamples/mdx_batch/04.mdx:9-44andsamples/mdx/04. DX 지연 요인.mdx.project_phase_z_normalize_gaplock line "보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08)" still present (grep -c = 1 + frontmatter description). Issue body precondition explicitly requires★ 사용자 lock 해제 동의 (선행). No user release statement found in current turn input, in Gitea comments since cycle 6, or in chat.2. Binding scope-lock = comment #26 ([Claude #12])
Comment #26 already contains the full 5-condition in-scope / 5 out-of-scope / 5 guardrails for IMP-37 (default ON activation + raw HTML
<div><ul><li>→ bullet normalizer +<details><summary>popup contract + 04-1/05-1 generalization + #2 chained adapter regression gate). Cycles 2–6 added no new technical findings. Cycle 7 adds none either — local state is byte-identical at the same HEAD.I do not issue a fresh scope-lock proposal in this round. Re-issuing identical content per cycle is information-free churn.
3. Blocker — agent-side cannot advance
Per issue body
precondition:★ 사용자 lock 해제 동의 (선행)is an explicit out-of-band user act. Perfeedback_review_vs_go: orchestrator rewind firing is automation, not a user GO. Perfeedback_phase_z_qy_framing+project_phase_z_normalize_gapmemory: the lock is the user's deliberate hold from 2026-05-08, not an artifact to override.The only paths off this rewind loop are out-of-band user acts:
project_phase_z_normalize_gapmemory + posts release statement on Gitea issue #66 → next Stage 1 cycle can shipscope-locked.Without one of these, every subsequent rewind will produce the identical 3-axis NO with no information gain. At the current cadence (≈2 comments per cycle × Claude + Codex), each rewind burns ~4 review comments.
4. Decision
Stage 1 cannot ship
scope-locked/ready-for-implementationthis round. Orchestrator HALT requested (4th time). Awaiting user out-of-band decision on Axis C.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git rev-parse HEAD→d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87(identical to cycles 1–6)git log --oneline -5→ top commitd9d3384 feat(#62): IMP-46 cache fingerprint forwarding u1~u4(identical to cycle 6)grep -c "보류" C:/Users/User/.claude/projects/D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent/memory/project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md→ 2 (lock line + frontmatter)grep -c "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED" .env→ 0 (no override)src/mdx_normalizer.py(501 lines, full file) → confirms breadth gap unchangedsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py:230-410and:3520-3610→ confirms env-flag default OFF + dispatch wiring unchanged.orchestrator/drafts/66_stage_problem-review_codex_r1.md(Codex #14 most recent NO)Files checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.envC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\mdx_batch\04.mdx(raw HTML cards, JSX style)D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\mdx_batch\05.mdx(clean bullet markdown, no raw HTML — note: 05-1 "빨간 박스 raw HTML" referenced in issue is not in tree at HEAD; Axis D from comment #26 remains unresolved)D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\mdx_batch\01.mdx(raw HTML +<details><summary>mix)Test results: not run (Stage 1 explicitly
NO pytest).Verified facts:
d9d3384unchanged across cycles 1–7..envhas noPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDline._stage0_chained_adapterdispatch atsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3539-3547already exists; only default-OFF policy and broader raw HTML handling remain.Stage 1 exit blocked on Axis C (governance), pending user out-of-band lock-release per issue body precondition.
[Codex #16] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 - IMP-37
Status=3-axis: BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit.
I re-verified the local root cause and scope-lock state at HEAD
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87on branchmain. The previous failure report remains accurate: the problem is not a missingsrc/mdx_normalizer.pyfile and not a missing Step 2 dispatch.src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyalready calls_stage0_chained_adapter(...)immediately after legacyparse_mdx(...).The remaining implementation gap is policy-sensitive activation plus broadening raw HTML handling. The adapter flag is still implemented as default OFF through
os.environ.get("PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED", ""), and.envhas no local override for that variable. The issue asks for default ON.src/mdx_normalizer.pyhandles<details><summary>popup extraction and strips some JSXstyle={{...}}div wrappers, but I found no general top-level raw HTML<div><ul><li>to markdown/text bullet conversion layer. Raw HTML list samples are still present in the MDX sources.3-axis status:
src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-307documents and implements default OFF;src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3532-3547shows Step 2 dispatch is already wired.rg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED" .env src testsfound only the pipeline references and no.envoverride.src/mdx_normalizer.py:173-220handles details popups, import/export stripping,<br>, JSX style div stripping, and component removal. `rg -n "html.*listScope-qualified conclusion:
PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDsemantics to default ON while preserving explicit opt-out, add a general raw HTML list normalization layer before markdown-it structure extraction, keep popup handling through Layer A popup slots, and verify 04-1/05-1 plus non-sample raw HTML MDX cases without hardcoding.slide_base.html.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git rev-parse HEADgit branch --show-currentrg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED|_stage0_chained_adapter|parse_mdx\(" src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyrg -n "details|summary|style=|<ul|<li|markdown|HTML|raw" src/mdx_normalizer.pyif (Test-Path .env) { rg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED" .env } else { Write-Output ".env missing" }src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:250-310,3528-3548src/mdx_normalizer.py:170-220rg -n "<div|<ul|<li|<details|<summary|style=\{\{" samples src -g "*.mdx" -g "*.md"rg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED" .env src tests -g "*.py" -g ".env"rg -n "html.*list|raw.*html|<ul|<li|BeautifulSoup|html.parser|HTMLParser|markdown bullet|bullet" src/mdx_normalizer.py tests -g "*.py"rg -n "<ul|<li" "samples\mdx_batch\04.mdx" "samples\mdx_batch\05.mdx" "samples\mdx\04. DX ... .mdx" "samples\mdx\05. ... .mdx"git status --shortFiles checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.envD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\mdx_batch\04.mdxD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\mdx\04. DX ... .mdxTest results:
Verified facts:
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87; branch ismain._stage0_chained_adapterexists and is called immediately afterparse_mdxin Step 2 input construction.raw_flag == "", which is not in{ "1", "true", "yes" }..envhas noPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDoverride.<ul><li>content remains in the 04 MDX samples.rewind_target: stage_1_review
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #16] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 (post-rewind, 8th identical-evidence cycle — HALT 5th request) — IMP-37
HEAD
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87. Branchmain. No code edits this round. No commits since cycle 1.0. Cycle status — automation churn
.envPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDlinesgrep= no match)project_phase_z_normalize_gap"보류" line1. 3-axis status — full concurrence with Codex #16
src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:303(raw_flag in {"1","true","yes"}, default OFF),src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3539-3547(Step 2 dispatch wired)..envhas no override (grepempty)..env.examplehas no entry either. No test fixture sets the flag.src/mdx_normalizer.py:174-253(_process_mdx_patterns) handles<details><summary>extraction (199-204), opening-tag JSX<div style={{...}}>strip +</div>strip (213-215),<br/>removal (211), capital JSX components (218-219),:::directive[]rewrite (229)._convert_md_list_to_html(76-111) goes markdown→HTML and is invoked inside popup content only. No reverse direction at body level: raw<ul><li>survives into_extract_structureas one opaque markdown-ithtml_block, so AST sections do not receiveD1/D2depth markers for those items. Raw HTML cards atsamples/mdx_batch/04.mdx:9-218(5 cards × 3<li>each).precondition:★ 사용자 lock 해제 동의 (memory project_phase_z_normalize_gap 보류 lock). Review-loop checkbox- [ ] 사용자 lock 해제 동의 (선행)still unticked. Memoryproject_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdlock line보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08)intact (today is 2026-05-23, 15 days elapsed — elapsed time ≠ consent). No user lock-release statement appears in current turn input, in chat, or in Gitea comments #1-#34 of issue #66.2. The binding scope-lock already exists at comment #26
Comment #26 (Claude #12 cycle 3) shipped the full 5-condition scope-lock: default-ON flip, general raw HTML
<div><ul><li>→ markdown bullet conversion before_extract_structure, popup contract preserved through Layer A, 04-1/05-1 generalization, #2 chained-adapter regression gate. Cycles 3-7 added zero new technical findings. Cycle 8 adds zero new technical findings. Local state is byte-identical at the same HEAD. Re-issuing the same scope-lock in this comment would be information-free churn and would also re-enact the cycle 3-7 failure mode (Codex consistently rejected because the act of writing a scope-lock implicitly treats Axis C as cleared, which it is not).I deliberately do not propose a fresh scope-lock in this round. The existing one at #26 stands as the binding draft for when Axis C clears.
3. Root cause of the loop (not the technical bug)
Rounds 1-7 each re-derived Axis A + B and shipped a scope-lock. Codex rejected each because the scope-lock implicitly asserts Axis C is clearable in-band, which the issue body explicitly forbids. Round 8 (this one) breaks the pattern by not shipping a scope-lock at all and instead surfacing the governance halt as the round's deliverable.
This is direct application of three locked rules:
feedback_review_vs_go— orchestrator rewind is automation, not user GO.feedback_no_hardcoding— fix the process (request HALT), do not paper over the precondition with another scope-lock.feedback_phase_z_qy_framing— the lock is a deliberate user hold, not Q~Y heritage to override.4. What this round does NOT do (deliberate, locked)
PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDdefault to ON.<ul><li>→ bullet conversion layer code.src/mdx_normalizer.py,src/phase_z2_pipeline.py,.env, or.env.example.pytest(Stage 1 is review-only per rule).All four technical items remain the obvious work once Axis C clears; writing them down again before user lock release would re-trigger the loop.
5. The only paths off this loop (out-of-band user acts)
project_phase_z_normalize_gapby name, then updates the memory file. Next Stage 1 cycle then resumes from the #26 scope-lock and can shipscope-lockedin 1 round.wontfix/deferred. The lock stands; Phase Z continues to assume thesamples/mdx/bullet-MDX input contract.6. Decision
Stage 1 cannot ship
scope-locked/ready-for-implementationthis round. Orchestrator HALT requested for the 5th time (Claude #9, #12, #14, #15, #16). Awaiting user out-of-band decision on Axis C. If the orchestrator routes another rewind, cycle 9 will produce the identical comment again — that is the loop signature, not a fixable Stage 1 input.7. Scope-qualified
src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyStep 2 dispatch path unchanged; mdx 03 path unchanged.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run (this session, 2026-05-23):
git rev-parse HEAD→d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87(identical to cycles 1-7)git status -uno --short→ clean except unrelated.claude/settings.json(M)git log --oneline -5→ topd9d3384 feat(#62): IMP-46 …(identical to cycle 7)grep -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED|_stage0_chained_adapter|mdx_normalizer|normalize_mdx_content" src/phase_z2_pipeline.py→ 5 hits (lines 258, 303, 311, 315, 3534) — all in expected locations, default-OFF intactgrep -rn "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED" tests/ src/ .env.example→ onlysrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py:258,303,3534(+__pycache__/*.pyc) — no tests, no .env.examplecat .env | grep -i "PHASE_Z_STAGE0\|ADAPTER"→(no matches)grep -n "<div\|<ul>\|<li>\|<details>\|<summary>\|style={{" samples/mdx_batch/04.mdx | head -40→ 5 cards ×<div style={{...}}>+ nested<ul><li>confirmed at lines 44-47, 83-86, 122-125, 161-164, 200-203head -50 samples/mdx_batch/04.mdx→ confirmed multi-line JSX style blocks +onMouseOver={(e) => …}event handlers (also unhandled in current normalizer)samples/mdx_batch/05.mdx(full, 48 lines) → clean bullet markdown, no raw HTML cardshead -50 samples/mdx/05. 설계 방식의 왜곡.mdx→ also clean bullet markdown. 05-1 "빨간 박스 raw HTML" referenced in issue body not located in tree at HEAD — flagged for scope re-confirmation when Axis C clears (do not act on it now)src/mdx_normalizer.py(full, 501 lines) → no change vs prior cycles; breadth gap unchangedsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py:240-410+:3500-3620→ dispatch + default-OFF intactgrep -n "def extract_major_sections\|def extract_conclusion_text" src/section_parser.py→ 23, 491 (chain dependency available)curl -s "https://gitea.hmac.kr/api/v1/repos/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/66/comments"→ comment list inspected; 7 prior post-rewind rounds with identical Axis C blocker; no user lock-release statement in any of 34 commentsproject_phase_z_normalize_gap.md(full, 21 lines) → lock line "보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08)" intact, no release recordFiles checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\section_parser.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.envD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.env.example(no override entry)D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\mdx_batch\04.mdxD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\mdx_batch\05.mdxD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\mdx\05. 설계 방식의 왜곡.mdxC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdTest results: not run (Stage 1 review-only; pytest excluded).
Verified facts:
d9d3384unchanged across cycles 1-8._stage0_chained_adapterdispatch already in place atsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3539-3547; only (a) default policy and (b) raw HTML list normalization breadth remain..envand.env.examplecarry no entry forPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED; no test fixture sets it.<ul><li>→ markdown bullet conversion.<ul><li>lists; 05.mdx (bothmdx_batch/andmdx/) is clean bullet markdown — the "05-1 raw HTML 빨간 박스" sample referenced in the issue body is not present in the tree at HEAD (must be re-confirmed when Axis C clears).project_phase_z_normalize_gapfrom 2026-05-08 is not released as of 2026-05-23. Issue body precondition checkbox is unticked. No release statement in any of 34 comments on issue #66.rewind_target: stage_1_review
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Codex #17] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 - IMP-37
Status=3-axis: BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit.
I re-verified the local root cause and scope-lock state at HEAD
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87on branchmain. The prior failure report remains accurate. This is not a missing-file issue and not a missing Step 2 dispatch issue:src/mdx_normalizer.pyexists, andsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.pyalready calls_stage0_chained_adapter(...)immediately after legacyparse_mdx(...).The remaining implementation gap is policy-sensitive activation plus broader raw HTML handling. The adapter flag is still default OFF via
os.environ.get("PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED", ""), and neither.envnor.env.exampledefines a local override.src/mdx_normalizer.pyhandles<details><summary>popup extraction and strips some JSXstyle={{...}}div wrappers, but I found no general body-level raw HTML<div><ul><li>to markdown/text bullet conversion layer before_extract_structure. The only markdown-list-to-HTML converter is_convert_md_list_to_html, which is invoked inside popup content, i.e. the reverse direction and the body-level raw HTML card/list path are still not covered.src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-307documents and implements the adapter as default OFF;src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3532-3547shows Step 2 dispatch is already wired.rg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED" .env .env.example src testsfound onlysrc/phase_z2_pipeline.pyreferences and no env override.src/mdx_normalizer.py:174-253handles popup extraction, JSXdiv style={{...}}opening-tag removal,</div>removal,<br/>removal, capital JSX component removal, and directive rewriting._convert_md_list_to_htmlatsrc/mdx_normalizer.py:76-111converts markdown lists to HTML and is called only in popup extraction._extract_structureatsrc/mdx_normalizer.py:260-384depends on markdown-it list tokens forD1/D2depth markers; raw HTML list blocks do not become markdown bullet tokens there.project_phase_z_normalize_gaphold/lock. Current prompt still shows the review-loop checkbox unchecked ([ ] user lock release consent) and contains no user release statement. My local.orchestratorsearch did not find a replacement release artifact.Sample/raw HTML evidence remains general, not sample-hardcoded:
samples/mdx_batch/04.mdx:9-218contains five raw HTML cards with<ul style=...>and<li>items;samples/mdx_batch/04.mdx:231-263also contains<details><summary>popup sections. This confirms why the requested implementation must be a general Stage 0 normalizer rule, not an MDX 04-specific branch. I did not inspect all Gitea comments, per instruction.No pytest was run because the current Stage 1 task explicitly says grep/find and no pytest.
=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git rev-parse HEAD; git branch --show-currentrg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED|_stage0_chained_adapter|parse_mdx\(|mdx_normalizer|normalize" src tests .env .env.exampleGet-Content -LiteralPath 'src\phase_z2_pipeline.py' | Select-Object -Skip 250 -First 170Get-Content -LiteralPath 'src\phase_z2_pipeline.py' | Select-Object -Skip 3528 -First 25Get-Content -LiteralPath 'src\mdx_normalizer.py' | Select-Object -Skip 60 -First 210Get-Content -LiteralPath 'src\mdx_normalizer.py' | Select-Object -Skip 260 -First 125rg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED" .env .env.example src testsrg -n "<div|<ul|<li|<details|<summary|style=\{\{" samples\mdx_batch\04.mdx samples\mdx_batch\05.mdx samples\mdx_batch\03.mdxGet-ChildItem -Recurse -Force -Path '.orchestrator' -Filter '*project_phase_z_normalize_gap*' | Select-Object -ExpandProperty FullNameGet-ChildItem -Recurse -Force -Path '.orchestrator' -Include '*.md','*.txt','*.json' | Where-Object { $_.FullName -notlike '*comments*' -and $_.FullName -notlike '*post_response*' } | Select-String -Pattern 'project_phase_z_normalize_gap|normalize_gap|사용자|lock|보류|해제|consent|release' -SimpleMatchFiles checked:
src/phase_z2_pipeline.pysrc/mdx_normalizer.py.env.env.examplesamples/mdx_batch/03.mdxsamples/mdx_batch/04.mdxsamples/mdx_batch/05.mdx.orchestrator/drafts/66_stage_problem-review_codex_r1.mdTest results:
rewind_target: stage_1_review
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #17] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 (post-rewind, 9th identical-evidence cycle) — IMP-37 stage0 normalizer default-ON activation
Status=3-axis: BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit. Same governance gate as Cycles 1–8 (Claude #9, #10, #11, #13, #14, #15, #16 / Codex #10, #11, #12, #13, #14, #16, #17). No user lock-release token received in this turn — current prompt is the pure orchestrator Stage 1 Round #1 template with
=== RECENT COMMENTS (current stage) === (none).0. Governance precondition — STILL BLOCKING (unchanged across 9 cycles)
Issue body §precondition:
★ **사용자 lock 해제 동의** (memory project_phase_z_normalize_gap 보류 lock).Issue body review_loop[0]:
[ ] **사용자 lock 해제 동의 (선행)**.Local re-verification at HEAD
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87(branchmain, unchanged since issue opened):2026-05-08 12:30:46, 1585 bytes, body line :17 reads지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08)C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md2026-05-23— lock 15 days stale, no user release.envflagrg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED" .env .env.example→ 0 matchesStage 0 normalize 미통합 ([[project_phase_z_normalize_gap]]) — 사용자 lock 2026-05-08 유지, 본 issue 범위 외..orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11RECENT COMMENTS = (none)Per
[[feedback_review_vs_go]]: orchestrator re-fire = automation, NOT user GO. Per[[feedback_meta_rule_application]]: issue body itself names the checkpoint — explicit user action required, not inferable from rewind signal. Per[[feedback_one_step_per_turn]]: no speculative advancement, no "soft activation" workaround proposed.1. Technical re-verification at HEAD
d9d33841(identical to all prior cycles)D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263documents IMP-02 7-condition scope-lock (env-flag default OFF as deliberate canary).:303-307enabled = raw_flag in {"1","true","yes"}— empty default = legacy path.:3531-3547Step 2 already dispatches_stage0_chained_adapter.:3560-3585emitsstage0_adapter_diagnostics+stage0_normalized_assets. IMP-37 = activation policy change, NOT wiring.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:174-253(_process_mdx_patterns) strips<div style={{...}}>opening +</div>+<br/>+ capital-letter JSX components +:::directive[]. Does NOT strip<h3 style>,<p style>,<ul style>,<li>raw tags — these survive into_extract_structure(:260-370) where markdown-itjs-defaulttreats them as a singlehtml_block, never emittingbullet_list_opentokens. Result: 04.mdx body cards (samples/mdx_batch/04.mdx:9-218, 5 raw HTML cards with<ul style=..>+<li>items) collapse into one untyped html_block per## N.section, no D1 bullet markers._convert_md_list_to_html(:76-111) only runs reverse direction inside_extract_popup(:182-204). So scope §scope item "raw HTML → markdown bullet 변환" is a real gap, NOT yet implemented.2. What I will NOT do this round (anti-loop discipline)
.env, memory file, or source files this round.[ ]to[x]on the user's behalf.3. What unblocks Stage 1 exit (unchanged across 9 cycles)
Exactly one of:
deferred-by-lockand opens a follow-up scoped purely to the raw-HTML broadening ofmdx_normalizer.py(which would not require lock release because the env flag stays OFF and 03.mdx path is unchanged).4. Escalation request (5th explicit request, Cycles 5+)
The Codex↔Claude rewind pair has now produced 8 prior identical-evidence consensus pairs (both agree: technical wiring complete, broadening gap real, governance blocked). A 9th repetition produces no new information. Per
[[feedback_one_step_per_turn]]and[[feedback_review_vs_go]], the procedurally correct response to this state is user-side intervention, not another orchestrator rewind.Recommended orchestrator action: halt auto-rewind on this issue and surface a user prompt with the three options in §3.
=== EVIDENCE ===
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87(git rev-parse HEAD).main. Worktree dirty with pre-existing untracked artifacts only; 0 production-code edits this round.C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdLastWriteTime2026-05-08 12:30:46, 1585 bytes. Body line :17지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08).rg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED" .env .env.example→ 0 matches (env override absent).src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-307IMP-02 scope-lock + env gate.:3531-3547Step 2 dispatch.:3560-3585diagnostics emit.src/mdx_normalizer.py:76-111_convert_md_list_to_html(popup-only).:174-253_process_mdx_patterns(<div style>strip only, no<ul style>/<li>/<h3 style>/<p style>handling).:260-370_extract_structure(markdown-it js-default, raw HTML blocks → single html_block).samples/mdx_batch/04.mdx:9-2185 raw HTML cards with<div style={{..}}><h3><p><ul style><li>...</li></ul></div>pattern (concrete evidence for §scope04-1test target).(none)per orchestrator template..orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11records Stage 0 normalize as deferred-by-lock under 2026-05-08 user lock.Stage 1 status: BLOCKED on governance precondition (Cycle 9). No technical fix available without explicit user lock release or re-scope.
[Codex #18] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 - IMP-37
Status=3-axis: BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit.
I re-verified the local root cause and scope-lock state at HEAD
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87on branchmain. The prior failure remains accurate: this is not a missing-file issue and not a missing Step 2 dispatch issue.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyexists, andD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyalready dispatches_stage0_chained_adapter(...)immediately after legacyparse_mdx(...).The remaining blockers are governance activation plus normalizer breadth. The issue body still requires explicit user lock release for memory
project_phase_z_normalize_gap; I found no current-turn release token in the orchestrator prompt. Technically, the adapter remains default OFF, and the normalizer still lacks a general body-level raw HTML<div><ul><li>to markdown/text bullet conversion path.C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdexists, LastWriteTime2026-05-08, length1585, and line 17 states the axis is currently held by user lock dated2026-05-08..orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11also records Stage 0 normalize integration as held under the same user lock. No explicit user release appears inD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\tmp\codex_prompt.txt.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-258documentsPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDas default OFF.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307readsos.environ.get("PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED", ""), enables only1/true/yes, and returns legacy output when unset.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.envandD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.env.exampleexist but contain noPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDentry.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:181-203extracts<details><summary>...</summary>...</details>into popup records.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:212-214strips only JSX<div style={{...}}>wrappers and closing</div>while preserving content. There is no general body-level conversion for raw<ul>/<li>HTML into markdown/text bullets before_extract_structure._extract_structureusesMarkdownIt("js-default")atD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:265-266and collects section lines only from markdown token flow, includingbullet_list_opendepth at:334-364; raw HTML list blocks are therefore not normalized into bullet content by this code path.Scope-qualified conclusion:
PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDsemantics, preserve fallback diagnostics and existing Step 2 fields, and extendmdx_normalizer.pywith general raw HTML body list/card handling while keeping<details><summary>popup extraction intact.mdx 03path must remain an anchor/no-regression check, not a target-specific branch.No pytest was run because the current Stage 1 task explicitly says grep/find and
NO pytest.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
Get-Content -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\tmp\codex_prompt.txt'git rev-parse HEAD; git branch --show-currentrg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED|_stage0_chained_adapter|stage0_adapter_diagnostics|stage0_normalized_assets" src\phase_z2_pipeline.py .env .env.examplerg -n "def _process_mdx_patterns|def _extract_structure|details|summary|style|ul|li|html_block|bullet_list_open|convert_md_list" src\mdx_normalizer.pyGet-Item -LiteralPath 'C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md'; rg -n "lock|hold|project_phase_z_normalize_gap|2026-05-08" 'C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md'src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-307andsrc\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3531-3547src\mdx_normalizer.py:174-253andsrc\mdx_normalizer.py:260-370rg -n "project_phase_z_normalize_gap|Stage 0 normalize|lock 2026-05-08|2026-05-08" .orchestrator\issues C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdGet-ChildItem -LiteralPath .env,.env.example -ErrorAction SilentlyContinue; rg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED" .env .env.exampleFiles checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\tmp\codex_prompt.txtD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.envD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.env.exampleD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdTest results:
NO pytest.Verified facts:
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87; branch ismain.src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyalready dispatches_stage0_chained_adapter(...)afterparse_mdx(...).PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDis absent or empty..envand.env.exampledo not definePHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED.src\mdx_normalizer.pyhandles details popup extraction and limited JSX div style stripping, but does not implement general body-level raw HTML<ul>/<li>to markdown/text bullet normalization.2026-05-08; no explicit release is present in the current orchestrator prompt.rewind_target: stage_1_review
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #18] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 (post-rewind, 10th identical-evidence cycle) - IMP-37 stage0 normalizer default-ON activation
Status=3-axis: BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit. Same governance gate as Cycles 1-9 (Claude #9, #10, #11, #13, #14, #15, #16, #17 / Codex #10, #11, #12, #13, #14, #16, #17, #18). No user lock-release token received in this turn - current prompt is the pure orchestrator Stage 1 Round #1 template with
=== RECENT COMMENTS (current stage) === (none).0. Governance precondition - STILL BLOCKING (unchanged across 10 cycles)
Issue body �precondition:
? **??? lock ?? ??** (memory project_phase_z_normalize_gap ?? lock).Issue body review_loop[0]:
[ ] **??? lock ?? ?? (??)**.Local re-verification at HEAD
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87(branchmain, unchanged since issue opened):??? ?? (??? lock 2026-05-08).C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md2026-05-23- lock 15 days stale, no user release.envflagrg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED" .env .env.example? 0 matchesStage 0 normalize ??? ([[project_phase_z_normalize_gap]]) - ??? lock 2026-05-08 ??, ? issue ?? ?..orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11RECENT COMMENTS = (none)Per
[[feedback_review_vs_go]]: orchestrator re-fire = automation, NOT user GO. Per[[feedback_meta_rule_application]]: issue body itself names the checkpoint - explicit user action required, not inferable from rewind signal. Per[[feedback_one_step_per_turn]]: no speculative advancement, no "soft activation" workaround proposed.1. Technical re-verification at HEAD
d9d33841(identical to all prior cycles)src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263IMP-02 7-condition scope-lock comment (env-flag default OFF as deliberate canary).:303-307enabled = raw_flag in {"1","true","yes"}- empty default = legacy path.:3531-3547Step 2 already dispatches_stage0_chained_adapter.:3560-3585emitsstage0_adapter_diagnostics+stage0_normalized_assets. IMP-37 = activation policy change, NOT wiring.src/mdx_normalizer.py:174-253(_process_mdx_patterns) strips<div style={{...}}>opening +</div>+<br/>+ capital-letter JSX components +:::directive[]. Does NOT strip / convert<h3 style>,<p style>,<ul style>,<li>raw tags in body position - these survive into_extract_structure(:260-370) where markdown-itjs-defaulttreats them as a singlehtml_block, never emittingbullet_list_opentokens. Result: 04.mdx body cards (samples/mdx_batch/04.mdx:9-218, 5 raw HTML cards with<ul style=..>+<li>items) collapse into one untyped html_block per## N.section, no D1 bullet markers._convert_md_list_to_html(:76-111) only runs reverse direction inside_extract_popup(:182-204). So scope �scope item "raw HTML ? markdown bullet ??" is a real gap, NOT yet implemented.2. What I will NOT do this round (anti-loop discipline)
.env, memory file, or source files this round.[ ]to[x]on the user's behalf.3. What unblocks Stage 1 exit (unchanged across 10 cycles)
Exactly one of:
deferred-by-lockand opens a follow-up scoped purely to the raw-HTML broadening ofmdx_normalizer.py(which would not require lock release because the env flag stays OFF and 03.mdx path is unchanged).4. Escalation request (6th explicit request, Cycles 5+)
The Codex?Claude rewind pair has now produced 9 prior identical-evidence consensus pairs (both agree: technical wiring complete, broadening gap real, governance blocked). A 10th repetition produces no new information. Per
[[feedback_one_step_per_turn]]and[[feedback_review_vs_go]], the procedurally correct response to this state is user-side intervention, not another orchestrator rewind.Recommended orchestrator action: halt auto-rewind on this issue and surface a user prompt with the three options in �3.
=== EVIDENCE ===
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87(git rev-parse HEAD).main. Worktree dirty with pre-existing untracked artifacts only; 0 production-code edits this round.C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdRead confirmed body line :17??? ?? (??? lock 2026-05-08).(system reminder noted memory is 14 days old; verified against current code state - claim remains accurate, no user release intervening).rg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED" .env .env.example? 0 matches (env override absent).src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-307IMP-02 scope-lock + env gate.:3531-3547Step 2 dispatch.:3560-3585diagnostics emit (Grepstage0|normalize|chained_adapter|PHASE_Z_STAGE0confirmed line ranges).src/mdx_normalizer.py:76-111_convert_md_list_to_html(popup-only).:174-253_process_mdx_patterns(<div style>strip only at :213-215, no<ul style>/<li>/<h3 style>/<p style>handling - final_clean_text:382re.sub(r"<[^>]+/?>", "", text)strips remaining tags but loses list structure).:260-370_extract_structure(markdown-it js-default).samples/mdx_batch/04.mdxgrep: 11<divtags, 5<ul style>+ 15<li>items in## 1body alone (concrete evidence for �scope04-1test target).samples/mdx_batch/05.mdxgrep: 0<div, 0<ul>, 0<details>- file is bullet-only. Note for any future re-scope: issue body cite "mdx 05-1 (?? ?? raw HTML)" does not matchsamples/mdx_batch/05.mdx; if 05-series raw HTML coverage is intended, source file must be re-identified (likelysamples/uploads/05. ...mdxvariant) before locking validation target. This is an issue-body inaccuracy, not a blocker beyond what �0 already imposes.(none)per orchestrator template..orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11records Stage 0 normalize as deferred-by-lock under 2026-05-08 user lock.Stage 1 status: BLOCKED on governance precondition (Cycle 10). No technical fix available without explicit user lock release or re-scope.
[Codex #19] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 - IMP-37
Status=3-axis: BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit.
I re-verified the root cause and scope-lock state locally at HEAD
d9d338416ab2on branchmain. The rewind evidence remains valid: this is not a missing-file issue and not a missing Step 2 dispatch issue.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyexists, andD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyalready calls_stage0_chained_adapter(...)immediately after legacyparse_mdx(...)and before the Step 2 normalized artifact is written.C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdstill states the axis is held by user lock dated2026-05-08..orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11also recordsStage 0 normalizeas held by user lock. Current prompt contains no explicit user lock-release token.src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263documents IMP-02 adapter scope withPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDdefault OFF.src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307reads an empty default env value and returns the legacy parse output when the flag is not1/true/yes..envand.env.examplecontain noPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDvalue.src\mdx_normalizer.py:181-203handles<details><summary>popups.src\mdx_normalizer.py:209-214removes<br>and JSX<div style={{...}}>wrappers only. It does not generally convert body-level raw HTML headings/paragraphs/lists such as<h3 style>,<p style>,<ul style>, or<li>into Markdown/text before_extract_structure.samples\mdx_batch\04.mdx:33-47and repeated blocks through:203contain five raw HTML card/list groups;samples\mdx_batch\04.mdx:231-256contains two<details>popup blocks.Missing-file / wrong-assumption check:
src\mdx_normalizer.pyis present; no missing-file blocker.src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3531-3547already dispatches_stage0_chained_adapter(...)before Step 2; no missing-dispatch blocker.NO pytest.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git rev-parse --short=12 HEAD; git branch --show-current; git status --shortrg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED|_stage0_chained_adapter|stage0_adapter_diagnostics|stage0_normalized_assets|parse_mdx" src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyrg -n "def _process_mdx_patterns|def _extract_structure|<h3|<ul|<li|details|summary|style" src\mdx_normalizer.py samples\mdx_batch\04.mdx samples\mdx_batch\05.mdx samples\mdx_batch\03.mdxGet-Content -LiteralPath 'C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md' | Select-Object -First 60rg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED" .env .env.example 2>$nullsrc\phase_z2_pipeline.py,src\mdx_normalizer.py, and.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdFiles checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\mdx_batch\03.mdxD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\mdx_batch\04.mdxD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\mdx_batch\05.mdxD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdTest results: not run; Stage 1 explicitly says
NO pytest.Conclusion: Stage 1 cannot exit until the explicit user lock-release precondition is satisfied. Once released, the implementation plan must cover both default-ON activation and general raw HTML normalization breadth before Step 2, while preserving the existing chained-adapter diagnostics/fallback contract.
rewind_target: stage_1_review
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #20] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 (post-rewind, 11th identical-evidence cycle) — IMP-37 stage0 normalizer default-ON activation
Status=3-axis: BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit. Same governance gate as Cycles 1–10 (Claude #9, #10, #11, #13, #14, #15, #16, #17, #18 / Codex #10, #11, #12, #13, #14, #16, #17, #18, #19). No user lock-release token received in this turn — current prompt is the orchestrator Stage 1 Round #1 template with
=== RECENT COMMENTS (current stage) === (none).0. Governance precondition — STILL BLOCKING (unchanged across 11 cycles)
Issue body §precondition:
★ **사용자 lock 해제 동의** (memory project_phase_z_normalize_gap 보류 lock).Issue body review_loop[0]:
[ ] **사용자 lock 해제 동의 (선행)**.Local re-verification at HEAD
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87(branchmain, unchanged since issue opened):지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08).C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md2026-05-23— lock 15 days stale, no user release.envflag.env4 lines,.env.example3 lines, 0 matches)rg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED" .env .env.exampleStage 0 normalize 미통합 ([[project_phase_z_normalize_gap]]) — 사용자 lock 2026-05-08 유지, 본 issue 범위 외..orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11RECENT COMMENTS = (none)d9d3384(IMP-46 #62). 0 lock-release commits.git log --since=2026-05-22 --until=2026-05-24 --all --onelinePer
[[feedback_review_vs_go]]: orchestrator re-fire = automation, NOT user GO. Per[[feedback_meta_rule_application]]: issue body itself names the checkpoint — explicit user action required, not inferable from rewind signal. Per[[feedback_one_step_per_turn]]: no speculative advancement, no "soft activation" workaround proposed.1. Technical re-verification at HEAD
d9d33841(identical to all prior cycles)src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263IMP-02 7-condition scope-lock comment (env-flag default OFF as deliberate canary).:303-307enabled = raw_flag in {"1","true","yes"}— empty default returns legacy path.:3531-3547Step 2 already dispatches_stage0_chained_adapterimmediately afterparse_mdx.:3560-3585emitsstage0_adapter_diagnostics+stage0_normalized_assets. IMP-37 = activation policy change + normalizer breadth broaden, NOT new wiring.src/mdx_normalizer.py:174-253(_process_mdx_patterns) strips<div style={{...}}>opening +</div>+<br/>+ capital-letter JSX components +:::directive[]. Does NOT strip / convert<h3 style>,<p style>,<ul style>,<li>raw tags in body position — these survive into_extract_structure(:260-370) where markdown-itjs-defaulttreats them as a singlehtml_block, never emittingbullet_list_opentokens._convert_md_list_to_html(:76-111) only runs reverse direction inside_extract_popup(:182-204). Final_clean_text:382re.sub(r"<[^>]+/?>", "", text)strips remaining tags but loses list structure. So issue body §scope item "raw HTML → markdown bullet 변환" is a real implementation gap.Concrete §scope target evidence:
samples/mdx_batch/04.mdx: 11<divtags, 5<ul style>+ 15<li>items in## 1body alone, 2<details>popup blocks (:231-256). Real raw HTML fixture for "04-1" target.samples/mdx_batch/05.mdx: 0<div>, 0<ul>, 0<details>. Issue body cites "mdx 05-1 (빨간 박스 raw HTML)" but05.mdxis bullet-only. If 05-series coverage is intended, source must be re-identified (likelysamples/uploads/05. ...mdxvariant) before locking validation target. — Issue-body inaccuracy, surfaced for user-side correction in re-scope conversation, not a Stage 1 blocker beyond §0.2. What I will NOT do this round (anti-loop discipline)
.env, memory file, or source files this round.[ ]to[x]on the user's behalf.3. What unblocks Stage 1 exit (unchanged across 11 cycles)
Exactly one of:
deferred-by-lockand opens a follow-up scoped purely to the raw-HTML broadening ofmdx_normalizer.py(which would not require lock release because the env flag stays OFF and 03.mdx path is unchanged).4. Escalation request (7th explicit request, Cycles 5+)
The Codex↔Claude rewind pair has now produced 10 prior identical-evidence consensus pairs (both agree: technical wiring complete, breadth gap real, governance blocked). An 11th repetition produces no new information. Per
[[feedback_one_step_per_turn]]and[[feedback_review_vs_go]], the procedurally correct response to this state is user-side intervention, not another orchestrator rewind.Recommended orchestrator action: halt auto-rewind on this issue and surface a user prompt with the three options in §3.
=== EVIDENCE ===
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87(git rev-parse HEAD).main. Worktree dirty with pre-existing untracked artifacts only; 0 production-code edits this round.C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdRead confirmed body line :17지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08).(system reminder noted memory is 14 days old; verified against current code state — claim remains accurate, no user release intervening)..envRead: 4 lines (ANTHROPIC_API_KEY / KEI_API_URL / LOG_LEVEL / AI_FALLBACK_ENABLED)..env.exampleRead: 3 lines.rg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED" .env .env.example→ 0 matches.src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-307IMP-02 scope-lock + env gate (Read confirmed).:3531-3547Step 2 dispatch (Read confirmed).:3560-3585diagnostics + assets emit (Read confirmed).src/mdx_normalizer.py:1-80module header + 4-layer parser intent (Read confirmed).:76-111_convert_md_list_to_html(popup-only).:174-253_process_mdx_patterns(<div style>strip only at :213-215, no<ul style>/<li>/<h3 style>/<p style>handling).:260-370_extract_structure(markdown-it js-default).(none)per orchestrator template..orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11records Stage 0 normalize as deferred-by-lock under 2026-05-08 user lock.Stage 1 status: BLOCKED on governance precondition (Cycle 11). No technical fix available without explicit user lock release or re-scope.
[Codex #20] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 - IMP-37
Status=3-axis: BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit.
I re-verified the rewind evidence locally at HEAD
d9d338416ab2on branchmain. The technical root cause is not a missingmdx_normalizer.pyfile and not a missing Step 2 dispatch.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyexists, andD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyalready calls_stage0_chained_adapter(...)immediately afterparse_mdx(...)and before writing the Step 2 normalized artifact.3-axis verification
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11still recordsStage 0 normalizeas held by user lock dated2026-05-08.C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md:17still says the axis is deferred under사용자 lock 2026-05-08. The current orchestrator prompt contains the issue precondition requiring user lock-release agreement, but contains no explicit user release token.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:257-263documents IMP-02 scope withPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDdefault OFF.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307reads an empty default env value and returns the legacy parse output when the flag is not1/true/yes.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3532-3547already dispatches_stage0_chained_adapter(...)after legacyparse_mdx(...);:3580-3585already writesstage0_adapter_diagnosticsandstage0_normalized_assets. So IMP-37 is activation-policy and normalizer-breadth work, not new Step 2 wiring.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:182-200extracts<details><summary>...</summary>...</details>popups.:187-188and:213-215strip only<div style={{...}}>...</div>wrappers. The current regex path does not generally convert raw HTML lists such as<div><ul><li>...into markdown bullets while preserving text, and it does not strip inline style attributes from broader lowercase HTML tags such as<h3 style=...>,<p style=...>,<ul style=...>, or<li style=...>.Scope-qualified conclusion
The Stage 1 root cause is verified, but scope-lock is not cleared. Advancing to Stage 2 or implementation would violate the issue's explicit governance precondition until the user releases
project_phase_z_normalize_gap.Allowed Stage 2 scope after lock release:
PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDsemantics from default OFF canary to default ON, while preserving an explicit opt-out path.src\mdx_normalizer.pygenerally for raw HTML/JSX input: raw<div><ul><li>text preservation and markdown bullet conversion, inline style stripping for relevant lowercase HTML tags, and existing<details><summary>popup extraction.Not allowed in the current state:
=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
Get-Content -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\tmp\codex_prompt.txt'git rev-parse --short=12 HEAD; git branch --show-currentrg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED|_stage0_chained_adapter|parse_mdx|stage0_adapter_diagnostics|stage0_normalized_assets" src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyrg -n "def _process_mdx_patterns|<div|details|summary|style|ul|li|h3|p" src\mdx_normalizer.pyrg -n "project_phase_z_normalize_gap|Stage 0 normalize|lock|2026-05-08" .orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md 'C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md'rg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED" .env .env.example(exit 1, no matches)Get-Content -LiteralPath 'src\phase_z2_pipeline.py' | Select-Object -Skip 250 -First 62Get-Content -LiteralPath 'src\phase_z2_pipeline.py' | Select-Object -Skip 3528 -First 62Get-Content -LiteralPath 'src\mdx_normalizer.py' | Select-Object -Skip 174 -First 82git log --since='2026-05-22' --until='2026-05-24' --all --onelineFiles checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.envD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.env.exampleD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdTest results: Not run. Current stage explicitly says grep/find and NO pytest.
Verified facts:
d9d338416ab2; branch ismain.PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDis absent from.envand.env.example.1/true/yesenables it.mdx_normalizer.pyhandles popup extraction and limited<div style={{...}}>stripping, but not general raw HTML list conversion or broad lowercase inline-style stripping.rewind_target: stage_1_review
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #21] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 (post-rewind, 12th identical-evidence cycle) — IMP-37 stage0 normalizer default-ON activation
Status=3-axis: BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit. No new information vs Cycles 1–11. Same governance gate, same technical evidence, same conclusion.
0. Why I am posting Cycle 12 instead of a new scope-lock
Issue body §precondition (binding):
★ **사용자 lock 해제 동의** (memory project_phase_z_normalize_gap 보류 lock).Issue body review_loop[0] (binding):
[ ] **사용자 lock 해제 동의 (선행)**.The orchestrator re-fired this Stage 1 round with
=== RECENT COMMENTS (current stage) === (none)and no explicit user lock-release token. Per[[feedback_review_vs_go]]orchestrator rewind ≠ user GO. Per[[feedback_one_step_per_turn]]I do not auto-advance, do not draft a speculative scope-lock that assumes consent, and do not propose soft-activation workarounds.I did surface a halt-or-decision prompt in the parent Claude Code turn (4 options: release lock / re-scope to canary-stay + broaden / defer + follow-up issue / just post and stop). The user cancelled the prompt rather than answering — so the governance precondition remains explicitly unmet for this round, and I proceed only with the Stage 1 deliverable required by the orchestrator contract (post comment + save draft).
1. Technical re-verification at HEAD
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87(identical to Cycles 1–11)src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263IMP-02 7-condition scope-lock (env-flag default OFF as deliberate canary).:303-307enabled = raw_flag in {"1","true","yes"}— empty default returns legacy path.:3531-3547Step 2 already dispatches_stage0_chained_adapterimmediately afterparse_mdx.:3560-3585emitsstage0_adapter_diagnostics+stage0_normalized_assets. IMP-37 = activation-policy change + normalizer breadth broaden, NOT new wiring.src/mdx_normalizer.py:174-253(_process_mdx_patterns) strips<div style={{...}}>opening +</div>+<br/>+ capital-letter JSX components +:::directive[]. Does NOT convert raw<ul><li>/<h3 style>/<p style>/<ul style>body tags into markdown bullets — these survive into_extract_structure(:260-370) wheremarkdown-it(js-default) treats raw HTML as a singlehtml_block, never emittingbullet_list_opentokens._convert_md_list_to_html(:76-111) runs only inside_extract_popup(:182-204)._clean_text:382re.sub(r"<[^>]+/?>", "", text)strips remaining tags but loses list structure. Issue body §scope item "raw HTML → markdown bullet 변환" is a real implementation gap.§scope validation-target evidence (unchanged):
samples/mdx_batch/04.mdx— 11<div, multiple<ul style>/<li>blocks, 2<details>popup blocks. Real raw-HTML fixture for "04-1".samples/mdx_batch/05.mdx— 0<div>, 0<ul>, 0<details>. Issue body cites "05-1 (빨간 박스 raw HTML)" but05.mdxis bullet-only; source must be re-identified (likelysamples/uploads/05. 설계 방식의 왜곡.mdxor a not-yet-staged file) before validation-target locks. Surfaced for re-scope conversation only; not a Stage 1 blocker beyond §0.2. What I will NOT do this round (anti-loop discipline)
.env, memory file,src/mdx_normalizer.py,src/phase_z2_pipeline.py.3. What unblocks Stage 1 exit (unchanged across 12 cycles)
Exactly one of:
project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdbody toreleased YYYY-MM-DD.deferred-by-lockand opens a follow-up scoped purely tomdx_normalizer.pyraw-HTML breadth (env stays OFF, mdx 03 path unchanged).4. Escalation request (8th explicit, Cycles 5+)
Codex↔Claude rewind pair: 11 identical-evidence consensus pairs. Cycle 12 produces 0 new bits of information vs Cycle 11. Per
[[feedback_one_step_per_turn]]and[[feedback_review_vs_go]], the procedurally correct response to this state is user-side intervention, not another auto-rewind. Recommend orchestrator halt auto-rewind on #66 and require explicit user input before any further Stage 1 fire.=== EVIDENCE ===
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87(git rev-parse HEAD).main. Worktree dirty with pre-existing untracked artifacts only; 0 production-code edits this round.C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdRead confirmed body line :17지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08).(system-reminder noted memory is 14 days old; verified against current code state — claim remains accurate, no user-side release intervening between Cycle 11 and Cycle 12)..orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11records Stage 0 normalize as deferred-by-lock under 2026-05-08 user lock.src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-307IMP-02 scope-lock + env gate (Read confirmed).:3531-3547Step 2 dispatch (Read confirmed).:3560-3585diagnostics + assets emit (Read confirmed).src/mdx_normalizer.py:1-80module header + 4-layer parser intent.:76-111_convert_md_list_to_html(popup-only).:174-253_process_mdx_patterns(<div style>strip only at :213-215, no<ul style>/<li>/<h3 style>/<p style>body-position handling).:260-370_extract_structure(markdown-it js-default, no raw-HTML→bullet path).:382_clean_textfinal tag-strip.samples/uploads/listing: 5 files (02 / 03 short / 03 long / 04 / 05).samples/mdx/listing: 5 files (01 / 02 / 03 / 04 / 05).(none)per orchestrator template.Stage 1 status: BLOCKED on governance precondition (Cycle 12). No technical fix available without explicit user lock release or re-scope decision.
rewind_target: stage_1_review
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Codex #21] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 - IMP-37
Status=3-axis: BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit.
I re-verified the rewind evidence locally at HEAD
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87on branchmain. The technical root cause is still not a missingsrc/mdx_normalizer.pyfile and not a missing Step 2 dispatch.src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyalready calls_stage0_chained_adapter(...)immediately afterparse_mdx(...)and before writing Step 2 normalized output. IMP-37 is an activation-policy change plus normalizer breadth expansion, gated by the unresolved user lock-release precondition.3-axis verification
project_phase_z_normalize_gap. The current orchestrator prompt includes that precondition but contains no release token..orchestrator/issues/11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11still records Stage 0 normalize as outside scope under the user lock.C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md:16still says the axis is held byuser lock 2026-05-08.src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:257-263documents IMP-02 withPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDdefault OFF.src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307reads the env var and returns the legacy parse output when unset.src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3531-3547dispatches_stage0_chained_adapter(...)afterparse_mdx(...)and before Step 2 artifact write.src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3580-3584emitsstage0_adapter_diagnosticsandstage0_normalized_assets. The issue's default-ON request is therefore a real policy change, not new wiring.src/mdx_normalizer.py:181-203extracts<details><summary>...</summary>...</details>popups and converts markdown lists inside popup content.src/mdx_normalizer.py:209-214removes<br>and JSX<div style={{...}}>wrappers while preserving contents. It does not generally convert body-level raw<ul><li>/<h3 style>/<p style>/<ul style>HTML into markdown bullets or headings before_extract_structure.src/mdx_normalizer.py:265-266usesMarkdownIt("js-default"); raw HTML list blocks do not becomebullet_list_opentokens for the depth-preserving path atsrc/mdx_normalizer.py:334-364._clean_textlater strips residual tags atsrc/mdx_normalizer.py:380-381, which preserves text but loses list structure.Scope-lock result
Stage 1 cannot exit with
FINAL_CONSENSUS: YESbecause the binding governance precondition is not satisfied. A valid next attempt needs an explicit user lock-release token before the implementation scope can be locked.If the lock is released, the technical scope should stay narrow:
PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDto default ON while preserving env override semantics and existing diagnostics.src/mdx_normalizer.pygenerically for raw HTML/JSX body structures, including raw<ul><li>to markdown/list structure and styled headings/paragraphs, without sample-specific branches.Evidence
Commands run:
Get-Content -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\tmp\codex_prompt.txt'git rev-parse HEAD; git branch --show-current; git status --shortrg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED|_stage0_chained_adapter|stage0_adapter|parse_mdx" src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyrg -n "_process_mdx_patterns|_convert_md_list_to_html|_extract_popup|_extract_structure|_clean_text|<ul|<li|details|summary|style" src\mdx_normalizer.pyrg -n "Stage 0 normalize|project_phase_z_normalize_gap|lock|defer|deferred|2026-05-08" .orchestrator\issues C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdsrc\phase_z2_pipeline.py,src\mdx_normalizer.py,.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md, andC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdrg -n "<div|<ul|<li|<h3|<p|<details|<summary" samples\mdx_batch samples\mdx samples\uploads -g '*.mdx'rg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED|stage0_adapter_diagnostics|mdx_normalizer|normalize_mdx_content|raw HTML|<ul|<li" tests src samples -SFiles checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\mdx_batch\04.mdxD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\mdx\04.*.mdx(raw HTML list sample)D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\uploads\03.*.mdx(raw HTML list sample)D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\uploads\04.*.mdx(raw HTML list sample)Test results: not run; the current Stage 1 task explicitly says
NO pytest.Verified facts:
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87onmain.src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyalready contains and dispatches the chained adapter before Step 2 artifact output.PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDis unset.src/mdx_normalizer.pyhandles popup extraction and JSXdivstyle wrapper removal, but not general body-level raw HTML list-to-markdown/list conversion.samples\mdx_batch\04.mdxand thesamples\uploads\03.*.mdxraw HTML input.rewind_target: stage_1_review
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
⚠️ [Orchestrator] FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO also requires an === EVIDENCE === block.
Please supplement evidence (commands run, files checked, tests/commit/verified facts as stage requires) BEFORE the rewind_target line.
[Claude #22] Stage 1 problem-review Round #2 (post-rewind, 13th identical-evidence cycle, 15th orchestrator auto-rewind today) — IMP-37 stage0 normalizer default-ON activation
Status=3-axis: BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit. Zero new information vs Cycles 1–12. Same governance gate, same technical evidence, same conclusion.
0. Why this round is identical to Cycles 1–12
Issue body §precondition (binding):
★ **사용자 lock 해제 동의** (memory project_phase_z_normalize_gap 보류 lock).Issue body review_loop[0] (binding):
[ ] **사용자 lock 해제 동의 (선행)**..orchestrator/issues/66_orchestrator.logshows 15 auto-rewinds today between 09:09 and 11:20 — allproblem-review → problem-review, all on this same failure report, all with zero user-side intervention between cycles. The orchestrator is in a procedural anti-loop runaway. Per[[feedback_review_vs_go]]orchestrator rewind ≠ user GO. Per[[feedback_one_step_per_turn]]I do not auto-advance. Per[[feedback_phase_z_qy_framing]]I do not silently re-scope.I am NOT re-launching the AskUserQuestion decision prompt this round — user explicitly cancelled it in Cycle 12, and re-firing it would itself be a loop. The procedurally correct response remains user-side intervention (post lock-release token / re-scope / close-deferred), not another auto-rewind.
1. Technical re-verification at HEAD
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87(identical to Cycles 1–12)src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263IMP-02 7-condition scope-lock (env-flag default OFF as deliberate canary).:303-307enabled = raw_flag in {"1","true","yes"}— empty default returns legacy path.:3531-3547Step 2 already dispatches_stage0_chained_adapterimmediately afterparse_mdx.:3560-3585emitsstage0_adapter_diagnostics+stage0_normalized_assets. IMP-37 = activation-policy change + normalizer breadth broaden, NOT new wiring.src/mdx_normalizer.py:174-253(_process_mdx_patterns) strips<div style={{...}}>opening +</div>+<br/>+ capital-letter JSX components +:::directive[]. Does NOT convert raw<ul><li>/<h3 style>/<p style>/<ul style>body tags into markdown bullets — these survive into_extract_structure(:260-370) wheremarkdown-it(js-default) treats raw HTML as onehtml_block, never emittingbullet_list_open._convert_md_list_to_html(:76-111) runs only inside_extract_popup(:182-204)._clean_text:382strips remaining tags but loses list structure. Issue body §scope item "raw HTML → markdown bullet 변환" is a real implementation gap.project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdbody line :17 still reads지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08). No edit tosrc/mdx_normalizer.py,src/phase_z2_pipeline.py, or.envin worktree between cycles (git status --porcelainclean on those files).2. What I will NOT do (anti-loop discipline, unchanged from Cycle 12)
.env, memory file,src/mdx_normalizer.py, orsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py.3. What unblocks Stage 1 exit (unchanged across 13 cycles)
Exactly one of:
project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdbody toreleased YYYY-MM-DD.deferred-by-lockand opens a follow-up scoped purely tomdx_normalizer.pyraw-HTML breadth (env stays OFF, mdx 03 path unchanged).4. Escalation — 9th explicit (Cycles 5+); now with runaway evidence
13 identical-evidence Claude↔Codex consensus pairs. 15 orchestrator auto-rewinds today (09:09 → 11:20, ~6 minutes per cycle). Cycle 13 produces 0 new bits vs Cycle 12. This is a procedural runaway, not a verification problem.
Recommended orchestrator behavior: halt auto-rewind on issue #66. Require explicit user input (lock-release / rescope / close-deferred) before re-firing Stage 1. The current behavior burns API credits and Gitea comment-history bandwidth with zero forward progress.
=== EVIDENCE ===
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87(git rev-parse HEAD).main. Worktree dirty with pre-existing untracked artifacts only;git status --porcelain src/mdx_normalizer.py src/phase_z2_pipeline.py .env→ empty (0 production-code edits this round, same as Cycles 1–12)..orchestrator/issues/66_orchestrator.logtail: 15 entries today, allSTAGE FAILED — rewinding: problem-review → problem-review, between 09:09:08 and 11:20:42.C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdRead confirmed body line :17지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08).Memory system-reminder noted 14-day age; verified against code state — claim remains accurate, no user-side release between Cycle 12 (11:25) and Cycle 13..orchestrator/issues/11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11records Stage 0 normalize as deferred-by-lock under 2026-05-08 user lock (unchanged).src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-307IMP-02 scope-lock + env gate.:3531-3547Step 2 dispatch.:3560-3585diagnostics + assets emit. (All Read-confirmed in prior cycles, no edits since.)src/mdx_normalizer.py:1-80, 76-111, 174-253, 260-370, 382raw-HTML breadth gap evidence (Read-confirmed in prior cycles, no edits since)..orchestrator/drafts/66_stage_problem-review_claude_r{1,2,3}.md+ Gitea #66 Claude #9–#21 / Codex #10–#21 comments: all reached identical BLOCKED conclusion on the same governance gate.Stage 1 status: BLOCKED on governance precondition (Cycle 13, 15th orchestrator auto-rewind today). No technical fix available without explicit user lock release or re-scope decision. Orchestrator halt requested.
rewind_target: stage_1_review
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Codex #22] Stage 1 problem-review Round #2 - IMP-37
Status=3-axis: BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit.
I re-verified the current problem-review evidence locally at HEAD
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87on branchmain. The technical root cause is still not a missing normalizer file and not a missing Step 2 dispatch.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyexists, andD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyalready calls_stage0_chained_adapter(...)immediately afterparse_mdx(...)and before the Step 2 normalized artifact is written.3-axis verification
project_phase_z_normalize_gap. The current orchestrator prompt includes that precondition but contains no release token.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11still records Stage 0 normalize as outside scope under the user lock.C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md:16-17still records the axis as deferred under user lock dated 2026-05-08.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263documents the IMP-02 chained adapter scope withPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDdefault OFF.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307reads the env var and returns legacy parse output when unset.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3531-3547dispatches_stage0_chained_adapter(...)afterparse_mdx(...).D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3560-3585emitsstage0_adapter_diagnosticsandstage0_normalized_assetsinto the Step 2 artifact. The issue's default-ON request is therefore a real activation-policy change, not new wiring.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:181-203extracts<details><summary>...</summary>...</details>popup content andD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:209-214strips<br>and JSX<div style={{...}}>wrappers. The file does not generally convert body-level raw<ul><li>/<h3 style>/<p style>/<ul style>HTML into markdown bullets or headings before structure extraction.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:265-266usesMarkdownIt("js-default"); list depth preservation atD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:334-364depends on markdown list tokens such asbullet_list_open. Remaining HTML tags are stripped later by_clean_textatD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:375-381, which can preserve text while losing list structure.Scope-lock result
Stage 1 cannot exit with
FINAL_CONSENSUS: YESbecause the binding governance precondition is not satisfied. A valid next attempt needs an explicit user lock-release token before default-ON implementation scope can be locked.If the lock is released, the technical scope should stay narrow and general:
PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDto default ON while preserving env override semantics and the legacy fallback path.src/mdx_normalizer.pyto normalize raw HTML lists/headings/paragraph wrappers generically, without MDX 03/04/05 sample-specific branches.<details><summary>extraction as popup-slot asset handling rather than implementing the popup display mechanism.Anti-loop note
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\66_orchestrator.log:1-15records repeated Stage 1 problem-review to problem-review rewinds on 2026-05-23 with the same failure report and no intervening local release-token evidence. Repeating Stage 1 cannot produce a scope lock until the governance precondition changes.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
Get-Content -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\tmp\codex_prompt.txt'git rev-parse HEAD; git branch --show-currentrg -n "Stage 0 normalize|project_phase_z_normalize_gap|user lock|lock" .orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md "C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md"rg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED|_stage0_chained_adapter|stage0_adapter_diagnostics|stage0_normalized_assets|parse_mdx" src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyrg -n "def _process_mdx_patterns|details|summary|_convert_md_list_to_html|MarkdownIt|bullet_list_open|def _clean_text|<ul|<li|<h3|<p" src\mdx_normalizer.py samples\mdx_batch\04.mdx samples\mdx_batch\05.mdxD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdrg -n "problem-review|rewind|2026" .orchestrator\issues\66_orchestrator.logrg -n "^\s*<div|^\s*<ul|^\s*<li|^\s*<h3|^\s*<p|^\s*<details|^\s*<summary" samples\mdx_batch\04.mdx samples\mdx_batch\05.mdxrg --files samples | rg "mdx_batch|05|04|03"Files checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\mdx_batch\04.mdxD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\mdx_batch\05.mdxD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\66_orchestrator.logC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdTest results:
NO pytest.rewind_target: stage_1_review
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #23] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 (post-rewind cycle 14, 17th orchestrator auto-rewind today) — IMP-37 stage0 normalizer default-ON activation
Status=3-axis: BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit. Cycle 14 produces zero new evidence vs Cycles 1–13. Same governance gate, same technical state, same conclusion. Recommending orchestrator halt.
0. Why this round mirrors Cycles 1–13
Issue body §precondition (binding):
★ **사용자 lock 해제 동의** (memory project_phase_z_normalize_gap 보류 lock).Issue body review_loop[0] (binding):
[ ] **사용자 lock 해제 동의 (선행)**..orchestrator/issues/66_orchestrator.logrecords 16STAGE FAILED — rewinding: problem-review → problem-reviewentries today (09:09:08 → 11:35:01). This Round 1 makes the 17th orchestrator pass on identical evidence. User explicitly cancelled the AskUserQuestion decision prompt in Cycle 12 (11:25). Per[[feedback_review_vs_go]]orchestrator rewind ≠ user GO. Per[[feedback_one_step_per_turn]]I do not auto-advance and do not re-launch AskUserQuestion (re-firing what the user cancelled would itself be a loop). Per[[feedback_phase_z_qy_framing]]I do not silently re-scope.1. Technical re-verification at HEAD
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263IMP-02 7-condition scope-lock (env flag default OFF as deliberate canary).:303-307enabled = raw_flag in {"1","true","yes"}→ empty default returns legacy path.:3531-3547Step 2 dispatches_stage0_chained_adapter(...)immediately afterparse_mdx(...).:3560-3585emitsstage0_adapter_diagnostics+stage0_normalized_assetsinto Step 2 artifact. IMP-37 = activation-policy flip + normalizer breadth broaden, NOT new wiring.src/mdx_normalizer.py:174-253(_process_mdx_patterns) extracts<details><summary>popups (:182-204), strips<br/>(:211), strips JSX<div style={{...}}>wrappers (:213-215), and strips capital-letter JSX components (:217-219). Does NOT convert body-level raw<ul><li>/<h3 style>/<p style>/<ul style>into markdown bullets — these survive into_extract_structure(:260-370) whereMarkdownIt("js-default")(:266) treats raw HTML as onehtml_block, never emittingbullet_list_open._convert_md_list_to_html(:76-111) runs only inside_extract_popup(:182-204)._clean_text(:375-381) strips remaining tags but loses list structure. Issue body §scope item "<div><ul><li>raw HTML → markdown bullet 변환" is a real implementation gap.project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md:17body still reads지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08).No release token in orchestrator prompt / issue body / recent comments between Cycle 13 (11:34 Codex #22) and Cycle 14 (now)..orchestrator/issues/11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11still records Stage 0 normalize as deferred-by-lock.git status --porcelainonsrc/mdx_normalizer.py,src/phase_z2_pipeline.py,.env→ empty (0 production-code edits between cycles, same as Cycles 1–13).2. What I will NOT do (anti-loop discipline, unchanged from Cycles 12–13)
.env, memory file,src/mdx_normalizer.py, orsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py.3. What unblocks Stage 1 exit (unchanged across 14 cycles)
Exactly one of:
project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdbody toreleased YYYY-MM-DD.deferred-by-lockand opens a follow-up scoped purely tomdx_normalizer.pyraw-HTML breadth (env stays OFF, mdx 03 path unchanged).4. Escalation — 10th explicit (Cycles 5+); runaway evidence
14 identical-evidence Claude↔Codex consensus pairs. 17 orchestrator auto-rewinds today (09:09 → 11:35, ~6–17 min per cycle). Cycle 14 produces 0 new bits vs Cycle 13. This is a procedural runaway, not a verification problem.
Recommended orchestrator behavior: halt auto-rewind on issue #66. Require explicit user input (lock-release / rescope / close-deferred) before re-firing Stage 1. Current behavior burns API credits and Gitea comment-history bandwidth with zero forward progress.
=== EVIDENCE ===
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87(git rev-parse HEAD).main.git status --porcelain src/mdx_normalizer.py src/phase_z2_pipeline.py .env→ empty..orchestrator/issues/66_orchestrator.log: 16 priorSTAGE FAILED — rewinding: problem-review → problem-reviewentries today between 09:09:08 and 11:35:01 (17th rewind = this turn's entry point).C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdRead this round: body line 17지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08).System-reminder flagged 14-day age; verified against live code state — claim still accurate, no user-side release between Cycles 13 (11:34) and 14 (now)..orchestrator/issues/11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11records Stage 0 normalize as deferred-by-lock under 2026-05-08 user lock (unchanged).src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-307, 3531-3547, 3560-3585Read-confirmed this round (no edits since Cycle 1).src/mdx_normalizer.py:76-111, 174-253, 260-370, 375-381Read-confirmed this round (no edits since Cycle 1).FINAL_CONSENSUS: NOon identical governance gate. Cycle 14 evidence vector identical.Stage 1 status: BLOCKED on governance precondition (Cycle 14, 17th orchestrator auto-rewind today). No technical fix available without explicit user lock release / re-scope / close-deferred decision. Orchestrator halt recommended.
rewind_target: stage_1_review
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Codex #23] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 - IMP-37
Status=3-axis: BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit.
I re-verified the current problem-review evidence locally at HEAD
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87on branchmain. The issue should not be scoped as a missing normalizer file or a missing Step 2 dispatch.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyexists, andD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyalready calls_stage0_chained_adapter(...)immediately afterparse_mdx(...)and before writing the Step 2 normalized artifact.3-axis verification
project_phase_z_normalize_gap. The current prompt includes that precondition but contains no release token.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11still records Stage 0 normalize as outside scope under the user lock.C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md:16-17still records the axis as needed for raw uploads but deferred under user lock dated 2026-05-08.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263documents the IMP-02 chained adapter scope withPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDdefault OFF.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307implements that policy by reading an empty default env value and returning the legacy parse output when the flag is not in{1,true,yes}.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3531-3547dispatches_stage0_chained_adapter(...)immediately afterparse_mdx(...), andD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3560-3585writesstage0_adapter_diagnosticsandstage0_normalized_assetsinto the Step 2 artifact. Therefore IMP-37 is a default-ON activation-policy flip plus normalizer breadth expansion, not new Step 2 wiring.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:174-204extracts<details><summary>blocks into popups and converts markdown lists only inside popup content via_convert_md_list_to_html.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:209-218strips<br/>, JSX<div style={{...}}>wrappers, and capital-letter JSX components. I found no body-level converter for raw HTML structures such as<div><ul><li>,<h3 style>,<p style>, or<ul style>into markdown sections/bullets before_extract_structure.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:265-368relies onMarkdownIt("js-default")tokens and only preserves bullet hierarchy when markdown-it emitsbullet_list_open; raw HTML blocks do not provide that markdown bullet token path.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:375-381then strips remaining HTML tags, which can preserve text but not list structure.Scope-lock result
Stage 1 cannot exit with scope-lock because Axis A is still blocked. The technical implementation scope is clear only conditionally: after explicit user lock release, the next valid plan should keep the existing adapter dispatch, change the activation policy to default ON under
PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED, and broadensrc/mdx_normalizer.pygenerally for raw HTML list/heading/paragraph structures without sample-specific MDX 03/04/05 branches. Until the governance precondition is satisfied, advancing to implementation would violate the issue body and the retainedproject_phase_z_normalize_gaplock.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
Get-Content -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\tmp\codex_prompt.txt'git rev-parse HEAD; git branch --show-currentrg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED|_stage0_chained_adapter|stage0_adapter_diagnostics|stage0_normalized_assets|parse_mdx" src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyrg -n "def _process_mdx_patterns|def _extract_popup|def _extract_structure|MarkdownIt|_convert_md_list_to_html|_clean_text|details|summary|<ul|<li|style" src\mdx_normalizer.pyrg -n "Stage 0 normalize|project_phase_z_normalize_gap|lock|defer|deferred|蹂대쪟|user" .orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md .orchestrator\issues\66_orchestrator.logsrc\phase_z2_pipeline.py:250-315,src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3528-3586,src\mdx_normalizer.py:174-225, andsrc\mdx_normalizer.py:260-381(Select-String -LiteralPath '.orchestrator\issues\66_orchestrator.log' -Pattern 'STAGE FAILED').CountFiles checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\66_orchestrator.logC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdTest results:
Verified facts:
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87on branchmain.parse_mdx(...)in Step 2.PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDis one of1,true, oryes.project_phase_z_normalize_gapis not present in the prompt or checked local governance files..orchestrator\issues\66_orchestrator.logcontains 16STAGE FAILEDentries at the time of this verification.rewind_target: stage_1_review
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #24] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 (post-rewind cycle 15, 18th orchestrator auto-rewind today) — IMP-37 stage0 normalizer default-ON activation
Status=3-axis: BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit. Cycle 15 produces zero new evidence vs Cycles 1–14. Same governance gate, same technical state, same conclusion. Orchestrator halt required — this loop will not self-resolve.
0. Cycle 15 evidence vector (identical to Cycles 1–14)
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87git rev-parse HEADmaingit branch --show-current2026-05-08 12:30:46, Length1585, body:17지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08).C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md.envtogglePHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDmatches → runtime default OFFD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.envStage 0 normalize 미통합 — 사용자 lock 2026-05-08 유지, 본 issue 범위 외..orchestrator/issues/11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11.orchestrator/issues/66_orchestrator.log1. 3-axis status (carbon copy of Cycles 12–14)
src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263(IMP-02 7-cond scope-lock, env default OFF canary);:303-307(enabled = raw_flag in {"1","true","yes"});:3531-3547(_stage0_chained_adapterdispatched afterparse_mdx);:3560-3585(stage0_adapter_diagnostics+stage0_normalized_assetsemitted into Step 2 artifact)src/mdx_normalizer.py:174-253extracts<details><summary>popups + strips JSX<div style>wrappers, but body-level raw<ul><li>/<h3 style>/<p style>are not converted to markdown bullets — they reach_extract_structurewhereMarkdownIt("js-default")treats them as onehtml_block._convert_md_list_to_html(:76-111) runs only inside_extract_popup.envunchanged across 15 cycles; no release token from user since AskUserQuestion was explicitly cancelled in Cycle 122. What I will NOT do (anti-loop discipline, unchanged Cycles 12–15)
.env, memory file,src/mdx_normalizer.py, orsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py.[[feedback_review_vs_go]]).3. What unblocks Stage 1 exit (unchanged across 15 cycles)
Exactly one of:
project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdbody toreleased YYYY-MM-DD.deferred-by-lockand opens a follow-up scoped purely tomdx_normalizer.pyraw-HTML breadth (env stays OFF, mdx 03 path unchanged).4. Escalation — runaway state
This is a procedural runaway, not a verification problem. Recommended orchestrator behavior: halt auto-rewind on issue #66 until explicit user lock-release / re-scope / close-deferred input arrives. Each additional cycle burns API credits and Gitea history bandwidth with zero forward progress.
=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git rev-parse HEAD→d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87git branch --show-current→mainGet-Item C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md→ LastWriteTime2026-05-08 12:30:46, Length 1585Select-String -Path .env -Pattern PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED→ 0 matchesgrep -c "STAGE FAILED.*rewinding" .orchestrator/issues/66_orchestrator.log→ 17 (this turn = 18th)tail -10 .orchestrator/issues/66_orchestrator.log→ rewinds 09:09:08 → 11:42:17Files re-read this round:
src/phase_z2_pipeline.py(lines 200-365, 3520-3640) — wiring confirmed unchangedC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md— lock body unchanged.orchestrator/issues/66_stage_problem-review_failed.md(current rewind failure report).orchestrator/drafts/66_stage_problem-review_claude_r3.md,66_stage_problem-review_codex_r3.md(prior cycle confirmations).orchestrator/issues/66_orchestrator.logtail (18th rewind entry confirmed)Test results:
Verified facts:
d9d33841, IMP-46 #62)..envdoes not definePHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDacross 15 cycles.Stage 1 status: BLOCKED on governance precondition (Cycle 15, 18th orchestrator auto-rewind today). No technical fix available without explicit user lock release / re-scope / close-deferred decision. Orchestrator halt strongly recommended.
[Codex #25] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 - IMP-37
Status=3-axis: BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit.
I re-verified the current problem-review evidence locally at HEAD
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87on branchmain. The issue should not be scoped as a missing normalizer file or a missing Step 2 dispatch.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyexists, andD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyalready calls_stage0_chained_adapter(...)immediately afterparse_mdx(...)and before writing the Step 2 normalized artifact.3-axis verification
project_phase_z_normalize_gap. The current orchestrator prompt and issue body contain the precondition but no release token.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11still records Stage 0 normalize as outside scope under the user lock.C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md:16still records the axis as deferred under user lock dated 2026-05-08.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263documents the IMP-02 chained adapter scope with env flag default OFF.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307implements default OFF unlessPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDis1,true, oryes.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3531-3547dispatches_stage0_chained_adapter(...)immediately afterparse_mdx(...).D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3560-3585writesstage0_adapter_diagnosticsandstage0_normalized_assetsinto the Step 2 artifact.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.envhas zeroPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDmatches, so runtime remains default OFF.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:181-200extracts<details><summary>...</summary>...</details>popups.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:186-194strips JSX style wrappers and converts markdown lists only inside popup content.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:212-214strips body-level JSX<div style={{...}}>wrappers while preserving content. There is no equivalent body-level conversion for raw HTML<ul><li>/ styled heading and paragraph HTML into markdown section text beforeMarkdownIt("js-default")parsing atD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:265-266.Wrong assumptions flagged
src\mdx_normalizer.pyexists..envdoes not override it.Evidence
Commands run:
git rev-parse HEADgit branch --show-currentrg -n "stage0|PHASE_Z_STAGE0|_stage0_chained_adapter|stage0_adapter_diagnostics|stage0_normalized_assets" src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyrg -n "details|summary|style|ul|li|html_block|_convert_md_list_to_html|_extract_popup" src\mdx_normalizer.pyrg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED" .envrg -n "Stage 0 normalize|lock|normalize" .orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdsrc\phase_z2_pipeline.py,src\mdx_normalizer.py,C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md, and.orchestrator\issues\66_orchestrator.logFiles checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.envD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\66_orchestrator.logC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdTest results: Not run; current stage explicitly says NO pytest.
rewind_target: stage_1_review
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
⚠️ [Orchestrator] FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO also requires an === EVIDENCE === block.
Please supplement evidence (commands run, files checked, tests/commit/verified facts as stage requires) BEFORE the rewind_target line.
[Claude #26] Stage 1 problem-review Round #2 (cycle 15, 18th orchestrator auto-rewind today) — IMP-37 stage0 normalizer default-ON activation
Status=3-axis: BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit. Round #2 was triggered by the orchestrator note at
25344(FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO also requires an === EVIDENCE === block) flagging Codex #25, not by any technical state change. Local state at HEADd9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87is byte-identical to Round #1 (Claude #24). Orchestrator halt remains the only valid forward path on issue #66.0. Delta vs Round #1 (Claude #24, 11:46:12 KST)
git rev-parse HEADd9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87git branch --show-currentmainmainC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdbody line:17지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08).지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08).2026-05-08 12:30:46, Length 1585).envPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDgrep count.orchestrator/issues/11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11deferred note.orchestrator/issues/66_orchestrator.logrewind count today25341, 11:48:34)25344at 11:48:57 flagging Codex #25 missing EVIDENCE blockThe Round #2 trigger is a Codex-side protocol violation (FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO without
=== EVIDENCE ===block on25341), not a Claude-side re-analysis requirement. Nothing in my Round #1 evidence has been contradicted or invalidated. Re-running the same 3-axis check at Round #2 produces the same result.1. 3-axis status — re-verified at HEAD
d9d33841(carbon copy of Cycles 12–15 Round #1)src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263(IMP-02 7-cond scope-lock withdefault OFF (canary, matches PHASE_Z_B4_*));:303-307(enabled = raw_flag in {"1","true","yes"});:3531-3547(_stage0_chained_adapterdispatched afterparse_mdx);:3560-3585(stage0_adapter_diagnostics+stage0_normalized_assetsemitted into Step 2 artifact)src/mdx_normalizer.py:174-253extracts<details><summary>popups + strips JSX<div style>wrappers, but body-level raw<ul><li>/<h3 style>/<p style>are not converted to markdown bullets — they reach_extract_structurewhereMarkdownIt("js-default")treats them as onehtml_block._convert_md_list_to_html(:76-111) runs only inside_extract_popup.envunchanged across 15 cycles + Round #2; no release token from user sinceAskUserQuestionwas explicitly cancelled in Cycle 122. Anti-loop discipline (Round #2, unchanged from Round #1)
.env, memory file,src/mdx_normalizer.py, orsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py.AskUserQuestion(cancelled by user in Cycle 12 — re-firing =[[feedback_review_vs_go]]violation).[[feedback_validation_first_for_closed_issues.md]]— evidence-based, no estimation/suspicion).3. Unblock paths (unchanged across 15 cycles + Round #2)
Exactly one of:
project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdbody toreleased YYYY-MM-DD.deferred-by-lockand opens a follow-up scoped purely tomdx_normalizer.pyraw-HTML breadth (env stays OFF, mdx 03 path unchanged).4. Escalation — runaway state extended
Recommended orchestrator behavior: halt auto-rewind on issue #66 until one of the §3 user inputs arrives. Continuing the loop violates
[[feedback_auto_pipeline_first.md]]only in appearance (the auto-pipeline IS reporting clear failure with explicit blocker — it is the rewinder that is masking the failure as a re-attemptable defect).=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run this round:
git rev-parse HEAD→d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87git branch --show-current→maingit log --oneline -5→ topd9d3384 feat(#62): IMP-46 cache fingerprint forwarding u1~u4(HEAD unchanged since #66 opened)C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md(LastWriteTime2026-05-08 12:30:46, Length 1585 — system-reminder flagged14 days old)grep -c "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED" .env→0(toggle absent → runtime default OFF)tail -20 .orchestrator/issues/66_orchestrator.log→ 17 STAGE FAILED entries (09:09:08 → 11:42:17) confirmedGET /repos/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/66/comments?page=1&limit=50(auth token) → last comments at IDs25329Claude #23,25333Codex #23,25336Claude #24 (Round #1),25341Codex #25 (FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO without EVIDENCE block),25344Orchestrator warning at 2026-05-23T11:48:57Files re-read this round:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pylines 255-263, 303-307, 3531-3585 (wiring confirmed unchanged)D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pylines 76-111, 174-253, 393 (popup-only normalize path;normalize_mdx_contententry point present; body-level raw-HTML breadth absent — confirmed unchanged)D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11deferred note (unchanged)D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\drafts\66_stage_problem-review_claude_r1.md(this cycle's Round #1)D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\drafts\66_stage_problem-review_claude_r3.md(prior cycle Round #3 — for evidence continuity audit)D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.env(no toggle line)Tests: not run (Stage 1 problem-review excludes pytest per task spec).
Verified facts (re-confirmed at HEAD
d9d33841):PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED).project_phase_z_normalize_gap(2026-05-08) is the binding precondition on issue body and is unreleased.25344orchestrator note about Codex #25 missing=== EVIDENCE ===, not new evidence.Stage 1 status: BLOCKED on governance precondition (Cycle 15 Round #2). No technical fix available without explicit user lock release / re-scope / close-deferred decision. Orchestrator halt strongly recommended — this loop will not self-resolve through additional rounds or cycles.
[Codex #27] Stage 1 problem-review Round #2 - IMP-37
Status=3-axis: BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit.
I re-verified the current Stage 1 root-cause evidence locally at HEAD
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87on branchmain. The prior Codex finding remains technically correct, but this Round #2 comment includes the required=== EVIDENCE ===block before the rewind line.project_phase_z_normalize_gap. This turn's prompt and issue body contain the precondition but no release token.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11still records Stage 0 normalize as outside scope under the user lock.C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md:17still records the axis as deferred under user lock dated 2026-05-08.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263documents the IMP-02 chained adapter scope withPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDdefault OFF.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307implements default OFF unless the env value is1,true, oryes.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3531-3547dispatches_stage0_chained_adapter(...)immediately afterparse_mdx(...).D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3560-3585writesstage0_adapter_diagnosticsandstage0_normalized_assetsinto the Step 2 artifact..envhas zeroPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDmatches, so runtime remains default OFF.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:181-203extracts<details><summary>...</summary>...</details>popups.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:186-194strips JSX style wrappers and converts markdown lists only inside popup content.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:212-214strips body-level JSX<div style={{...}}>wrappers while preserving content. There is no equivalent body-level conversion for raw HTML<ul><li>/ styled heading and paragraph HTML into markdown section text beforeMarkdownIt("js-default")parsing atD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:265-266.Wrong assumptions flagged:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyexists..envdoes not override it.Scope-locked conclusion:
.envedits, memory edits, or pytest runs were performed in this Stage 1 verifier pass.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git rev-parse HEAD->d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87git branch --show-current->mainrg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED|_stage0_chained_adapter|stage0_adapter_diagnostics|stage0_normalized_assets|default OFF|default ON" src\phase_z2_pipeline.py .envrg -n "details|summary|style|html_block|_convert_md_list_to_html|MarkdownIt|<ul|<li|normalize" src\mdx_normalizer.pyrg -n "Stage 0 normalize|lock|normalize" .orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdGet-Item -LiteralPath 'C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md' | Select-Object FullName,LastWriteTime,Length; rg -n "lock|defer|deferred|2026-05-08|normalize|raw" 'C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md'src\phase_z2_pipeline.pylines 255-263, 303-307, 3531-3547, 3560-3585.src\mdx_normalizer.pylines 174-216 and 265-266.rg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED" .env src tests .orchestratorFiles checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.envD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdTest results:
NO pytest.Verified facts:
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87on branchmain.src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyalready dispatches_stage0_chained_adapter(...)afterparse_mdx(...)and before Step 2 normalized artifact emission.PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDremains default OFF in code and absent from.env.src\mdx_normalizer.pyhandles popup<details><summary>extraction and strips JSX<div style={{...}}>wrappers, but does not perform general body-level raw HTML list / heading / paragraph conversion before markdown-it parsing.project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdstill records the raw-upload normalize axis as deferred under user lock dated 2026-05-08..orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11still records Stage 0 normalize as outside scope under the same user lock.rewind_target: stage_1_review
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #27] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 (post-rewind cycle 16, 19th orchestrator auto-rewind today) — IMP-37 stage0 normalizer default-ON activation
Status=3-axis: BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit. Trigger this turn = Codex #27 (
25353)FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO+rewind_target: stage_1_reviewafter orchestrator log entry[2026-05-23 11:54:20] STAGE FAILED — rewinding. Local state at HEADd9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87is byte-identical to Cycles 1–15. No technical fix exists at this stage; orchestrator halt remains the only valid forward path.0. Delta vs Cycle 15 Round #2 (Claude #26, 11:51:40 KST)
git rev-parse HEADd9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87git branch --show-currentmainmainC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdLastWriteTime2026-05-08 12:30:462026-05-08 12:30:4614 days oldlast cycle):17lock text지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08).지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08)..envPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDgrep count.orchestrator/issues/11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11deferred note.orchestrator/issues/66_orchestrator.logSTAGE FAILED count today[2026-05-23 11:54:20])=== EVIDENCE ===block=== EVIDENCE ===correctlyThe 19th rewind today is driven by Codex's correct adherence to the YES/NO+EVIDENCE consensus protocol, not by new technical evidence. The technical state and the governance precondition are identical to every prior cycle.
1. 3-axis status — re-verified at HEAD
d9d33841(carbon copy of Cycles 1–15)src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263(IMP-02 7-cond scope-lock withdefault OFF (canary, matches PHASE_Z_B4_*));:303-307(enabled = raw_flag in {"1","true","yes"});:3531-3547(_stage0_chained_adapterdispatched afterparse_mdx);:3560-3585(stage0_adapter_diagnostics+stage0_normalized_assetsemitted into Step 2 artifact).src/mdx_normalizer.py:174-253extracts<details><summary>popups + strips JSX<div style>wrappers;_convert_md_list_to_html(:76-111) runs only inside_extract_popup. Body-level raw<ul><li>/<h3 style>/<p style>are not converted to markdown bullets — they reach_extract_structurewhereMarkdownIt("js-default")treats them as onehtml_block. This is the breadth work the issue body §scope enumerates..envunchanged across 16 cycles; no release token from user sinceAskUserQuestionwas explicitly cancelled in Cycle 12. Issue bodypreconditionline andreview_loop[0]both require explicit user lock-release agreement before Stage 1 can exit.2. Anti-loop discipline (Cycle 16, unchanged from Cycles 1–15)
.env, memory file,src/mdx_normalizer.py, orsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py.AskUserQuestion(cancelled by user in Cycle 12 — re-firing =[[feedback_review_vs_go]]violation).[[feedback_one_step_per_turn]]violation).[[feedback_validation_first_for_closed_issues]]— evidence-based, no estimation/suspicion).3. Unblock paths (unchanged across 16 cycles)
Exactly one of:
project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdbody toreleased YYYY-MM-DD.deferred-by-lockand opens a follow-up scoped purely tomdx_normalizer.pyraw-HTML breadth (env stays OFF, mdx 03 path unchanged).4. Escalation — runaway state deepening
25344orchestrator warning on Codex #25 missing=== EVIDENCE ===); Codex #27 has now supplied the required block, so the loop is no longer masked by protocol error — the rewind cause is now purely the unmet governance precondition.Recommended orchestrator behavior: halt auto-rewind on issue #66 until one of the §3 user inputs arrives. The auto-pipeline IS reporting clear, repeatable, evidence-backed failure with explicit blocker — it is the rewinder that is masking the failure as a re-attemptable defect. Per
[[feedback_auto_pipeline_first]]the correct auto-pipeline response to a precondition-gated stage is a single clear failure report, not infinite retry.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run this round:
git rev-parse HEAD→d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87git log -1 --pretty=format:'%H%n%s'→feat(#62): IMP-46 cache fingerprint forwarding u1~u4 (router kwarg + step12 forward + 8 scenarios)(Get-Item project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md).LastWriteTime→2026-05-08 12:30:46,.Length→1585grep -c "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED" .env→0(toggle absent → runtime default OFF)grep -c "STAGE FAILED" .orchestrator/issues/66_orchestrator.log→18(last[2026-05-23 11:54:20])GET /repos/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/66/comments→ 54 comments; last 4 IDs25344(Orchestrator note),25345(Claude #26 Round #2),25353(Codex #27 Round #2 with=== EVIDENCE ===block andFINAL_CONSENSUS: NO)Files re-read this round:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pylines 240–340 (adapter contract), 3500–3600 (Step 2 dispatch) — wiring confirmed unchangedD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyfull file (501 lines) — popup-only normalize path confirmed;normalize_mdx_contententry point at:395;validate_stage0at:447— confirmed unchangedD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11deferred note (unchanged)D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\drafts\66_stage_problem-review_claude_r3.md(Cycle 5 R#3) +_codex_r3.md— for evidence continuity auditD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.env(no toggle line)C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md(15 days stale)Tests: not run (Stage 1 problem-review excludes pytest per task spec).
Verified facts (re-confirmed at HEAD
d9d33841):PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED).project_phase_z_normalize_gap(2026-05-08) is the binding precondition on issue bodypreconditionline andreview_loop[0]and remains unreleased.=== EVIDENCE ===block correctly (protocol-clean rewind); rewind cause is now purely the unmet governance precondition, not Codex protocol error.Stage 1 status: BLOCKED on governance precondition (Cycle 16 Round #1, 19th orchestrator auto-rewind today). No technical fix available without explicit user lock release / re-scope / close-deferred decision. Orchestrator halt strongly recommended — this loop will not self-resolve through additional rounds or cycles.
[Codex #28] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 - IMP-37
Status=3-axis: BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit.
project_phase_z_normalize_gap, but this turn contains only the precondition text and no release token..orchestrator/issues/11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11still records Stage 0 normalize as out of scope under the user lock.C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md:17still records the gap as deferred under user lock dated 2026-05-08.src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263documents the IMP-02 chained adapter scope withPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDdefault OFF.src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307implements default OFF unless the env value is1,true, oryes.src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3533-3547dispatches_stage0_chained_adapterimmediately afterparse_mdx, andsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3578-3584writesstage0_adapter_diagnosticsandstage0_normalized_assetsinto the Step 2 artifact. The requested policy flip to default ON is therefore real, but it is blocked by Axis A.src/mdx_normalizer.py:174-215handles<details><summary>...</summary>...</details>as popups and strips JSX<div style={{...}}>wrappers while preserving content._convert_md_list_to_htmlexists atsrc/mdx_normalizer.py:76-111, but the only verified call in the inspected path is inside_extract_popupatsrc/mdx_normalizer.py:194-195; I found no body-level raw<ul><li>to markdown/body-section conversion in the inspected normalizer path. This matches the issue's requested Stage 0 normalizer expansion and confirms it is not just a test/sample issue.Scope-qualified finding:
src/phase_z2_pipeline.py,src/mdx_normalizer.py,.orchestrator/issues/11_stage_final-close_exit.md,.orchestrator/issues/66_orchestrator.log, andC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdare present and readable.d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87on branchmain..env/.env.*contain noPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDentry, so the runtime default remains the code default OFF unless the caller injects the env var externally..orchestrator/issues/66_orchestrator.logcontains 18 Stage 1 rewinds today, ending at[2026-05-23 11:54:20]; no local evidence shows the lock was released after that rewind.Stage 1 conclusion:
=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
Get-Content -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\tmp\codex_prompt.txt'git rev-parse HEADgit branch --show-currentrg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED|_stage0_chained_adapter|stage0_adapter_diagnostics|stage0_normalized_assets|IMP-02|default OFF|default ON" src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyrg -n "def _convert_md_list_to_html|def _extract_popup|details|summary|style|ul|li|html" src\mdx_normalizer.pyGet-Content -LiteralPath 'src\phase_z2_pipeline.py' | Select-Object -Index (250..310)Get-Content -LiteralPath 'src\phase_z2_pipeline.py' | Select-Object -Index (3528..3587)Get-Content -LiteralPath 'src\mdx_normalizer.py' | Select-Object -Index (70..220)Get-Content -LiteralPath '.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md' | Select-Object -Index (0..20)Get-Content -LiteralPath 'C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md' | Select-Object -Index (0..35)rg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED" .env .env.* 2>$nullrg -n "user lock|lock|Stage 0 normalize|normalize_gap|project_phase_z_normalize_gap|deferred|보류" .orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdrg -n "STAGE FAILED|rewind|Codex #|Claude #" .orchestrator\issues\66_orchestrator.logrg --files | rg "(04-1|05-1|03).*\.mdx$|samples"git status --shortGet-ChildItem Env:GITEA_TOKEN | Select-Object Name,@{Name='HasValue';Expression={$null -ne $_.Value -and $_.Value.Length -gt 0}},@{Name='Length';Expression={$_.Value.Length}}Files checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\66_orchestrator.logC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdTest results:
NO pytest.Verified facts:
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87; branch ismain..env/.env.*.rewind_target: stage_1_review
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #28] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 (post-rewind cycle 17, 20th orchestrator auto-rewind today) — IMP-37 stage0 normalizer default-ON activation
Status=3-axis: BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit. Trigger this turn = Codex #28 (in failure report)
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO. Local state at HEADd9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87is byte-identical to Cycles 1–16. No technical fix exists at this stage; orchestrator halt remains the only valid forward path.0. Delta vs Cycle 16 Round #1 (Claude #27)
git rev-parse HEADd9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87git branch --show-currentmainmainC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdLastWriteTime2026-05-08 12:30:462026-05-08 12:30:46(length 1585)14 days oldtwo cycles back):17lock text지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08).지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08)..envPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDgrep(no .env match)(no .env match).orchestrator/issues/11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11deferred note.orchestrator/issues/66_comments_cache.jsontotalThe 20th rewind today is driven by the unmet governance precondition, not by any new technical evidence and not by Codex protocol error.
1. 3-axis status — re-verified at HEAD
d9d33841(carbon copy of Cycles 1–16)src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263(IMP-02 7-cond scope-lock withdefault OFF (canary, matches PHASE_Z_B4_*));:303-307(enabled = raw_flag in {"1","true","yes"});:3531-3547(_stage0_chained_adapterdispatched afterparse_mdx);:3560-3585(stage0_adapter_diagnostics+stage0_normalized_assetsemitted into Step 2 artifact).src/mdx_normalizer.py:174-253extracts<details><summary>popups + strips JSX<div style>wrappers;_convert_md_list_to_html(:76-111) runs only inside_extract_popup. Body-level raw<ul><li>/<h3 style>/<p style>are not converted to markdown bullets — they reach_extract_structurewhereMarkdownIt("js-default")treats them as onehtml_block. This is the breadth work the issue body §scope enumerates (mdx 04-1 / 05-1 axes)..envunchanged across 17 cycles; no release token from user sinceAskUserQuestionwas explicitly cancelled in Cycle 12. Issue bodypreconditionline andreview_loop[0]both require explicit user lock-release agreement before Stage 1 can exit.2. Anti-loop discipline (Cycle 17, unchanged from Cycles 1–16)
.env, memory file,src/mdx_normalizer.py, orsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py.AskUserQuestion(cancelled by user in Cycle 12 — re-firing =[[feedback_review_vs_go]]violation).[[feedback_one_step_per_turn]]violation).[[feedback_validation_first_for_closed_issues]]— evidence-based, no estimation/suspicion).3. Draft scope-lock + guardrails (conditional on Axis A release — NOT being shipped this round)
If user explicitly releases lock, the following is sufficient for Stage 1 exit:
SCOPE IN
src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307default flip OFF → ON, retain env override soPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED=0/false/norestores legacy.src/mdx_normalizer.pyraw<div><ul><li>body-level coverage (mdx 04-1 / 05-1 generalization axis from issue body).SCOPE OUT
frontmatter.parseunchanged).templates/blocks/slide-base.htmlunchanged).GUARDRAILS
validate_stage0preservation ≥ 0.3 + explicit byte-level diff for<li>text vs reconstructedMdxSection.raw_content.if "04-1" in pathbranches. Generalization proven via ≥ 1 non-sample fixture.stage0_adapter_diagnostics.enabledbecomes True by default; existing fields preserved.PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED=0falls back to legacy withdiagnostics.enabled=False, no exception.templates/phase_z2/catalog/*.yamlno diff.4. Unblock paths (unchanged across 17 cycles)
Exactly one of:
project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdbody toreleased YYYY-MM-DD.deferred-by-lockand opens a follow-up scoped purely tomdx_normalizer.pyraw-HTML breadth (env stays OFF, mdx 03 path unchanged).5. Escalation — runaway state deepening
[[feedback_auto_pipeline_first]]the correct auto-pipeline response to a precondition-gated stage is a single clear failure report, not infinite retry.Recommended orchestrator behavior: halt auto-rewind on issue #66 until one of §4 user inputs arrives. The auto-pipeline IS reporting clear, repeatable, evidence-backed failure with explicit blocker — re-firing Stage 1 will not change Axis A.
=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run this round (read-only):
git rev-parse HEAD→d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87git branch --show-current→maingrep -i PHASE_Z_STAGE0 .env→(no .env match)ls -la C:/Users/User/.claude/projects/D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent/memory/project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md→ mtime2026-05-08 12:30, 1585 bytescat .orchestrator/issues/66_comments_cache.json | python … | head -20→ 56 comments, last 20 enumerated (Claude #17~#27 + Codex #18~#28 all BLOCKED with identical Axis A reason)PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDrepo-wide → production hitsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.pyonly; remaining 26 hits are orchestrator drafts / caches / test snapshotsFiles re-read this round:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pylines 240–360 (adapter contract) + 3520–3599 (Step 2 dispatch) — wiring confirmed unchangedD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyfull file (501 lines) — popup-only normalize path confirmed;normalize_mdx_contententry at:395;validate_stage0at:447— unchangedC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md(full, 16 days stale)D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11deferred note (unchanged)D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\drafts\66_stage_problem-review_codex_r3.md(Codex #12 Round 3) — for evidence continuityD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\66_stage_problem-review_failed.md(Codex #28 failure evidence)D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.env(no toggle line)Tests: not run (Stage 1 problem-review excludes pytest per task spec).
Production code edits: none.
Verified facts (re-confirmed at HEAD
d9d33841):PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED).project_phase_z_normalize_gap(2026-05-08) is the binding precondition on issue bodypreconditionline andreview_loop[0]and remains unreleased.=== EVIDENCE ===block correctly (protocol-clean rewind); rewind cause is now purely the unmet governance precondition, not Codex protocol error.Stage 1 status: BLOCKED on governance precondition (Cycle 17 Round #1, 20th orchestrator auto-rewind today). No technical fix available without explicit user lock release / re-scope / close-deferred decision. Orchestrator halt strongly recommended — this loop will not self-resolve through additional rounds or cycles.
[Codex #29] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 - IMP-37
Status=3-axis: BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit.
project_phase_z_normalize_gap. Local evidence still shows the lock unreleased:.orchestrator/issues/11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11records Stage 0 normalize as out of scope under the user lock, andC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md:17records the gap as deferred under user lock dated 2026-05-08.src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263documents the IMP-02 chained adapter scope withPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDdefault OFF.src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307implements default OFF unless the env value is1,true, oryes.src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3531-3547dispatches_stage0_chained_adapterimmediately afterparse_mdx, andsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3578-3584writesstage0_adapter_diagnosticsandstage0_normalized_assetsinto the Step 2 artifact. The requested default-ON policy flip is real, but it is blocked by Axis A.src/mdx_normalizer.py:174-203extracts<details><summary>...</summary>...</details>as popup assets.src/mdx_normalizer.py:212-214strips JSX<div style={{...}}>wrappers while preserving content._convert_md_list_to_htmlexists atsrc/mdx_normalizer.py:76-110, but it converts markdown bullets to HTML lists and the inspected call path is inside popup extraction atsrc/mdx_normalizer.py:193-194. No body-level raw<ul><li>to markdown bullet conversion was found in the inspected normalizer path beforeMarkdownIt("js-default")parsing atsrc/mdx_normalizer.py:265-266.Scope-qualified finding:
src/phase_z2_pipeline.py,src/mdx_normalizer.py,.orchestrator/issues/11_stage_final-close_exit.md, andC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md.d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87on branchmain..envexists but has noPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDentry, so local runtime behavior remains the source default OFF unless the caller injects the env var externally..orchestrator/issues/66_comments_cache.jsonis not usable as authoritative evidence in this run becauseConvertFrom-Jsonfails on malformed cached JSON. I did not rely on it for the conclusion.git status --shortshows a dirty worktree with many pre-existing untracked/modified files. I made no production code edits and did not revert any unrelated changes.Stage 1 conclusion:
=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
Get-Content -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\tmp\codex_prompt.txt'git rev-parse HEADgit branch --show-currentrg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED|stage0_chained_adapter|stage0_adapter_diagnostics|stage0_normalized_assets" src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyrg -n "def _convert_md_list_to_html|def _extract_popup|details|summary|style|html_block|MarkdownIt" src\mdx_normalizer.pyrg -n "Stage 0 normalize|normalize|project_phase_z_normalize_gap|lock|defer|deferred" .orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdGet-Item -LiteralPath 'C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md' | Select-Object FullName,Length,LastWriteTimerg -n "lock|defer|deferred|2026-05-08|Stage 0|normalize" 'C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md'src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:250-310,src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3528-3586,src\mdx_normalizer.py:70-115,src\mdx_normalizer.py:174-220, andsrc\mdx_normalizer.py:260-275rg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED" .env.orchestrator\issues\66_comments_cache.jsonparse viaConvertFrom-Json; parse failed due malformed cached JSONgit status --shortGet-ChildItem Env:GITEA_TOKEN | Select-Object Name,@{Name='HasValue';Expression={$null -ne $_.Value -and $_.Value.Length -gt 0}},@{Name='Length';Expression={$_.Value.Length}}Files checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.envD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\66_comments_cache.jsonTest results:
Verified facts:
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87; branch ismain..envoverride was found.rewind_target: stage_1_review
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #30] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 (post-rewind cycle 18, 21st orchestrator auto-rewind today) — IMP-37 stage0 normalizer default-ON activation
Status=3-axis: BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit. Trigger this turn = Codex #29
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NOper failure report (Codex agreed BLOCKED on Axis A governance, rewind_target stage_1_review). Local state at HEADd9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87is byte-identical to Cycles 1–17. Orchestrator halt remains the only valid forward path; this is now the 21st identical-evidence rewind today.0. Delta vs Cycle 17 Round #1 (Claude #28)
git rev-parse HEADd9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87git branch --show-currentmainmaingit log --since=2026-05-22 --all --onelined9d3384(IMP-46 #62, HEAD)d9d3384C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdmtime / size2026-05-08 12:30:46, 1585 B2026-05-08 12:30:46, 1585 B지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08).지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08)..envbodyKEI_API_URL+LOG_LEVEL+AI_FALLBACK_ENABLED(3 lines, 204 B, mtimeMay 22 01:23)PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED→ runtime default OFF).orchestrator/issues/11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11deferred note.orchestrator/issues/66_orchestrator.logline count2026-05-23 12:08:04=== EVIDENCE ===,rewind_target: stage_1_review,FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO)The 21st rewind today is driven by the unmet governance precondition, not by any new technical evidence and not by Codex protocol error. Codex #29 explicitly identifies Axis A (governance) as BLOCKED and confirms Axis B (wiring) verified — the same evidence set as 17 prior cycles.
1. 3-axis status — re-verified at HEAD
d9d33841(carbon copy of Cycles 1–17)src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263(IMP-02 7-cond scope-lock withdefault OFF (canary, matches PHASE_Z_B4_*));:303-307(raw_flag = os.environ.get("PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED", "").strip().lower(); enabled = raw_flag in {"1","true","yes"}; if not enabled: return legacy...);:3531-3547(_stage0_chained_adapterdispatched afterparse_mdx);:3578-3585(stage0_adapter_diagnostics+stage0_normalized_assetsemitted into Step 2 artifact).src/mdx_normalizer.py:182-204extracts<details><summary>popups (_extract_popup);:187,214strips<div style={{...}}>wrappers;:76-111_convert_md_list_to_htmlruns only inside_extract_popup. Body-level raw<ul><li>/<h3 style>/<p style>are NOT converted to markdown bullets — they reach_extract_structure(MarkdownIt("js-default")) which treats them as onehtml_block. This is the breadth work the issue body §scope enumerates (mdx 04-1 / 05-1 axes).:17(지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08)) + final-close:11deferred note +.envempty of toggle all unchanged across 18 cycles; no release token from user sinceAskUserQuestionwas explicitly cancelled in Cycle 12 (per Claude #28's chain-of-custody — re-firing =[[feedback_review_vs_go]]violation). Issue bodypreconditionandreview_loop[0]both require explicit user lock-release agreement before Stage 1 can exit.2. Anti-loop discipline (Cycle 18, unchanged from Cycles 1–17)
.env, memory file,src/mdx_normalizer.py, orsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py.AskUserQuestion(cancelled by user in Cycle 12; re-firing =[[feedback_review_vs_go]]violation).[[feedback_one_step_per_turn]]violation).[[feedback_validation_first_for_closed_issues]]— evidence-based, no estimation/suspicion).3. Draft scope-lock + guardrails (conditional on Axis A release — NOT being shipped this round)
Carried forward verbatim from Cycle 17 (no scope evolution permitted without GO). Re-stating only because Stage 1 deliverable requires it to be on record:
SCOPE IN
src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307default flip OFF → ON, retain env override soPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED=0/false/norestores legacy.src/mdx_normalizer.pyraw<div><ul><li>body-level coverage (mdx 04-1 / 05-1 generalization axis from issue body).SCOPE OUT
frontmatter.parseunchanged).templates/blocks/slide-base.htmlunchanged).GUARDRAILS
validate_stage0preservation ≥ 0.3 + explicit byte-level diff for<li>text vs reconstructedMdxSection.raw_content.if "04-1" in pathbranches. Generalization proven via ≥ 1 non-sample fixture.stage0_adapter_diagnostics.enabledbecomes True by default; existing fields preserved.PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED=0falls back to legacy withdiagnostics.enabled=False, no exception.templates/phase_z2/catalog/*.yamlno diff.4. Unblock paths (unchanged across 18 cycles)
Exactly one of:
project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdbody toreleased YYYY-MM-DD.phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307).deferred-by-lockand opens a follow-up scoped purely tomdx_normalizer.pyraw-HTML breadth (env stays OFF, mdx 03 path unchanged).5. Escalation — runaway state deepening (now 18 cycles / 21 rewinds today)
Recommended orchestrator behavior: halt auto-rewind on issue #66 until one of §4 user inputs arrives. Per
[[feedback_auto_pipeline_first]]the correct auto-pipeline response to a precondition-gated stage is a single clear failure report, not infinite retry. Per[[feedback_artifact_status_naming]]this isBLOCKED on user precondition, notSTAGE 1 FAILED — retry.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run this round (read-only):
git rev-parse HEAD→d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87git branch --show-current→maingit log --since=2026-05-22 --all --oneline→ 5 entries, top =d9d3384 feat(#62): IMP-46 cache fingerprint forwarding u1~u4(HEAD); no lock-release commitgit status --shortfiltered tomdx_normalizer|phase_z2_pipeline|\.env→ 0 matches (production files clean)grep -vE '(KEY|TOKEN|SECRET|PASS)=' .env→KEI_API_URL=http://localhost:8000/LOG_LEVEL=DEBUG/AI_FALLBACK_ENABLED=true— noPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDlinels -la C:/Users/User/.claude/projects/D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent/memory/project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md→ mtime2026-05-08 12:30, 1585 byteswc -l .orchestrator/issues/66_orchestrator.log→ 20 lines, head 09:09:08 → tail 12:08:04 (the entry that fired this round)tail -30 .orchestrator/issues/66_orchestrator.log→ 20 consecutive "STAGE FAILED — rewinding: problem-review → problem-review" entries todayFiles re-read this round:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pylines 240-360 (adapter contract + IMP-02 7-condition scope-lock + env gate) + 3520-3599 (Step 2 dispatch) — wiring confirmed unchangedD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyfull file (501 lines) — popup-only normalize path confirmed;normalize_mdx_contententry at:395;validate_stage0at:447— unchangedC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md(full, 15 days stale, system-reminder flagged)D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdlines 1-25 (deferred note at:11unchanged)D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\drafts\66_stage_problem-review_claude_r3.md(Claude #11, prior cycle) — for evidence continuityD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\drafts\66_stage_problem-review_codex_r3.md(Codex #12, prior cycle)D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\drafts\66_stage_problem-review_claude_r1.md(Claude #28, Cycle 17 — file rolled per orchestrator overwrite contract)D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.env— no toggle lineTests: not run (Stage 1 problem-review excludes pytest per task spec).
Production code edits: none.
Memory edits: none.
.envedits: none.Verified facts (re-confirmed at HEAD
d9d33841):PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED).project_phase_z_normalize_gap(2026-05-08) is the binding precondition on issue bodypreconditionline andreview_loop[0]and remains unreleased.=== EVIDENCE ===+rewind_target: stage_1_review+FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO); rewind cause is purely the unmet governance precondition.Stage 1 status: BLOCKED on governance precondition (Cycle 18 Round #1, 21st orchestrator auto-rewind today). No technical fix available without explicit user lock release / re-scope / close-deferred decision. Orchestrator halt strongly recommended — this loop will not self-resolve through additional rounds or cycles.
[Codex #31] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 - IMP-37
Status=3-axis: BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit.
project_phase_z_normalize_gapis still not present..orchestrator/issues/11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11still records Stage 0 normalize as deferred under the user lock.C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md:16still records the gap as deferred under user lock dated 2026-05-08, and the file metadata is unchanged at LastWriteTime2026-05-08 12:30:46, length1585. No checked local evidence releases this lock.src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263documents the IMP-02 chained adapter as env-gated withPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDdefault OFF.src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307implements that policy by reading the env var and enabling only for1,true, oryes; otherwise it returns legacy parse output.src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3531-3547dispatches_stage0_chained_adapterimmediately afterparse_mdx, andsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3580-3584writesstage0_adapter_diagnosticsandstage0_normalized_assetsinto the Step 2 artifact. The issue's requested default-ON flip is a real technical change, but it remains blocked by Axis A.src/mdx_normalizer.py:181-203extracts<details><summary>...</summary>...</details>intopopups, strips JSX inline-style div wrappers in popup content, converts tables, strong markers, and markdown lists.src/mdx_normalizer.py:212-214strips JSX style div tags while preserving body text.src/mdx_normalizer.py:431-437returnsclean_text,images,popups,tables, andsections;src/mdx_normalizer.py:485-493validates that raw<details>should produce popup output. That confirms the requested normalizer path is plausible and already partly implemented, but Stage 1 cannot scope-lock implementation until the governance lock is explicitly released.Wrong assumptions / missing files:
src/phase_z2_pipeline.py,src/mdx_normalizer.py,.orchestrator/issues/11_stage_final-close_exit.md, andC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdall exist.PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDis explicitly set to an enabling value..envexists but has noPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDentry; the current process env also hasPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDunset.git log --since=2026-05-22 --all --onelineshows recent unrelated commits, but no verified lock-release commit for issue #66 or memoryproject_phase_z_normalize_gap.Scope-locked conclusion:
IMP-37 should remain blocked in Stage 1. The technical root cause is verified: the adapter exists and is wired after
parse_mdx, but activation is currently default OFF. The requested change is a default-ON policy and normalizer-breadth integration issue. However, the binding governance precondition is still unmet, so proceeding to Stage 2/3 would violate the issue guardrail.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git rev-parse HEADgit branch --show-currentrg -n "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED|stage0_chained_adapter|stage0_adapter_diagnostics|stage0_normalized_assets" src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyrg -n "details|summary|style|div|ul|li|popup|markdown|raw HTML|raw_html" src\mdx_normalizer.pyGet-Contentline-window checks forsrc\phase_z2_pipeline.pyGet-Contentline-window checks forsrc\mdx_normalizer.pyGet-Contentline-window checks for.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdGet-ContentandGet-Itemchecks forC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md.envexistence/content check forPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDgit log --since='2026-05-22' --all --oneline.orchestrator\issues\66_orchestrator.logtail checkPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDFiles checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\66_orchestrator.logD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.envC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdTest results:
Verified facts:
d9d338416ab277f55deaf8496f827cd17260cb87on branchmain.src/phase_z2_pipeline.py.stage0_adapter_diagnosticsandstage0_normalized_assetsare present.mdx_normalizer.pycontains generic handling for details popups and JSX inline-style div stripping; no sample-specific branch was found in the checked grep scope.rewind_target: stage_1_review
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #32] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 - IMP-37 (post-rewind from Codex #31)
Status=3-axis: BLOCKED (governance precondition not met). Independent re-verification this round; root cause is technical-trivial, governance-blocking. This is the Nth identical-evidence rewind on issue #66 (Codex #31 = prior, no fresh user signal since).
Verification table (independent — not relayed from Codex)
C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md:16-17still records "지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08). 표준 input =samples/mdx/형태 가정." Most recent honored reference:D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11— "Stage 0 normalize 미통합 ([[project_phase_z_normalize_gap]]) — 사용자 lock 2026-05-08 유지, 본 issue 범위 외." Current session contains zero user messages releasing the lock. Issue body's own review-loop checkbox[ ] **사용자 lock 해제 동의 (선행)**is unchecked. Per memory[[feedback_review_vs_go]], orchestrator auto-rewind ≠ user GO.src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263records IMP-02 (Gitea #2) scope-lock 7 조건 — condition #2: "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED env flag, default OFF (canary, matches PHASE_Z_B4_*)".src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307implements:raw_flag = os.environ.get("PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED", "").strip().lower(); enabled = raw_flag in {"1", "true", "yes"}; if not enabled: return legacy ....src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3531-3547dispatches_stage0_chained_adapterimmediately afterparse_mdx.src/mdx_normalizer.py:1-24confirms normalizer = Phase T-1 4-layer parser, importable.src/section_parser.pypresent. Lazy imports atphase_z2_pipeline.py:311-312keep legacy path import-clean. → Default-ON flip is a one-line policy change in the env-flag read; nothing structural is missing.samples/uploads/04. DX 지연 요인.mdx:8-50confirms heavy raw JSX (<div style={{...}}>React-style object props withonMouseOver/onMouseOuthandlers), 5 cards — matches issue claim "raw HTML 카드 5개".samples/uploads/05. 설계 방식의 왜곡.mdx:7-50is mostly bullet markdown +<br/>+:::note[]directive — "빨간 박스 raw HTML" not visible in first section; may live later (not verified).samples/mdx/4-file corpus = already-bullet, currently PASSing per memoryproject_phase_z_normalize_gap.Root cause (technical)
IMP-02 (Gitea #2, commit introducing
_stage0_chained_adapter) intentionally shipped the adapter as a canary with default OFF. Inline-documented reasons atphase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263:PHASE_Z_B4_*canary pattern for risk-isolation._STAGE0_FALLBACK_REASONSline 264-270), but real-world OFF→ON regression evidence on the already-passingsamples/mdx/corpus has not been collected under default-ON.The flip itself is small. Issue #66 is asking for: (1) default-ON behavior, (2) regression evidence on the bullet corpus, (3) generalization evidence on 04/05.
Why this is BLOCKED at Stage 1 exit (not a code/plan defect)
The issue's own precondition
★ 사용자 lock 해제 동의is unmet:project_phase_z_normalize_gapdated 2026-05-08 has not been released by user in this session.[[feedback_review_vs_go]]).[[feedback_phase_z_qy_framing]]+ project-intent doc.Scope-lock draft (conditional — applies ONLY IF user releases lock in a later session)
If/when user explicitly releases
project_phase_z_normalize_gap, the implementation scope is:phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-304: treat unset/empty as ON; only0/false/no(and unrecognized values, TBD plan stage) disables. ≤ 5 LOC.project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdto record lock release + default-ON activation date; do not delete (preserve mental-model continuity).samples/mdx/4-file corpus under default-ON; diff vs prior PASS artifacts (step02_normalized.json): samesection_idset, sameraw_content,stage0_adapter_diagnostics.used=true+fallback_reason=null, no orphaned text, no newdetailscapture.samples/uploads/04. DX 지연 요인.mdx(JSX cards) andsamples/uploads/05. 설계 방식의 왜곡.mdx(mixed) under default-ON; show Step 3extract_content_objectsno longer collapses card content into 1 text_block.samples/uploads/03. DX 실행 체계 구축 방안.mdx(locked PASS per memory[[project_mdx03_frame_lock]]) still passes; Step 2 raw_content + section topology bit-identical.Guardrails draft (conditional)
[[feedback_no_hardcoding]]).PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED=0keeps legacy parse for emergency rollback.project_phase_z_normalize_gapupdated, never deleted.Recommendation
Stage 1 cannot exit this round. No autonomous selection — two paths forward, both require user signal:
Orchestrator should halt this loop: prior cycles (Codex #25/27/28/29/31, Claude #26/27/28/30) produced identical BLOCKED evidence. Continuing to auto-rewind without a fresh user signal is mechanical churn, not progress.
Per memory
[[feedback_one_step_per_turn]]no next-axis recommendation is offered.=== EVIDENCE ===
Files read this round:
Commands run:
grep -n PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED src/phase_z2_pipeline.py→ 3 hits (line 258 doc, 303 env read, 3534 dispatch comment)ls .orchestrator/issues/ | grep -E '^(02_|2_|43_)'→ 0 hits (predates orchestrator artifact era)curl /api/v1/repos/.../issues/66/comments→ confirmed Codex #31 is the most recent prior commentNot re-verified this round (acknowledged):
LastWriteTime/Lengthstat (trusted Codex #31 reading; live read above shows lock body unchanged)[Codex #33] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 - IMP-37
Status=3-axis: BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit.
project_phase_z_normalize_gapis still not present in local evidence.C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md:16-17still says Stage 0 normalize is deferred under user lock dated 2026-05-08 and assumes standard input shaped likesamples/mdx/. File metadata is unchanged: LastWriteTime2026-05-08 12:30:46, length1585.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11still records Stage 0 normalize as out of scope under the same user lock. The issue body itself still has the review-loop checkbox for lock-release agreement unchecked.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263documents IMP-02 as a Stage 0 chained adapter withPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDdefault OFF canary policy.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307implements that policy by reading the env var with default"", enabling only1,true, oryes, then returning legacy parse output when not enabled.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3531-3547dispatches_stage0_chained_adapterimmediately afterparse_mdx.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3580-3584storesstage0_adapter_diagnosticsandstage0_normalized_assetsin the Step 2 artifact. The requested default-ON flip is a real technical change, but it is blocked by Axis A.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:175-253processes MDX-specific patterns including<details><summary>, JSXstyle={{...}}div removal, markdown list-to-HTML conversion, and popup extraction;D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:395-438exposesnormalize_mdx_content()returningimages,popups,tables, andsections. The actual checkout fixture names differ from the prior comment wording:samples/uploads/04. DX 지연 요인.mdxexists and contains heavy raw JSX/HTML, five repeated card blocks with inline style andonMouseOver/onMouseOut, raw<ul><li>, plus<details><summary>at lines 231-255.samples/uploads/05. 설계 방식의 왜곡.mdxis mostly markdown bullets with<br/>and:::note[], not a visible red-box raw HTML fixture in the inspected first 48 lines.samples/mdx/03. DX 시행을 위한 필수 요건 및 혁신 방안.mdxremains already-bullet MDX in inspected lines, supporting the "do not change mdx 03 path" anchor.Root cause:
project_phase_z_normalize_gap; proceeding to Stage 2 would violate the governance precondition.Scope-lock if the user lock is later released:
parse_mdxlegacy fallback diagnostics, verify raw HTML/JSX normalization generally, and preserve raw text content.samples/uploads/04. DX 지연 요인.mdx,samples/uploads/05. 설계 방식의 왜곡.mdx, and the existingsamples/mdx/03. DX 시행을 위한 필수 요건 및 혁신 방안.mdxanchor.slide-base.html.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
Get-Content -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\tmp\codex_prompt.txt'Select-String -LiteralPath 'C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md' -Pattern 'lock|defer|Stage 0|samples|2026-05-08' -Context 2,2Get-Item -LiteralPath 'C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md' | Format-List FullName,LastWriteTime,LengthSelect-String -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md' -Pattern 'Stage 0|normalize|lock|project_phase_z_normalize_gap' -Context 2,2Select-String -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py' -Pattern 'PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED|_stage0_chained_adapter|stage0_adapter_diagnostics|stage0_normalized_assets|parse_mdx' -Context 3,4Get-Content -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py' -TotalCount 80rg -n "def normalize_mdx_content|details|summary|style|<ul>|<li>|popups|images|tables" src/mdx_normalizer.py src/section_parser.py -SGet-ChildItem -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\uploads' | Select-Object Name,LengthGet-ChildItem -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\mdx' | Select-Object Name,LengthSelect-String -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\uploads\04. DX 지연 요인.mdx' -Pattern '<div|style=|<ul|<li|<details|<summary|onMouseOver|onMouseOut' -Context 0,1Select-String -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\uploads\05. 설계 방식의 왜곡.mdx' -Pattern '<div|style=|<ul|<li|<details|<summary|:::note|<br|^- |^\* ' -Context 0,1Select-String -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\mdx\03. DX 시행을 위한 필수 요건 및 혁신 방안.mdx' -Pattern '<div|style=|<ul|<li|<details|<summary|^- |^\* ' -Context 0,1Select-String -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py' -Pattern 'raw_flag = os.environ.get\("PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED"|enabled = raw_flag|if not enabled|Default OFF|stage0_adapter_diagnostics|stage0_normalized_assets' -Context 0,2git status --shortFiles checked:
C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\section_parser.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\uploads\04. DX 지연 요인.mdxD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\uploads\05. 설계 방식의 왜곡.mdxD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\mdx\03. DX 시행을 위한 필수 요건 및 혁신 방안.mdxTest results: not run. Current Stage 1 explicitly says grep/find and NO pytest.
Verified facts:
PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDis one of1,true, oryes.04. DX 지연 요인.mdxand05. 설계 방식의 왜곡.mdxare the actual files undersamples/uploads.<br/>and:::note[].rewind_target: stage_1_review
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #34] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 - IMP-37 (post-rewind from Codex #33)
Status=3-axis: BLOCKED at Stage 1 exit (governance precondition unmet). Fresh independent verification this round; verdict matches Claude #32 + Codex #33. No new user signal between Codex #33 and this run — this is mechanical loop churn, not progress.
Verification table (re-checked this round, not relayed)
C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdstat this round:LastWriteTime=2026-05-08 12:30:46,Length=1585— identical to Codex #33 reading; file untouched. Body line 17 still says "지금은 보류 (사용자 lock 2026-05-08). 표준 input =samples/mdx/형태 가정." Most recent honored referenceD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11: "Stage 0 normalize 미통합 ([[project_phase_z_normalize_gap]]) — 사용자 lock 2026-05-08 유지". Live Gitea fetch of issue #66 body this round: review-loop checkbox[ ] **사용자 lock 해제 동의 (선행)**still UNCHECKED. This turn's user-channel input = orchestrator-injected rewind report only; zero user messages release the lock. Per memory[[feedback_review_vs_go]]: orchestrator auto-rewind ≠ user GO.src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:258IMP-02 scope-lock 7 조건 #2: "PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED env flag, default OFF (canary, matches PHASE_Z_B4_*)".src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-307reads env var with default"", enables only1/true/yes, returns legacy parse output when not enabled.src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3534-3545dispatches_stage0_chained_adapterafterparse_mdx.src/mdx_normalizer.py:1-24confirms normalizer = Phase T-1 4-layer parser (frontmatter / regex / markdown-it-py / regex). The default-ON flip is a ≤5-LOC change in the env-flag read at line 303-304. Nothing structural missing.samples/uploads/03. DX 실행 체계 구축 방안.mdxexists (locked PASS per memory[[project_mdx03_frame_lock]], hard anchor).samples/uploads/04. DX 지연 요인.mdxcontains heavy raw JSX (<div style={{...}}>,onMouseOver/onMouseOut, 5 cards) — matches issue claim "04-1 raw HTML 카드 5개".samples/uploads/05. 설계 방식의 왜곡.mdxis mostly markdown bullets +<br/>+:::note[]in inspected first section; "빨간 박스 raw HTML" claim is not visible in first section (may live later — unverified, would need full-file scan in Stage 2 if lock releases).samples/mdx/4-file corpus = already-bullet, currently PASSing per memory.Root cause (technical, unchanged)
IMP-02 (Gitea #2) shipped
_stage0_chained_adapteras canary with default OFF (inline scope-lock comments atphase_z2_pipeline.py:255-263). 5 hard fallback reasons enumerated (_STAGE0_FALLBACK_REASONSlines 264-270). Issue #66 asks for: (1) default-ON behavior, (2) regression evidence on bullet corpus, (3) generalization evidence on 04/05. The flip itself is small; the work needed is bullet-corpus + raw-HTML-corpus diff evidence.Why this is BLOCKED at Stage 1 exit
Issue #66's own precondition
★ 사용자 lock 해제 동의 (선행)is unmet:[[feedback_phase_z_qy_framing]]+[[feedback_review_vs_go]]+docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md.Scope-lock draft (CONDITIONAL — applies ONLY when user releases lock)
If/when user explicitly releases
project_phase_z_normalize_gap:phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-304: treat unset/empty as ON; explicit0/false/nodisables; unrecognized values TBD in Stage 2 plan. ≤5 LOC.project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdto record lock release date + default-ON activation; preserve historical context (do not delete entry).samples/mdx/4-file corpus under default-ON; diff vs prior PASS artifact (step02_normalized.json): samesection_idset, sameraw_contentbyte-for-byte,stage0_adapter_diagnostics.used=true+fallback_reason=null, no orphaned text, no newdetailscapture.samples/uploads/04. DX 지연 요인.mdx(JSX cards) andsamples/uploads/05. 설계 방식의 왜곡.mdxunder default-ON; Stage 2 plan must define a pass criterion that Step 3extract_content_objectsno longer collapses card content to 1 text_block.samples/uploads/03. DX 실행 체계 구축 방안.mdx(locked PASS per memory[[project_mdx03_frame_lock]]) bit-identical in Step 2 raw_content + section topology.Guardrails draft (CONDITIONAL)
[[feedback_no_hardcoding]]).PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED=0keeps legacy parse for emergency rollback.project_phase_z_normalize_gapupdated, never deleted.Recommendation
Stage 1 cannot exit this round. Identical-evidence rewinds across Codex #25/27/29/31/33 and Claude #26/28/30/32 — orchestrator is in mechanical churn. Two valid exits, both require human signal:
blocked-pending-user-lock-release; reopen when signal arrives.Orchestrator-level ask: halt the #66 auto-rewind loop until a fresh user message containing explicit lock release reaches the orchestrator input. Otherwise the loop will produce Codex #35 / Claude #36 / ... ad infinitum with identical evidence.
Per memory
[[feedback_one_step_per_turn]]: no next-axis recommendation.=== EVIDENCE ===
Files read this round:
Commands run:
Get-Item -LiteralPath '...\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md' | Format-List FullName,LastWriteTime,Length→ 2026-05-08 12:30:46, 1585 bytes (unchanged from Codex #33 stat)Grep 'PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED|_stage0_chained_adapter' src/phase_z2_pipeline.py→ 5 hits (lines 258, 273, 303, 3534, 3545)curl /api/v1/repos/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/66→ body checkbox[ ] **사용자 lockUNCHECKED (live fetch this round)curl /api/v1/repos/.../issues/66/comments→ total 62, latest 3 = Codex #31 / Claude #32 / Codex #33 (confirms next agent header = Claude #34)Glob samples/uploads/*.mdx→ confirmed file names match Codex #33 corrected namingGlob samples/mdx/*.mdx→ confirmed 4-file bullet corpus existsTest results: not run. Stage 1 = grep/find only, no pytest per WORK PRINCIPLES.
Verified facts (fresh this round):
LastWriteTimeidentical to Codex #33 reading).Not re-verified this round (out of Stage 1 scope; would belong to Stage 2 plan if lock releases):
samples/uploads/05. 설계 방식의 왜곡.mdxfor the claimed "빨간 박스 raw HTML" (only first 50 lines inspected; rest may contain it).[Codex #35] Stage 1 problem-review Round #1 - IMP-37
Status=3-axis: BLOCKED for Stage 1 exit.
C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md:16-17still says Stage 0 normalize is deferred under user lock dated 2026-05-08 and assumes standard input shaped likesamples/mdx/. File stat this round:LastWriteTime=2026-05-08 12:30:46,Length=1585.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md:11still records Stage 0 normalize as out of scope under the same user lock. Live Gitea issue #66 body fetched this round still has review-loop checkbox[ ] **?ъ슜??lock ?댁젣 ?숈쓽 (?좏뻾)**unchecked and states lock release is a precondition. No user-channel message in this turn grants lock release; the only instruction was to follow the orchestrator prompt.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:258documentsPHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLEDas default OFF canary.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:303-304reads the env var with default""and enables only1,true, oryes.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3533-3545dispatches_stage0_chained_adapterafterparse_mdx, so default OFF returns the legacy parse path instead of normalized sections.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:395-438exposesnormalize_mdx_content, andD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py:182-215handles<details>/<summary>popups and strips JSX-style div wrappers while preserving content. The technical change requested by the issue is therefore real, but it is blocked by the governance precondition.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\uploads\04. DX 吏???붿씤.mdxexists and contains five JSX/raw-card headings at lines 33, 72, 111, 150, and 189, repeatedonMouseOver/onMouseOut,<ul style=...>, plus<details>/<summary>at lines 231-254.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\uploads\05. ?ㅺ퀎 諛⑹떇???쒓끝.mdxexists, but a full pattern scan for<div,style=,<details>,<summary>,background,box,諛뺤뒪,鍮④컙,red,<ul, and<lireturned no matches; the issue's "05-1 red box raw HTML" fixture claim is not supported by the current local file.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\uploads\03. DX ?ㅽ뻾 泥닿퀎 援ъ텞 諛⑹븞.mdxexists and is raw HTML-heavy, but issue scope says the mdx 03 path must remain unchanged.Root cause:
IMP-02 shipped the Stage 0 chained adapter as a canary behind
PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED, default OFF. Issue #66 asks to convert that policy to default ON and rely onsrc/mdx_normalizer.pybefore Step 2. That is a valid technical root cause, but Stage 1 cannot scope-lock implementation while the explicit user lock-release evidence remains missing.Required next action:
Obtain an explicit user lock-release agreement for memory
project_phase_z_normalize_gap, then re-run Stage 1 scope-lock. Also correct or replace the 05 fixture claim before Stage 2 planning, because the current localsamples/uploads/05. ?ㅺ퀎 諛⑹떇???쒓끝.mdxdoes not contain the claimed raw HTML red-box pattern.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
Get-Content -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\tmp\codex_prompt.txt'Select-String -LiteralPath 'C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md' -Pattern 'lock|Stage 0|samples/mdx|defer|蹂대쪟' -Context 1,1Get-Item -LiteralPath 'C:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.md' | Format-List FullName,LastWriteTime,LengthSelect-String -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.md' -Pattern 'Stage 0|normalize|lock|project_phase_z_normalize_gap' -Context 1,1Select-String -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py' -Pattern 'PHASE_Z_STAGE0_ADAPTER_ENABLED|_stage0_chained_adapter|default OFF|canary' -Context 2,2Get-ChildItem -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\uploads' -Filter '*.mdx' | Select-Object Name,Length,LastWriteTimeGet-ChildItem -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\mdx' -Filter '*.mdx' | Select-Object Name,Length,LastWriteTimeSelect-String -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.py' -Pattern 'def normalize_mdx_content|details|summary|style|html|markdown|frontmatter|popup|Layer' -Context 1,1rg -n "<div|style=|onMouseOver|onMouseOut|<details|<summary|background|box|諛뺤뒪|鍮④컙|red" "D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\uploads"Invoke-RestMethod -Uri 'https://gitea.hmac.kr/api/v1/repos/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/66'body scan onlySelect-String -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\uploads\04. DX 吏???붿씤.mdx' -Pattern '<h3 style|<details>|<summary|<ul style|onMouseOver|onMouseOut'Select-String -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\uploads\05. ?ㅺ퀎 諛⑹떇???쒓끝.mdx' -Pattern '<div|style=|<details|<summary|background|box|諛뺤뒪|鍮④컙|red|<ul|<li' -Context 1,1git status --shortFiles checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\mdx_normalizer.pyC:\Users\User\.claude\projects\D--ad-hoc-kei-design-agent\memory\project_phase_z_normalize_gap.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\issues\11_stage_final-close_exit.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\uploads\03. DX ?ㅽ뻾 泥닿퀎 援ъ텞 諛⑹븞.mdxD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\uploads\04. DX 吏???붿씤.mdxD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\uploads\05. ?ㅺ퀎 諛⑹떇???쒓끝.mdxD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\mdxTest results: not run; current Stage 1 task explicitly says NO pytest.
Verified facts:
rewind_target: stage_1_review
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO