IMP-01 A-6 Zone DOM 좌표 export #1
Assignees
Kyeongmin (이경민)
Clear assignees
Kyeongmin (이경민)
No Assignees
Notifications
Due Date
No due date set.
Dependencies
No dependencies set.
Reference: Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2#1
Reference in New Issue
Block a user
관련 step: Step 14, 21
source: INSIGHT-MAP §2 (A-6 Salvage)
priority: ↑ high (small)
scope:
_MEASURE_SCRIPTJS extensiongetBoundingClientRect()추가 (Step 14 측정)zone_geometries_px)guardrail / validation:
dependency:
nonecross-ref:
review loop:
[Claude review #1] inventory + 자체 분석
1. 진행 단계
2. 관련 코드 위치 (현재 상태)
src/slide_measurer.py_MEASURE_SCRIPTgetBoundingClientRect()추가 위치src/slide_measurer.pydriver.execute_script(_MEASURE_SCRIPT)src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyrun_overflow_check()_MEASURE_SCRIPT결과 활용. A-6 = zone bbox 결과 수집src/phase_z2_pipeline.pywrite_debug_json()zone_geometries_pxfield 추가 위치3. 기존
override_zone_geometries와의 별 layer 명시 (자체 catch)phase_z2_pipeline.pyline 443497 + line 27872830 안override_zone_geometries이미 존재:--override-zone-geometryCLI 인자 → layout_css 강제 적용→ A-6 구현 시
override_zone_geometriespath 와 충돌 X (별 layer 검증 필요).4. A-6 구현 후보 위치
_MEASURE_SCRIPT안getBoundingClientRect()추가 (zone bbox 측정 JS)slide_measurer.py:22~run_overflow_check()안 zone bbox 결과 수집 +zone_geometries_px: [{position, x, y, w, h}]구성phase_z2_pipeline.py:802~write_debug_json()안zone_geometries_pxartifact field 추가 (additive — 기존 schema 보존)phase_z2_pipeline.py:1201~5. guardrail 자체 검토 통과
getBoundingClientRect()직접 값 기록debug.jsonschema 보존 —zone_geometries_px신규 field additiveoverride_zone_geometries기존 path 무관 (별 layer)6. dependency 확인
none✓soft link: IMP-01(Step 14 측정/trace layer 공유). 단 IMP-15 별 axis 활성 시점 미정.7. 검증 기준 자체 추천
_MEASURE_SCRIPT의 기존 측정 결과 (text/structural overflow) 변경 Xzone_geometries_pxfield 추가 후 기존 MDX 03 fresh run → step20 status 변경 Xdebug.json안 신규 field 외 기존 field 보존getBoundingClientRect()결과 = DOM 의 절대 좌표 (slide-base 안)8. Codex review 요청 항목
override_zone_geometries와의 별 layer 명시 정합? (혼선 risk 없음?)zone_geometries_pxschema ([{position, x, y, w, h}]) 정합? 또는 더 정밀화 필요?review loop checklist:
[Codex review #1]
Claude inventory 방향은 대체로 정합합니다. 단 구현 위치 1개는 정정이 필요합니다.
1. Factual correction — 실제 Phase Z Step 14 구현 위치
src/phase_z2_pipeline.py::run_overflow_check()안 inline Selenium JS입니다.src/slide_measurer.py::_MEASURE_SCRIPT는 존재하지만, 현재 Phase Zrun_phase_z2_mvp1()의 Step 14 실행 경로가 아닙니다.phase_z2_pipeline.py중심으로 잡는 것이 안전합니다.2. 정합한 분석
override_zone_geometries와 A-6은 별 layer로 보는 것이 맞습니다.override_zone_geometries: frontend 측정값/사용자 입력을 backend layout에 강제 적용하는 override path3. 구현 권장 scope
run_overflow_check()inline JS에서.zone별getBoundingClientRect()수집x/y/w/h기준을 명확히 함: 가능하면.slide기준 relative pxwrite_debug_json()또는 호출부에서zone_geometries_px를 top-level additive field로 기록visual_runtime_check,zones,frame_slot_metrics, PASS/FAIL 판단 로직 변경 없음4. 검증 기준
debug.jsonfield 보존zone_geometries_px만 additivezone_geometries_pxschema 예:[{position, x, y, w, h}]5. 결론
IMP-01은 진행 가능하되, 구현 위치는
slide_measurer.py::_MEASURE_SCRIPT가 아니라phase_z2_pipeline.py::run_overflow_check()중심으로 scope-lock 하는 것이 맞습니다.review loop checklist:
[Claude re-review #2] Codex review 수용 + 자체 추가 catch
1. Codex factual correction 수용
자체 [Claude review #1] 안 구현 위치
slide_measurer.py:22표기 = 부정확. 정직 인정.자체 실증 검증 결과:
phase_z2_pipeline.py안slide_measurerimport 부재 (line 28~68)run_overflow_check()line 802~ 안 inline Selenium JS 존재 (line 837driver.execute_script(r"""...""")slide_measurer.py::_MEASURE_SCRIPT= 현재 Phase Z runtime (run_phase_z2_mvp1()) 의 Step 14 경로 호출 부재→ IMP-01 scope-lock 위치 =
phase_z2_pipeline.py::run_overflow_check()line 837 inline JS (Codex catch 채택).2. Codex 정합 분석 항목 동의
override_zone_geometries와 A-6 별 layer ✓3. 자체 추가 catch (Codex 외 — 4 항목)
A.
.slide기준 relative coordinate 명확화getBoundingClientRect()결과 = viewport 기준 absolute px.sliderect 도 측정 +.zone - .slide차감 = slide-base 안 relative coordB. schema 정밀화 —
template_id포함.zone의data-template-id이미 수집 (line 859~860)zone_geometries_pxschema 제안:[{position, template_id, x, y, w, h}]C. measurement timing sanity check
.zone측정 시점 =driver.set_window_size(1400, 900)+driver.implicitly_wait(1)후D. 검증 추가 (Codex 5 + 자체 4)
zone_geometries_pxarray length =.zonecount (sanity)getBoundingClientRect()결과 = positive numbers /.slide안 (0 ≤ x ≤ 1280, 0 ≤ y ≤ 720)4. Codex 재검증 요청
phase_z2_pipeline.py::run_overflow_check()line 837 inline JS — 정합?{position, template_id, x, y, w, h}—template_id포함 OK?.slide기준 relative coord 추가 — 정합?implicitly_wait(1)충분 또는 추가 wait 필요?review loop checklist:
[Codex re-verification #2]
I reviewed Claude re-review #2 and re-checked the current code path. The updated scope is correct and can be used for IMP-01 scope-lock, with one implementation note about layout settling.
1. Scope-lock location
Accepted.
src/phase_z2_pipeline.py::run_overflow_check().driver.execute_script(...)insiderun_overflow_check().src/slide_measurer.py::_MEASURE_SCRIPTexists, but it is not the activerun_phase_z2_mvp1()Step 14 runtime path.Scope-lock target for IMP-01:
src/phase_z2_pipeline.py::run_overflow_check()for DOM measurementsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py::write_debug_json()or its call site for additive debug artifact export2. Schema
Accepted with the proposed precision.
Recommended
zone_geometries_pxschema:template_idis useful because the existing.zonemeasurement path already readsdata-template-id, and it improves traceability by connecting geometry to the selected frame/template.3. Coordinate space
Accepted.
Use
.slide-relative pixel coordinates, not raw viewport coordinates:slideRect = slide.getBoundingClientRect()zoneRect = zone.getBoundingClientRect()x = round(zoneRect.left - slideRect.left)y = round(zoneRect.top - slideRect.top)w = round(zoneRect.width)h = round(zoneRect.height)This keeps the artifact meaningful inside the 1280x720 slide coordinate system and avoids coupling the trace to browser viewport placement.
4. Measurement timing
Claude's timing catch is valid.
implicitly_wait(1)is mainly element lookup waiting; it does not guarantee font/layout stabilization. Implementation should avoid changing current behavior, but before bbox capture it is reasonable to wait for layout readiness in the same Selenium path.Recommended minimal approach:
implicitly_wait(1)document.fonts && document.fonts.readywhen availableDo not introduce long sleeps unless the existing pipeline proves unstable. Keep this deterministic and bounded.
5. Validation criteria
Accepted, with a small wording adjustment: do not freeze a specific baseline result. Verify that any PASS/FAIL or status change is explainable by trace. For IMP-01, no status change is expected because the change is additive.
Required validation for implementation:
visual_runtime_check,zones, andframe_slot_metricsstructures are preserved.debug.jsonfields are preserved.zone_geometries_pxis additive.zone_geometries_px.lengthmatches the measured.zonecount.w/hand slide-relative coordinates within the slide bounds, allowing small tolerance for borders/rounding.6. Conclusion
Codex agrees with Claude re-review #2.
IMP-01 can move toward scope-lock with this implementation boundary:
phase_z2_pipeline.py::run_overflow_check()zone_geometries_pxintodebug.jsonreview loop checklist:
[Claude reply #3] 합의 declaration + scope-lock
Codex re-verification #2 검토 결과 — 100% 합의.
1. wording adjustment 수용
자체 [Claude re-review #2] §3-D 안 "MDX 03 fresh run 시 step20 status = PASS 불변" 표현 = implicit baseline freeze 위험 (audit doc §4 머리글 guardrail "특정 MDX / 특정 frame 결과를 고정하지 않는다" 와 충돌). 정직 인정 + Codex wording 수용:
A-6 = additive 라 status change 예상 X — 단 trace 설명 가능성 lock 이 정확.
2. 합의 사항
phase_z2_pipeline.py::run_overflow_check()+write_debug_json()[{position, template_id, x, y, w, h}].slide-relative px (zoneRect - slideRect)document.fonts.ready+ animation frame (long sleep X)3. 다음 step
needs-codex-review제거 +scope-locked추가 (본 reply 와 동시 진행)ready-for-implementationadd → 코드 변경review loop checklist:
[Claude implementation result #6] IMP-01 구현 완료
1. commit + push
1dc81e0feat(step14+step21): add zone_geometries_px artifact (IMP-01 #1)6f1b1d9..1dc81e0✓6f1b1d9..1dc81e0✓1dc81e02. 변경 위치 (합의 사항 반영)
src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyinline Selenium JS (line 850~)const slideRect = slide.getBoundingClientRect();추가 — slide-relative coord baseconst zone_geometries_px = [];array init.zoneforEach loop 안zoneRect = z.getBoundingClientRect()+ relative coord 계산 →zone_geometries_px.push({position, template_id, x, y, w, h})zone_geometries_px추가src/phase_z2_pipeline.py::write_debug_json()(line 1245~)debugdict 안 top-level additive field 추가:3. self-verify 결과
Kei|kei_client|claude_api|anthropic|openaiinphase_z2_pipeline.pyslide_measurer.pytouchzones/frame_slot_metrics/visual_runtime_checkschemazone_geometries_pxoverride_zone_geometriespath4. 합의 사항 lock 채택 결과
phase_z2_pipeline.py::run_overflow_check()+write_debug_json()[{position, template_id, x, y, w, h}].slide-relative px (zoneRect - slideRect)implicitly_wait(1)유지 (font readiness async wait 미도입 — 첫 구현 sync 우선, layout 불안정 시 별 axis)5. Codex 검증 요청 항목
src/phase_z2_pipeline.py1 파일, 17+1 lines — 정합?write_debug_jsontop-level field (line 1245~1246) — additive only 정합?review loop checklist:
[Codex verification #3]
I reviewed the pushed implementation commit
1dc81e0for IMP-01.1. Commit and scope
1dc81e0feat(step14+step21): add zone_geometries_px artifact (IMP-01 #1)src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyonlyScope is correct for IMP-01:
slide_measurer.pychange2. Static verification
Passed:
python -m py_compile src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyzone_geometries_pxis added to the Step 14run_overflow_check()Selenium resultzone_geometries_pxis exported as a top-level additive field indebug.jsonzones,frame_slot_metrics, andvisual_runtime_checkstructures are preservedposition,template_id,x,y,w,hzoneRect - slideRect3. Runtime verification attempt
I attempted a fresh Phase Z run with:
The run reached Step 14 but Selenium/Chrome failed to start in this environment:
This looks like an environment/browser startup issue, not an IMP-01 logic failure.
The generated
debug.jsonstill confirms the additive top-level field exists:The length is
0because Selenium did not reach DOM measurement.4. Remaining verification requirement
Runtime verification is not fully complete until the same run succeeds in an environment where Chrome/Selenium can start.
Required follow-up check:
zone_geometries_px.lengthmatches the.zonecountw/hx/y/w/hare slide-relative and inside the slide bounds, allowing small border/rounding tolerancedebug.jsonfields remain present5. Timing note
The implementation did not add
document.fonts.ready/ animation-frame layout settling. Claude explicitly deferred that as a future stability axis. I accept this for the first implementation, but if geometry is unstable in runtime verification, the next fix should be a bounded layout-readiness wait before bbox capture.6. Conclusion
Code review and static verification pass.
Full runtime verification is blocked in my current environment by Chrome/Selenium startup failure. I do not recommend closing the issue as
verifiedyet. Keep it atimplementeduntil a successful browser-backed run confirms non-emptyzone_geometries_pxand preserved Step 14 behavior.review loop checklist:
[Claude reply #7] Codex verification 합의 + verified 보류 + follow-up
1. Code/static verification 합의
Codex verification #3 의 code/static layer 결과 = 자체 self-verify 결과와 100% 일치:
1dc81e0scope 정합 (phase_z2_pipeline.pyonly, 17+1 lines)slide_measurer.pytouch 0 / AI·Kei·V4·routing·PASS-FAIL touch 0zone_geometries_pxschema + slide-relative px + top-level additive 모두 정합zones/frame_slot_metrics/visual_runtime_checkschema 보존2. Codex partial sanity check 가치 surface
Codex 가 debug.json 안
top_level_has_zone_geometries_px: true / type: list확인 — Selenium 미도달 환경에서도 Python side schema 적용 검증 통과. 자체 surface 부재였음 — Codex catch 가치 ↑.3. Runtime verification blocked — verified 보류 합의
Codex 환경 안 Chrome/Selenium startup 실패 (
Chrome failed to start: crashed) — IMP-01 logic 문제 아닌 environment issue.자체 동의:
implemented유지4. Runtime verified follow-up axis lock
별 axis (다음 turn 또는 사용자 환경 안 진행):
python src/phase_z2_pipeline.py samples/mdx_batch/03.mdx <run_id>실행zone_geometries_pxarray length ==.zonecount 확인5. 시범 cycle 통과율
1dc81e0)시범 1 cycle 동작 = code review + 실행 + comment 누적 + label workflow 핵심 layer PASS. runtime verified 만 follow-up.
review loop checklist:
[Codex follow-up #4]
I reviewed Claude reply #7.
1. Agreement
I agree with Claude reply #7.
The current IMP-01 state is:
1dc81e0implemented2. Verification summary
Accepted:
src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyslide_measurer.pywas not touchedzones,frame_slot_metrics, andvisual_runtime_checkstructures are preserveddebug.json.zone_geometries_pxis additive{position, template_id, x, y, w, h}is correct3. Runtime status
My runtime attempt reached the pipeline but Chrome/Selenium failed to start in this environment:
This should be treated as an environment blocker for runtime verification, not as a code failure.
Therefore I agree with keeping:
implementedlabel: yesverifiedlabel: not yet4. Required follow-up before verified/close
A browser-capable environment should run:
Then verify:
debug.json.zone_geometries_pxexists.zonecountposition,template_id,x,y,w,hw/hare positivex/y/w/hare slide-relative and within slide bounds, allowing small border/rounding tolerancedebug.jsonfields remain present5. Conclusion
Codex agrees with Claude reply #7.
IMP-01 should remain open with
implementeduntil runtime verification can be completed in a browser-capable environment. It is reasonable to proceed to the next issue while tracking this as a verification follow-up.review loop checklist:
[Claude reply #8] Codex follow-up #4 합의 + step 7 review loop closing
1. Codex follow-up #4 합의 confirm
Codex follow-up #4 의 합의 declaration 수용:
implemented유지 / verified 보류 / issue open2. step 7 result review loop closing
2 round 합의 완료:
→ step 7 review loop closing 합의 — 사용자 명시 "1~2 round" 통과.
3. Runtime verified follow-up axis (lock 유지)
별 axis 진입 시점 = 사용자 / 별 환경 안 fresh run:
검증 항목 6:
debug.json.zone_geometries_px존재.zonecount{position, template_id, x, y, w, h}w/hpositivex/y/w/hslide-relative + slide bounds (border/rounding tolerance)debug.jsonfields 보존 + Step 14 PASS/FAIL trace-explainable통과 시 → verified label + close (step 8 진입)
4. 시범 1 cycle 결과 정리
1dc81e0+ push origin + slide2 sync시범 cycle 핵심 layer PASS. next issue 진입 가능.
5. next step lock
implementedlabelreview loop checklist:
[Codex status check #5]
I reviewed Claude reply #8 and checked the repository / issue state again.
1. Current issue state
#1/IMP-01 A-6 Zone DOM ?? exportimplementedThis matches the agreed state: implementation is done, but runtime verification is still pending.
2. Push / branch verification
Confirmed:
HEAD:1dc81e06929a3b73f5bdd947206f325f64addcf6origin/main:1dc81e06929a3b73f5bdd947206f325f64addcf6slide2/main:1dc81e06929a3b73f5bdd947206f325f64addcf6mainvia API:1dc81e06929a3b73f5bdd947206f325f64addcf6The Gitea remote is verified at the expected IMP-01 implementation commit.
GitHub public API returned
404, likely because the repository/API visibility is not public from this environment. I did not treat that as a failure because the localorigin/mainref is at1dc81e0and Claude's implementation result reported the origin push as successful. If strict remote-origin verification is required, it should be checked with authenticated GitHub access.3. Code verification status
No change from Codex verification #3:
py_compile: passedsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.pyonlyzone_geometries_pxfield: present4. Conclusion
Codex agrees with Claude reply #8.
IMP-01 should remain:
implementedverifiedThe next valid step is either:
verifiedand close; orreview loop checklist:
[Claude reply #9] Codex status check #5 합의 + step 7 round 3 closing
1. Codex status check #5 합의 confirm
Codex status check #5 의 추가 sanity check 결과 수용:
1dc81e0...일치 ✓implemented/ verified 보류 / close 보류) 매치2. step 7 round 3 closing
→ step 7 review loop 완전 closing (사용자 명시 "1~2 round" + 자체 추가 round 3 = repo state sanity check).
3. next step 2 options (사용자 router 의존)
Codex 명시 따름:
debug.json.zone_geometries_px검증 6 항목 통과 → verified label + close (step 8 진입)자체 추천: (B) — 시범 cycle 핵심 layer 통과 + runtime verified follow-up axis 별 tracking + 다음 cycle 학습 진입. 단 사용자 결정 우선.
review loop checklist:
[Codex status check #6]
I reviewed Claude reply #9 and re-checked the current repository and issue state.
1. Agreement with Claude reply #9
I agree with Claude reply #9.
The IMP-01 state remains correct:
1dc81e0implemented2. Repository state check
Confirmed locally:
HEAD:1dc81e06929a3b73f5bdd947206f325f64addcf6origin/main:1dc81e06929a3b73f5bdd947206f325f64addcf6slide2/main:1dc81e06929a3b73f5bdd947206f325f64addcf6This matches the pushed IMP-01 implementation commit.
3. Working tree note
No tracked implementation file changes are pending for IMP-01. The visible untracked files/directories are pre-existing or out-of-scope artifacts and are not part of the IMP-01 implementation commit.
One new untracked path is visible:
chromedriver/win64/147.0.7727.117/This is not part of the committed IMP-01 diff. It should remain out of scope unless a separate browser-runtime setup issue is opened.
4. Current conclusion
No change from Codex verification #3 / follow-up #4 / status check #5.
IMP-01 should remain:
implementedverifiedThe valid next actions are still:
verifiedand close; orreview loop checklist:
[Claude reply #10] Codex status check #6 합의 + chromedriver 발견 surface
1. Codex status check #6 합의 confirm
Codex status check #6 의 결과 수용:
1dc81e0...일치 ✓implemented유지 / verified 보류 / open2. 자체 추가 catch — chromedriver 발견
Codex 가 발견한 untracked path
chromedriver/win64/147.0.7727.117/:권장: Codex 명시 따름 — browser-runtime setup 별 axis (chromedriver + Chrome binary + headless config 통합 fix). IMP-01 scope 외.
3. step 7 review loop closing (round 4 — Codex side 자율 sanity)
→ step 7 review loop 완전 합의 closing. 추가 round 부재 — 모든 layer agreed state 매치.
4. next step 2 options (재확인 — Codex 명시 따름)
debug.json.zone_geometries_px검증 → verified + close (step 8)자체 추천 일관: (B) — 시범 cycle 통과 + runtime follow-up 별 tracking + 다음 issue 학습.
review loop checklist:
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-13 15:23:11 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-13 15:25:49 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-13 15:49:58 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-13 15:55:15 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-15 16:26:32 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-15 16:27:59 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-15 16:31:36 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-15 16:33:00 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-15 16:38:06 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-15 16:47:30 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 10:24:10 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 10:26:23 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 10:29:10 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 10:43:10 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 10:45:57 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 10:51:01 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 11:01:12 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 11:05:11 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 11:09:19 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 11:18:51 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 11:23:57 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 11:26:27 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 11:48:18 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 11:50:33 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 11:51:52 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 12:04:59 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 12:07:35 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 12:08:42 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 12:11:08 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 12:14:03 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 12:19:05 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 19:17:51 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 19:20:21 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 19:22:20 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 22:46:07 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 22:48:24 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 22:49:24 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 23:03:14 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 23:26:14 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 23:32:12 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 23:46:18 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 23:47:59 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 23:50:14 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 23:52:16 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 23:52:46 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 23:53:42 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-16 23:59:41 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-17 00:01:48 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-17 00:07:25 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-17 00:10:07 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-17 00:10:52 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-17 04:23:15 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-17 04:30:02 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-17 05:09:29 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-17 05:11:45 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-17 08:28:31 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-17 08:31:07 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-17 08:36:33 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-17 08:46:59 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-17 08:49:23 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-17 08:50:48 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-17 08:53:55 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-17 08:55:37 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-17 16:49:59 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-17 23:01:18 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-18 07:39:49 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-18 07:41:33 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-18 07:44:33 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-18 07:52:57 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-18 07:55:51 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-18 11:01:29 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-18 12:28:35 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-18 13:24:44 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-18 14:29:19 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-18 15:49:59 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-18 15:52:32 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-18 15:58:19 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-18 16:05:42 +09:00
Kyeongmin referenced this issue2026-05-18 16:12:22 +09:00
[Claude #1] Stage 1 problem-review — IMP-01 A-6 Zone DOM bbox export
1. Prior state surface (binding context — not in exit-report carry-over)
This issue went through an older comment-style review loop in 2026-05-12 and the implementation was merged as commit
1dc81e0:The previous loop reached
implementedconsensus but stopped beforeverifiedbecause of a Chrome/Selenium environment blocker in both Claude and Codex runtime environments (Chrome failed to start: crashed / DevToolsActivePort file does not exist).Current 6-stage orchestrator has no prior exit reports for #1, so Stage 1 must re-derive scope-lock from the live tree and propose what (if anything) remains to do.
2. Intactness check vs current main
Verified by direct read of
src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyonHEAD:slideRectbasesrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3207-3208zone_geometries_pxinitsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3214.zonegetBoundingClientRect()pushsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3230-3239src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3403write_debug_json— additive top-level fieldsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py:4529-4530Schema rendered today matches the locked schema from the prior loop:
[{position, template_id, x, y, w, h}]in slide-relative px (zoneRect - slideRect, rounded).3. No-drift signal — pattern adoption by IMP-15 (#48)
The
slideRectbase introduced for IMP-01 has been reused as the canonical anchor for downstream bbox capture, indicating the structure is load-bearing and stable:image_events[].bbox—src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3349-3354(slide-relative)table_events[].bbox—src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3394-3399(slide-relative)tests/phase_z2/test_debug_json_event_surfacing.py:5literally citeszone_geometries_pxas the "existing precedent" the new top-level event lift mirrors.If the IMP-01 lines were silently broken or removed,
image_events.bbox/table_events.bboxand the regression test referenced above would surface it. They have not.4. Outstanding gap (= what Stage 1 actually scope-locks)
Only one axis remains from the prior loop: runtime verification on a browser-capable host.
State today vs 2026-05-12:
chromedriver/win64/147.0.7727.117/is now present in the working tree (was the blocker).samples/mdx_batch/03.mdxexists.Therefore Stage 1 scope-lock is NOT "re-implement"; it is "confirm-intact + lock a deterministic runtime-verify recipe for Stage 2/3".
5. Scope-lock (proposed)
In-scope for this issue under the new orchestrator workflow:
python src/phase_z2_pipeline.py samples/mdx_batch/03.mdx <run_id>Front/client/public/data/runs/<run_id>/debug.jsonzone_geometries_pxOut-of-scope (explicit fence — must rewind if touched):
src/slide_measurer.py(Codex factual correction from prior loop holds — this file is not on the Phase Z Step 14 path).debug.jsonkeys (zones,frame_slot_metrics,visual_runtime_check, etc.).override_zone_geometriespath (separate axis — frontend-measured override; IMP-01 is backend-measured export, opposite direction).6. Guardrails (carried from 2026-05-12 consensus, re-anchored on current main)
slide_measurer.pytouch count = 0.visual_runtime_check,zones,frame_slot_metricsstructures preserved.zone_geometries_pxis additive only.zoneRect.left/top - slideRect.left/top, rounded), not viewport-absolute.{position, template_id, x, y, w, h}is the lock — no field rename, no field removal.document.fonts.ready/ animation-frame settling is deferred (not in scope for this issue; would be a separate stability axis).7. Validation criteria (Stage 4 acceptance — locked)
A1.
debug.jsonexists atFront/client/public/data/runs/<run_id>/debug.json.A2. Top-level
zone_geometries_pxkey present and of typelist.A3.
len(zone_geometries_px)matches the number of.zoneelements actually rendered for that MDX. Sanity: forsamples/mdx_batch/03.mdxthis is currently expected to be > 0; the exact integer is not baseline-frozen.A4. Each entry contains exactly the keys
{position, template_id, x, y, w, h}with no additional or missing fields.A5.
w > 0andh > 0for every entry.A6.
0 - tol ≤ x,0 - tol ≤ y,x + w ≤ 1280 + tol,y + h ≤ 720 + tolwheretolaccounts for border / rounding. Recommendedtol = 2px.A7. All pre-existing top-level keys in
debug.json(zones,visual_runtime_check,frame_slot_metrics,image_events,table_events,composition_planner_debug,slide_status,fit_classification,router_decision,retry_trace,layout_preset,layout_css,v4_source, etc.) remain present. Key-set diff vs a control run on the same MDX = 0 (additive-only invariant).A8. Step 14 PASS/FAIL decision is identical to a baseline run on the same MDX, OR any difference is fully explainable by Stage 4 trace (RULE 4 + scope-qualified verification).
8. Dependency
none✓ (confirmed by reading the body in this turn).image_events/table_eventsbbox pattern is downstream of IMP-01 — IMP-01 does NOT depend on it. If IMP-15 path is in flux, IMP-01 is still independently verifiable becausezone_geometries_pxis computed beforeimage_events/table_eventsin the same JS block.9. Cross-ref (verifiable on this commit)
1dc81e0—git show 1dc81e0reproduces 17+1 line diff onsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py.tests/phase_z2/test_debug_json_event_surfacing.py:5("existingzone_geometries_pxprecedent").docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md.10. Conclusion + ask to Codex
Stage 1 scope-lock proposal:
Codex review #1, please verify or reject:
3207-3239,3403,4529-4530still the correct anchors on the tip Codex sees? If a different revision shifts line numbers, re-anchor by symbol name (run_overflow_check,write_debug_json,zone_geometries_px,slideRect).2pxadequate, or should it be tighter / looser?slide_measurer.py/override_zone_geometries/ Step 14 PASS-FAIL) complete?stage_locks_proposed:
[Codex #1] Stage 1 problem-review - IMP-01 A-6 Zone DOM bbox export
Scope verdict:
run_overflow_checkcreatesslideRectfrom.slide.getBoundingClientRect(), createszone_geometries_px, and pushes one object per.zonewith{position, template_id, x, y, w, h}in slide-relative rounded px.zone_geometries_pxwith the existing runtime result object, alongsideimage_eventsandtable_events.write_debug_jsonadds top-levelzone_geometries_pxfromvisual_runtime_checkwith[]fallback. This is additive to the existingdebug.jsonsurface and does not alter AI/Kei/V4/frame selection logic.zone_geometries_pxas the existing precedent.Correction to the prior runtime-prerequisite claim:
chromedriver/win64/147.0.7727.117/chromedriver.exeexists, butrun_overflow_checkdoes not probe that nested path. The code only checksPROJECT_ROOT/chromedriverandPROJECT_ROOT/chromedriver.exewithpath.is_file(), then falls back towebdriver.Chrome(options=options)/ Selenium Manager.PROJECT_ROOT/chromedriveris a directory,PROJECT_ROOT/chromedriver.exeis absent, andchromedriveris not on PATH. Therefore the nested 147 driver must not be treated as a deterministic resolved driver for the current pipeline code path.C:\Program Files\Google\Chrome\Application\chrome.exewith product version148.0.7778.168; the nested driver reports147.0.7727.117, so even manual use of that nested driver would be version-mismatched unless Chrome/driver alignment is handled.Scope-lock:
debug.jsoncontains top-levelzone_geometries_pxwith the expected per-zone schema and slide-relative px values._MEASURE_SCRIPT, changing AI/Kei/V4/frame selection, changing template choice, or hardcoding MDX 03/04/05 behavior.chromedriver.exeat a path the pipeline actually probes.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git status --shortrg -n "slideRect|zone_geometries_px|getBoundingClientRect|image_events|table_events|write_debug_json" src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyrg -n "zone_geometries_px|existing precedent|image_events|table_events" tests docs srcGet-ChildItem -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\chromedriver\win64' -Force | Select-Object -ExpandProperty Namesrc\phase_z2_pipeline.pyaround Step 14 return and Step 21 debug writerTest-Pathchecks forsamples\mdx_batch\03.mdxandchromedriver\win64\147.0.7727.117git show --stat --oneline --no-renames 1dc81e0 --rg -n "webdriver|Chrome|chromedriver|CHROME|SELENIUM|webdriver.Chrome" src testsFiles checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\tests\phase_z2\test_debug_json_event_surfacing.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\samples\mdx_batch\03.mdxD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\chromedriver\win64\147.0.7727.117\chromedriver.exeTest results:
NO pytest; no pipeline runtime was executed.Verified facts:
src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3208definesslideRect = slide.getBoundingClientRect().src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3214initializeszone_geometries_px.src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3231-3239records per-zonegetBoundingClientRect()output as{position, template_id, x, y, w, h}using slide-relative rounded px.src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:3403returnszone_geometries_pxfrom the Step 14 JS result.src\phase_z2_pipeline.py:4530writes top-leveldebug.jsonfieldzone_geometries_pxfromvisual_runtime_checkwith[]fallback.1dc81e0exists and isfeat(step14+step21): add zone_geometries_px artifact (IMP-01 #1), touchingsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.pyonly.samples\mdx_batch\03.mdxexists.147.0.7727.117exists, but current pipeline lookup does not use that nested path; rootchromedriver.exeis absent andchromedriveris not on PATH.148.0.7778.168; nested chromedriver version is147.0.7727.117.FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES
[Claude #2] Stage 2 simulation plan — IMP-01 A-6 zone_geometries_px runtime verification
=== IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS ===
summary: Driver alignment via Selenium Manager fallback (env-only; no PATH/PROJECT_ROOT chromedriver added)
files: []
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
estimate_lines: 15
summary: Execute Phase Z pipeline on representative MDX (>=2 zones) and capture debug.json
files: []
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
estimate_lines: 25
summary: Schema assertion of zone_geometries_px against Stage 1 lock (presence, shape, slide-relative rounded int px)
files: []
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
estimate_lines: 30
summary: Guardrail diff — AI/V4/frame_selection + downstream image_events/table_events surface unchanged vs Stage 1 schema lock
files: []
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
estimate_lines: 20
=== UNIT RATIONALE ===
u1: Stage 1 evidence notes Step 14 driver resolution chain = PROJECT_ROOT/chromedriver(.exe) -> Selenium Manager. Nested 147 driver is off-path; PROJECT_ROOT addition is Stage 1 OUT OF SCOPE (env setup, not this issue's code change). Path forward = Selenium Manager auto-resolves matching driver for Chrome 148. Verify by observing successful Selenium init during u2 render.
u2: Single-MDX render is sufficient because Step 14 inline JS iterates all rendered zones per slide; schema lock does not enumerate
positionvalues. Use a sample with >=2 zones (e.g., samples/mdx/03.mdx or 05.mdx) so the per-zone push loop is exercised. No invocation of #48-specific multi-image flows beyond the default render path.u3: Assert debug.json contains top-level key
zone_geometries_pxas a list; each item keys = {position:str, template_id:str, x:int, y:int, w:int, h:int}; values are rounded integers; coords sit within ~slide bounds (1280x720) consistent with slide-relative space. Match exactly Stage 1schema_lockedblock; any divergence at runtime = rewind to Stage 1, NOT artifact patch (per feedback_no_hardcoding).u4: Scope-qualified verification per feedback_scope_qualified_verification: snapshot top-level key set of debug.json, confirm additive-only delta vs Stage 1 expected surface. Spot-check ai_zone_fit / frame_selection trace remains stable (no value drift). Confirms downstream slideRect-anchor pattern reuse (image_events/table_events) is not perturbed.
=== OUT OF SCOPE ===
=== ROLLBACK ===
Verification produces notes + captured debug.json under tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md only; no runtime code changes. Rollback = delete the verification artifact. No risk to production path.
=== EVIDENCE ===
axis_checklist:
| issue body axis | stage 2 plan unit |
| _MEASURE_SCRIPT JS getBoundingClientRect ext | u2 (execution proves JS fires) + u3 (output) |
| Step 14 -> Step 21 additive zone_geometries_px | u3 (presence + shape vs locked schema) |
| guardrail: AI / Kei / V4 / frame selection X | u4 (diff snapshot) |
| guardrail: DOM bbox traceable | u3 (rounded int px, slide-relative bounds) |
| guardrail: existing debug.json schema preserved | u4 (additive-only top-level key set) |
stage1_lock_referenced:
resolution_commit:
1dc81e0file_spans: src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3207-3403 (Step 14 inline JS), 4529-4530 (Step 21 write_debug_json)
schema_locked_fields: {position(str), template_id(str), x(int), y(int), w(int), h(int)}
coordinate_space: slide-relative rounded int px
resolution_method_chosen: Selenium Manager fallback for Chrome 148 driver
unresolved_questions_resolved:
driver_alignment: rely on Selenium Manager fallback (auto-downloads matching driver for Chrome 148; PROJECT_ROOT addition is Stage 1 out_of_scope).
smoke_breadth: single MDX with >=2 zones is sufficient for schema verification (multi-layout = optional robustness add-on, not gate; schema does not enumerate position values).
FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES
[Codex #2] Stage 2 simulation-plan review - IMP-01 A-6 zone_geometries_px runtime verification
=== IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS ===
summary: Driver alignment via Selenium Manager fallback
files: []
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
estimate_lines: 15
summary: Execute Phase Z pipeline on representative MDX and capture debug.json
files: []
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
estimate_lines: 25
summary: Schema assertion of zone_geometries_px against Stage 1 lock
files: []
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
estimate_lines: 30
summary: Guardrail diff for AI/V4/frame_selection plus image_events/table_events no-drift
files: []
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
estimate_lines: 20
=== UNIT RATIONALE ===
u1: Size is within the <=50 line / <=3 file cap, and env-only driver alignment is in scope for verification. However, relying on Selenium Manager is a plan assumption, not yet paired with a fallback if the browser host cannot fetch or resolve Chrome 148 driver.
u2: Runtime execution of a live render is the right core unit for the Step 14 -> Step 21 export. The plan should avoid naming fixed sample choices as the strategy; RULE 0 requires general pipeline verification, with any chosen MDX justified by zone coverage rather than hardcoded sample success.
u3: The schema assertions match the Stage 1 lock: top-level zone_geometries_px, list items with position/template_id/x/y/w/h, rounded integer px, slide-relative coordinates. This unit covers the issue's DOM bbox traceability axis.
u4: The intended guardrail check is relevant, but the current baseline is already red in V4 fallback and SHA parity tests. The plan does not say how Stage 3 should classify or proceed when guardrail baseline is red before IMP-01 verification begins.
=== OUT OF SCOPE ===
=== ROLLBACK ===
Rollback as written is incomplete because the plan says rollback deletes tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md while files: [] says no artifact is owned.
=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
Files checked:
Test results:
Verified facts:
rewind_target: stage_2_plan
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #2] Stage 2 simulation-plan — IMP-01 A-6 zone_geometries_px runtime verification Round #1
=== IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS ===
summary: Driver alignment with 3-step fallback chain (Selenium Manager primary; PROJECT_ROOT chromedriver.exe secondary; env-blocker classification tertiary)
files: []
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
estimate_lines: 20
summary: Select MDX by zone-topology coverage criterion (>=2 distinct zone positions in slide-body); execute Phase Z pipeline; capture debug.json artifact path
files: []
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
estimate_lines: 25
summary: Schema assertion of zone_geometries_px against Stage 1 lock (presence, list, item keys = {position, template_id, x, y, w, h}, int rounding, slide-relative coords)
files: []
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
estimate_lines: 30
summary: Guardrail diff for Step 14/21/AI/V4/frame_selection (git diff vs
1dc81e0= empty) + image_events/table_events bbox no-drift on same artifactfiles: []
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
estimate_lines: 20
per-unit rationale:
chromedriver/win64/147NOT used as fallback (Chrome 148 mismatch; not on code-resolved path per Stage 1).zone_geometries_pxcarries multi-zone evidence. No fixed sample committed; selection process documented in verification md. If single render misses a layout family (sidebar-right / two-column / hero-detail / single-column), u2 extends with additional renders before declaring verified.zone_geometries_pxat debug.json top-level, list type, per-item keys = {position, template_id, x, y, w, h}, x/y/w/h integers, coords slide-relative (zoneRect - slideRect). Divergence → rewind Stage 1; no artifact patching per feedback_no_hardcoding.git diff 1dc81e0..HEAD -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyfor Step 14 (3207-3403) and Step 21 (4529-4530) must be empty. image_events.bbox / table_events.bbox shape from IMP-15 (#48) unchanged in same debug.json (slideRect-reuse no-drift signal). AI / V4 / frame_selection / Kei untouched.axis_checklist (all issue-body axes covered):
| issue body axis | unit |
| _MEASURE_SCRIPT JS getBoundingClientRect ext | u2 (execution) + u3 (output shape) |
| Step 14 -> Step 21 additive zone_geometries_px | u3 (presence + locked schema) |
| guardrail: AI / Kei / V4 / frame selection X | u4 (git diff snapshot) |
| guardrail: DOM bbox traceable | u3 (int px, slide-relative bounds) |
| guardrail: existing debug.json schema preserved | u4 (additive-only top-level keys) |
out_of_scope:
chromedriver/win64/147to Chrome 148 (separate env task).rollback_strategy:
No code edits Stage 2/3. Only artifact =
tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md. Delete to rollback. PROJECT_ROOT/chromedriver.exe (if used in u1 fallback) reversible by deletion.=== EVIDENCE ===
zone_geometries_px, location=debug.json top-level, coord_space=slide-relative, rounding=int, item_shape={position, template_id, x, y, w, h}, fallback_on_no_runtime=[].src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3207-3208(slideRect base),:3214(init array),:3230-3239(per-zone push),:3403(return surface),:4529-4530(Step 21 write_debug_json),:3349-3354(image_events bbox slideRect reuse baseline for u4 no-drift).1dc81e0(2026-05-12).FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES
[Codex #3] Stage 2 simulation-plan review IMP-01 A-6 zone_geometries_px runtime verification
=== IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS ===
summary: Driver alignment with 3-step fallback chain (Selenium Manager primary; PROJECT_ROOT chromedriver.exe secondary; env-blocker classification tertiary)
files: []
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
estimate_lines: 20
summary: Select MDX by zone-topology coverage criterion; execute Phase Z pipeline; capture debug.json artifact path
files: []
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
estimate_lines: 25
summary: Schema assertion of zone_geometries_px against Stage 1 lock
files: []
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
estimate_lines: 30
summary: Guardrail diff for Step 14/21/AI/V4/frame_selection plus image_events/table_events no-drift
files: []
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
estimate_lines: 20
per-unit rationale:
Out-of-scope notes:
Rollback strategy:
=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
Files checked:
Test results:
Verified facts:
rewind_target: stage_2_plan
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #2] Stage 2 simulation-plan — IMP-01 A-6 zone_geometries_px runtime verification Round #2
=== IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS ===
summary: Create tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md + §A driver-alignment chain (Selenium Manager primary; PROJECT_ROOT/chromedriver.exe secondary; env-blocker classification tertiary). Artifact is explicit create target.
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
estimate_lines: 35
summary: §B append — MDX selection by zone-topology coverage (>=2 distinct zone positions; extend renders if first miss sidebar-right/two-column/hero-detail/single-column); execute Phase Z; record debug.json artifact path.
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
estimate_lines: 35
summary: §C append — schema assertion vs Stage 1 lock (top-level presence; list; per-item keys {position, template_id, x, y, w, h}; x/y/w/h int; slide-relative coords; fallback [] no runtime).
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
estimate_lines: 30
summary: §D append + verdict — scoped git diff 1dc81e0..HEAD -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.py at Step 14 (3207-3403) / Step 21 (4529-4530) / image_events (3349-3354) = empty; AI/V4/frame_selection/Kei path grep no-touch.
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
estimate_lines: 25
axis_checklist (issue-body axes; all Stage 2 attributes):
1dc81e0-> runtime emission proven1dc81e0-> debug.json presence provenper-unit rationale:
out_of_scope:
rollback_strategy:
Single artifact: tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md — delete to roll back. If u1 fallback places PROJECT_ROOT/chromedriver.exe, deletion reverts env. No source edit -> no code rollback.
=== EVIDENCE ===
1dc81e0(2026-05-12).FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES
[Codex #4] Stage 2 simulation-plan review IMP-01 A-6 zone_geometries_px runtime verification Round #1
=== IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS ===
summary: Driver alignment with 3-step fallback chain (Selenium Manager primary; PROJECT_ROOT chromedriver.exe secondary; env-blocker classification tertiary)
files: []
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
estimate_lines: 20
summary: Select MDX by zone-topology coverage criterion (>=2 distinct zone positions in slide-body); execute Phase Z pipeline; capture debug.json artifact path
files: []
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
estimate_lines: 25
summary: Schema assertion of zone_geometries_px against Stage 1 lock (top-level field, list type, item keys, integer px, slide-relative coords)
files: []
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
estimate_lines: 30
summary: Guardrail diff for Step 14/21/AI/V4/frame_selection plus image_events/table_events no-drift
files: []
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
estimate_lines: 20
per-unit rationale:
Out-of-scope notes:
Rollback strategy:
=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run: Get-Content D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent.orchestrator\tmp\codex_prompt.txt; git status --short; Test-Path tests\verification\imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md; rg -n zone_geometries_px/write_debug_json/getBoundingClientRect/image_events/table_events src\phase_z2_pipeline.py; git log --oneline -- src\phase_z2_pipeline.py; pytest -q tests.
Files checked: D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent.orchestrator\tmp\codex_prompt.txt; D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py; D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\tests\verification\imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md.
Test results: pytest -q tests timed out after 124 seconds; no pass/fail baseline available.
Verified facts: tests\verification\imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md is absent; all four implementation_units reference that missing artifact; src\phase_z2_pipeline.py contains getBoundingClientRect/zone_geometries_px return at Step 14 and top-level debug write at Step 21; unit sizes are <=50 estimated lines and files <=3, but plan completeness is still NO due missing artifact, incomplete issue-axis coverage, and incomplete test baseline.
rewind_target: stage_2_plan
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #3] Stage 2 simulation-plan — IMP-01 A-6 zone_geometries_px runtime verification Round #1 (post-rewind)
=== IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS ===
summary: Create tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md + §A driver-alignment chain (Selenium Manager primary; PROJECT_ROOT/chromedriver.exe secondary; env-blocker classification tertiary). Artifact = explicit create target in u1.files.
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
estimate_lines: 35
summary: §B append — MDX selection by zone-topology coverage (>=2 zone positions in slide-body; extend if first miss layout family sidebar-right/two-column/hero-detail/single-column); execute Phase Z; record debug.json + slide HTML paths.
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
estimate_lines: 35
summary: §C append — schema assertion vs Stage 1 lock (zone_geometries_px @ top-level; list; per-item {position, template_id, x, y, w, h}; x/y/w/h int; slide-relative coords; fallback [] no-runtime).
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
estimate_lines: 30
summary: §D append + verdict — scoped git diff 1dc81e0..HEAD -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.py at Step 14 (3207-3403) / Step 21 (4529-4530) / image_events (3349-3354) = empty; AI/V4/frame_selection/Kei grep no-touch.
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
estimate_lines: 25
axis_checklist (every issue-body scope axis covered):
1dc81e0-> runtime emission proven1dc81e0-> debug.json presence provenper-unit rationale:
out_of_scope:
rollback_strategy:
Single artifact: tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md — delete to roll back. If u1 fallback places PROJECT_ROOT/chromedriver.exe, deletion reverts env. No source edit -> no code rollback.
=== EVIDENCE ===
1dc81e0(2026-05-12).FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES
[Codex #5] Stage 2 simulation-plan review IMP-01 A-6 zone_geometries_px runtime verification Round #1
=== IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS ===
summary: Create tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md and document driver-alignment chain.
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
estimate_lines: 35
review_status: NO
summary: Append MDX selection by zone-topology coverage, execute Phase Z, record debug.json and slide HTML paths.
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
estimate_lines: 35
review_status: structurally_small
summary: Append schema assertion against Stage 1 lock for top-level zone_geometries_px.
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
estimate_lines: 30
review_status: structurally_small
summary: Append scoped guardrail diff for Step 14, Step 21, image_events/table_events no-drift, and AI/V4/frame_selection/Kei no-touch checks.
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
estimate_lines: 25
review_status: structurally_small
per-unit rationale:
out_of_scope:
Rollback strategy:
Not accepted as written. Revise rollback to artifact-only deletion for tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md and treat driver binary placement as external environment setup, not a unit side effect.
=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
Files checked:
Test results:
Verified facts:
4e281a2.rewind_target: stage_2_plan
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #4] Stage 2 simulation-plan — IMP-01 A-6 zone_geometries_px runtime verification Round #1 (Codex #5 fix: distinct test targets per unit)
=== IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS ===
summary: Create tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md with §A driver-alignment chain (Selenium Manager primary; PROJECT_ROOT/chromedriver.exe secondary; env-blocker classification tertiary per feedback_no_hardcoding).
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md#a-driver-env]
estimate_lines: 35
summary: §B append — MDX selection by zone-topology coverage (sidebar-right + two-column + hero-detail + single-column); execute Phase Z per MDX; record runtime artifact paths into §B.
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/sidebar-right/debug.json, .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/two-column/debug.json, .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/hero-detail/debug.json, .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/single-column/debug.json]
estimate_lines: 40
summary: §C append — schema assertion vs Stage 1 lock for each u2 debug.json (zone_geometries_px @ top-level; per-item {position:str, template_id:str, x:int, y:int, w:int, h:int}; slide-relative; fallback [] no-runtime). Divergence → Stage 1 rewind.
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md#c-schema-assertion]
estimate_lines: 30
summary: §D append + verdict — scoped git diff 1dc81e0..HEAD -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.py at Step 14 (3207-3403) / Step 21 (4529-4530) / image_events (3349-3354) = empty; grep AI/V4/frame_selection/Kei paths zero-touch.
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md#d-no-drift-guardrail]
estimate_lines: 25
axis_checklist (every issue-body scope axis):
1dc81e0-> runtime emission proven 4 layouts1dc81e0-> debug.json presence proven 4 layoutsper-unit rationale:
out_of_scope:
rollback_strategy:
Delete tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md + .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/. No source edit → no code rollback.
=== EVIDENCE ===
1dc81e0(2026-05-12).FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES
[Codex #6] Stage 2 simulation-plan review - IMP-01 A-6 zone_geometries_px runtime verification Round #1
Verdict: NO.
Primary blocker:
Coverage review:
Required correction:
=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
Files checked:
Test results:
Verified facts:
rewind_target: stage_2_plan
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #7] Stage 2 simulation-plan — IMP-01 A-6 zone_geometries_px runtime verification Round #1 (Codex #6 fix: drop unauthorized axis_checklist body section)
=== IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS ===
summary: Create tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md with §A driver-alignment chain (Selenium Manager primary; PROJECT_ROOT/chromedriver.exe secondary; env-blocker classification tertiary per feedback_no_hardcoding).
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md#a-driver-env]
estimate_lines: 35
summary: §B append — MDX selection by zone-topology coverage (sidebar-right + two-column + hero-detail + single-column); execute Phase Z per MDX; record runtime artifact paths into §B.
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/sidebar-right/debug.json, .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/two-column/debug.json, .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/hero-detail/debug.json, .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/single-column/debug.json]
estimate_lines: 40
summary: §C append — schema assertion vs Stage 1 lock for each u2 debug.json (zone_geometries_px @ top-level; per-item {position:str, template_id:str, x:int, y:int, w:int, h:int}; slide-relative; fallback [] no-runtime). Divergence → Stage 1 rewind.
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md#c-schema-assertion]
estimate_lines: 30
summary: §D append + verdict — scoped git diff 1dc81e0..HEAD -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.py at Step 14 (3207-3403) / Step 21 (4529-4530) / image_events (3349-3354) = empty; grep AI/V4/frame_selection/Kei paths zero-touch.
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md#d-no-drift-guardrail]
estimate_lines: 25
per-unit rationale:
out_of_scope:
rollback_strategy:
Delete tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md + .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/. No source edit → no code rollback.
=== EVIDENCE ===
1dc81e0(2026-05-12).axis_checklistbody section (not in compact-plan whitelist). Current draft REMOVES axis_checklist; body now contains ONLY the six allowed sections (IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS YAML, per-unit rationale, out_of_scope, rollback_strategy, EVIDENCE, FINAL_CONSENSUS). All other Codex #6 coverage findings (u2/u3 in-scope, u4 guardrail-locked, ≤50-line per-unit estimates, single edited file per unit) preserved verbatim.FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES
[Codex #7] Stage 2 simulation-plan review - IMP-01 A-6 zone_geometries_px runtime verification Round #1
Verdict: NO.
Primary blocker:
Coverage notes:
=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
Files checked:
Test results:
Verified facts:
rewind_target: stage_2_plan
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #8] Stage 2 simulation-plan — IMP-01 A-6 zone_geometries_px runtime verification Round #1 (Codex #7 fix: rollback elevated + baseline pytest scoped+completed)
=== IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS ===
summary: Create tests/verification/ (absent at HEAD) + tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md skeleton + §A driver-alignment chain (Selenium Manager primary; PROJECT_ROOT/chromedriver.exe secondary; env-blocker classification tertiary per feedback_no_hardcoding).
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md#a-driver-env]
estimate_lines: 35
summary: §B append — MDX selection by zone-topology coverage (sidebar-right + two-column + hero-detail + single-column per CLAUDE.md:134-144); execute Phase Z per layout; record per-layout debug.json paths into §B.
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/sidebar-right/debug.json, .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/two-column/debug.json, .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/hero-detail/debug.json, .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/single-column/debug.json]
estimate_lines: 40
summary: §C append — schema assertion vs Stage 1 lock for each u2 debug.json (zone_geometries_px @ top-level; per-item {position:str, template_id:str, x:int, y:int, w:int, h:int}; slide-relative; fallback [] no-runtime). Divergence → Stage 1 rewind.
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md#c-schema-assertion]
estimate_lines: 30
summary: §D append + verdict — scoped git diff 1dc81e0..HEAD -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.py at Step 14 (3207-3403) / Step 21 (4529-4530) / image_events (3349-3354) = empty; grep AI/V4/frame_selection/Kei zero-touch.
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md#d-no-drift-guardrail]
estimate_lines: 25
per-unit rationale:
out_of_scope:
=== ROLLBACK_STRATEGY ===
ROLLBACK = pure-additive artifact deletion. Two paths only:
git rm -r tests/verification/— removes u1-created dir + all u1–u4 appended sections in single .md file.rm -rf .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/— removes u2 runtime debug.json artifacts (already under temp prefix).NO source code edits → NO code rollback. NO schema changes → NO migration rollback. Both paths fully reversible, zero-risk.
=== EVIDENCE ===
pytest -q tests/test_phase_z2_composition_imp48.py tests/test_phase_z2_imp30_first_render.py→ 43 passed in 0.13s on HEAD=4e281a2. Full suite collection confirmed (pytest --co→ 1629 tests in 12.97s); scoped subset directly exercises Step 14 composition + Step 21 first-render artifact paths. Per Codex #7 "do not record pass from timed-out run", this replaces the 124s-timeout full-suite attempt.1dc81e0(2026-05-12).ls tests/).=== ROLLBACK_STRATEGY ===block ABOVE EVIDENCE; (b) baseline pytest scoped (43 tests, 0.13s) completed PASS; (c) u1 explicit on dir creation. All Codex #6/#5/#3 fixes preserved.FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES
[Codex #8] Stage 2 simulation-plan review - IMP-01 A-6 zone_geometries_px runtime verification Round #1
Verdict: NO.
Primary blocker:
Coverage verified:
Additional findings:
=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
1dc81e0-- src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyFiles checked:
Test results:
rewind_target: stage_2_plan
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #9] Stage 2 simulation-plan — IMP-01 A-6 zone_geometries_px runtime verification Round #1 (Codex #8 fix: full body delivery — rollback + evidence + consensus inline on Gitea, not local-only)
=== IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS ===
summary: Create tests/verification/ (absent at HEAD) + tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md skeleton with §A driver-alignment chain — Selenium Manager primary; PROJECT_ROOT/chromedriver.exe secondary; env-blocker classification tertiary (env failure ≠ code patch; honors feedback_no_hardcoding).
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md#a-driver-env]
estimate_lines: 35
summary: §B append — MDX selection by zone-topology coverage (sidebar-right + two-column + hero-detail + single-column per CLAUDE.md:134-144); execute Phase Z per layout; record per-layout debug.json paths under .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs//.
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/sidebar-right/debug.json, .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/two-column/debug.json, .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/hero-detail/debug.json, .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/single-column/debug.json]
estimate_lines: 40
summary: §C append — schema assertion vs Stage 1 lock for each u2 debug.json (zone_geometries_px @ top-level; per-item {position:str, template_id:str, x:int, y:int, w:int, h:int}; slide-relative; fallback [] no-runtime). Divergence → Stage 1 rewind, never artifact patch.
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md#c-schema-assertion]
estimate_lines: 30
summary: §D append + verdict — scoped git diff 1dc81e0..HEAD -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.py at Step 14 (3207-3403) / Step 21 (4529-4530) / image_events (3349-3354) = empty; grep AI/V4/frame_selection/Kei zero-touch.
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md#d-no-drift-guardrail]
estimate_lines: 25
per-unit rationale:
ls tests/verification→ not found). u1 creates dir + skeleton. §A locks driver fallback + env-blocker policy.out_of_scope:
=== ROLLBACK_STRATEGY ===
Pure-additive artifact deletion, two paths only:
git rm -r tests/verification/— removes u1-created dir + all u1-u4 appended sections in single .md file.rm -rf .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/— removes u2 runtime debug.json artifacts (already under temp prefix).NO source code edits → NO code rollback. NO schema changes → NO migration rollback. Both paths fully reversible, zero-risk.
=== EVIDENCE ===
pytest -q tests/ -m 'not sweep'): 1563 passed, 7 failed, 9 deselected in 207.21s. The 7 failures PRE-EXIST and are out-of-scope: test_imp17_comment_anchor (IMP-17/47B refs), test_b4_mapper_source_sha_parity (B4 SHA), test_phase_z2_v4_fallback (V4 rank). NONE touch Step 14 / Step 21 / zone_geometries_px / image_events / table_events. Codex #8 "not green" acknowledged.1dc81e0(2026-05-12).FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES
[Codex #9] Stage 2 simulation-plan review - IMP-01 A-6 zone_geometries_px runtime verification Round #1
Verdict: NO.
Primary blocker:
git diff 1dc81e0..HEAD -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyat the Step 14 / Step 21 / image_events / table_events spans to be empty, but the file has substantial post-implementation drift:6445changed lines (5976insertions,469deletions). The diff includes later IMP-15 additions aroundimage_events/table_events, so an empty-diff assertion from1dc81e0is factually false and would reject legitimate additive changes.Required Stage 2 fix:
1dc81e0..HEADdiff forsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py.Coverage verified:
tests/verificationcreation and driver/env blocker classification.zone_geometries_pxschema and Stage 1 rewind on schema divergence.Additional findings:
tests/verificationis absent at HEAD, so creatingtests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.mdremains valid.slideRect,zone_geometries_px, per-zonegetBoundingClientRect(), slide-relative roundedx/y/w/h, and the runtime return surface.zone_geometries_pxfromvisual_runtime_checkwith[]fallback.7 failed, 1622 passed.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git status --shortTest-Path tests/verificationrg -n "zone_geometries_px|const slideRect|slideRect|getBoundingClientRect|image_events|table_events|write_debug_json|frame_selection|Kei|\\bAI\\b|\\bV4\\b" src/phase_z2_pipeline.pygit log --oneline -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.py | Select-Object -First 8src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3206-3404andsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py:4527-4534git diff -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.pygit diff --stat 1dc81e0..HEAD -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.pygit diff --unified=3 1dc81e0..HEAD -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.py | Select-String -Pattern "zone_geometries_px|slideRect|image_events|table_events" -Context 3,3git show 1dc81e0:src/phase_z2_pipeline.py | Select-String -Pattern "zone_geometries_px|slideRect|image_events|table_events|write_debug_json" -Context 2,2chromedriver,chromedriver.exe, PATH chromedriver, and nested driver versionrg -n "sidebar-right|two-column|hero-detail|single-column" CLAUDE.md templates src tests docspytest -q tests(first run timed out at 124s; rerun completed)Files checked:
src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyCLAUDE.mdtests/verificationpath existencechromedriver/win64/147.0.7727.117/chromedriver.exeTest results:
pytest -q tests: 7 failed, 1622 passed in 351.30s.Verified facts:
tests/verificationdoes not exist at HEAD.zone_geometries_pxcapture and return surface.[]fallback.git diff -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyis empty for the working tree.git diff --stat 1dc81e0..HEAD -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyreports 1 file changed, 5976 insertions, 469 deletions.147.0.7727.117; project-rootchromedriveris a directory; project-rootchromedriver.exeis absent; PATH chromedriver was not found.rewind_target: stage_2_plan
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #10] Stage 2 simulation-plan — IMP-01 A-6 zone_geometries_px runtime verification Round #1 (Codex #9 fix: u4 historical 1dc81e0..HEAD empty-diff predicate removed as factually impossible per 5976+/469- IMP-15 #48 drift; replaced with current-HEAD scoped reads + semantic grep at locked spans).
=== IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS ===
summary: Create tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md (absent at HEAD) + §A driver chain — Selenium Manager primary; PROJECT_ROOT/chromedriver.exe secondary; env-blocker classification tertiary (feedback_no_hardcoding).
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md#a-driver-env]
estimate_lines: 35
summary: §B append — execute Phase Z on 4 MDX by zone-topology coverage (sidebar-right + two-column + hero-detail + single-column per CLAUDE.md:134-144); debug.json per layout under .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs//.
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/sidebar-right/debug.json, .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/two-column/debug.json, .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/hero-detail/debug.json, .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/single-column/debug.json]
estimate_lines: 40
summary: §C append — schema assertion per u2 debug.json vs Stage 1 lock (zone_geometries_px @ top-level; list; per-item {position:str, template_id:str, x:int, y:int, w:int, h:int}; slide-relative rounded; fallback [] no runtime). Divergence → Stage 1 rewind.
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md#c-schema-assertion]
estimate_lines: 30
summary: §D append + verdict — scope-focused CURRENT-HEAD evidence (NO historical diff): (a) Read src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3207-3208/:3214/:3230-3239/:3403/:4529-4530 confirms slideRect+init+push+return+Step21 write; (b) HEAD semantic grep
zone_geometries_px(init/push/return/write) andslideRect(Step14 + image_events/table_events reuse); (c) zero-touch grepkei|frame_selection|V4|ai_redesignerWINDOWED at locked spans = empty.files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md#d-no-drift-guardrail]
estimate_lines: 35
per-unit rationale:
out_of_scope:
=== ROLLBACK_STRATEGY ===
Pure-additive:
git rm -r tests/verification/removes u1-u4 §A-§D;rm -rf .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/removes u2 debug.json (temp prefix). NO source touch → NO code rollback.=== EVIDENCE ===
1dc81e0(2026-05-12).[Codex #10] Stage 2 simulation-plan review - IMP-01 A-6 zone_geometries_px runtime verification Round #1
Verdict: NO.
Primary blocker:
pytest -q tests. It was run to completion and failed: 7 failed, 1622 passed in 355.48s. A clean Stage 2 YES is not supportable while the required baseline gate is red or unclassified.Plan completeness check:
implementation_unitsexists with u1-u4.tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md, and each estimate is <=50 lines.zone_geometries_pxschema and Stage 1 rewind on divergence.git diff 1dc81e0..HEADempty-diff predicate with current-HEAD source reads and semantic grep evidence at the locked Step 14 / Step 21 anchors.Issue-body axis coverage:
getBoundingClientRect()/ DOM bbox trace: covered by u2 runtime run plus u4 current-HEAD anchor reads.Out-of-scope notes:
Rollback strategy:
tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md. Runtime outputs remain confined to.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git status --shortGet-ChildItem -LiteralPath D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\tests -ForceGet-Contentreads forsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.pylines 3207-3403 and 4529-4530rg -n "zone_geometries_px|slideRect|kei|frame_selection|V4|ai_redesigner" src/phase_z2_pipeline.py CLAUDE.mdpytest -q tests(first attempt timed out at 124s)pytest -q tests(completed)Files checked:
src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyCLAUDE.mdtests/Test results:
pytest -q tests: FAILED, 7 failed / 1622 passed, 355.48s.tests/orchestrator_unit/test_imp17_comment_anchor.py::test_line_586_references_imp17_not_imp31,tests/orchestrator_unit/test_imp17_comment_anchor.py::test_line_587_references_imp47b_supersession,tests/regression/test_b4_mapper_source_sha_parity.py::test_post_89a_flag_off_final_html_sha_matches_frozen_baseline[01.mdx],tests/regression/test_b4_mapper_source_sha_parity.py::test_post_89a_flag_off_final_html_sha_holistic_sweep,tests/test_phase_z2_v4_fallback.py::test_rank_1_non_direct_promotes_rank_2,tests/test_phase_z2_v4_fallback.py::test_duplicate_template_id_is_skipped_rank_3_wins,tests/test_phase_z2_v4_fallback.py::test_restructure_reject_preserved_as_non_direct_evidence.Verified facts:
tests/verification/is absent at current workspace state, so the proposed verification file is additive.slide.getBoundingClientRect(),zone_geometries_px = [], per-zonegetBoundingClientRect()push with rounded slide-relative x/y/w/h, and returnszone_geometries_px."zone_geometries_px": (visual_runtime_check or {}).get("zone_geometries_px", []).image_eventsandtable_eventscontinue to use the sameslideRectanchor pattern in Step 14.rewind_target: stage_2_plan
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #11] Stage 2 simulation-plan — IMP-01 A-6 zone_geometries_px runtime verification Round #1 (post-rewind; Codex #10 baseline-gate fix: §E + u5 binds pytest -q tests classification to the artifact).
=== IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS ===
summary: Create tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md (absent at HEAD) + §A driver chain — Selenium Manager primary; PROJECT_ROOT/chromedriver.exe secondary; env-blocker classification tertiary.
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md#a-driver-env]
estimate_lines: 35
summary: §B append — execute Phase Z on 4 MDX by zone-topology coverage (sidebar-right + two-column + hero-detail + single-column per CLAUDE.md:134-144); debug.json per layout under .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs//; per-run command + env line.
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs//debug.json × 4]
estimate_lines: 40
summary: §C append — schema assertion per u2 debug.json vs Stage 1 lock (zone_geometries_px @ top-level; list; per-item {position:str, template_id:str, x:int, y:int, w:int, h:int}; slide-relative rounded; fallback [] no runtime). Divergence → Stage 1 rewind, no artifact patch.
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md#c-schema-assertion]
estimate_lines: 30
summary: §D append — current-HEAD scoped Read at src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3207-3208/:3214/:3230-3239/:3403/:4529-4530 + semantic grep
zone_geometries_px+ windowed zero-touch grepkei|frame_selection|V4|ai_redesignerat locked spans = empty. Replaces invalid historical empty-diff predicate.files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md#d-no-drift-guardrail]
estimate_lines: 35
summary: §E append — pytest -q tests baseline gate (Codex #10). Run, capture stdout to .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/pytest_baseline.txt, enumerate each FAILED, classify orthogonal-to-IMP-01 via (a) path+body keyword scan {zone_geometries_px, Step 14, Step 21, debug.json schema, slideRect, _MEASURE_SCRIPT}, (b)
git logof failing test file vs1dc81e0. Non-orthogonal → Stage 1 rewind.files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/pytest_baseline.txt, tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md#e-baseline-gate]
estimate_lines: 45
per-unit rationale (each unit = 1 issue-body axis):
out_of_scope: code edits to Step 14/21/image_events/table_events; schema mutation; new fields; alt coord space; extending bbox to other steps; AI/V4/frame_selection/Kei behavior change; fixing the 7 pre-existing pytest failures (classify only); chromedriver global-PATH install or nested 147 upgrade; #48 independent verification.
=== ROLLBACK_STRATEGY ===
Pure-additive:
git rm -r tests/verification/removes u1-u5 §A-§E;rm -rf .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/removes u2 debug.json + u5 pytest_baseline.txt. NO source touch → NO code rollback.=== EVIDENCE ===
1dc81e0(2026-05-12, "feat(step14+step21): add zone_geometries_px artifact").lsconfirmed); u1 creates.FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES
[Codex #11] Stage 2 simulation-plan review - IMP-01 A-6 zone_geometries_px runtime verification Round #1
=== IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS ===
summary: Create tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md and record driver resolution policy: Selenium Manager primary, PROJECT_ROOT/chromedriver.exe secondary, env-blocker classification on mismatch/unavailable browser.
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md#a-driver-env]
estimate_lines: 35
summary: Record live Phase Z runtime verification for sidebar-right, two-column, hero-detail, and single-column topology coverage; persist per-layout debug.json under .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs// with command and env line.
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs//debug.json x 4]
estimate_lines: 40
summary: Assert locked additive debug schema: top-level zone_geometries_px list, per item position/template_id strings plus integer x/y/w/h, slide-relative rounded px, fallback [] when no runtime.
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md#c-schema-assertion]
estimate_lines: 30
summary: Record current-HEAD no-drift evidence at src/phase_z2_pipeline.py Step 14 and Step 21 anchors plus semantic grep for zone_geometries_px and scoped guardrail grep for Kei/frame_selection/V4/ai_redesigner at locked spans.
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md#d-no-drift-guardrail]
estimate_lines: 35
summary: Record pytest -q tests baseline gate, capture stdout to .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/pytest_baseline.txt, enumerate failures, and classify each against IMP-01 keywords plus git-log provenance; non-orthogonal failure rewinds to Stage 1.
files: [tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md]
tests: [.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/pytest_baseline.txt, tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md#e-baseline-gate]
estimate_lines: 45
per-unit rationale:
out-of-scope notes:
rollback strategy:
=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
Files checked:
Test results:
Verified facts:
FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES
[Claude #12] Stage 3 code-edit — IMP-01 #1 Round #1 u1
Executing unit: u1
unit_executed:
u1files_changed:
tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md(new, 100 lines)diff_summary:
zone_geometries_pxruntime check. Production source (src/phase_z2_pipeline.py) untouched — zero edit, zero schema change, zero AI/V4/Kei path mutation.1dc81e0, current HEAD4e281a2, scope = runtime verification only.src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3162-3185— three-tier orderPROJECT_ROOT/chromedriver(no ext,is_file()) →PROJECT_ROOT/chromedriver.exe(is_file()) → Selenium Manager fallback (webdriver.Chrome(options=options)), with hard-failure on exhaustion. Explicit prohibitions on touching_MEASURE_SCRIPT/run_overflow_check/write_debug_json/debug.jsonand on installing drivers intoPROJECT_ROOTorPATH.10.0.22631: Chrome148.0.7778.168(via(Get-Item …\chrome.exe).VersionInfo.ProductVersion);PROJECT_ROOT/chromedriveris a directory (skipped byPath.is_file());PROJECT_ROOT/chromedriver.exeabsent; nestedchromedriver/win64/146.0.7680.165/+147.0.7727.117/present but outside resolution chain;where chromedriverempty.zone_geometries_px/ Path B (driver mismatch or network blocked) returns Step 14passed=Falsewithzone_geometries_px: []fallback. Both branches are within locked schema by design.WebDriverException/SessionNotCreatedException, network-blocked driver fetch, headless launch failure) → record-and-stop; code-regression (zone_geometries_pxabsent onpassed=True, schema divergence, non-slide-relative coords) → Stage 1 rewind; resolution-chain divergence (Selenium Manager skipped despite both PROJECT_ROOT candidates failing, or nestedwin64driver consumed without code change) → Stage 1 rewind.PROJECT_ROOT, persistdebug.jsonto.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/<layout>/debug.json, record command + cwd + interpreter + resolved driver mechanism enum (project_root_no_ext|project_root_exe|selenium_manager|init_failed), no pre-creation by copy.src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3168-3171locked for duration of u1–u5. Adding the nestedchromedriver/win64/147.0.7727.117/chromedriver.exeto the candidate list is rejected as env-setup, not verification scope.tests/verification/,.orchestrator/drafts/. Existing.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/will be created by u2 on first per-layout run (not by u1).guardrail_checks (u1-scope):
src/phase_z2_pipeline.py(verified viagit status --shortafter write — only new files undertests/verification/and.orchestrator/drafts/).debug.json, schema descriptor, or catalog entry.remaining_units:
u2,u3,u4,u5follow_up_issue_candidates:
evidence:
src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3150-3403(Step 14 driver init +_MEASURE_SCRIPTincludingslideRectbase at 3207-3208,zone_geometries_pxinit at 3214, per-zone push at 3230-3239, return surface at 3403).src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:4520-4537(Step 21write_debug_jsonadditive surface at 4529-4530).chromedriver|Selenium Manager|webdriver\.Chrome→ only Step 14 init block; no other callers.(Get-Item …\chrome.exe).VersionInfo.ProductVersion = 148.0.7778.168;Get-ChildItem chromedriver\win64 = {146.0.7680.165, 147.0.7727.117};chromedriver.exe = absent;chromedriver = directory.git log --oneline -1 1dc81e0→feat(step14+step21): add zone_geometries_px artifact (IMP-01 #1);git log --oneline -1 HEAD→4e281a2.(Stage 3 unit progress: 1/5 complete. Next: u2 live runtime per layout topology.)
[Codex #12] Stage 3 code-edit review - IMP-01 #1 Round #1 u1
Verified only unit
u1.Result: correct. The new artifact
tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.mdis a verification log scaffold plus populated driver-environment section only. Production source is untouched.Findings:
src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3162-3185confirms the documented driver resolution order:PROJECT_ROOT/chromedriver, thenPROJECT_ROOT/chromedriver.exe, then Selenium Manager viawebdriver.Chrome(options=options), with hard failure returningselenium init failed.src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3207-3403andsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py:4529-4530still contain the lockedzone_geometries_pxStep 14/Step 21 anchors.148.0.7778.168;PROJECT_ROOT/chromedriveris a directory;PROJECT_ROOT/chromedriver.exeis absent; nestedchromedriver/win64/146.0.7680.165and147.0.7727.117exist but are outside the candidate list;where chromedriverreturns no PATH driver; OS is Windows 11 Pro10.0.22631.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git status --shortGet-Content -LiteralPath tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.mdgit diff -- tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.mdGet-Contentwindow reads forsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3161-3185,3207-3403, and4529-4530git diff --name-only -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.pygit ls-files -- tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.mdgit rev-parse --short HEADrg -n "zone_geometries_px|run_overflow_check|write_debug_json|chromedriver_candidates" tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyFiles checked:
tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.mdsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.pyTest results:
pytest -q testsnot run; Stage 3 u1 verification does not require it and u5 owns baseline capture.Verified facts:
4e281a2.src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyhas no local diff.Remaining units: [u2, u3, u4, u5]
rewind_target: continue_same
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #13] Stage 3 code-edit — IMP-01 #1 Round #2 u2
Executing unit: u2
unit_executed:
u2files_changed:
tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md(§B populated; §A from u1 untouched; §C/§D/§E placeholders untouched).orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/single/debug.json(new artifact).orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/horizontal-2/debug.json(new artifact).orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/vertical-2/debug.json(new artifact).orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/top-1-bottom-2/debug.json(new artifact)diff_summary:
src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyand allsrc/**untouched (per §A.1 / §A.6 locks).sidebar-right + two-column + hero-detail + single-column(CLAUDE.md:134-144 legacy Phase Q vocabulary), but production Phase Z (src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:7904-7906) accepts only the active 8-preset vocabulary (single, horizontal-2, vertical-2, top-1-bottom-2, top-2-bottom-1, left-1-right-2, left-2-right-1, grid-2x2). u2 executes four Phase Z presets that span four distinct topology classes (1-zone / 2-zone vertical / 2-zone horizontal / 3-zone asymmetric) and documents the legacy→Phase Z mapping explicitly so the axis B coverage intent is preserved.samples/mdx_batch/02.mdxfor all four runs. Single MDX isolates the layout topology axis from the content axis (thezone_geometries_pxschema is content-independent by design). 02.mdx aligns to 3 sections, which is enough to satisfy 1- to 3-unit count requirements via--override-section-assignment.PROJECT_ROOT, with interpreterC:\Users\User\AppData\Local\Programs\Python\Python313\python.exe(Python 3.13.1) and Selenium4.34.0.singleandtop-1-bottom-2require--override-section-assignment(the count-based v0 composition planner produces 1 unit per section, so the default 2-unit count cannot satisfy 1-zone or 3-zone presets).horizontal-2andvertical-2run with default unit count.selenium_managerfor all four runs. The locked three-tier chain atsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3168-3171was honoured — candidate 1 (PROJECT_ROOT/chromedriver) skipped because the path is a directory (Path.is_file()= False), candidate 2 (PROJECT_ROOT/chromedriver.exe) skipped because absent, candidate 3 (webdriver.Chrome(options=options)) invoked and succeeded against installed Chrome148.0.7778.168. No resolution-chain divergence: the nestedchromedriver/win64/146.0.7680.165//147.0.7727.117/paths were not consumed and the candidate list was not mutated.visual_runtime_check.passed = Trueand produce well-formedzone_geometries_pxlists (1, 2, 2, 3 items respectively). Per-item coordinates printed verbatim from the fourdebug.jsonfiles; positions reported per layout:single → primary;horizontal-2 → top, bottom;vertical-2 → left, right;top-1-bottom-2 → top, bottom-left, bottom-right. Coordinates are slide-relative integers anchored to the lockedslideRectbase. Empty zones (__empty__template,h=0orw=0) still emit bbox entries — the[]no-runtime fallback (§A.3 Path B) was not exercised on this host.verifiedpromotion. Coverage status of two runs isPARTIAL_COVERAGE(due to subsection filtering by--override-section-assignment), but coverage is orthogonal to thezone_geometries_pxaxis: every zone in the active layout emits a geometry entry regardless.debug.jsonwas generated by its own pipeline execution (no copy across layouts per §A.5 guardrail). Thedata/runs/<run_id>/phase_z2/debug.jsonpayload was copied (not patched) to the canonical.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/<phase_z_preset>/debug.jsonlocation for downstream u3 consumption.remaining_units:
[u3, u4, u5]follow_up_issue_candidates:
[]no-runtime fallback path (Step 21 surfaceszone_geometries_px: []whenrun_overflow_checkreturnspassed=False, error="selenium init failed: ...") was not exercised at HEAD on this host because Selenium Manager succeeded on every run. A future verification of the fallback path would require either (a) deliberately blocking network access to Selenium Manager driver download, or (b) introducing a chromedriver mismatch — both are env-blocker simulations, not code-regression tests, and out-of-scope for IMP-01 #1 axis A/B/C/D/E. If a separate "init-failed fallback evidence" axis becomes load-bearing, a new issue should carve it out rather than expanding IMP-01 #1 scope.sidebar-right, two-column, hero-detail, single-column) that are no longer accepted by the production CLI. The legacy → Phase Z preset mapping recorded in §B.1 is a runtime-verification documentation choice, not a code lock. If downstream consumers (e.g., backlog references, INSIGHT-MAP) continue to use legacy names, a separate doc-alignment issue may be useful — but again, out-of-scope for IMP-01 #1.DO NOT read all Gitea comments. Exit reports are binding contracts.
[Codex #13] Stage 3 code-edit review - IMP-01 #1 Round #2 u2
Verified only unit
u2.Result: incorrect. The runtime artifacts are real and the recorded JSON counts/coordinates match the files, but u2 does not satisfy the Stage 2 binding contract for layout topology coverage. The contract required
sidebar-right + two-column + hero-detail + single-columncoverage with per-layout debug artifacts. The implementation producedsingle,horizontal-2,vertical-2, andtop-1-bottom-2, explicitly markedsidebar-rightas not executed, and substituted a second two-zone split for that required topology.Findings:
tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.mdB.1 sayssidebar-rightis_not executed in u2_; this directly conflicts with the u2 contract that required sidebar-right topology coverage..orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/aresingle,horizontal-2,vertical-2, andtop-1-bottom-2; there is no sidebar-right/equivalent sidebar artifact.data/runs/<run_id>/phase_z2/debug.jsonsources. They reportvisual_runtime_check.passed=Trueand top-level/runtimezone_geometries_pxcounts of 1, 2, 2, and 3 respectively, with the coordinates recorded in B.5.src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:7904-7906confirms the active Phase Z CLI vocabulary issingle, horizontal-2, vertical-2, top-1-bottom-2, top-2-bottom-1, left-1-right-2, left-2-right-1, grid-2x2. If legacysidebar-rightcannot be invoked by name, u2 still needs an explicit active-preset sidebar-equivalent run or a Stage 2 plan rewind; as implemented, skipping it is not within the binding u2 scope.git diff -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyis empty, and the locked driver chain still resolvesPROJECT_ROOT/chromedriver,PROJECT_ROOT/chromedriver.exe, then Selenium Manager.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git status --shortGet-Content -LiteralPath tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.mdGet-ChildItem -LiteralPath .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs -Recurse | Select-Object FullName,Length,LastWriteTimegit diff --name-only -- src tests .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runsGet-Contentline reads forsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3162-3185and7900-7910git diff -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.py.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/<preset>/debug.jsonfilesdata/runs/<run_id>/phase_z2/debug.jsonpython -c "import selenium, sys; ..."rg -n "02\.mdx|F-5|mdx_batch" tests/CLAUDE.md CLAUDE.mdrg -n "sidebar-right|two-column|hero-detail|single-column|horizontal-2|vertical-2|top-1-bottom-2|left-1-right-2|grid-2x2" CLAUDE.md tests/CLAUDE.md docs src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyrg -n "chromedriver|selenium init failed|webdriver\.Chrome|zone_geometries_px|write_debug_json" src/phase_z2_pipeline.pygit rev-parse --short HEADFiles checked:
tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/single/debug.json.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/horizontal-2/debug.json.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/vertical-2/debug.json.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/top-1-bottom-2/debug.jsondata/runs/imp01_a6_single_probe/phase_z2/debug.jsondata/runs/imp01_a6_horizontal2/phase_z2/debug.jsondata/runs/imp01_a6_vertical2/phase_z2/debug.jsondata/runs/imp01_a6_probe_sections/phase_z2/debug.jsonsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.pyCLAUDE.mdtests/CLAUDE.mdTest results:
pytest -q testsnot run; current Stage 3 u2 verification does not require it and u5 owns baseline capture.Verified facts:
4e281a2.src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyhas no local diff.data/runs/<run_id>/phase_z2/debug.jsonsources.sidebar-righttopology; B.1 explicitly says it was not executed.Remaining units: [u2, u3, u4, u5]
rewind_target: stage_3_edit
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #14] Stage 3 code-edit Round #1 — IMP-01 #1 u2 retry (post-rewind from Codex #13 failure report)
Executing unit: u2
Round #1 scope
Single implementation_unit: u2 (per-layout runtime verification with
sidebar-right + two-column + hero-detail + single-columntopology coverage).Codex #13 rejected the prior u2 because
sidebar-rightwas explicitly marked_not executed_andhorizontal-2was substituted in its place — a contract violation against the Stage 2 binding plan. This round corrects the substitution.Changes (artifacts only — production source zero-touch)
unit_executed
u2files_changed
tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md— §B.1 / §B.3 / §B.4 / §B.5 rewritten to bind the 4 contracted topologies to Phase Z presets viatemplates/phase_z2/layouts/layouts.yamlevidence (no more "not executed" row, nohorizontal-2substitute)..orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/left-1-right-2/debug.json— new runtime artifact covering thesidebar-rightcontract topology (positions[left, right-top, right-bottom],len(zone_geometries_px) = 3)..orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/horizontal-2/— deleted (was the unjustified substitute forsidebar-right; not in the Stage 2 contract).diff_summary
Sidebar-right coverage gap closed via
left-1-right-2preset.layouts.yaml:94-105declaresleft-1-right-2withcss_areas: "left right-top" "left right-bottom"— a single row-spanningleftcell alongside two stacked right cells. That is the topological shape of CLAUDE.md:135sidebar-rightgrid ("body sidebar"with65fr 35fr) once the right column carries the conventional ≥2 stacked sidebar items.vertical-2does not satisfy this row because it is symmetric (no row-spanning main + stacked sidebar items), so it remains bound totwo-columnrather than being double-counted.Runtime executed (no patching).
python -m src.phase_z2_pipeline samples/mdx_batch/02.mdx imp01_a6_sidebar_right --override-layout left-1-right-2 --override-section-assignment left=02-1 --override-section-assignment right-top=02-2-sub-1 --override-section-assignment right-bottom=02-2-sub-2selenium_manager(same locked chain as prior 3 runs; no PROJECT_ROOT chromedriver install, noPATHmutation, no §A.6 candidate-list edit).[override] layout_preset: single → left-1-right-2andpreset: left-1-right-2 (1 units, composition v0 count-based), confirming the override path is the active code branch.visual_runtime_check.passed = True.data/runs/imp01_a6_sidebar_right/phase_z2/debug.jsoncopied byte-equivalently to.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/left-1-right-2/debug.json(no patching, no schema mutation).Locked-schema cross-check (all 4 artifacts pass; full assertion is u3 scope).
Per-item key set matches
{position, template_id, x, y, w, h};x/y/w/hare integers across all 9 items (1 + 2 + 3 + 3); top-levelzone_geometries_pxis a list.leftcarries the rendered frame template; the two empty right zones still emit well-formed bbox entries (w=0/h=0, not the[]no-runtime fallback), matching the existing behaviour observed for__empty__zones invertical-2andtop-1-bottom-2. Slide-relative origin (x=50,y=76page padding) is consistent across all four runs — the lockedslideRectanchor is intact.Production source — zero edit.
src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyStep 14 (:3162-3185driver candidates,:3207-3208slideRect base,:3214init,:3230-3239per-zone push,:3403return), Step 21 (:4529-4530zone_geometries_pxsurface),_MEASURE_SCRIPT,run_overflow_check,write_debug_json, and thelayouts.yamlpreset definitions are all untouched. The locked debug.json schema and the[]no-runtime fallback claim from §A.3 Path B remain code-grounded (not exercised on this host this round).Artifact-tidy on horizontal-2. The prior round's
.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/horizontal-2/directory was deleted in this round. It was a 2-zonetop/bottomsubstitute forsidebar-right, which Codex #13 classified as a contract violation. Deletion is purely artifact tidy under.orchestrator/tmp/— no production source, no production runs, no schema impact.remaining_units
u3— Schema assertion (top-levelzone_geometries_pxlist, per-item key set{position, template_id, x, y, w, h}, integer coords, slide-relative bounds check,[]fallback claim).u4— No-drift evidence atsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3207-3208/:3214/:3230-3239/:3403/:4529-4530plus scoped guardrail grep forkei|frame_selection|V4|ai_redesignerat locked spans.u5—pytest -q testsbaseline gate captured to.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/pytest_baseline.txtplus IMP-01 keyword + git-log provenance classification.follow_up_issue_candidates
src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:7904-7906andtemplates/phase_z2/layouts/layouts.yamlcarry the active Phase Z names). It is out of scope for IMP-01 verification and is not load-bearing for thezone_geometries_pxStep 14 → Step 21 export.guardrails honoured
_MEASURE_SCRIPT/run_overflow_check/write_debug_json/layouts.yamlall untouched).layout_preset+section_assignment— both pre-existing CLI surfaces).feedback_one_step_per_turn.STOP per
feedback_one_step_per_turn.[Codex #14] Stage 3 code-edit review - IMP-01 #1 u2 retry
Verified only unit
u2.Result: correct. The prior
horizontal-2substitution is gone, and the current artifacts cover the Stage 2 contract's four topology classes viasingle,vertical-2,left-1-right-2, andtop-1-bottom-2. Theleft-1-right-2artifact is a live Phase Z run for the sidebar-right topology class, not a patched JSON artifact.Key checks:
tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.mdnow mapssidebar-righttoleft-1-right-2and no longer says sidebar-right was not executed..orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/horizontal-2/is absent..orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/left-1-right-2/debug.jsonexists and is byte-identical todata/runs/imp01_a6_sidebar_right/phase_z2/debug.json.data/runs/imp01_a6_sidebar_right/phase_z2/debug.jsonreportslayout_preset: left-1-right-2,visual_runtime_check.passed: True, and top-level/runtimezone_geometries_pxentries forleft,right-top, andright-bottom.templates/phase_z2/layouts/layouts.yaml:94-100definesleft-1-right-2aspositions: [left, right-top, right-bottom]withcss_areas: "left right-top" "left right-bottom", which satisfies the missing row-spanning main + stacked right-side topology evidence that Codex #13 required.data/runs/.../phase_z2/debug.jsonsources:single,vertical-2, andtop-1-bottom-2.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git status --shortGet-ChildItem -LiteralPath '.orchestrator\tmp\imp01_a6_runs' | Select-Object -ExpandProperty NameSelect-String -LiteralPath 'tests\verification\imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md' -Pattern 'sidebar-right|left-1-right-2|horizontal-2|not executed|Command:|visual_runtime_check|zone_geometries_px' -Context 2,2Select-String -LiteralPath 'templates\phase_z2\layouts\layouts.yaml' -Pattern 'left-1-right-2|css_areas|right-top|right-bottom|vertical-2|single|top-1-bottom-2' -Context 2,4.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/<preset>/debug.jsonartifacts against theirdata/runs/<run_id>/phase_z2/debug.jsonsources.layout_preset,visual_runtime_check.passed, top-level/runtimezone_geometries_pxcounts, positions, and primitive value types.Test-Path -LiteralPath '.orchestrator\tmp\imp01_a6_runs\horizontal-2'Select-String -LiteralPath 'src\phase_z2_pipeline.py' -Pattern 'choices=\["single"|horizontal-2|vertical-2|left-1-right-2|grid-2x2' -Context 2,2Files checked:
tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.mdtemplates/phase_z2/layouts/layouts.yamlsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/single/debug.json.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/vertical-2/debug.json.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/left-1-right-2/debug.json.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/top-1-bottom-2/debug.jsondata/runs/imp01_a6_single_probe/phase_z2/debug.jsondata/runs/imp01_a6_vertical2/phase_z2/debug.jsondata/runs/imp01_a6_sidebar_right/phase_z2/debug.jsondata/runs/imp01_a6_probe_sections/phase_z2/debug.jsonVerified facts:
single,vertical-2,left-1-right-2,top-1-bottom-2;horizontal-2is absent.data/runs/.../phase_z2/debug.jsonsource files.single:layout_preset=single,passed=True,zone_geometries_pxcount1, positions[primary].vertical-2:layout_preset=vertical-2,passed=True,zone_geometries_pxcount2, positions[left, right].left-1-right-2:layout_preset=left-1-right-2,passed=True,zone_geometries_pxcount3, positions[left, right-top, right-bottom].top-1-bottom-2:layout_preset=top-1-bottom-2,passed=True,zone_geometries_pxcount3, positions[top, bottom-left, bottom-right].Remaining units: [u3, u4, u5]
rewind_target: continue_same
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #15] Stage 3 code-edit Round #2 — IMP-01 #1 u3 (schema assertion)
Executing unit: u3
Round #2 scope
Single implementation_unit: u3 — deterministic in-doc schema assertion against the four
debug.jsonartifacts produced in u2 (single,vertical-2,left-1-right-2,top-1-bottom-2). Reuses u2 artifacts; no new runtime invocation. Per Stage 2 contract: top-levelzone_geometries_pxlist / per-item{position:str, template_id:str, x|y|w|h:int}/ slide-relative rounded /[]no-runtime fallback (source-grounded).Prior round status (Codex #14, FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES): u2 verified correct —
sidebar-righttopology covered vialeft-1-right-2preset,horizontal-2/substitute removed, all four artifacts byte-identical to theirdata/runs/.../phase_z2/debug.jsonsources. This round proceeds to u3 without rewinding u2.unit_executed
u3files_changed
tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md— §C populated. Replaced the placeholder block ("Reserved. Will assert...") with §C.1 locked-schema table → §C.2 deterministic assertion harness → §C.3 executed result → §C.4 per-item PASS table → §C.5 SHA256 artifact byte-binding → §C.6[]fallback source grounding → §C.7 divergence → Stage 1 rewind matrix → §C.8 explicit u3 non-claims.Production source under
src/phase_z2_pipeline.py: zero edit (per Stage 1 binding contractscope_lock.out_of_scopeand Stage 2guardrails). No new.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/<preset>/debug.jsonfiles. The artifact byte-binding in §C.5 is recorded against the existing u2 outputs.diff_summary
§C.1 — locked schema table, source-grounded per axis. Each row binds an axis (surface location, top-level type, per-item type, key set, per-key types, coordinate space, coordinate units, envelope, no-runtime fallback) to the exact source line in
src/phase_z2_pipeline.py(e.g., per-item shape ↔:3232-3239, coordinate space ↔:3208 + :3235-3238, fallback[]↔:4530). This locks every assertion in §C.2 to a source provenance, so a future divergence can be classified deterministically per §C.7.§C.2 — assertion harness (deterministic, in-doc, no production import). 40-line
python -cblock that iterates the four u2 artifacts and runs 5 assertion axes per item: (a) top-level surface present + list type, (b) per-item key set + types, (c) slide-relative envelope (0 ≤ x ≤ 1281,0 ≤ y ≤ 721,0 ≤ x+w ≤ 1281,0 ≤ y+h ≤ 721per CSS-pixelMath.roundsemantics with +1 round-tolerance). The harness checksnot isinstance(v, bool)afterisinstance(v, int)to rejectbool(PythonTrue/Falsesubclassint). Working dirD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent, interpreterPython 3.13.1.§C.3 — assertion result, executed against HEAD
4e281a2. Stdout is the verbatimALL_SCHEMA_ASSERTIONS_PASSsingle-line success token. 8 items audited (1 + 2 + 3 + 3 across the four artifacts). ZeroAssertionError. Zero divergence triggers.§C.4 — per-item PASS table. 8 items × 5 axes = 40 atomic assertions, all PASS. Each cell carries the actual
x+w/y+h/(x, y)numeric value (not just the word "PASS") so the table is byte-traceable to the artifacts in §C.5 without re-executing the harness.§C.5 — SHA256 artifact byte-binding. All four
.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/<preset>/debug.jsonfiles hashed (hashlib.sha256) at u3 time. Hashes:The §C.3 assertion is bound to these exact bytes. Per u2 §B.3, each is byte-identical to its
data/runs/<run_id>/phase_z2/debug.jsonsource — no patching, no schema mutation between u2 produce and u3 audit. Codex #14 already verified the artifact↔data binding for these four files; §C.5 now adds the SHA256 fingerprint as the lock surface.§C.6 —
[]fallback claim, explicitly source-grounded (not runtime-observed). Records the exact source expression(visual_runtime_check or {}).get("zone_geometries_px", [])atsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py:4530and enumerates the two Python branches that yield[]: (1)visual_runtime_check is None, (2)visual_runtime_check is dictbut key absent. Both branches PASS C.2.a + C.2.b vacuously. Discloses that on this host at HEAD4e281a2, all four runs succeeded withvisual_runtime_check.passed = True, so the[]branch is a source-grounded claim, not a runtime-observed branch in this round (consistent with B.6).§C.7 — divergence → Stage 1 rewind matrix. 6-row table that classifies each possible AssertionError outcome as
code regression(Stage 1 rewind, NO artifact patching) vsenv-blocker(PASS vacuously). The "top-level[]whilevisual_runtime_check.passed=Trueand non-emptyzones" row is the explicit guard against the Step 21(visual_runtime_check or {}).get(..., [])masking a Step 14 regression. The "top-level[]whilevisual_runtime_check.passed=False" row is the explicit allow for the env-blocker case where the fallback IS the locked behaviour.§C.8 — u3 non-claims. Explicitly excludes u4 (no-drift evidence at Step 14 / Step 21 anchors), u5 (pytest baseline), other HEADs, and IMP-15
image_events/table_eventsschemas (separate axis).Schema axes audited (per §C.2)
zone_geometries_pxindebug.jsonas JSON list:4530{position, template_id, x, y, w, h}:3232-3239position/template_idisstr:3224 + :3225x/y/w/hisint(NOTbool):3235-3238(Math.round)0 ≤ x ≤ 1281,0 ≤ y ≤ 721):3206 (slide=1280×720)+:3208 (slideRect base)x+w ≤ 1281,y+h ≤ 721,w/h ≥ 0)Total: 40 atomic assertions PASS, 0 fail, 0 divergence. Stdout:
ALL_SCHEMA_ASSERTIONS_PASS.remaining_units
u4— record current-HEAD no-drift evidence at locked anchors (src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3207-3208 / :3214 / :3230-3239 / :3403 / :4529-4530) and confirm scoped guardrail grep windows (kei|frame_selection|V4|ai_redesigner) are empty within those spans.u5— capturepytest -q testsstdout to.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/pytest_baseline.txt, enumerate failures, classify each against IMP-01 keywords +git logprovenance. Non-orthogonal failure rewinds to Stage 1.Already executed and verified by Codex consensus:
u1(driver resolution policy in §A),u2(per-layout runtime verification in §B withsidebar-rightcovered vialeft-1-right-2).follow_up_issue_candidates
None this round. No scope-lock violation surfaced during u3:
[]no-runtime fallback was NOT runtime-observed on this host, but the Stage 2 contract treats the source-grounded claim as sufficient (perschema_locked.fallback_on_no_runtime: "[]"and consistent with u2 §B.6). Promoting "[] runtime observation" to a required axis would be a Stage 2 plan change, not a u3 follow-up, and is rejected here.image_events/table_events) cross-contamination — §C.8 explicitly walls off that axis.webdriver.Chromeat all (u3 is pure JSON audit).Guardrails honored
scope_lock.out_of_scope+ Stage 2guardrails). Confirmed viagit status— onlytests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.mdmodified;src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyclean.guardrails+[[feedback_no_hardcoding]]). §C.5 audits artifact bytes; does not rewrite them.schema_lockedblock verbatim.remaining_unitsfor future rounds, not implemented here.[Codex #15] Stage 3 code-edit review - IMP-01 #1 u3 schema assertion
Verified only unit
u3.Result: incorrect. The schema assertion logic itself passes against the four u2 artifacts, but the
u3documentation records the audited item count incorrectly. The artifacts contain 9zone_geometries_pxentries, not 8:singlehas 1,vertical-2has 2,left-1-right-2has 3, andtop-1-bottom-2has 3. This makes the recorded assertion result and atomic assertion total internally inconsistent with the files being certified.Findings:
tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.mdC.3 says "8 items audited across 4 artifacts" while the actual total is 9.tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.mdC.4 says "8 items x 5 schema axes = 40 atomic assertions PASS" while the table immediately below contains 9 item rows, so the correct count is 45 atomic item-axis checks under the stated 5-axis framing.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git status --shortSelect-String -LiteralPath 'tests\verification\imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md' -Pattern '^## C|^### C\.|ALL_SCHEMA_ASSERTIONS_PASS|left-1-right-2|single|vertical-2|top-1-bottom-2|fallback|Stage 1 rewind|bool|1281|721|SHA256|u3' -Context 2,2Get-ChildItem -LiteralPath '.orchestrator\tmp\imp01_a6_runs' -Directory | Select-Object -ExpandProperty NameSelect-String -LiteralPath 'src\phase_z2_pipeline.py' -Pattern 'zone_geometries_px|slideRect|getBoundingClientRect|Math.round|write_debug_json' -Context 2,2pythonschema assertion over.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/{single,vertical-2,left-1-right-2,top-1-bottom-2}/debug.jsonGet-FileHash -Algorithm SHA256 -LiteralPath ...src\phase_z2_pipeline.pylines 3220-3226 and 4527-4532git diff -- tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runsFiles checked:
tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.mdsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/single/debug.json.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/vertical-2/debug.json.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/left-1-right-2/debug.json.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/top-1-bottom-2/debug.jsonVerified facts:
single,vertical-2,left-1-right-2,top-1-bottom-2.ALL_SCHEMA_ASSERTIONS_PASS 9.single=f8162bdb1c86f04c6b7202b4d71e022456c6278ac1b2a1081eef1cdf13168da6;vertical-2=66eadcb5cb2cbff663365eddcab2b5eb90bcbe1999c4d52c48eb99a17beaa5e3;left-1-right-2=37ea4e09c09bc1a4e4ff39a9ac9fabd0c1139733a62f27ec09b04255418424c6;top-1-bottom-2=a12a07fd0bd0cda59c49f8bd1a1bc592e2536a0572b70c44acc683a4c2c99857.position,template_id,Math.roundinteger fields, and Step 21 fallback matchessrc/phase_z2_pipeline.pyat the checked anchors.git diff -- tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runsproduced no tracked diff because these verification artifacts are currently untracked in this worktree.Remaining units: [u3, u4, u5]
rewind_target: stage_3_edit
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #16] Stage 3 code-edit Round #1 — IMP-01 #1 u3 schema-assertion count defect fix (post Codex #15 rewind)
Executing unit: u3
unit_executed
u3 — Schema assertion documentation re-attempt. No production source edit. Documentation-only count correction to bring the §B.5 / §C.3 / §C.4 reported item totals into agreement with the audited u2 artifacts and the C.4 per-item table.
files_changed
tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md(documentation-only, three text replacements within u2/u3 sections)diff_summary
tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.mdEvery item shape matches {position: str, ...} (8 distinct items across 4 runs).Every item shape matches {position: str, ...} (9 distinct items across 4 runs).single1 +vertical-22 +left-1-right-23 +top-1-bottom-23 = 9.tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.mdALL_SCHEMA_ASSERTIONS_PASS (8 items audited across 4 artifacts: single 1 item, vertical-2 2 items, left-1-right-2 3 items, top-1-bottom-2 3 items).ALL_SCHEMA_ASSERTIONS_PASS (9 items audited across 4 artifacts: single 1 item, vertical-2 2 items, left-1-right-2 3 items, top-1-bottom-2 3 items).the recorded assertion result and atomic assertion total internally inconsistent with the files being certified.tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md### C.4 Per-item assertion outcomes (8 items × 5 axes)…All 8 items × 5 schema axes = 40 atomic assertions PASS.### C.4 Per-item assertion outcomes (9 items × 5 axes)…All 9 items × 5 schema axes = 45 atomic assertions PASS.single/primary,vertical-2/left,vertical-2/right,left-1-right-2/left,left-1-right-2/right-top,left-1-right-2/right-bottom,top-1-bottom-2/top,top-1-bottom-2/bottom-left,top-1-bottom-2/bottom-right). 9 × 5 = 45 atomic checks under the locked 5-axis framing.scope guardrails (re-confirmed, post-fix)
src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyStep 14 (:3207-3239,:3403) and Step 21 (:4529-4530) untouched..orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/<preset>/debug.json): byte-untouched. Byte counts and SHA256 in §C.5 still bind the same files (no re-run, no patch).for it in zg:and is therefore independent of any documented item-count total — it asserts what it asserts regardless of the prose count.evidence (verbatim re-count against u2 artifacts)
Per-run item counts taken directly from §B.5 coordinate listing (lines 146-155, unchanged):
C.4 table row count after fix: 9 rows × 5 axis columns = 45 PASS cells, internally consistent with the §C.3 audit total and the §B.5 distinct-item count.
Locked schema (§C.1) and assertion harness (§C.2) re-read at HEAD
4e281a2: unchanged. The 5 schema axes used for the C.4 totals are:{position, template_id, x, y, w, h}).position,template_id).x, y, w, h).x+w ≤ 1281,y+h ≤ 721).x ≥ 0,y ≥ 0; non-edge zones non-trivially > 0).remaining_units
src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3207-3208 / :3214 / :3230-3239 / :3403 / :4529-4530+ guardrail grepkei|frame_selection|V4|ai_redesignerempty within those spans.pytest -q testsbaseline capture to.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/pytest_baseline.txt, failure classification against IMP-01 keywords +git logprovenance.follow_up_issue_candidates
None. The Codex #15 finding was strictly a documentation count defect inside u3 (no production source defect, no runtime artifact defect, no schema divergence, no env-blocker reclassification). No new axis surfaced; no scope-lock spillover.
stop signal
Single-unit (u3) completed per
1 turn = 1 step(feedback_one_step_per_turn). No commit, no push, no advance to u4. Awaiting Codex review.[Codex #16] Stage 3 code-edit review - IMP-01 #1 u3 schema assertion
Verified only unit
u3.Result: correct. The documentation-only count correction now matches the four existing runtime artifacts. The prior defect is fixed: the audited total is 9 items, and the atomic assertion count is 45 under the documented 5-axis framing.
Findings:
8 items,8 distinct, or40 atomicschema-count text remains intests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md..orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/<layout>/debug.jsonartifacts containzone_geometries_pxcounts ofsingle=1,vertical-2=2,left-1-right-2=3, andtop-1-bottom-2=3, total9.zone_geometries_pxitem has exactly{position, template_id, x, y, w, h}with stringposition/template_idand integer non-bool coordinate fields.src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyis not modified in the working tree, so the Stage 3 u3 re-attempt remains documentation/artifact verification only.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git status --shortSelect-String -LiteralPath 'tests\verification\imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md' -Pattern '8 items|9 items|40 atomic|45 atomic|distinct items|ALL_SCHEMA_ASSERTIONS_PASS|Per-item assertion outcomes' -Context 1,1Get-ChildItem -LiteralPath '.orchestrator\tmp\imp01_a6_runs' -Recurse -Filter 'debug.json' | Select-Object -ExpandProperty FullNamerg -n "8 items|40 atomic|8 distinct|ALL_SCHEMA_ASSERTIONS_PASS|9 items|45 atomic|distinct items" tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.mdgit diff -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.py tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/*/debug.jsonFiles checked:
tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/single/debug.json.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/vertical-2/debug.json.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/left-1-right-2/debug.json.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/top-1-bottom-2/debug.jsonsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.pyworking-tree statusVerified facts:
tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md:158records9 distinct items across 4 runs.tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md:242recordsALL_SCHEMA_ASSERTIONS_PASS (9 items audited across 4 artifacts: single 1 item, vertical-2 2 items, left-1-right-2 3 items, top-1-bottom-2 3 items).tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md:244recordsPer-item assertion outcomes (9 items x 5 axes).tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md:258recordsAll 9 items x 5 schema axes = 45 atomic assertions PASS.left-1-right-2: count=3 bad=none,single: count=1 bad=none,top-1-bottom-2: count=3 bad=none,vertical-2: count=2 bad=none,TOTAL=9.Remaining units: [u4, u5]
rewind_target: continue_same
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #17] Stage 3 code-edit Round #2 — IMP-01 #1 u4 no-drift guardrail evidence
Executing unit: u4
unit_executed
u4 — No-drift guardrail. Verification-doc-only deliverable: scoped Read at locked
src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyanchors (Step 14:3207-3208 / :3214 / :3230-3239 / :3403; Step 21:4529-4530), semantic grep forzone_geometries_pxacross production source, scoped guardrail grep (kei|frame_selection|V4|ai_redesigner) within the locked spans, git-blame provenance per anchor, and working-tree no-touch verification. No production source edit.files_changed
tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md(verification-doc only; §D placeholder replaced with §D.1 ~ §D.6)diff_summary
tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md_Reserved._(single-line placeholder):3403audit, §D.5 working-tree no-touch verification, §D.6 scope-of-claimssrc/phase_z2_pipeline.pygit diff -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.py= 0 bytes at §D authorship.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/**/debug.jsonevidence captured in §D (deterministic)
§D.1 — Locked anchor verbatim Read at HEAD
4e281a2:3207-3208—// A-6 (IMP-01 #1) — slide-relative bbox base+const slideRect = slide.getBoundingClientRect();:3214—const zone_geometries_px = [];:3230-3239—// A-6 (IMP-01 #1) — zone bbox in slide-relative px (additive trace, no layout side effect)+ per-zonezone_geometries_px.push({position, template_id, x: Math.round(...), y: Math.round(...), w: Math.round(...), h: Math.round(...)});:3403—return { slide: slideM, slide_body: bodyM, zones, frame_slot_metrics, zone_geometries_px, image_events, table_events };:4529-4530—# A-6 (IMP-01 #1) — additive top-level zone bbox trace (slide-relative px)+"zone_geometries_px": (visual_runtime_check or {}).get("zone_geometries_px", []),§D.2 — Semantic grep for
zone_geometries_pxin production sourcesrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py(lines:3214,:3232,:3403,:4530).write_debug_json. No second export path introduced.§D.3 — Scoped guardrail grep
kei|frame_selection|V4|ai_redesignerwithin locked spans:3207-3208:3214:3230-3239:3403:4529-4530Observed
TOTAL_HITS=0matches the Stage 2 contract expected value. The bbox export is syntactically isolated from AI / Kei / V4 / frame_selection / ai_redesigner subsystems at every locked anchor.§D.4 — git-blame provenance per locked span
:3207-3208,:3214,:3230-3239,:4529-4530→ blame commit1dc81e0(feat(step14+step21): add zone_geometries_px artifact (IMP-01 #1)), 2026-05-12.:3403→ blame commit28276228(feat(IMP-16): Step 14 table_self_overflow detection), 2026-05-18.:3403audit: the only IMP-16 semantic change at this line is, table_eventsappended afterimage_events.zone_geometries_pxmember preserved verbatim in the same 4th-position object shorthand. This is the IMP-15 (#48) / IMP-16 (#46) additive append pattern locked at Stage 1 — NOT a drift on thezone_geometries_pxaxis. Cross-ref:.orchestrator/issues/48_stage_final-close_exit.md:22records IMP-15 surfacing pattern as "mirroringzone_geometries_pxprecedent".§D.5 — Working-tree no-touch verification (this round)
git diff -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.py→ 0 bytes of diff output at §D authorship.scope guardrails (re-confirmed)
src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyStep 14 (:3207-3208 / :3214 / :3230-3239 / :3403) and Step 21 (:4529-4530) untouched in this round (and across u1~u4)..orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/<preset>/debug.json): byte-untouched. SHA256 bindings recorded in §C.5 remain valid.chromedriverinstall intoPROJECT_ROOTorPATH(env-blocker classification rule from §A.4 unchanged).remaining_units
u5— Baseline gate. Will capturepytest -q testsstdout to.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/pytest_baseline.txt, enumerate failures, and classify each against IMP-01 keywords +git logprovenance. Non-orthogonal failure → Stage 1 rewind.follow_up_issue_candidates
:3403drift candidate was audited under §D.4.a and confirmed as the Stage 1-locked additive append pattern, not a new issue.source_comment_ids
commit_sha
4e281a2.1dc81e0.:3403:28276228.[Codex #17] Stage 3 code-edit review - IMP-01 #1 u4 no-drift guardrail
Verified only unit
u4.Result: correct. The verification document's Section D now records the required no-drift evidence for the locked Step 14 / Step 21 anchors without modifying production source or runtime artifacts.
Findings:
tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md.slideRectbase at:3207-3208,zone_geometries_pxinitialization at:3214, per-zone push at:3230-3239, JS return surface at:3403, and Step 21 top-level debug export at:4529-4530.zone_geometries_pxappears exactly 4 times insrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py, all inside the locked anchor spans (:3214,:3232,:3403,:4530).kei|frame_selection|V4|ai_redesignerover the locked spans returnsTOTAL_HITS=0.git blameprovenance matches the documented boundary:1dc81e0owns the IMP-01 anchor lines except:3403, and28276228owns:3403after appendingtable_eventswhile preservingzone_geometries_px.git show 28276228 -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyconfirms the relevant return-line change appendedtable_events; it did not rename, remove, or repositionzone_geometries_px.src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyhas no working-tree diff. The four u2 debug artifacts still match the C.5 byte counts and SHA256 hashes, so the u4 doc update did not patch runtime evidence.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git status --shortSelect-String -LiteralPath 'tests\verification\imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md' -Pattern '^## D|^### D\.|zone_geometries_px|TOTAL_HITS|4 occurrences|working-tree|git blame|scope-of-claims|Reserved' -Context 1,2rg -n "zone_geometries_px" src/phase_z2_pipeline.pygit diff -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.py tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.mdsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.pylocked lines3207,3208,3214,3230-3239,3403,4529,4530kei|frame_selection|V4|ai_redesignerover locked spansgit blame -L 3207,3208 -L 3214,3214 -L 3230,3239 -L 3403,3403 -L 4529,4530 -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.pygit show --stat --oneline --no-renames 28276228 -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.pygit show --unified=1 --no-ext-diff 28276228 -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.py | Select-String -Pattern 'return \{ slide: slideM' -Context 1,1Test-Path -LiteralPath '.orchestrator\issues\48_stage_final-close_exit.md'Select-String -LiteralPath '.orchestrator\issues\48_stage_final-close_exit.md' -Pattern 'mirroring|zone_geometries_px|2739|precedent' -Context 1,1git diff --name-only -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.pygit status --short -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.py tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runsGet-FileHash -Algorithm SHA256over the four.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/*/debug.jsonartifactsSelect-String -LiteralPath 'tests\verification\imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md' -Pattern 'SHA256|single/debug.json|vertical-2/debug.json|left-1-right-2/debug.json|top-1-bottom-2/debug.json' -Context 0,1Get-Itemlength check over the four.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/*/debug.jsonartifacts(Get-Content -LiteralPath 'tests\verification\imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md').Countgit rev-parse --short=7 HEADgit rev-parse HEADgit log -1 --oneline 1dc81e0git log -1 --oneline 28276228Files checked:
tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.mdsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/single/debug.json.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/vertical-2/debug.json.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/left-1-right-2/debug.json.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/top-1-bottom-2/debug.json.orchestrator/issues/48_stage_final-close_exit.mdRemaining units: [u5]
Verified facts:
4e281a20d8e7acfa771a72384e2c45b0f6407dc5(4e281a2).src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3207-3208contains the slide-relative bbox base andslide.getBoundingClientRect().src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3214initializesconst zone_geometries_px = [];.src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3230-3239pushes{position, template_id, x, y, w, h}using rounded slide-relativezoneRect - slideRectcoordinates.src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3403returnszone_geometries_pxin the runtime result object.src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:4529-4530surfaces top-level debug JSON with(visual_runtime_check or {}).get("zone_geometries_px", []).SPAN 3207-3208 HITS=0,SPAN 3214-3214 HITS=0,SPAN 3230-3239 HITS=0,SPAN 3403-3403 HITS=0,SPAN 4529-4530 HITS=0,TOTAL_HITS=0.1dc81e06for lines3207-3208,3214,3230-3239, and4529-4530; line3403is28276228.1dc81e0 feat(step14+step21): add zone_geometries_px artifact (IMP-01 #1)and2827622 feat(IMP-16): Step 14 table_self_overflow detection..orchestrator/issues/48_stage_final-close_exit.md:22records theimage_events/table_eventssurfacing pattern as mirroring thezone_geometries_pxprecedent.single=102220,vertical-2=108608,left-1-right-2=153072,top-1-bottom-2=153107.f8162bdb1c86f04c6b7202b4d71e022456c6278ac1b2a1081eef1cdf13168da6,66eadcb5cb2cbff663365eddcab2b5eb90bcbe1999c4d52c48eb99a17beaa5e3,37ea4e09c09bc1a4e4ff39a9ac9fabd0c1139733a62f27ec09b04255418424c6, anda12a07fd0bd0cda59c49f8bd1a1bc592e2536a0572b70c44acc683a4c2c99857.rewind_target: continue_same
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #18] Stage 3 code-edit Round #3 — IMP-01 #1 u5 baseline gate (pytest -q tests)
Executing unit: u5
unit_executed
u5 — Baseline gate.
pytest -q testscaptured at HEAD4e281a2into.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/pytest_baseline.txt. Failures enumerated and classified against IMP-01 keyword set +git logowner-commit provenance. Verification-doc only deliverable; production source byte-untouched.files_changed
tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md(§E_Reserved._placeholder replaced with §E.1 ~ §E.9).orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/pytest_baseline.txt(new artifact, 287 lines, captured viatee)diff_summary
tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md_Reserved._(single-line placeholder).orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/pytest_baseline.txtteecapture ofpython -m pytest -q testsstdout at HEAD4e281a27 failed, 1622 passed in 360.92s (0:06:00)src/phase_z2_pipeline.pygit status --short -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.py= empty.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/<preset>/debug.jsonbaseline gate result (verbatim)
7 failures (verbatim from
short test summary infoblock)tests/orchestrator_unit/test_imp17_comment_anchor.py::test_line_586_references_imp17_not_imp31tests/orchestrator_unit/test_imp17_comment_anchor.py::test_line_587_references_imp47b_supersessiontests/regression/test_b4_mapper_source_sha_parity.py::test_post_89a_flag_off_final_html_sha_matches_frozen_baseline[01.mdx]tests/regression/test_b4_mapper_source_sha_parity.py::test_post_89a_flag_off_final_html_sha_holistic_sweeptests/test_phase_z2_v4_fallback.py::test_rank_1_non_direct_promotes_rank_2tests/test_phase_z2_v4_fallback.py::test_duplicate_template_id_is_skipped_rank_3_winstests/test_phase_z2_v4_fallback.py::test_restructure_reject_preserved_as_non_direct_evidenceClassification (per §E.4 + §E.5)
f3ef4d9 feat(#64): IMP-35 details_popup_escalation u1~u10b1bbe27 feat(#89): IMP-89 89-a u1~u5 Layer A render path activation1186ad8 feat(#76): IMP-47B reject-as-AI-adaptation activationRegex
zone_geometries|IMP-01|step.?14|step.?21|slideRect|imp01over each failing test file body returned 0 hits total. No failing test references the locked IMP-01 axis (zone_geometries_px, Step 14slideRectbase / per-zone push / return surface, Step 21debug.jsonsurface).Cross-reference vs Stage 2 baseline (
pytest_stage2_codex_r1.txt)The failure SET (7 IDs) and pass/fail counts (
7 failed, 1622 passed) are byte-identical between Stage 2 baseline and Stage 3 u5 capture. Only elapsed time differs (364.29svs360.92s; host noise). Zero new failure introduced by u1~u5.scope guardrails (re-confirmed, post-u5)
src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyStep 14 (:3207-3239,:3403) and Step 21 (:4529-4530) untouched.git status --short -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyreturns empty..orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/<preset>/debug.json): byte-untouched in this round (§C.5 SHA256 bindings remain valid).Stage 2 contract gate evaluation
Per Stage 2 EXIT REPORT
baseline_tests: "pytest -q tests(full suite) captured as artifact; non-orthogonal failure rewinds to Stage 1."1dc81e0).git diff -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.py= 0 bytes).Verdict: BASELINE_GATE_PASS — Stage 1 rewind NOT triggered.
remaining_units
[](empty)All Stage 2 implementation_units complete:
debug.jsonartifacts (§B) — prior roundfollow_up_issue_candidates
Non-IMP-01 axes surfaced by §E baseline gate. Each is a SEPARATE issue scope, NOT bundled into IMP-01 #1:
src/phase_z2_pipeline.pylines 586/587 have drifted past the IMP-35 Round #3 anchor pin (possibly by IMP-45 #74--override-slide-cssinjector or IMP-55 #93 manual section swap). Needs another anchor re-pin scoped under #64 IMP-35 follow-up.slide_overrides.cssinjector at Step 13, or IMP-55 #93 manual section swap detection) changed final.html bytes for 01.mdx + holistic sweep. Needs intentional re-capture viatests/regression/scripts/capture_89a_pre_baseline.pyscoped under #89 follow-up.Per feedback_validation_first_for_closed_issues + feedback_one_step_per_turn + feedback_no_hardcoding: do NOT bundle any of the above into IMP-01 #1, do NOT auto-create the follow-up issues from this Stage 3 turn, and do NOT patch any failing test as part of this verification. Each is a separate fresh-validation scope.
next stage
Stage 3 u1~u5 implementation_units COMPLETE. Ready for Stage 4 (test-verify) entry per orchestrator routing. STOP here per Stage 3 contract (no commit, no push — comment is the deliverable).
[Codex #18] Stage 3 code-edit review - IMP-01 #1 u5 baseline gate
Verified only unit
u5.Result: correct. The baseline-gate documentation and captured artifact satisfy the Stage 2 contract:
pytest -q testswas captured to.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/pytest_baseline.txt, the seven failures are enumerated, and each is classified as orthogonal to IMP-01 using keyword checks plus file-owner provenance. Since u5 is the last implementation unit, Stage 3 is complete.Findings:
.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/pytest_baseline.txtexists, has 287 lines, and ends with7 failed, 1622 passed in 360.92s (0:06:00).tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.mdrecords the capture command, summary line, seven failure IDs, IMP-01 keyword orthogonality check, git-log owner provenance, Stage 2 baseline comparison, gate verdict, negative claims, and follow-up axes.zone_geometries|IMP-01|step.?14|step.?21|slideRect|imp01returns no hits.git log -1over the failing test files matches the documented owners:f3ef4d9for the anchor tests,b1bbe27for the B4 mapper SHA tests, and1186ad8for the V4 fallback tests..orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/pytest_stage2_codex_r1.txthas the same seven failing test IDs and the same pass/fail counts (7 failed, 1622 passed); only elapsed time differs.src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyhas no working-tree diff, so u5 did not touch production source or the locked Step 14 / Step 21 implementation.=== EVIDENCE ===
Remaining units: none
Commands run:
git status --shortSelect-String -LiteralPath 'tests\verification\imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md' -Pattern '^## E|^### E\.|pytest_baseline|7 failed|1622 passed|Orthogonal|IMP-01|Reserved|negative claims|Stage 2 contract|follow-up' -Context 1,2Get-Content -LiteralPath '.orchestrator\tmp\imp01_a6_runs\pytest_baseline.txt' -Tail 80git diff -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.py tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/pytest_baseline.txt(Get-Content -LiteralPath '.orchestrator\tmp\imp01_a6_runs\pytest_baseline.txt').CountSelect-String -LiteralPath '.orchestrator\tmp\imp01_a6_runs\pytest_baseline.txt' -Pattern '^FAILED 'rg -n -i "zone_geometries|IMP-01|step.?14|step.?21|slideRect|imp01" tests/orchestrator_unit/test_imp17_comment_anchor.py tests/regression/test_b4_mapper_source_sha_parity.py tests/test_phase_z2_v4_fallback.pyGet-ChildItem -LiteralPath '.orchestrator\tmp\imp01_a6_runs' -Recurse -File | Select-Object FullName,Length,LastWriteTimegit diff --name-only -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.py tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.mdGet-Content -LiteralPath '.orchestrator\tmp\imp01_a6_runs\pytest_stage2_codex_r1.txt' -Tail 20git log -1 --oneline -- tests/orchestrator_unit/test_imp17_comment_anchor.py; git log -1 --oneline -- tests/regression/test_b4_mapper_source_sha_parity.py; git log -1 --oneline -- tests/test_phase_z2_v4_fallback.pySelect-String -LiteralPath 'tests\verification\imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md' -Pattern '^## D|^### D\.5|git diff -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.py|ZERO production-source|## E|^### E\.' -Context 0,1git status --short -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.py tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/pytest_baseline.txt .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/pytest_stage2_codex_r1.txtFiles checked:
tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/pytest_baseline.txt.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/pytest_stage2_codex_r1.txttests/orchestrator_unit/test_imp17_comment_anchor.pytests/regression/test_b4_mapper_source_sha_parity.pytests/test_phase_z2_v4_fallback.pysrc/phase_z2_pipeline.pyVerified facts:
7 failed, 1622 passed in 360.92s (0:06:00).7 failed, 1622 passed in 364.29s (0:06:04).f3ef4d9,b1bbe27, and1186ad8.git diff --name-only -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.py tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.mdprints only the verification document path, not production source.src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyis not modified; u5 adds only the local pytest artifact plus documentation.FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES
[Claude #19] Stage 4 test-verify Round #1 — IMP-01 #1 A-6 Zone DOM bbox export
Verdict
PASS — All Stage 2 implementation_units (u1–u5) deliverables match the contracted scope, schema lock holds against every u2 runtime artifact, production source byte-untouched at the Stage 1 locked anchors, and the u5 pytest baseline parity gate against Stage 2 is satisfied.
Verification table (against Stage 2 contract)
tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md§A.1–§A.6 recorded the 3-step driver chain, captured Chrome 148.0.7778.168 + nested driver 147.0.7727.117, predicted Path A resolution, no-touch guardrail onsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3168-3171single,vertical-2,left-1-right-2,top-1-bottom-2) withlayouts.yamlgrounding; §B.3 verbatim CLI commands per topology; §B.4 all four runspassed=Trueviaselenium_manager; §B.5 per-item coordinates dumped (9 items across 4 runs); artifacts present at.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/{single, vertical-2, left-1-right-2, top-1-bottom-2}/debug.jsonzone_geometries_pxlist /{position:str, template_id:str, x,y,w,h:int}/ slide-relative rounded /[]no-runtime fallbackALL_SCHEMA_ASSERTIONS_PASS(9 items × 5 axes — key set, str types, int-not-bool types, envelope ≤ 1280×720+1, origin slide-relative); §C.5 SHA256 byte-bindings recorded; §C.6[]fallback grounded in source not runtime-observed:3207-3208/:3214/:3230-3239/:3403/:4529-4530; §D.2 semantic grep ofzone_geometries_pxmatches source-of-truth count; §D.3 scoped `keipython -m pytest -q testsat HEAD4e281a2; §E.2 verbatim summary7 failed, 1622 passed in 360.92s (0:06:00); §E.4 0 IMP-01 keyword hits across 3 failing files; §E.5 owner commitsf3ef4d9/b1bbe27/1186ad8; §E.6 Stage 2 byte-identical failing-test-ID set parity; §E.7 contract gate verdict PASS; §E.9 7 follow-up axes (F1–F7) drafted as separate candidatesDiff vs. plan (Stage 2 contract
files)No scope creep. Verification doc growth is exactly the §A–§E layout the Stage 2 plan promised. Artifact set is exactly the 4 layout
debug.json+ 1 baseline txt the plan promised. Zero production-source diff at the Step 14 / Step 21 locked anchors.Hardcoding audit (RULE 7, feedback_no_hardcoding)
debug.jsonpatching: §C.5 SHA256 bindings for the 4 u2 artifacts remain stable; §C.3 ran assertions over the unmodified files and the run succeeded → there was no need (and no act) to edit the JSON to make the schema pass.:3232-3239) and Step 21 (:4530) at HEAD4e281a2are byte-identical to the Stage 1 lock; the schema observed at runtime is the schema declared in source.tests/verification/...mdinjection of fabricated values: every per-item coordinate in §B.5 ("x= 50 y= 76 w=1180 h=585" etc.) is reproducible viapython -c "import json; ..."against the JSON files on disk — re-verified in this Stage 4 round.samples/mdx_batch/02.mdx(per §B.2 isolation rationale: content-axis is orthogonal to the geometry-export axis). The export is generic — sameslideRect-anchored math runs against every layout. Coverage = 4 distinct topology classes.Honored RULE 0 (PIPELINE-CONSTRUCTION): no MDX 03/04/05 special-casing in the verification doc; geometry export is a general Step 14 inline-JS path applicable to every MDX.
Regression check
7 failed, 1622 passed(pytest_stage2_codex_r1.txttail)7 failed, 1622 passed(pytest_baseline.txt:287)test_imp17_comment_anchor.py::test_line_586_…,…::test_line_587_…,test_b4_mapper_source_sha_parity.py::test_post_89a_flag_off_final_html_sha_matches_frozen_baseline[01.mdx],…::test_post_89a_flag_off_final_html_sha_holistic_sweep,test_phase_z2_v4_fallback.py::test_rank_1_non_direct_promotes_rank_2,…::test_duplicate_template_id_is_skipped_rank_3_wins,…::test_restructure_reject_preserved_as_non_direct_evidencef3ef4d9(IMP-17 anchor) /b1bbe27(IMP-89 SHA parity) /1186ad8(V4 fallback)Stage 2 contract gate (Stage 3 failing set ⊆ Stage 2 failing set, byte-identical) satisfied. The 7 failures are owned by IMP-17 / IMP-89 / V4-fallback axes — orthogonal to IMP-01 #1 by both keyword check and git-log provenance. They are surfaced as follow-up issue candidates F1–F7 in §E.9, not bundled into this issue.
Guardrail summary (Stage 2 binding contract)
debug.jsonpatching, no schema mutation, no new export field).:3207-3239/:4529-4530confirmed empty, §D.3).chromedriverinstall intoPROJECT_ROOTorPATH(resolved via Selenium Manager, §B.4).4e281a2).Decision
Stage 4 Round #1 → PASS, advance to Stage 5 (commit / push).
The verification artifact set (doc + 4×
debug.json+pytest_baseline.txt) is committable as-is; no production source change to bundle. Once committed, this issue can transition toverified— the IMP-01 #1 backlog acceptance criteria (Step 14getBoundingClientRect()extension + Step 21 additivezone_geometries_pxsurfacing + AI/V4/frame-selection isolation) are all live-evidenced at HEAD4e281a2.=== EVIDENCE ===
git status --short -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.py tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/→?? tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md+?? .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/only;src/phase_z2_pipeline.pybyte-untouched.git log -1 --format="%h %ad %s" -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.py→4e281a2 Mon May 25 08:27:09 2026 +0900 feat(#93): IMP-55 …(frontend manual-section-swap, IMP-01-orthogonal; no drift on Step 14/21 spans).src/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3200-3249and:3395-3403and:4525-4534→ IMP-01 #1 comment markers (// A-6 (IMP-01 #1) — slide-relative bbox base@:3207,// A-6 (IMP-01 #1) — zone bbox in slide-relative px (additive trace, no layout side effect)@:3230,# A-6 (IMP-01 #1) — additive top-level zone bbox trace (slide-relative px)@:4529) intact at locked spans; per-zone push at:3232-3239matches locked shape{position, template_id, x:Math.round(…), y:Math.round(…), w:Math.round(…), h:Math.round(…)}.ls .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/{single, vertical-2, left-1-right-2, top-1-bottom-2}/→ all 4 directories containdebug.json(sizes 102220 / 108608 / 153072 / 153107 bytes; mtimes 14:39–14:47 prior to this round).python -c "import json; …over 4 artifacts → per-layoutzone_geometries_pxitem countssingle=1,vertical-2=2,left-1-right-2=3,top-1-bottom-2=3(9 total); every item key set ={h, position, template_id, w, x, y}; types ={h:int, position:str, template_id:str, w:int, x:int, y:int}(no float, no bool).tail -3 .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/pytest_baseline.txt→7 failed, 1622 passed in 360.92s (0:06:00).grep -n "^FAILED" pytest_baseline.txt→ 7 IDs matching Stage 3 exit report exactly (test_imp17_comment_anchor.py×2 /test_b4_mapper_source_sha_parity.py×2 /test_phase_z2_v4_fallback.py×3).tail -30 pytest_stage2_codex_r1.txt(UTF-16 — read directly) → same 7 IDs +7 failed, 1622 passed in 364.29s (0:06:04); failing-test-ID set parity confirmed.grep -cE "zone_geometries_px|IMP-01|step.?14|step.?21|slideRect|imp01" pytest_baseline.txt→0(IMP-01 keyword orthogonal).tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.mdheadings → §A.1–§A.6, §B.1–§B.6, §C.1–§C.8, §D.1–§D.6, §E.1–§E.9 all present at sizes consistent with Stage 3 exit report.source_comment_ids:
commit_sha:
4e281a2(unchanged through Stage 3 → Stage 4; verification doc + artifact uncommitted pending Stage 5)[Codex #19] Stage 4 test-verify Round #1 - IMP-01 #1 A-6 Zone DOM bbox export
Verdict: PASS. I independently re-checked the Stage 2/3 deliverables, the runtime artifact schema, the locked Step 14/Step 21 source anchors, and the Stage 4 full-suite test result. The implementation remains scope-locked: doc/artifact-only verification output, no production-source diff, no schema mutation, and no AI / Kei / V4 / frame-selection coupling at the locked spans.
Verification findings:
.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/{single,vertical-2,left-1-right-2,top-1-bottom-2}/debug.json.ALL_SCHEMA_ASSERTIONS_PASS; SHA256 values match the document bindings (f8162bdb...,66eadcb5...,37ea4e09...,a12a07fd...).zone_geometries_pxappears exactly four times insrc/phase_z2_pipeline.pyat lines 3214, 3232, 3403, and 4530; the locked spans at 3207-3208, 3214, 3230-3239, 3403, and 4529-4530 match the Stage 1/2 anchors; scoped grep forkei|frame_selection|V4|ai_redesignerover those spans returnedTOTAL_HITS=0.python -m pytest -q testsproduced the same seven failing test IDs and the same pass/fail count as the saved baseline class:7 failed, 1622 passed. IMP-01 keyword grep over the three failing test files returned zero hits.The seven pytest failures are preexisting and orthogonal to IMP-01:
tests/orchestrator_unit/test_imp17_comment_anchor.py::{test_line_586_references_imp17_not_imp31,test_line_587_references_imp47b_supersession}tests/regression/test_b4_mapper_source_sha_parity.py::{test_post_89a_flag_off_final_html_sha_matches_frozen_baseline[01.mdx],test_post_89a_flag_off_final_html_sha_holistic_sweep}tests/test_phase_z2_v4_fallback.py::{test_rank_1_non_direct_promotes_rank_2,test_duplicate_template_id_is_skipped_rank_3_wins,test_restructure_reject_preserved_as_non_direct_evidence}No rewind target is required. Commit scope is OK for the IMP-01 verification doc/artifacts only.
=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git status --shortgit rev-parse --short HEADGet-Content -LiteralPath tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.mdGet-ChildItem -LiteralPath .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs -Recurse | Select-Object FullName,Length,LastWriteTimeGet-FileHash -Algorithm SHA256 .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/{single,vertical-2,left-1-right-2,top-1-bottom-2}/debug.jsondebug.jsonartifactsrg -n "zone_geometries_px" src/phase_z2_pipeline.pygit diff -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.py tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/pytest_baseline.txtsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.pyanchors 3207-3208, 3214, 3230-3239, 3403, 4529-4530kei|frame_selection|V4|ai_redesignerover the locked spanspython -m pytest -q tests.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/pytest_baseline.txtFiles checked:
src/phase_z2_pipeline.pytests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/single/debug.json.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/vertical-2/debug.json.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/left-1-right-2/debug.json.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/top-1-bottom-2/debug.json.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/pytest_baseline.txttests/orchestrator_unit/test_imp17_comment_anchor.pytests/regression/test_b4_mapper_source_sha_parity.pytests/test_phase_z2_v4_fallback.pyTest results:
ALL_SCHEMA_ASSERTIONS_PASS7 failed, 1622 passed in 351.86s (0:05:51)7 failed, 1622 passed in 360.92s (0:06:00)Verified facts:
4e281a2src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyscoped diff: emptydebug.jsonartifact SHA256 values match the verification documentzone_geometries_pxschema is top-level list with locked per-item keys and integer slide-relative coordinates across all four artifactszone_geometries_pxproduction occurrences are limited to the locked Step 14/Step 21 anchorsFINAL_CONSENSUS: YES
[Claude #20] Stage 5 commit-push Round #1 — IMP-01 #1 A-6 Zone DOM bbox export
📌 Commit + push completed, both remotes synced.
■ Decisions
tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md(NEW, 499 lines) only..orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/**(debug.json x4, pytest_baseline.txt, pytest_stage2_codex_r1.txt) honored as LOCAL ARTIFACTS per work-principle (TEMP / LOCAL ARTIFACTS: .orchestrator/tmp/ ... only) — NOT committed; SHA256 bindings in §C.5 of the doc bind those artifacts in-place.src/phase_z2_pipeline.pybyte-untouched (Stage 1 lock honored; implementation already shipped at1dc81e0, 2026-05-12).docs(#1)chosen because this stage is verification-doc-only (no production diff). Matches "what was actually staged" rather thanfeat(which would imply a feature change).■ Scope-locked file list
git diff --staged --statmatched exactly that one path.git status --short src/empty → no production drift.■ Commit
■ Push
git push origin main→4e281a2..ec7471e main -> main(GitHub,git@github.com:keimin86/design_agent.git)git push slide2 main→4e281a2..ec7471e main -> main(Gitea mirror,https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2.git)■ Remote-head verification (post-fetch)
All three SHAs identical → push lossless on both remotes.
■ Scope guardrails preserved
src/phase_z2_pipeline.pybyte-untouched at locked anchors:3162-3185,:3207-3208,:3214,:3230-3239,:3403,:4529-4530.zone_geometries_pxlist /{position:str, template_id:str, x|y|w|h:int}/ slide-relative rounded /[]no-runtime fallback) unchanged.[[feedback_workflow_atomicity_rules]]honored: 1 commit = 1 decision unit (verification doc), specific path staged (nogit add -A).[[feedback_one_step_per_turn]]honored: Stage 5 only; no auto-advance to Stage 6.■ Next stage
Stage 6 (final close) — pending Codex #20 review consensus on this commit-push round.
=== EVIDENCE ===
commands_run:
git status --short(pre-stage scope check, identified verification doc as only IMP-01 candidate)git add tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md(specific path; no-A)git status --short tests/verification/ .orchestrator/→A tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md+?? .orchestrator/(LOCAL, intentional)git diff --staged --stat→1 file changed, 499 insertions(+)git diff --staged --name-only→ exactlytests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.mdgit status --short src/→ empty (production source untouched)git commit -m "docs(#1): IMP-01 A-6 u1~u5 zone_geometries_px runtime verification log (...)"git push origin main→ success (4e281a2..ec7471e)git push slide2 main→ success (4e281a2..ec7471e)git fetch --all→ success (origin, gitea, slide2)git rev-parse HEAD origin/main slide2/main→ all three =ec7471ed594b887cf34610318ba0e0dc8b04d977files_committed:
tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md(NEW, 499 lines)files_intentionally_uncommitted (LOCAL per work-principle):
.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/single/debug.json(SHA256f8162bdb...).orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/vertical-2/debug.json(SHA25666eadcb5...).orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/left-1-right-2/debug.json(SHA25637ea4e09...).orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/top-1-bottom-2/debug.json(SHA256a12a07fd...).orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/pytest_baseline.txt(Stage 3 capture, 287 lines, tail7 failed, 1622 passed in 360.92s).orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/pytest_stage2_codex_r1.txt(Stage 2 baseline, same failing-test class)commit_sha:
ec7471ed594b887cf34610318ba0e0dc8b04d9774e281a2(verified pre-push)1dc81e0(2026-05-12, untouched)remote_state:
origin(git@github.com:keimin86/design_agent.git) →main = ec7471eslide2(https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2.git) →main = ec7471esource_comment_ids:
rewind_signal: none (Stage 5 commit-push completed cleanly; awaiting Codex #20 review)
[Codex #20] Stage 5 commit-push review -- IMP-01 #1 A-6 Zone DOM bbox export
Stage 5 verification result: PASS.
I verified Claude #20's commit/push claims against local git state, refreshed remote refs, and live remote heads. Local
HEAD,origin/main, andslide2/mainall resolve to:ec7471ed594b887cf34610318ba0e0dc8b04d977Commit scope is correct and additive:
docs(#1): IMP-01 A-6 u1~u5 zone_geometries_px runtime verification log (driver chain + 4-topology runs + schema lock + no-drift guardrail + pytest baseline gate; production source untouched, impl at 1dc81e0)kyeongmin <b24009@hanmaceng.co.kr>,2026-05-25T15:49:23+09:00A tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md499 0 tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.mdsrc/path is present inHEAD^..HEAD..orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/**path is present inHEAD.Remote reflection is correct:
git ls-remote origin refs/heads/mainreturnsec7471ed594b887cf34610318ba0e0dc8b04d977.git ls-remote slide2 refs/heads/mainreturnsec7471ed594b887cf34610318ba0e0dc8b04d977.HEAD.Artifact handling claim is correct:
.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/remains local/untracked.single/debug.json: 102220 bytes, SHA256f8162bdb1c86f04c6b7202b4d71e022456c6278ac1b2a1081eef1cdf13168da6vertical-2/debug.json: 108608 bytes, SHA25666eadcb5cb2cbff663365eddcab2b5eb90bcbe1999c4d52c48eb99a17beaa5e3left-1-right-2/debug.json: 153072 bytes, SHA25637ea4e09c09bc1a4e4ff39a9ac9fabd0c1139733a62f27ec09b04255418424c6top-1-bottom-2/debug.json: 153107 bytes, SHA256a12a07fd0bd0cda59c49f8bd1a1bc592e2536a0572b70c44acc683a4c2c99857pytest_baseline.txtexists locally and tails with7 failed, 1622 passed in 360.92s (0:06:00).Workspace note:
git status --shortshows many pre-existing untracked files, including.orchestrator/local artifacts, but none are included in commitec7471e. This is not a Stage 5 push anomaly.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git status --shortgit rev-parse HEAD origin/main slide2/maingit log -1 --format='%H%n%an <%ae>%n%ad%n%s%n%b' --date=iso-strictgit show --stat --oneline --name-status --format=fuller HEADgit remote -vgit diff --name-status HEAD^ HEADgit diff --numstat HEAD^ HEADgit status --short -- src tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runsgit fetch origin maingit fetch slide2 maingit ls-remote origin refs/heads/maingit ls-remote slide2 refs/heads/maingit diff --name-only HEAD^ HEAD -- srcgit show --name-only --format= HEAD | Select-String -Pattern '^\\.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/'Select-String -Path 'tests\\verification\\imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md' -Pattern 'ALL_SCHEMA_ASSERTIONS_PASS|7 failed, 1622 passed|zone_geometries_px|production source untouched|f8162bdb|66eadcb5|37ea4e09|a12a07fd'Get-ChildItem -LiteralPath '.orchestrator\\tmp\\imp01_a6_runs' -Recurse -File | Where-Object { $_.Name -in @('debug.json','pytest_baseline.txt','pytest_stage2_codex_r1.txt') } | Select-Object FullName,LengthGet-FileHash -Algorithm SHA256 '.orchestrator\\tmp\\imp01_a6_runs\\single\\debug.json','.orchestrator\\tmp\\imp01_a6_runs\\vertical-2\\debug.json','.orchestrator\\tmp\\imp01_a6_runs\\left-1-right-2\\debug.json','.orchestrator\\tmp\\imp01_a6_runs\\top-1-bottom-2\\debug.json' | Select-Object Path,HashGet-Content -Tail 5 -LiteralPath '.orchestrator\\tmp\\imp01_a6_runs\\pytest_baseline.txt'git show HEAD:tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md | Select-String -Pattern '^# IMP-01 A-6|ALL_SCHEMA_ASSERTIONS_PASS|7 failed, 1622 passed|f8162bdb|66eadcb5|37ea4e09|a12a07fd'Files checked:
tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/single/debug.json.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/vertical-2/debug.json.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/left-1-right-2/debug.json.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/top-1-bottom-2/debug.json.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/pytest_baseline.txtsrc/diff scope viagit diff --name-only HEAD^ HEAD -- srcTest results:
Commit SHA:
ec7471ed594b887cf34610318ba0e0dc8b04d977Verified facts:
HEAD, refreshedorigin/main, refreshedslide2/main, and livels-remoteheads all equalec7471ed594b887cf34610318ba0e0dc8b04d977.tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md..orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/.FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES
[Claude #21] Stage 6 final-close Round #1 — IMP-01 #1 A-6 Zone DOM 좌표 export
Goal vs Result
_MEASURE_SCRIPTJS extensiongetBoundingClientRect()(Step 14)1dc81e0(2026-05-12, +18 LOC atsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py).orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/{single,vertical-2,left-1-right-2,top-1-bottom-2}/debug.json) allpassed=Truevia Selenium Managerzone_geometries_pxfield (top-leveldebug.json)1dc81e0(write_debug_jsonadditive)ALL_SCHEMA_ASSERTIONS_PASS; SHA256 bound:f8162bdb…,66eadcb5…,37ea4e09…,a12a07fd…kei|frame_selection|V4|ai_redesignerat locked spans = 0 hits{position, template_id, x, y, w, h}slide-relative rounded pxdebug.jsonschema 보존 (additive)Commit on origin (post-Stage 5)
Independently re-verified Stage 6:
git show --stat ec7471e→ 1 file,+499 -0, path =tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.mdgit diff --stat 4e281a2..ec7471e -- src/→ empty (production source byte-untouched at HEAD scope)git show 1dc81e0 --stat→ confirms implementation already shipped 2026-05-12 (src/phase_z2_pipeline.py +18)git show ec7471e:tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md | wc -l→ 499 (matches Stage 5 numstat)Review-loop checklist (issue body)
Codex #1 YES)Claude #1)Codex #11 YES), Stage 4 (Codex #19 PASS), Stage 5 (Codex #20 PASS)1dc81e0(2026-05-12)ec7471everification doc + Stage 4 PASS + Stage 5 dual-remote push losslessFollow-up axes (NOT in IMP-01 #1; separate ownership)
u5 baseline gate captured
7 failed, 1622 passedat HEADec7471e. All 7 failures are IMP-01-orthogonal (keyword grepzone_geometries|IMP-01|step.?14|step.?21|slideRect|imp01over 3 failing test files = 0 hits) and were already failing at Stage 2 baseline (byte-identical failing set). They belong to separate axes:tests/orchestrator_unit/test_imp17_comment_anchor.py(ownerf3ef4d9, IMP-17 / IMP-35 anchor)tests/regression/test_b4_mapper_source_sha_parity.py(ownerb1bbe27, IMP-89 B4 mapper SHA parity)1186ad8, IMP-47B / #76)Stage 4 exit report explicitly classified these as orthogonal preexisting. Recommend opening as 3 grouped follow-up issues (per owner-commit) — final grouping decision out-of-scope for #1.
Labels (request — current Gitea state not auto-readable)
verified,implemented(if not already applied)area:phase-z,step:14,step:21(if such labels exist in project taxonomy)Close decision
CLOSE — IMP-01 #1 A-6 fully delivered:
1dc81e0(Step 14 inline JS bbox capture + Step 21 additive top-levelzone_geometries_px).ec7471e(tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md, 499 lines, §A driver-env / §B 4-topology runs / §C schema lock / §D no-drift / §E baseline gate).No rewind required. No within-scope unresolved questions remain.
source_comment_ids: Claude #21 (Stage 6 final-close Round #1), referencing Claude #1/#11/#18/#19/#20 + Codex #1/#11/#18/#19/#20.
[Codex #21] Stage 6 final-close Round #1 IMP-01 #1 A-6
Final independent verification result: PASS. Close OK.
Scope-qualified verdict:
1dc81e0changed onlysrc/phase_z2_pipeline.pyfor IMP-01 A-6 and added the Step 14/Step 21zone_geometries_pxsurface.ec7471ed594b887cf34610318ba0e0dc8b04d977adds onlytests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.mdwith numstat499 0; nosrc/diff exists from4e281a2..ec7471e.HEAD,origin/main,slide2/main,git ls-remote origin refs/heads/main, andgit ls-remote slide2 refs/heads/mainall resolve toec7471ed594b887cf34610318ba0e0dc8b04d977.visual_runtime_check.passed=True, andzone_geometries_pxhas the locked additive shape{position:str, template_id:str, x:int, y:int, w:int, h:int}with countssingle=1,vertical-2=2,left-1-right-2=3,top-1-bottom-2=3.single=f8162bdb1c86f04c6b7202b4d71e022456c6278ac1b2a1081eef1cdf13168da6,vertical-2=66eadcb5cb2cbff663365eddcab2b5eb90bcbe1999c4d52c48eb99a17beaa5e3,left-1-right-2=37ea4e09c09bc1a4e4ff39a9ac9fabd0c1139733a62f27ec09b04255418424c6,top-1-bottom-2=a12a07fd0bd0cda59c49f8bd1a1bc592e2536a0572b70c44acc683a4c2c99857.zone_geometries_pxappears exactly atsrc/phase_z2_pipeline.py:3214,:3232,:3403, and:4530; scoped checks over the locked spans found nokei,frame_selection,V4, orai_redesignerhits.7 failed, 1622 passed in 360.92s (0:06:00)and failing IDs are the known orthogonal set from IMP-17 anchor, B4 mapper SHA parity, and V4 fallback tests.No rewind target is required.
=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git rev-parse HEAD; git rev-parse origin/main; git rev-parse slide2/maingit status --shortgit show --stat --oneline --name-status ec7471egit diff --stat 4e281a2..ec7471e -- src/git ls-remote origin refs/heads/main; git ls-remote slide2 refs/heads/maingit show --numstat --format= ec7471e -- tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.mdgit show --stat --oneline 1dc81e0 -- src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyrg -n "zone_geometries_px|ALL_SCHEMA_ASSERTIONS_PASS|7 failed, 1622 passed|f8162bdb|66eadcb5|37ea4e09|a12a07fd" tests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.mdrg -n "zone_geometries_px" src/phase_z2_pipeline.pyGet-FileHash -Algorithm SHA256 .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/{single,vertical-2,left-1-right-2,top-1-bottom-2}/debug.jsonGet-Content -LiteralPath .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/pytest_baseline.txt -Tail 5rg -n "FAILED tests/" .orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/pytest_baseline.txtkei|frame_selection|V4|ai_redesignerover locked Step 14/21 spans.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/*/debug.jsonartifactsFiles checked:
src/phase_z2_pipeline.pytests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.md.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/single/debug.json.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/vertical-2/debug.json.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/left-1-right-2/debug.json.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/top-1-bottom-2/debug.json.orchestrator/tmp/imp01_a6_runs/pytest_baseline.txtVerified facts:
HEAD == origin/main == slide2/main == ec7471ed594b887cf34610318ba0e0dc8b04d977.git ls-remotefor bothorigin/mainandslide2/mainreturnsec7471ed594b887cf34610318ba0e0dc8b04d977.ec7471echanges onlytests/verification/imp01_a6_runtime_verification.mdwith numstat499 0.git diff --stat 4e281a2..ec7471e -- src/is empty.1dc81e0is the implementation commit for IMP-01 A-6 and changessrc/phase_z2_pipeline.pyby17 insertions(+), 1 deletion(-).7 failed, 1622 passed; Stage 6 did not rerun full pytest because current-stage instructions prohibit it unless explicitly required.FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES