IMP-26 J3 — html_generator utility 중복 cleanup #26
Assignees
Kyeongmin (이경민)
Clear assignees
Kyeongmin (이경민)
No Assignees
Notifications
Due Date
No due date set.
Dependencies
No dependencies set.
Reference: Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2#26
Reference in New Issue
Block a user
related module: §2.9
html_generator.pysource: INSIGHT-MAP §5 J3
priority: ↓ low (future)
scope:
normalize_mdx/_slice_mdx_sections/_get_definitions/_get_conclusion(vs §2.1 / §2.2 SoT)guardrail / validation:
trigger axis: Phase R' cleanup axis 활성 시
milestone: B-4 §4 cleanup (3) [#92]
cross-ref:
review loop:
[Claude #1] Stage 1 — IMP-26 problem review (J3 html_generator utility 중복 cleanup)
Root-cause framing
IMP-26 =
PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md §2.9footnote J3: deterministic helpers insidesrc/html_generator.py(normalize_mdx,_slice_mdx_sections,_get_definitions,_get_conclusion) duplicate the §2.1mdx_normalizer.py/ §2.2section_parser.pySoT. The audit classifies them as Reference Only inside an otherwise Archive Candidate module — and J3 explicitly says "Phase R' cleanup 시 제거/보존 여부를 별도 판단". The issue body declares the trigger as "Phase R' cleanup axis 활성 시" with priority ↓ low (future). The Stage 1 question is: is that trigger axis active today, and can the four helpers be removed in isolation?Answer (verified below): no, on both counts. The helpers are not isolated dead code — they have multiple live in-module callers plus an external import from
content_verifier.generate_with_retry, whichpipeline.pyStage 2 still dispatches for layout_template = Type A. Deleting them standalone breaks the Type A AI-HTML path that the active pipeline still consumes. The interfaces also diverge from the SoT (different return shapes / inputs), so the four helpers are not drop-in replaceable by §2.1 / §2.2 — a redirect would be a migration with adapter code, not "코드 제거만". The right scope-lock is therefore to defer IMP-26 until the full §2.9 archive trigger fires (i.e., when the Type A AI-HTML path is removed from the live pipeline), so the four helpers fall with their hosting module rather than as an isolated cleanup.Verified facts (value + path + upstream)
docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.mdIMP-26 §4 cleanup (3). Priority ↓ low (future). Trigger = "Phase R' cleanup axis 활성 시". Guardrail = "Phase R' 영역 — 코드 제거만, 다른 axis 무관".docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md §5 J3(별 axis 후보 cleanup) +docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md §2.9(src/html_generator.pyaudit, lines 900–991).html_generator.py= "Mixed (Archive heavy — Phase R' core). Salvage Candidate 0". The four helpers themselves = Reference Only with§2.1 / §2.2 에 더 직접적인 SoT 후보 존재(lines 946–951). J3 footnote (line 975): cleanup deferred to Phase R' archive timing.src/mdx_normalizer.py::normalize_mdx_content(line 395) — 4-layer parser (frontmatter / code-block protect / markdown-it-py AST / clean). Returns dict{clean_text, title, images, popups, tables, sections}.src/section_parser.py::extract_major_sections(line 23),extract_conclusion_text(line 491). Operates on already-normalized sections (list[dict]).src/html_generator.py:normalize_mdxline 752 — single-pass regex → str (vs §2.1 returns dict)._slice_mdx_sectionsline 830 — calls localnormalize_mdx, returnsdict[str, str]keyed by section name (vs §2.2 operates onlist[dict]and returnslist[dict])._get_definitionsline 930 — uses_slice_mdx_sections; matches "용어/정의" section._get_conclusionline 943 — uses_slice_mdx_sections; matches "요약/결론" (vs §2.2extract_conclusion_textwhich parses:::note[핵심 요약]from raw MDX).normalize_mdxreturns plain string. Adapter required.normalized_sections: list[dict]; helper_slice_mdx_sectionsinput = rawcontent: str. Different abstractions.extract_conclusion_textreads:::note[핵심 요약]directive; helper_get_conclusionreads section names by Korean substring. Behaviorally different. A pure deletion + import swap would change runtime behavior in the Type A path._slice_mdx_sections—generate_slide_htmlline 654;regenerate_arealine 1011._get_definitions—regenerate_arealine 1029._get_conclusion—generate_slide_htmlline 730 (footer fallback);regenerate_arealine 1041.normalize_mdx— only consumed by_slice_mdx_sectionsline 837 (private chain; deletable iff_slice_mdx_sectionsis also deleted).src/content_verifier.py:566—async def generate_with_retry(...)imports_slice_mdx_sections, _map_sections_for_role, _get_definitions, _get_conclusion. Uses_slice_mdx_sectionsat line 570;_map_sections_for_roleat line 594._get_definitions/_get_conclusionconsumed viaregenerate_areachain.scripts/test_phase_r_prime.py,test_phase_s.py,test_phase_t.py,test_phase_t_audit.py,test_phase_t_real.py) importgenerate_slide_html/_build_phase_t_supplementbut not the four helpers directly.src/pipeline.py:1196Stage 2:if context.analysis.layout_template in ("B", "B'", "B''"):→block_assembler.assemble_slide_html_final(bypasseshtml_generator). Otherwise (Type A) →from src.content_verifier import generate_with_retry; await generate_with_retry(...)(line 1241).src/pipeline.py:1653+ 1679 — second dispatch site (regenerate path / re-entry), samegenerate_with_retrycall.content_verifier.generate_with_retry → html_generator.generate_slide_html / regenerate_area. The four helpers are live transitively in this path.html_generator.pyas a whole is Archive Candidate per §2.9 audit, but its archival has not happened: pipeline.py still dispatches Type A through it. The J3 cleanup is by construction downstream of that archive, not parallel to it.a71355e0059caaae9d53372ba2987551998bd7b8(branchmain).src/html_generator.py/src/content_verifier.py/src/mdx_normalizer.py/src/section_parser.pydirty edits. No accidental cross-axis bleed surface.Scope-lock
SCOPE-LOCKED: NOT-READY-FOR-IMPLEMENTATION this cycle. IMP-26 cannot land standalone because:
content_verifier.py:566import + pipeline Stage 2 Type A path). Deletion breaks runtime.pipeline.py:1196 / 1241 / 1653 / 1679. Precondition for the J3 trigger axis is not the four helpers themselves but the archival of the hosting modulehtml_generator.py(and thecontent_verifier.generate_with_retryType A branch).Recommended action this cycle: keep IMP-26 in
pending/↓ lowstate, but tighten the trigger axis description from the loose "Phase R' cleanup axis 활성 시" to an explicit unblock precondition:This conversion is documentation-only (backlog row / status board), not a code edit. Defer all code work to a future cycle gated on the unblock precondition above.
OUT OF SCOPE (this cycle):
src/html_generator.py(no deletion of the four helpers; no redirect; no shim).src/content_verifier.py(line 566 import remains).src/mdx_normalizer.py/src/section_parser.py(SoT untouched).src/pipeline.pyStage 2 dispatch (Type A path remains).OUT OF SCOPE (axis bleed — separate axes):
html_generator.pyarchive itself (Phase R' main archive — bigger axis, separate issue).Guardrails
html_generator.pyarchive. Stage 1 lock honors that constraint.src/html_generator.py의 4 개 helper + their direct callers (generate_slide_html,regenerate_area,content_verifier.generate_with_retry) + dispatch (pipeline.pyStage 2). All grep claims qualified to these files; no "전체 통과" framing.Risk
Low (Stage 1 is read-only investigation).
Failure modes of the deferral decision itself:
pipeline.py:1196Type A branch is removed without IMP-26 firing. Mitigation: backlog row unblock precondition makes the dependency explicit; any later PR that touches Stage 2 dispatch is anchor-linked.content_verifier.py:566import grows new consumers in the meantime. Mitigation: J3 footnote already flags this as Reference Only; PHASE-Q-AUDIT §2.7 capscontent_verifier.pyas Reference Only too — no new Phase Z code should import either.normalize_mdxinhtml_generator.pywhile §2.1 evolves). Mitigation: §2.9 audit + this Stage 1 record document the divergence; future drift is detectable via audit re-pass.Failure modes of taking the standalone deletion path (i.e., rejecting this Stage 1's recommendation):
pipeline.py:1241 / 1679) — FATAL._get_conclusionKorean section-name match vs §2.2:::note[핵심 요약]directive parse) silently regresses without test surface.Open questions for Codex r1
_map_sections_for_role: J3 lists only the four helpers, butcontent_verifier.py:566also imports_map_sections_for_rolefrom the same Reference-Only set. Question: keep IMP-26 scope strictly to the four named helpers (audit J3 letter), or surface the fifth as a sibling note. Recommend strict letter — surfacing as scope expansion would violate PZ-2 / RULE 10.Stage 1 lock summary
src/html_generator.pywhole-module archive +content_verifier.generate_with_retryType A path retirement). Today the gate is not satisfied becausepipeline.pyStage 2 Type A still dispatches through that path.html_generator.pystaged for archive, (c)content_verifier.py:566import severed.=== EVIDENCE ===
git rev-parse HEAD→a71355e0059caaae9d53372ba2987551998bd7b8.git status --porcelain→ orchestrator WIP + audit docs only; nosrc/html_generator.py/src/content_verifier.py/src/mdx_normalizer.py/src/section_parser.py/src/pipeline.pydirty edits.find /d/ad-hoc/kei/design_agent/src -type f -name "*.py" | xargs grep -l "def normalize_mdx\|def _slice_mdx_sections\|def _get_definitions\|def _get_conclusion"→src/html_generator.py,src/mdx_normalizer.pyonly. Two duplicate definition surfaces confirmed (SoT vs Reference-Only).grep -rn "html_generator" --include="*.py" /d/ad-hoc/kei/design_agent/src /d/ad-hoc/kei/design_agent/scripts→ live consumers:src/content_verifier.py:566(non-test) + 5 test scripts (test_phase_r_prime.py,test_phase_s.py,test_phase_t.py,test_phase_t_audit.py,test_phase_t_real.py); none of the test scripts import the four helpers directly.grep -rn "generate_with_retry\|generate_slide_html\|regenerate_area" src app.py→src/pipeline.py:1196, 1222, 1241, 1653, 1679confirms Type A dispatch live inpipeline.pyStage 2.grep -n "^def \|^class " src/section_parser.py→ §2.2 SoT surface:extract_major_sections(23),detect_component_popups(100),_classify_sub_types(157),classify_group_relations(269),resolve_schema(363),get_recipe_for_schema(425),check_kind_compatibility(464),get_candidate_blocks_for_schema(473),extract_conclusion_text(491),map_topics_to_sections(508).src/html_generator.py(full file 1–1070, with focused inspection of helper definitions at 752 / 830 / 930 / 943 and live caller sites at 654 / 730 / 1011 / 1029 / 1041).src/mdx_normalizer.py(full file 1–501; SoTnormalize_mdx_contentline 395 confirmed; 4-layer architecture confirmed).src/section_parser.pylines 485–510 (§2.2 SoTextract_conclusion_textconfirmed).src/content_verifier.pylines 540–620 (live import at line 566 + usage at 570 / 594 confirmed;generate_with_retryasync entry confirmed).src/pipeline.pylines 1180–1270 (Stage 2 Type A dispatch confirmed; layout_template branching at line 1187 + 1196 + 1241).docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md§2.9 lines 900–991 (Mixed Archive-heavy verdict; Reference Only classification for the four helpers; J3 footnote at line 975 confirmed;_map_sections_for_rolecompanion Reference-Only at line 948 noted as Q3)..orchestrator/drafts/16_stage_problem-review_claude_r1.md(Stage 1 Claude-r1 precedent format reference).pipeline.py → content_verifier.generate_with_retry → html_generator.generate_slide_html / regenerate_area → four helpersis reachable today for layout_template = Type A (i.e., layout_template NOT in B / B' / B'').FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES
[Codex #1] Stage 1 problem review - IMP-26
I verified Claude #1's root-cause framing and scope-lock: IMP-26 should not proceed as an isolated helper deletion in the current state.
Findings:
normalize_mdx/_slice_mdx_sections/_get_definitions/_get_conclusion:docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md:93.html_generatorduplicate helpers vs the §2.1 / §2.2 SoT, also only when the Phase R' cleanup axis is active:docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md:150.html_generator.pyas "Mixed (Archive heavy - Phase R' core)", "Salvage Candidate 0", with the four helpers as Reference Only, not Salvage:docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md:940-948.docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md:956.src/mdx_normalizer.py:393-438exposesnormalize_mdx_content(raw_mdx) -> dictwithclean_text,title,images,popups,tables, andsections, whilesrc/html_generator.py:752-827exposesnormalize_mdx(raw_mdx) -> str.src/section_parser.py:23-45consumes alist[dict]of normalized sections and returns major-section structures;src/html_generator.py:830-842returnsdict[str, str]after local normalization. Replacing it with §2.2 would require adapter/migration work, not "code removal only".src/html_generator.py:654,src/html_generator.py:730,src/html_generator.py:1011,src/html_generator.py:1029, andsrc/html_generator.py:1041.src/content_verifier.py:535importsgenerate_slide_html,regenerate_area,_slice_mdx_sections,_map_sections_for_role,_get_definitions, and_get_conclusion;src/content_verifier.py:539immediately calls_slice_mdx_sections(content).src/pipeline.py:1187-1196branches Type B/B'/B'' to block assembly but importsgenerate_with_retryfor Type A, andsrc/pipeline.py:1241-1247calls it. A second legacy path also imports/callsgenerate_with_retryatsrc/pipeline.py:1653andsrc/pipeline.py:1679.Scope-lock decision:
html_generator.py/content_verifier.generate_with_retry.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
Get-Content -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\tmp\codex_prompt.txt'Get-ChildItem -Forcerg --filesgit status --shortrg -n "IMP-26|J3|html_generator|normalize_mdx|_slice_mdx_sections|_get_definitions|_get_conclusion|Phase R" docs src tests scriptsrg -n "generate_with_retry|layout_template|Type A|html_generator|normalize_mdx|_slice_mdx_sections|_get_definitions|_get_conclusion" src tests scriptsrg -n "def normalize_mdx_content|def extract_major_sections|def extract_conclusion_text|return \{" src\mdx_normalizer.py src\section_parser.pySelect-String -Path 'docs\architecture\PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md' -Pattern 'IMP-26' -Context 2,3Select-String -Path 'docs\architecture\PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md' -Pattern 'J3|html_generator|normalize_mdx|_slice_mdx_sections|_get_definitions|_get_conclusion' -Context 2,4Select-String -Path 'docs\architecture\PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md' -Pattern '2\.9|html_generator|normalize_mdx|_slice_mdx_sections|_get_definitions|_get_conclusion|J3|Reference Only|Archive' -Context 2,4rg -n "^def normalize_mdx|^def _slice_mdx_sections|^def _get_definitions|^def _get_conclusion|_slice_mdx_sections\(|_get_definitions\(|_get_conclusion\(" src\html_generator.py src\content_verifier.py src\pipeline.py scripts testssrc\html_generator.py,src\content_verifier.py,src\pipeline.py,src\mdx_normalizer.py,src\section_parser.py, anddocs\architecture\PHASE-Q-AUDIT.mdFiles checked:
docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.mddocs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.mddocs/architecture/PHASE-Q-AUDIT.mdsrc/html_generator.pysrc/content_verifier.pysrc/pipeline.pysrc/mdx_normalizer.pysrc/section_parser.pyTest results: not run; Stage 1 explicitly says "NO pytest".
Verified facts:
html_generatorhelpers.content_verifier.generate_with_retry.FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES
[Claude #2] Stage 2 simulation-plan — IMP-26 deferral formalization
=== IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS ===
summary: Mark IMP-26 backlog row deferred + expand trigger axis with SoT-signature precondition; mirror trigger axis text in INSIGHT-MAP §5 J3 row
files:
tests: []
estimate_lines: 6
=== AXIS / ITEM COVERAGE ===
Issue body explicit axes/items:
normalize_mdx/_slice_mdx_sections/_get_definitions/_get_conclusionpending, trigger="Phase R' cleanup axis 활성 시"deferred; trigger expanded with §2.1/§2.2 SoT signature alignment precondition (adapter migration violates "코드 제거만" guardrail) — actual removal NOT performedhtml_generator.normalize_mdx→str vs §2.1→dict)↓ low (future)retainedPer-unit rationale (≤ 3 lines):
Out-of-scope (carried from Stage 1 scope_lock):
src/html_generator.py(lines 752-827, 830-842, callers 654/730/1011/1029/1041).normalize_mdx_content/ §2.2section_parser.pipeline.pyStage 2 /content_verifier.generate_with_retry._parse_json(IMP-28) and catalog/_get_block_by_id(IMP-27) cleanups — separate issues.Rollback strategy:
git checkout -- docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md. No runtime/test impact, no migrations to undo.Tests:
Follow-up issue candidates (NOT created in this stage):
=== EVIDENCE ===
deferred, scope_lock="documentation-only", out_of_scope="actual helper deletion / adapter migration / Type A path removal".docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md:93— IMP-26 row, current status=pending, current trigger="Phase R' cleanup axis 활성 시".docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md:150— §5 J3 row, current trigger="Phase R' cleanup axis 활성 시".docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md:946,947,951— §2.9 footnote already classifies the four helpers as Reference Only + "Phase R' cleanup 시 별도 판단"; no edit needed.src/html_generator.py:752-827(normalize_mdx),:830-842(_slice_mdx_sections),:654,730,1011,1029,1041(in-module callers) — live, not orphaned (confirmed by both Claude #1 + Codex #1 in Stage 1).src/mdx_normalizer.py:393-438— §2.1normalize_mdx_content(raw)→dictSoT (signature divergence vs html_generator helper returning str).src/section_parser.py:23-45— §2.2section_parser(list[dict])→major-section dictSoT (signature divergence vs_slice_mdx_sections(raw)→dict[str,str]).src/content_verifier.py:535— external import ofhtml_generatorhelpers; transitive live reference.[Codex #2] Stage 2 simulation-plan review - IMP-26
=== IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS ===
units:
summary: Document IMP-26 deferral by changing the backlog row to deferred and mirroring the trigger/precondition wording in the INSIGHT-MAP J3 row.
files:
tests:
estimate_lines: 6
Rationale:
u1 covers all issue-body axes: the four helper-removal items are deferred, Phase R' cleanup remains the only execution axis, and SoT signature alignment is recorded as a prerequisite so eventual work can stay code-removal-only.
Unit size is acceptable: 2 files and 6 estimated lines, below the 3-file and 50-line caps.
No source edit is planned; this matches the Stage 1 scope lock and avoids adapter, pipeline, content_verifier, or html_generator changes.
Out-of-scope:
Actual helper deletion, adapter migration to mdx_normalizer/section_parser, Type A AI-HTML retirement, content_verifier/pipeline changes, and other html_generator helpers remain excluded.
The plan is documentation-only; no runtime side effects are expected beyond the required baseline test.
Rollback strategy:
Revert only the two documentation rows touched by u1, restoring their prior pending/single-trigger wording.
=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
Files checked:
Test results:
Verified facts:
FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES
[Claude #3] Stage 3 code-edit — IMP-26 unit u1 (deferral documentation)
Executing unit: u1
■ unit_executed
deferredand mirroring the trigger/precondition wording in the INSIGHT-MAP §5 J3 row.■ files_changed
docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md(1 line modified — IMP-26 row, line 93)docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md(1 line modified — §5 J3 row, line 150)■ diff_summary
PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md (line 93, §4 cleanup table):
Phase R' cleanup axis 활성 시→Phase R' archive trigger AND §2.1/§2.2 SoT signature unification (both preconditions required to keep guardrail = code-removal-only)pending→deferredPHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md (line 150, §5 J3 row, candidate table):
Phase R' cleanup axis 활성 시→Phase R' archive trigger AND §2.1/§2.2 SoT signature unification (both preconditions required to keep guardrail = code-removal-only)(verbatim mirror of backlog row per anchor sync rule)Other columns (ID, title, related module, source, priority, scope, guardrail/validation) preserved unchanged. No other rows touched. No source code modified.
■ scope verification
mdx_normalizer.py, §2.2section_parser.py, §2.9html_generator.py,content_verifier.py,pipeline.py— NOT touched.■ guardrail compliance
■ remaining_units
■ follow_up_issue_candidates
STOP (no commit, no push — per Stage 3 contract).
[Codex #3] Stage 3 code-edit verification - IMP-26 u1
Verification result: PASS.
docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.mdanddocs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md.IMP-26now has statusdeferredand the trigger axis isPhase R' archive trigger AND §2.1/§2.2 SoT signature unification (both preconditions required to keep guardrail = code-removal-only).J3mirrors the same trigger wording verbatim.git diff --name-only;src/html_generator.py,src/content_verifier.py,src/pipeline.py,src/mdx_normalizer.py, andsrc/section_parser.pywere not touched by this unit.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
Get-Content -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\tmp\codex_prompt.txt'git status --shortgit diff -- docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.mdrg -n "IMP-26|J3|Phase R' archive trigger|SoT signature unification|deferred" docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.mdgit diff --name-onlyFiles checked:
docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.mddocs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.mdRemaining units: none
Verified facts:
git diff --name-onlyreports only the two Stage 2 planned files.git diffshows one changed row in each planned file.rg -nconfirms the final backlog row at line 93 and INSIGHT-MAP J3 row at line 150.deferredin the backlog and mirrored trigger/precondition wording in both docs.FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES
[Claude #4] Stage 4 test-verify — IMP-26 u1 (documentation-only deferral)
📌 Verification summary
■ scope
■ diff verification (PASS)
git diff --name-only→docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.mddocs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.mdgit diff --stat→2 files changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-)src/*untouched: html_generator.py, mdx_normalizer.py, section_parser.py, content_verifier.py, pipeline.py — all clean).■ content verification (PASS)
pending→deferred✓Phase R' cleanup axis 활성 시→Phase R' archive trigger AND §2.1/§2.2 SoT signature unification (both preconditions required to keep guardrail = code-removal-only)✓statuscolumn — onlycandidate ID / 출처 / cleanup 대상 / trigger axis. Status transition lives only in BACKLOG row, as designed.■ baseline test (PASS)
python -m pytest -q tests→342 passed in 41.00s.■ guardrail verification (PASS)
■ regression check (PASS)
git statusare pre-existing (.orchestrator/,tests/matching/*,samples/, etc.) — unrelated to this commit scope.■ verdict
a71355e(pre-commit); Stage 5 will produce the commit sha for this doc-only change.=== EVIDENCE ===
commands_run:
git diff --stat docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md→2 files changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-).git diff --name-only→ exactly the two planned doc files; nosrc/entries.git diff docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md→ confirmed statuspending → deferredand trigger axis wording on both rows; no other column touched.python -m pytest -q tests→342 passed in 41.00s.git status --short→ only the two plannedMentries; remaining listings are pre-existing untracked artifacts (.orchestrator/,tests/matching/*,samples/,templates/phase_z2/*,scripts/*, etc.).git rev-parse HEAD→a71355e0059caaae9d53372ba2987551998bd7b8(pre-Stage-5 baseline).files_inspected:
docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.mdline 93 — IMP-26 row post-edit content verified.docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.mdline 150 — §5 J3 row post-edit content verified; trigger column matches BACKLOG wording verbatim.facts:
source_comment_ids:
commit_sha:
[Codex #4] Stage 4 test-verify - IMP-26 u1
Verification result: PASS.
Diff scope is limited to the planned documentation-only unit:
Verified content:
Baseline test result: PASS, 342 passed in 40.81s.
=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
Files checked:
Test results:
Verified facts:
a71355e.FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES
[Claude #5] Stage 5 commit-push — IMP-26 u1
📌 commit_sha:
2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc(short2896bb6)■ scope-locked diff
docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md— IMP-26 row (line 93)docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md— §5 J3 row (line 150)2 files changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-)Phase R' cleanup axis 활성 시→Phase R' archive trigger AND §2.1/§2.2 SoT signature unification (both preconditions required to keep guardrail = code-removal-only); statuspending→deferred. All other columns preserved.src/*, no test, no other doc touched.■ commit message
(Recent
docs(#NN): ...style preserved — cf.a71355e/b1897c0/447e702.)■ push verification
git push slide2 main→a71355e..2896bb6 main -> main(GiteaKyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2).git push origin main→a71355e..2896bb6 main -> main(GitHubkeimin86/design_agent).git ls-remote slide2 main→2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc.git ls-remote origin main→2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc.git rev-parse HEAD=2896bb6...matches both remote tips.■ scope-lock invariants held
git addinvoked with explicit file paths (RULE 6) — no-A/-u/..src/*(html_generator.py,mdx_normalizer.py,section_parser.py,content_verifier.py,pipeline.py), tests — all untouched.--no-verify, no force push, no amend, no hook bypass..orchestrator/,tests/matching/*,samples/uploads/, ...) acknowledged Stage 4 + remain out of Stage 5 commit scope.■ 다음 단계
Stage 6 (final-close) — Gitea issue #26 close as deferred (re-evaluation gated on dual precondition: Phase R' archive trigger + §2.1/§2.2 SoT signature unification). No follow-up issue draft required; IMP-26 itself is the carrier row with explicit unblock conditions.
=== EVIDENCE ===
git status --short docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md→ bothM(modified, unstaged) pre-add.git diff -- docs/architecture/...→ exactly the two row-level changes described above; LF→CRLF working-copy notice only (no behavior impact).git add docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md(explicit paths only).git diff --staged --stat→2 files changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-).git status --shortpost-add → both filesM(staged); all other entries are pre-existing untracked (no source files among them).git commit -m ...→[main 2896bb6] docs(#26): IMP-26 J3 status pending->deferred + dual-precondition trigger,2 files changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-).git log -1 --format="%H %s"→2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc docs(#26): IMP-26 J3 status pending->deferred + dual-precondition trigger.git push slide2 main→a71355e..2896bb6 main -> main.git push origin main→a71355e..2896bb6 main -> main.git ls-remote slide2 main→2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc.git ls-remote origin main→2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc.python -m pytest -q tests= 342 passed (Claude 41.00s / Codex 40.81s); doc-only diff requires no further regression run for push step.[Codex #5] Stage 5 commit-push verification - IMP-26 u1
Stage 5 verification result: PASS.
I verified the pushed commit and commit scope for IMP-26 u1. Local HEAD is
2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc, and both remote branch tips checked bygit ls-remotematch that exact SHA:slide2 refs/heads/main=2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabcorigin refs/heads/main=2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabcThe commit contains only the intended documentation files:
docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.mddocs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.mdCommit stat is
2 files changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-). Nosrc/*, tests, pipeline files, helper code, or unrelated documentation files are included in the commit. The worktree still has pre-existing untracked files, but they are not part of this commit.The committed content matches the Stage 4 contract:
deferred.Phase R' archive trigger AND section 2.1/2.2 SoT signature unification (both preconditions required to keep guardrail = code-removal-only).No tests were run in Stage 5 because the current stage task is commit and remote verification, and the prompt explicitly says not to run full pytest unless the current stage requires it.
=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git rev-parse HEADgit log -1 --pretty=format:'%H%n%s%n%b'git diff-tree --no-commit-id --name-status -r HEADgit diff-tree --stat --no-commit-id -r HEADgit remote -vgit ls-remote slide2 refs/heads/maingit ls-remote origin refs/heads/maingit status --shortgit show --stat --oneline --decorate --no-renames HEADrg -n "IMP-26|Phase R' archive trigger|SoT signature unification|deferred" docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.mdFiles checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\docs\architecture\PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\docs\architecture\PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.mdTest results:
python -m pytest -q testsas342 passed, and the current stage does not require rerunning tests.Commit SHA:
2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabcVerified facts:
2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc.slide2/mainequals2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc.origin/mainequals2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc.docs(#26): IMP-26 J3 status pending->deferred + dual-precondition trigger.docs/architecture.2 files changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-).deferred.FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES
[Claude #6] Stage 6 final-close round #1 — IMP-26 J3 deferral
📌 goal vs result
normalize_mdx/_slice_mdx_sections/_get_definitions/_get_conclusion) 중복 제거 (Phase R' 영역, 코드 제거만)pending→deferred문서화만 수행**trigger axis**: Phase R' cleanup axis 활성 시가 미충족이므로 실행 보류가 정답Phase R' archive trigger AND §2.1/§2.2 SoT signature unification (both preconditions)로 강화되어 향후 unblock 시점에도 code-removal-only 유지docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.mdline 93 +docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.mdline 150 verbatim mirror (anchor sync rule).src/*/ test / 기타 문서 무손상.📌 commit verification (origin + slide2)
2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabcrefs/heads/main2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabcrefs/heads/main2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabcdocs(#26): IMP-26 J3 status pending->deferred + dual-precondition trigger2 files changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-)docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md,docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md📌 content sanity (post-push)
... | Phase R' archive trigger AND §2.1/§2.2 SoT signature unification (both preconditions required to keep guardrail = code-removal-only) | deferred |📌 follow-up links (unblock conditions)
IMP-26 가 다시 실행 axis 로 올라오려면 두 사전조건이 동시에 만족 되어야 한다 :
html_generator.pyarchive trigger — Phase R' Type A AI-HTML path 폐기. 현재src/pipeline.pyStage 2 dispatch +src/content_verifier.py:535external import 가 살아있어 본 모듈을 archive 할 수 없음.src/mdx_normalizer.normalize_mdx_content(raw)→dict(line 393438) +45) 시그니처가src/section_parser.section_parser(list[dict])→major-section dict(line 23html_generator.normalize_mdx(raw)→str/_slice_mdx_sections(raw)→dict[str,str]와 drop-in 호환되지 않음. 통합 작업이 선행되어야 helper 삭제가 "코드 제거만" 으로 끝남.이 두 axis 는 각각 별도 issue (혹은 milestone) 로 트래킹되어야 하며, 본 IMP-26 의 후속 트리거는 둘 다 PASS 된 시점에만 fire 한다.
📌 labels + state recommendation
현재 상태:
openneeds-codex-review(Stage 1~5 review loop 잔여)B-4 §4 cleanup (3)(#92) — 유지 (해당 cleanup 묶음 내 deferred 상태 row)권고 (실행은 사용자 GO 신호 후) :
open유지 — 작업 완료가 아닌 deferral 이므로 close 불가. close 는 trigger 두 사전조건 모두 만족 + 실제 helper 4종 삭제 + 검증 완료 시점.needs-codex-review— Stage 15 deferral 결정의 Codex review (Codex #1#5 5회 PASS) 가 모두 끝났으므로 더 이상 review 대기 아님.blocked— IMP-26 은 위 두 사전조건이 풀릴 때까지 실행 불가 (deferred = blocked 의미와 일치, repo 의 기존 label vocabulary 범위 내).B-4 §4 cleanup (3)유지 — issue 자체가 cleanup 묶음에서 빠지는 것이 아니라 일정만 미루어지므로 milestone 잔류.📌 close decision
NOT CLOSE — 아래 두 사전조건이 모두 PASS 되고 helper 4종 실제 삭제가 완료된 시점에만 close 가능 :
html_generator.py모듈 archive)📌 guardrails (final)
IMP-26 trigger axis precondition한 개만, 다른 axis 무관)=== EVIDENCE ===
commands run (Stage 6 only — Stage 1~5 evidence in earlier exit reports) :
git rev-parse HEAD→2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabcgit log -1 --pretty=format:'%H%n%s%n%b' HEAD→ matches commit message abovegit ls-remote origin refs/heads/main→2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabcgit ls-remote slide2 refs/heads/main→2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabcgit show --stat --no-renames 2896bb6→ 2 files changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-)git diff-tree --no-commit-id --name-status -r 2896bb6→M docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md+M docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.mddeferred+ dual-precondition trigger axis content/repos/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/26→ stateopen, labels[needs-codex-review], milestoneB-4 §4 cleanup (3)/repos/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/labels→ vocabulary ={blocked, closed, implemented, needs-claude-review, needs-codex-review, ready-for-implementation, scope-locked, verified}—deferred라벨 없음 →blocked권고source_comment_ids :
commit_sha:
2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabcunresolved_questions: none for Stage 6.
next-step recommendation : 없음 (one-step-per-turn). 사용자 GO 후 label 갱신 (
needs-codex-reviewremove /blockedadd) 만 수행 권고.[Codex #6] Stage 6 final-close review - IMP-26 J3 deferral
Final independent verification result: PASS. The Stage 1-5 outcome is consistent with the issue guardrails: IMP-26 was not implemented as helper deletion because the Phase R' archive trigger and SoT signature unification preconditions are not both satisfied; instead, the deferral decision was recorded in the two authoritative documentation rows.
Verification summary:
2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabcwith commit messagedocs(#26): IMP-26 J3 status pending->deferred + dual-precondition trigger.origin/mainandslide2/mainare2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc.docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.mdanddocs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md.2 files changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-).src/*diff is empty, so no runtime, helper, pipeline, verifier, normalizer, parser, or test code was touched.deferredand uses trigger wording:Phase R' archive trigger AND �2.1/�2.2 SoT signature unification (both preconditions required to keep guardrail = code-removal-only).needs-codex-reviewand milestoneB-4 �4 cleanup (3), so this comment is the close-OK signal rather than an untracked state change.Close recommendation: OK to close Issue #26 for this cycle. The implemented outcome is a documented deferral, not code deletion, and that matches the verified precondition failure and the code-removal-only guardrail.
=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git rev-parse HEADgit log -1 --pretty=format:"%H%n%s"git diff-tree --no-commit-id --name-status -r HEADgit diff-tree --stat --no-commit-id -r HEADgit ls-remote slide2 refs/heads/maingit ls-remote origin refs/heads/maingit diff --name-only -- srcrg -n "IMP-26|Phase R' archive trigger|SoT signature unification|deferred" docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.mdInvoke-RestMethod https://gitea.hmac.kr/api/v1/repos/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/26Files checked:
docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.mddocs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.mdsrcdiff scopeCommit SHA:
2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabcVerified facts:
origin/main, andslide2/mainall match commit2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc.2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-).src/*files have a diff.deferred.needs-codex-reviewand milestoneB-4 �4 cleanup (3).FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES