[INTEGRATION-AUDIT-03][검토결과] Claude Code — closed 이슈 deliverable 정합성 검수 (post-#56) #59
Reference in New Issue
Block a user
Delete Branch "%!s()"
Deleting a branch is permanent. Although the deleted branch may continue to exist for a short time before it actually gets removed, it CANNOT be undone in most cases. Continue?
[INTEGRATION-AUDIT-03][검토결과] Claude Code — closed 이슈 deliverable 정합성 검수 (post-#56)
Audit anchor (cite at start of every stage)
This audit verifies closed issues' actual deliverables against their stated scope. It does not implement runtime code. It does not optimize any single MDX sample.
Purpose
#56 INTEGRATION-AUDIT-02 closed at 2026-05-20. Between #56 close and current execution (#39~#42 batch in progress), 11+ issues have been closed. The user explicitly requested a deliverable-vs-scope review of these closed issues — confirming the work performed matches the issue body intent, with no scope creep / regression / harm to the 22-step Phase Z pipeline / unintended AI activation.
This is a verification/report-only issue. Expected output is a deliverable-audit report and follow-up issue recommendations. No production code changes.
Sources (read-only inputs)
git show --statfor each closed issue commitdocs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md(issue body scope columns)src/phase_z2_pipeline.py,src/phase_z2_mapper.py,src/phase_z2_classifier.py,src/phase_z2_composition.py,src/phase_z2_verification_utils.pyAudit scope — 11 closed issues (post-#56)
#21, #22, #23, #24, #25, #26, #27, #28, #38, #57, #58.
(Out of scope for this audit: #19, #20, #50, #51~#54, #56 — already covered by #50/#56 prior cycles.)
Pre-audit empirical fact (Phase Z runtime safety check)
Grep result (read-only):
src/phase_z2_*.py, 5 modules) imports ofkei_client= 0pipeline.py(Phase Q+R'+T master) = 0MDX 03,건설산업 DX,BIM) in src/ = none introduced by post-#56 commits→ Phase Z 22-step runtime integrity = SAFE. AI/Kei persona has NOT been activated in normal path.
Issue-by-issue deliverable review
Group A — Clean (8 issues): deliverable matches stated scope
5590ef2PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md(3 lines)2ace54bPHASE-Q-AUDIT.md(2 lines)447e702PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md(2 lines)b1897c0PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md(1 line)a71355ePHASE-Q-AUDIT.md(1 line)8c1e563IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md(9 lines banner)134f52dDORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml+check_dormant_triggers.py+orchestrator.py+ test (+887 lines)b4872baFront/client/src/{components,services,types}(3 files)Group B — Direction change (1 issue): legitimate but worth flagging
#26 — commit
2896bb6J3 — html_generator utility 중복 cleanup(actual code cleanup work)pending → deferred+ dual-precondition trigger documentation (no actual cleanup performed)Group C — Scope creep (2 issues): functional-impact-zero but governance signal
#27 — commit
909bf75K5 — catalog 로드 + _get_block_by_id 중복 cleanupin §2.10 + §2.8 (3 modules: block_reference, block_selector, renderer)src/block_reference.py,src/block_selector.py,src/renderer.py✓ (within scope)src/catalog.py(76 lines, shared loader extraction) ⚠️tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py(421 lines) ⚠️catalog.py), which was not explicitly authorized in the issue body's "3 module" scope statement.catalog.py(verified). No regression introduced.#28 — commit
265d70eL4 — _parse_json 중복 cleanupin §2.11 + §2.6 + §2.9 (3 modules: pipeline, content_editor, html_generator)src/content_editor.py✓ (§2.6),src/pipeline.py✓ (§2.11)src/html_generator.pyNOT touched (was in stated scope but no_parse_jsonto dedup, presumably)src/json_utils.py(46 lines, shared utility) — same DRY pattern as #27src/design_director.py(-38 lines) ⚠️src/kei_client.py(-37 lines) ⚠️tests/test_json_utils.py(55 lines)kei_clientordesign_director(verified by grep).Findings classification
🟢 OK — deliverable matches scope
#21, #22, #23, #24, #25, #38, #57, #58 (8 issues)
🟡 Warning — direction change but justifiable
#26 — deferred instead of executed. Requires #58 DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml registration confirmation.
🟡 Warning — scope creep, functional-impact zero
#27 — added
src/catalog.py+ test (legitimate DRY, beyond stated scope)#28 — added
kei_client.py+design_director.pytouches (dedup only, beyond stated scope)❌ Blocker — none found
Phase Z 22-step pipeline integrity verdict
SAFE. No closed issue post-#56 has:
phase_z2_pipeline.py,phase_z2_mapper.py,phase_z2_classifier.py,phase_z2_composition.py) outside intended scopeThe 22-step pipeline continues to function as designed. Current batch (#39~#42) may proceed without halt.
Recommended follow-up issues (NOT auto-posted)
F-1 — Verify #26 registered in DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml
docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml(created by #58)F-2 — COMPACT_PLAN_RULE scope-lock hardening (future patch candidate)
F-3 — Backlog update for #27/#28 actual surface
PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.mdrows for #27/#28 still list stated scope, not actual surfaceOutput artifacts (Stage 3 deliverables)
Required:
docs/architecture/INTEGRATION-AUDIT-03-REPORT.md— full deliverable review reportAllowed updates:
docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md— for any backlog row corrections (F-3)docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml— for #26 dormant registration (F-1)Stage 3 directive (CRITICAL — audit-only mode)
This issue is audit/review/report-only.
Forbidden:
src/**,templates/**,tests/**modificationsAllowed:
docs/architecture/INTEGRATION-AUDIT-03-REPORT.md(main deliverable, created)docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md(status corrections per audit findings only)docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml(F-1 entry if found missing)If a blocker or runtime gap is discovered, propose a follow-up issue in the report — do NOT modify production code here.
Orchestrator runs in audit-only mode (P4/P4a) for this issue.
Acceptance Criteria
src/**,templates/**,tests/**) changesBody size budget
Each stage's Gitea comment body ≤ 8000 chars. Large evidence (full diffs, grep output, etc.) goes into
INTEGRATION-AUDIT-03-REPORT.md.Stage 2 IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS guidance
Stage 2 plan MUST produce IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS with non-empty
testsfield per unit.Expected units (Claude/Codex may refine):
phase_z_runtime_safety_recheck— tests: ["grep results in report: kei_client/pipeline/legacy imports = 0 from phase_z2_* modules"]per_issue_deliverable_vs_scope_table— tests: ["11 issues × (commit SHA, files changed, stated scope, verdict) table"]scope_creep_classification— tests: ["#27 / #28 scope creep details with risk assessment"]dormant_registry_check_for_#26— tests: ["DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml contains #26 entry OR follow-up issue draft included"]audit_report_assembly— tests: ["docs/architecture/INTEGRATION-AUDIT-03-REPORT.mdwritten with all sections"]followup_recommendation_list— tests: ["F-1, F-2, F-3 follow-up draft text written; not auto-posted"]Sequence note
This audit covers post-#56 closed issues. Current batch (#39~#42) execution may continue in parallel — this audit does not block them. Findings should be incorporated into the next cycle (after batch completes), not retroactively interrupt current work.
변화될 것 없음. 검증 완