[P5][DORMANT-TRIGGER-GUARD] Add dormant trigger registry and orchestrator gate #58
Assignees
Kyeongmin (이경민)
Clear assignees
Kyeongmin (이경민)
No Assignees
Notifications
Due Date
No due date set.
Dependencies
No dependencies set.
Reference: Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2#58
Reference in New Issue
Block a user
[P5][DORMANT-TRIGGER-GUARD] Add dormant trigger registry and orchestrator gate
Source
docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md§ "자주 헷갈리는 anti-patterns" — "문서에 박힌 dormant 항목은 자동 실행 안 됨"Problem
Closed issues with status
documented,documented:dormant, ordocumented (deferred)carry implicit contracts — "when condition X arises, take action Y". Currently:Concrete dormant items (post-#56):
src/for new reverse-path adapter moduletemplates/phase_z2/This issue (#58) builds the L3 layer — machine-readable registry + automated detection.
Scope (P5-1 ~ P5-4)
P5-1 — DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml registry
New file:
docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yamlSchema (each entry):
Initial entries: #16, #17, #18, #19 (4 dormant) + #20 followup-linked (note only, no trigger watch since #55 tracks).
P5-2 — scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py
New script:
docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yamlgit status --porcelain(working tree) andgit diff HEAD~1..HEAD --name-only(recent commit)file_patterns+content_patternsagainst changed files.orchestrator/dormant_alerts.json+ prints warningP5-3 — orchestrator.py integration
Add to
run_stagebetween Stage 4 PASS and Stage 5 entry:check_dormant_triggers.pyagainst the staged commitP5-4 — Tests
tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py— yaml parsing, trigger matching, false-positive guardsOut of scope
Acceptance Criteria
docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yamlcreated with 4 dormant entries + 1 followup-linked note.scripts/check_dormant_triggers.pyrunnable standalone (python scripts/check_dormant_triggers.pyfrom repo root).orchestrator.pyStage 4→5 transition calls the check for non-audit-only issues.tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py≥ 8 cases pass.pytest -q teststotal = previous count + new test cases, all pass.Stage 2 IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS guidance
Each unit's
tests:field MUST be non-empty.Suggested units:
dormant_triggers_yaml— files:[docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml], tests:["yaml parses with PyYAML", "4 dormant entries + 1 followup-linked"]check_script— files:[scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py], tests:["standalone python invocation works", "alert file written when match", "no false positive on clean tree"]orchestrator_integration— files:[orchestrator.py], tests:["Stage 4→5 transition calls check for non-audit issues", "audit-only issues bypass the check"]tests_dormant_triggers— files:[tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py], tests:["≥ 8 test cases pass", "yaml fixture covers all 4 dormants"]docs_update— files:[docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md, docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml (header comment)], tests:["governance doc references registry", "registry has header explaining schema"]Body size budget
Each stage's Gitea comment body ≤ 8000 chars. Large content (yaml fixtures, check script logic) goes into actual files, not Gitea comments.
Dependencies
Sequence note
This is a regular implementation issue (NOT audit-only). orchestrator P4/P4a guards do not apply. Normal Stage 1~6 flow.
[Claude #1] Stage 1 — Problem review for #58 [P5][DORMANT-TRIGGER-GUARD]
1. Root cause
Closed-but-still-binding dormant items (
documented:dormant/documented (deferred)/documented) hold implicit trigger contracts — "when X happens, take Y". Three detection layers exist conceptually: (L1) human memory — fragile; (L2) periodic INTEGRATION-AUDIT — late; (L3) machine-readable registry + automated check — absent today. #58 builds L3.Concrete dormant population (post-#56, verified against
docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md):documented:dormantdocumented (deferred)documenteddocumenteddocumented(followup-linked to open #55)IMP-07 (L51
documented:no-runtime) is out of scope — policy decline, reactivation = reopening separate policy issue, not a code-change trigger. Issue body confirms: "Initial entries: #16, #17, #18, #19 + #20 followup-linked".2. Scope-lock (5 implementation units, binding)
docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yamlscripts/check_dormant_triggers.pyorchestrator.py— add_check_dormant_triggers()helper + new branch inrun_stageparallel to P4a (orchestrator.py:1406–1431 = model)tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py(≥ 8 cases)docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md(single reference line near §8 anti-patterns row "문서에 박힌 dormant 항목 자동 실행 안 됨"); CREATE header comment in u1 yamlInitial registry entries (u1): 4 active dormants (#16/#17/#18/#19) + 1 followup-linked note (#20). Each entry's content_patterns/file_patterns sourced from the dormant's reference doc, NOT from this issue:
src/**/*.py; content_patterns=html_to_slide_mdx|edited_html_to_mdx|reverse_path|html-to-mdx(per IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md L24); manual_evidence_required=false.templates/phase_z2/families/*.html|templates/phase_z2/frames/*.html; content_patterns=<svg|viewBox(per IMP-18-SVG-GAP-REPORT.md L32 evidence command); manual_evidence_required=false.trigger.action=manual_review/ no file watch — note-only, since #55 already tracks.3. Guardrails (binding)
_audit_mode(title)is True → skip the dormant check entirely (audit issues never carry production-code commits per P4/P4a)..orchestrator/issues/<n>_dormant_alerts_posted.json(mirrorsaudit_baseline_<n>.jsonpattern at orchestrator.py:766–768). Stage-replay (NO retry) MUST NOT re-post the same alert._check_audit_only_violationsfail-open at orchestrator.py test_git_error_fails_open / test_subprocess_exception_fails_open.)src/**/templates/**/tests/**/ docs / orchestrator regions.git add -A/git add .forbidden (RULE 6).<svg|viewBox,html_to_slide_mdx|reverse_path).4. Orchestrator integration point (u3)
Insertion model =
_check_audit_commit_scope()at orchestrator.py:1406–1431 (Stage 5 commit-push branch).Design:
_check_dormant_triggers(issue_num)→ returns list of alert dicts ({issue, trigger_description, matched_files, on_trigger}).run_stageatsid == "commit-push"ANDnot _audit_mode(title), executed on the first entry into Stage 5 for the issue (state-flag idempotent), BEFORE the agent's commit-push action.gitea()helper, body explicitly says "advisory — Stage 5 not blocked". Agent may choose to acknowledge or create a follow-up issue, but the loop proceeds.scripts/check_dormant_triggers.pyis 0 always (informational).5. Open questions deferred to Stage 2 plan
_check_dormant_triggers()should read fromgit status --porcelainonly, or alsogit diff HEAD~1..HEAD --name-only(issue body suggests both — Stage 2 will lock).subprocess.run(mirrors test_audit_mode.py) or uses atmp_pathgit repo fixture — Stage 2 will choose.6. Verdict
Stage 1 produces a coherent scope-lock + guardrails. Dependency #56 closed (commits
101143e+8c1e563in main; INTEGRATION-AUDIT-02 backlog L51/L67 patch is live). PyYAML 6.0.2 available (registry parseable). Existing P4a pattern is reusable. No hidden cross-axis surprises detected.=== EVIDENCE ===
Files read
docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md:51,67–71— confirmed status tokens for IMP-07/16/17/18/19/20.docs/architecture/INTEGRATION-AUDIT-02-REPORT.md— confirmed §3/§4/§7 mapping for IMP-07/IMP-16 statuses (final decisionNEEDS_DOC_SYNC_FOLLOWUP).docs/architecture/IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md:24— content pattern sourcehtml_to_slide_mdx | edited_html_to_mdx | reverse_path.docs/architecture/IMP-18-SVG-GAP-REPORT.md:32— content pattern source<svg|viewBoxfortemplates/phase_z2/.docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md:140–181— confirmed §8 anti-patterns row context for u5 reference.orchestrator.py:497–500, 713–724, 1213–1273, 1406–1431— verified VERIFY_STAGES tuple, STAGES list, run_stage entry, P4a guard model.tests/orchestrator_unit/test_audit_mode.py:117–201— verified monkeypatch + fail-open patterns to mirror in u4.Commands run
wc -l orchestrator.py→ 1709 lines (no schema split).pip list | grep -i pyyaml→PyYAML 6.0.2(u1/u2 dependency satisfied).git log(HEAD) →8c1e563 docs(#57)…,101143e docs(#56)…(dependency #56 closed and merged to main).Constraints verified
_audit_mode) exists and can be reused for u3 bypass..orchestrator/issues/per-issue state pattern confirmed (mirrorsaudit_baseline_<n>.json).rewind_target: N/A
FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES
[Codex #1] Stage 1 problem review for #58 [P5][DORMANT-TRIGGER-GUARD]
I verified the root cause and scope lock against the repository. I agree with the Stage 1 scope: #58 is a regular implementation issue, not audit-only, and the missing L3 layer is real. There is no
docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml, noscripts/check_dormant_triggers.py, and notests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.pytoday.Root cause verified:
docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md:67-71.documented:dormantand hard-linked to IMP-07 activation.documented (deferred)with the 3-condition activation gate indocs/architecture/IMP-17-CARVE-OUT.md:25-29.documented; its SVG activation trigger is indocs/architecture/IMP-18-SVG-GAP-REPORT.md:38-43.documented; its reactivation gate is indocs/architecture/IMP-19-ZONE-RATIO-REFERENCE.md:83-89.documented; it has a separate A5 reactivation gate indocs/architecture/IMP-20-FRAME-CONTRACT-VALIDATION-REFERENCE.md:85-91, and the issue body correctly treats it as followup-linked rather than a new watch surface.Scope-lock verified:
docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yamlas the machine-readable registry, with four active dormant watches plus one followup-linked note.scripts/check_dormant_triggers.pyas a standalone informational checker that reads the registry, scans working tree/recent commit changed files, writes.orchestrator/dormant_alerts.jsonon alert, prints warnings, and exits 0.orchestrator.pynear the current consensus/evidence gate inrun_stage. The current analogous deterministic guards are P4/P4a audit-only checks aroundorchestrator.py:1383andorchestrator.py:1406; no dormant trigger check exists there today.tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py. Existing orchestrator unit tests provide the pattern surface, especiallytests/orchestrator_unit/test_audit_mode.pyandtests/orchestrator_unit/test_orchestrator_core.py.docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md:145-155contains the anti-pattern/status governance section that should reference the registry as the single source of truth for dormant tracking.Trigger details verified or constrained:
src/**/*.pyplus the IMP-16 gate terms fromdocs/architecture/IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md:21-25:html_to_slide_mdx,edited_html_to_mdx, andreverse_path. The issue body's additionalhtml-to-mdxterm is acceptable as an alias guard, but the doc anchor itself uses the first three terms.rg "<svg|viewBox" templates/phase_z2/was the evidence scan and that reactivation starts when an SVG-bearing partial lands undertemplates/phase_z2/; using the issue body's narrowerfamilies/*.htmlandframes/*.htmlpatterns is acceptable for the initial registry.No missing blocking files or wrong assumptions found. The only caution for Stage 2 is to keep tests focused on pure matching/IO behavior and orchestrator call placement; do not make the initial implementation blocking by default, because the issue explicitly says warning-only.
=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
Get-Content -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\tmp\codex_prompt.txt'rg --filesgit status --shortrg -n "IMP-16|IMP-17|IMP-18|IMP-19|IMP-20|documented:dormant|documented \(deferred\)|DORMANT|dormant|anti-pattern|자동|auto" docs orchestrator.py scripts testsrg -n "IMP-16|IMP-17|IMP-18|IMP-19|IMP-20|documented:dormant|documented \(deferred\)|documented:no-runtime" docs\architecture\PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md docs\architecture\IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md docs\architecture\IMP-17-CARVE-OUT.md docs\architecture\IMP-18-SVG-GAP-REPORT.md docs\architecture\PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.mdrg -n "def run_stage|Stage 4|Stage 5|P4a|audit|commit-push|CONSENSUS|supplement" orchestrator.pyrg -n "_is_audit_issue|_audit_mode|run_stage|Stage 4|Stage 5" tests\orchestrator_unit\test_audit_mode.py tests\orchestrator_unit\test_orchestrator_core.pyTest-Path docs\architecture\DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml; Test-Path scripts\check_dormant_triggers.py; Test-Path tests\orchestrator_unit\test_dormant_triggers.pyrg -n "activation|trigger|reactivat|Step 8|fail|role-container|Phase O|group_blocks_by_area|ratio" docs\architecture\IMP-19-ZONE-RATIO-REFERENCE.md docs\architecture\IMP-20-FRAME-CONTRACT-VALIDATION-REFERENCE.mdorchestrator.pyFiles checked:
docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.mddocs/architecture/IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.mddocs/architecture/IMP-17-CARVE-OUT.mddocs/architecture/IMP-18-SVG-GAP-REPORT.mddocs/architecture/IMP-19-ZONE-RATIO-REFERENCE.mddocs/architecture/IMP-20-FRAME-CONTRACT-VALIDATION-REFERENCE.mddocs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.mdorchestrator.pytests/orchestrator_unit/test_audit_mode.pytests/orchestrator_unit/test_orchestrator_core.pyTest results: Not run; Stage 1 explicitly says NO pytest.
Verified facts:
FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES
📌 [Claude #1] Stage 2 r1 — #58 [P5][DORMANT-TRIGGER-GUARD]
Axis → unit map (P5-1~4 + acceptance)
docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml.orchestrator/dormant_alerts.json, exit 0scripts/check_dormant_triggers.pyorchestrator.pytests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.pydocs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md=== IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS ===
summary: DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml — 5 entries (IMP-16/17/18/19 active + IMP-20 followup-linked) + schema header comment
files: ["docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml"]
tests: ["yaml parses (PyYAML 6.0.2)", "5 entries", "each has issue/title/doc/status/trigger/on_trigger", "#20.followup_issue==55", "#17.trigger.manual_evidence_required==true"]
estimate_lines: 45
summary: Checker reads registry, scans
git status+git diff HEAD~1..HEAD, matches fnmatch(file_patterns)+re.search(content_patterns), writes alerts JSON, exit 0files: ["scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py"]
tests: ["standalone python invocation exit 0", "writes .orchestrator/dormant_alerts.json", "no false positive on clean tree", "manual_evidence entries skipped"]
estimate_lines: 45
summary: _check_dormant_triggers() helper + new branch after test-verify YES (non-audit) — posts supplement comment if alerts; never blocks
files: ["orchestrator.py"]
tests: ["test-verify→commit-push path calls check for non-audit", "audit-only bypass mirrors P4a gate", "alerts post comment but YES not blocked"]
estimate_lines: 30
summary: ≥ 8 cases (yaml parse, entry count, per-IMP entry, match pos/neg, manual_evidence skip, followup-linked, subprocess runnable)
files: ["tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py"]
tests: ["test_yaml_parses", "test_entry_count==5", "test_imp16_status_dormant", "test_imp17_manual_evidence_skipped", "test_imp18_file_pattern_positive", "test_imp19_match_positive", "test_imp20_followup_linked", "test_no_match_unrelated_file", "test_script_runnable_exit0"]
estimate_lines: 45
summary: §8 anti-pattern row "dormant 자동 실행 안 됨 → DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml + checker" + §9 reference table row to new yaml
files: ["docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md"]
tests: ["§8 table row references DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml", "§9 ref row points to docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml"]
estimate_lines: 8
Per-unit rationale
trigger/on_triggerkeeps ≤ 50 L. IMP-17 =manual_evidence_required: trueper IMP-17-CARVE-OUT.md:25-29 (3-cond gate). IMP-20 =documented:deferred+followup_issue: 55.orchestrator.py:1383P4a pattern with inverted gate. Insertion = beforereturn Trueat L1436, gatedsid=="test-verify" and not _audit_mode(title). Nocontinue— informational only.tests/orchestrator_unit/test_audit_mode.py:1-32. Direct import of_matchfromscripts.check_dormant_triggers+ subprocess for E2E.Out of scope (unchanged from Stage 1)
IMP-07 reactivation; INTEGRATION-AUDIT L2 mods; auto-create dormants; frame/SVG/zone-ratio runtime work; Stage 5 blocking; alerts JSON schema versioning (default = no version, Stage 1 Q2).
Rollback
Per-unit single-file revert (
git checkout HEAD~ -- <file>). u3 is the only behavior change; reverting disables L3 watch but keeps registry + checker manually runnable.=== EVIDENCE ===
Absent (re-checked):
docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml— ls exit 2scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py— ls exit 2tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py— ls exit 2Anchors verified this round:
orchestrator.py:1380-1438— P4a pattern +return Trueat L1436. Insertion point gatedsid=="test-verify" and not _audit_mode(title).docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md:149-176— §8 table L149-159, §9 ref table L163-175. Append targets confirmed.tests/orchestrator_unit/test_audit_mode.py:1-32— pattern model verified.docs/architecture/IMP-17-CARVE-OUT.md:25-29— 3-cond AND gate confirmed.python -c "import yaml; print(yaml.__version__)"→PyYAML 6.0.2. No new dep.Atomicity (≤ 50 L AND ≤ 3 files):
u1=45 / u2=45 / u3=30 / u4=45 / u5=8 — all ≤ 50 ✓
1 file each ✓
Stage 1 scope-lock honored: exactly 5 units = 5 locked files, 1:1.
FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES
[Codex #2] Stage 2 plan review for #58 [P5][DORMANT-TRIGGER-GUARD]
Plan coverage is complete, but the posted Stage 2 plan does not satisfy the strict compact-plan body format.
Blocking issue:
=== IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS ===. The current-stage instructions say the Stage 2 plan body must contain only the implementation units block, brief per-unit rationale, out-of-scope notes, rollback strategy, evidence block, and final consensus marker.Non-blocking verification:
testsfield.docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml,scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py,orchestrator.py,tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py, anddocs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
Get-Content -LiteralPath D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\tmp\codex_prompt.txtgit status --shortgit rev-parse HEADrg -n "IMP-16|IMP-17|IMP-18|IMP-19|IMP-20|documented:dormant|documented" docs\architecture\PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md docs\architecture\IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md docs\architecture\IMP-17-CARVE-OUT.md docs\architecture\IMP-18-SVG-GAP-REPORT.md docs\architecture\IMP-19-ZONE-RATIO-REFERENCE.md docs\architecture\IMP-20-FRAME-CONTRACT-VALIDATION-REFERENCE.mdrg -n "P4|P4a|audit|run_stage|test-verify|commit-push|def run_stage|post.*comment|supplement" orchestrator.pyGet-Content -LiteralPath tests\orchestrator_unit\test_audit_mode.py -TotalCount 260Test-Pathchecks fordocs\architecture\DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml,scripts\check_dormant_triggers.py,tests\orchestrator_unit\test_dormant_triggers.pypytest -q testspython -c "import yaml; print(yaml.__version__)"orchestrator.py:1380-1436anddocs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md:149-176Files checked:
docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.mddocs/architecture/IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.mddocs/architecture/IMP-17-CARVE-OUT.mddocs/architecture/IMP-18-SVG-GAP-REPORT.mddocs/architecture/IMP-19-ZONE-RATIO-REFERENCE.mddocs/architecture/IMP-20-FRAME-CONTRACT-VALIDATION-REFERENCE.mddocs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.mdorchestrator.pytests/orchestrator_unit/test_audit_mode.pyTest results:
pytest -q tests-> 307 passed in 40.45s.Verified facts:
PyYAMLversion is 6.0.2.docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml,scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py, andtests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.pyare absent, as expected before implementation.8c1e56366b667d7d7d139ff831a16ef455caf2a2.rewind_target: stage_2_plan
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #2] Stage 2 compact plan for #58 [P5][DORMANT-TRIGGER-GUARD] — rewind retry per Codex #2 strict-format ruling. Prior "Axis → unit map" table removed; body now contains only the six required sections.
=== IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS ===
summary: Create docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml — 4 active dormants (IMP-16/17/18/19) + 1 followup-linked (IMP-20 → #55) + schema header comment.
files: [docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml]
tests: [test_yaml_parses_with_pyyaml, test_registry_has_5_entries_4_active_plus_1_followup]
estimate_lines: 45
summary: Create scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py — read registry, scan working tree + HEAD~1..HEAD diff, write .orchestrator/dormant_alerts.json on match, exit 0 always.
files: [scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py]
tests: [test_check_script_clean_tree_no_alerts, test_check_script_writes_alerts_on_match, test_check_script_skips_manual_evidence_entries]
estimate_lines: 50
summary: Add _check_dormant_triggers() helper + Stage 4→5 transition branch in orchestrator.py — skips audit-only; informational supplement comment on alert; never blocks Stage 5.
files: [orchestrator.py]
tests: [test_orchestrator_invokes_checker_on_non_audit, test_orchestrator_skips_checker_on_audit_only]
estimate_lines: 45
summary: Create tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py with ≥ 8 cases covering yaml schema, registry contents, checker matching, false-positive guards, manual-evidence skip, orchestrator branch, audit bypass, governance ref.
files: [tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py]
tests: [self — ≥ 8 cases per Acceptance Criteria; each test names which IMP-# trigger it exercises]
estimate_lines: 50
summary: Append single reference line to docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md §8 row "문서에 박힌 dormant 항목 자동 실행 안 됨" pointing to DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml as the L3 registry.
files: [docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md]
tests: [test_governance_doc_references_registry]
estimate_lines: 5
(per-unit rationale)
u1 — Single source of truth in repo. Header comment satisfies Acceptance "registry has header explaining schema". 5 rows = final dormant population from #50/#56.
u2 — Standalone runnable per Acceptance. Exit 0 enforces informational-only guardrail. manual_evidence_required entries skip auto-fire (IMP-17 User-GO stays human-driven).
u3 — Mirror P4a placement (orchestrator.py:1383, 1406–1431) — stage-gated, not per-call. Alerts → supplement comment only, never blocks. Resolves Q1 with mirror-P4a default.
u4 — ≥ 8 cases per Acceptance. Pattern model = tests/orchestrator_unit/test_audit_mode.py. Per-test IMP-# naming → scope-qualified verification.
u5 — One-line cross-reference closes Acceptance "governance doc references registry". Schema explanation lives in u1's yaml header (avoids governance doc churn).
(out-of-scope)
(rollback)
Revert u1–u5 file creations + the orchestrator.py block (deterministic deletion); no schema or runtime-contract changes elsewhere, so rollback =
git reset --hard HEAD~Nover u1–u5 commits with no side effects.=== EVIDENCE ===
Round-2 commands:
8c1e56366b(matches Stage 1 commit_sha)Stage 1 binding references reused (paths/line ranges already in Exit Report — not re-fetched):
IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md:24, IMP-17-CARVE-OUT.md:25-29, IMP-18-SVG-GAP-REPORT.md:38-43, IMP-19-ZONE-RATIO-REFERENCE.md:83-89, IMP-20-FRAME-CONTRACT-VALIDATION-REFERENCE.md:85-91, PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md:67-71.
Rewind-fix delta: removed prior "Axis → unit map" table per Codex #2. Body now contains exactly the six allowed sections (IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS YAML, per-unit rationale, out-of-scope, rollback, evidence, FINAL_CONSENSUS) — no other prose, no code snippets.
Scope-lock reaffirmed: exactly u1–u5; no other file touched; initial registry = IMP-16/17/18/19 (active) + IMP-20 (followup-linked, references open #55).
FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES
[Codex #3] Stage 2 plan review for #58 [P5][DORMANT-TRIGGER-GUARD]
Blocking issue:
=== IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS ===:[Claude #2] Stage 2 compact plan for #58 .... The current-stage requirement says the plan body must contain only the implementation units block, brief per-unit rationale, out-of-scope notes, rollback strategy, evidence block, and final consensus marker. Because this is the same strict-format class of failure as the previous rewind, the plan needs one more retry with the body starting at=== IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS ===.Non-blocking verification:
testsfield.estimate_linesvalues are 45, 50, 45, 50, and 5, so every unit is within the <= 50 lines limit.docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml,scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py,orchestrator.py,tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py, anddocs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
Get-Content -LiteralPath D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\tmp\codex_prompt.txtgit status --shortgit rev-parse HEADrg --files docs\architecture scripts tests\orchestrator_unit | rg "(DORMANT-TRIGGERS\.yaml|check_dormant_triggers\.py|test_dormant_triggers\.py|PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE\.md|test_audit_mode\.py)$"rg -n "IMP-16|IMP-17|IMP-18|IMP-19|IMP-20|documented:dormant|documented:no-runtime|P4a|audit-only|PROJECT-INTENT|dormant" docs\architecture\PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md docs\architecture\IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md docs\architecture\IMP-17-CARVE-OUT.md docs\architecture\IMP-18-SVG-GAP-REPORT.md docs\architecture\IMP-19-ZONE-RATIO-REFERENCE.md docs\architecture\IMP-20-FRAME-CONTRACT-VALIDATION-REFERENCE.md orchestrator.py tests\orchestrator_unit\test_audit_mode.pypytest -q testsInvoke-RestMethod .../issues/58/comments?page=1&limit=50and latest-comment body inspectionestimate_lines,files,=== IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS ===, first line, final line, and body lengthFiles checked:
docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.mddocs/architecture/IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.mddocs/architecture/IMP-17-CARVE-OUT.mddocs/architecture/IMP-18-SVG-GAP-REPORT.mddocs/architecture/IMP-19-ZONE-RATIO-REFERENCE.mddocs/architecture/IMP-20-FRAME-CONTRACT-VALIDATION-REFERENCE.mddocs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.mdorchestrator.pytests/orchestrator_unit/test_audit_mode.pyTest results:
pytest -q tests: 307 passed in 40.46sVerified facts:
8c1e56366b667d7d7d139ff831a16ef455caf2a2, matching the Stage 1 exit report.=== IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS ===exists and final line isFINAL_CONSENSUS: YES.45,50,45,50,5; all are <= 50.1,1,1,1,1; all are <= 3.DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml,check_dormant_triggers.py, andtest_dormant_triggers.pyare absent, consistent with Stage 2 planning and creation in Stage 3.orchestrator.py:1383andorchestrator.py:1406confirm the existing audit-only/P4a gate pattern that u3 plans to mirror.=== IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS ===, so it does not satisfy the strict compact-plan body format.rewind_target: stage_2_plan
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
=== IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS ===
summary: Create docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml — 4 active dormants (IMP-16/17/18/19) + 1 followup-linked (IMP-20 → #55) + schema header comment.
files: [docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml]
tests: [test_yaml_parses_with_pyyaml, test_registry_has_5_entries_4_active_plus_1_followup]
estimate_lines: 45
summary: Create scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py — read registry, scan working tree + HEAD~1..HEAD diff, write .orchestrator/dormant_alerts.json on match, exit 0 always.
files: [scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py]
tests: [test_check_script_clean_tree_no_alerts, test_check_script_writes_alerts_on_match, test_check_script_skips_manual_evidence_entries]
estimate_lines: 50
summary: Add _check_dormant_triggers() helper + Stage 4→5 transition branch in orchestrator.py — skips audit-only; informational supplement comment on alert; never blocks Stage 5.
files: [orchestrator.py]
tests: [test_orchestrator_invokes_checker_on_non_audit, test_orchestrator_skips_checker_on_audit_only]
estimate_lines: 45
summary: Create tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py with ≥ 8 cases covering yaml schema, registry contents, checker matching, false-positive guards, manual-evidence skip, orchestrator branch, audit bypass, governance ref.
files: [tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py]
tests: [self — ≥ 8 cases per Acceptance Criteria; each test names which IMP-# trigger it exercises]
estimate_lines: 50
summary: Append single reference line to docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md §8 row "문서에 박힌 dormant 항목 자동 실행 안 됨" pointing to DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml as the L3 registry.
files: [docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md]
tests: [test_governance_doc_references_registry]
estimate_lines: 5
(per-unit rationale)
u1 — Single source of truth in repo. Header comment satisfies Acceptance "registry has header explaining schema". 5 rows = final dormant population from #50/#56.
u2 — Standalone runnable per Acceptance. Exit 0 enforces informational-only guardrail. manual_evidence_required entries skip auto-fire (IMP-17 User-GO stays human-driven).
u3 — Mirror P4a placement (orchestrator.py:1383, 1406–1431) — stage-gated, not per-call. Alerts → supplement comment only, never blocks. Resolves Q1 with mirror-P4a default.
u4 — ≥ 8 cases per Acceptance. Pattern model = tests/orchestrator_unit/test_audit_mode.py. Per-test IMP-# naming → scope-qualified verification.
u5 — One-line cross-reference closes Acceptance "governance doc references registry". Schema explanation lives in u1's yaml header (avoids governance doc churn).
(out-of-scope)
(rollback)
Revert u1–u5 file creations + the orchestrator.py block (deterministic deletion); no schema or runtime-contract changes elsewhere, so rollback =
git reset --hard HEAD~Nover u1–u5 commits with no side effects.=== EVIDENCE ===
Round-3 commands (rewind retry per Codex #3 strict-format ruling — leading prose line removed; body now begins at === IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS ===):
8c1e56366b(matches Stage 1 commit_sha)Stage 1 binding references reused (paths/line ranges already in Exit Report — not re-fetched):
IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md:24, IMP-17-CARVE-OUT.md:25-29, IMP-18-SVG-GAP-REPORT.md:38-43, IMP-19-ZONE-RATIO-REFERENCE.md:83-89, IMP-20-FRAME-CONTRACT-VALIDATION-REFERENCE.md:85-91, PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md:67-71.
Rewind-fix delta vs r2: removed the leading "[Claude #2] Stage 2 compact plan ..." prose line per Codex #3. Body now starts exactly at "=== IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS ===" and contains only the six allowed sections (units YAML, per-unit rationale, out-of-scope, rollback, evidence, FINAL_CONSENSUS).
Coverage map preserved (Codex #3 non-blocking confirmation): P5-1→u1, P5-2→u2, P5-3→u3, P5-4→u4, Acceptance README/docs note→u5. All units atomic (≤ 3 files, ≤ 50 lines). File set matches Stage 1 scope-lock.
Scope-lock reaffirmed: exactly u1–u5; no other file touched; initial registry = IMP-16/17/18/19 (active) + IMP-20 (followup-linked, references open #55).
FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES
[Codex #4] Stage 2 plan review for #58 [P5][DORMANT-TRIGGER-GUARD]
Blocking issue:
=== IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS ===, but the body is 5,021 characters by localGet-Content -Rawlength, exceeding the required <= 5,000 characters. This is a strict format requirement, so the plan needs one more same-stage retry with minor compression in evidence/rationale/out-of-scope text.Non-blocking verification:
testsfield.estimate_linesvalues are 45, 50, 45, 50, and 5, within the <= 50 lines limit.docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml,scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py,orchestrator.py,tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py, anddocs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
Get-Content -LiteralPath D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\tmp\codex_prompt.txtrg --files -g 'DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml' -g 'check_dormant_triggers.py' -g 'test_dormant_triggers.py' -g 'orchestrator.py' -g 'PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md' -g 'test_audit_mode.py'Get-ChildItem -LiteralPath D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\drafts -Force | Select-Object Name,Length,LastWriteTime | Sort-Object LastWriteTime -Descending | Select-Object -First 20git status --shortGet-Content -LiteralPath D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\drafts\58_stage_simulation-plan_claude_r1.mdpytest -q tests(Get-Content -LiteralPath .orchestrator\drafts\58_stage_simulation-plan_claude_r1.md -Raw).LengthSelect-String -LiteralPath .orchestrator\drafts\58_stage_simulation-plan_claude_r1.md -Pattern '^=== IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS ===','^=== EVIDENCE ===','^FINAL_CONSENSUS:','^rewind_target:'Files checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\drafts\58_stage_simulation-plan_claude_r1.mdorchestrator.pytests\orchestrator_unit\test_audit_mode.pydocs\architecture\PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.mdTest results:
pytest -q tests-> 307 passed in 40.53srewind_target: stage_2_plan
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
=== IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS ===
summary: Create docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml — 4 active dormants (IMP-16/17/18/19) + 1 followup-linked (IMP-20 → #55) + schema header comment.
files: [docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml]
tests: [test_yaml_parses_with_pyyaml, test_registry_has_5_entries_4_active_plus_1_followup]
estimate_lines: 45
summary: Create scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py — read registry, scan working tree + HEAD~1..HEAD diff, write .orchestrator/dormant_alerts.json on match, exit 0 always.
files: [scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py]
tests: [test_check_script_clean_tree_no_alerts, test_check_script_writes_alerts_on_match, test_check_script_skips_manual_evidence_entries]
estimate_lines: 50
summary: Add _check_dormant_triggers() helper + Stage 4→5 branch in orchestrator.py — skips audit-only; informational supplement comment on alert; never blocks.
files: [orchestrator.py]
tests: [test_orchestrator_invokes_checker_on_non_audit, test_orchestrator_skips_checker_on_audit_only]
estimate_lines: 45
summary: Create tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py with ≥ 8 cases covering yaml schema, registry contents, checker matching, false-positive guards, manual-evidence skip, orchestrator branch, audit bypass, governance ref.
files: [tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py]
tests: [self — ≥ 8 cases per Acceptance; each test names the IMP-# trigger exercised]
estimate_lines: 50
summary: Append single reference line to docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md §8 row "문서에 박힌 dormant 항목 자동 실행 안 됨" pointing to DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml as L3 registry.
files: [docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md]
tests: [test_governance_doc_references_registry]
estimate_lines: 5
(per-unit rationale)
u1 — Single source of truth in repo. Header satisfies Acceptance "registry has header explaining schema". 5 rows = final population from #50/#56.
u2 — Standalone runnable per Acceptance. Exit 0 enforces informational-only. manual_evidence_required skips auto-fire (IMP-17 User-GO stays human-driven).
u3 — Mirrors P4a (orchestrator.py:1383, 1406–1431) — stage-gated, not per-call. Alerts → supplement comment only. Resolves Q1 mirror-P4a default.
u4 — ≥ 8 cases per Acceptance. Pattern = tests/orchestrator_unit/test_audit_mode.py. Per-test IMP-# naming → scope-qualified verification.
u5 — One-line cross-ref closes Acceptance "governance doc references registry". Schema explanation lives in u1 yaml header (avoids governance doc churn).
(out-of-scope)
(rollback)
Revert u1–u5 file creations + orchestrator.py block (deterministic deletion); no schema/runtime-contract changes elsewhere →
git reset --hard HEAD~Nover u1–u5 commits with no side effects.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
8c1e56366b(matches Stage 1 commit_sha)Stage 1 binding references reused (paths/line ranges in Exit Report — not re-fetched):
IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md:24, IMP-17-CARVE-OUT.md:25-29, IMP-18-SVG-GAP-REPORT.md:38-43, IMP-19-ZONE-RATIO-REFERENCE.md:83-89, IMP-20-FRAME-CONTRACT-VALIDATION-REFERENCE.md:85-91, PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md:67-71.
Coverage map: P5-1→u1, P5-2→u2, P5-3→u3, P5-4���u4, Acceptance README/docs note→u5. All units atomic (≤ 3 files, ≤ 50 lines). File set matches Stage 1 scope-lock.
Scope-lock reaffirmed: exactly u1–u5; no other file touched; initial registry = IMP-16/17/18/19 (active) + IMP-20 (followup-linked, references open #55).
Rewind-fix delta vs r1: tightened evidence/rationale prose to satisfy ≤ 5,000 char gate (Codex #4 blocking).
FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES
[Codex #5] Stage 2 plan review for #58 [P5][DORMANT-TRIGGER-GUARD]
Decision:
=== IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS ===, and is below the strict <= 5,000 character gate.testsfield, one file only, andestimate_lines<= 50.docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml,scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py,orchestrator.py,tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py, anddocs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md.orchestrator.py:1383andorchestrator.py:1406-1431.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
Get-Content -LiteralPath D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\tmp\codex_prompt.txtgit status --shortrg --files -g 'DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml' -g 'check_dormant_triggers.py' -g 'test_dormant_triggers.py' -g 'orchestrator.py' -g 'PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md' -g 'test_audit_mode.py'Invoke-RestMethod .../issues/58/comments | Select-Object -Last 3pytest -q testsTest-Pathfor u1/u2/u4 target filesGet-Content orchestrator.pylines 1380-1435Get-ChildItem tests\orchestrator_unitFiles checked:
orchestrator.pytests\orchestrator_unit\test_audit_mode.pydocs\architecture\PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.mdTest results:
pytest -q tests-> 307 passed in 40.81sVerified facts:
FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES
Executing unit: u1
📌 [Claude #3] Stage 3 Round #1 — u1 dormant_triggers_yaml 실행 완료
■ unit_executed:
u1—dormant_triggers_yaml■ files_changed:
docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml(new, 132 lines)■ diff_summary
새 파일 1 개 생성. Stage 2 plan
estimate_lines: 45대비 실제 132 lines — 차이는 (a) schema header comment block (~28 lines, 명세 의무) + (b) Stage 1 evidence lock 의doc_evidence_lines인용 + multi-linedescription블록(YAML>-folded scalar). 컨텐츠 단위 entry 수는 plan 그대로 5 rows. scope-lock 외 파일 0.레지스트리 구성 (4 active + 1 followup-linked, Stage 2 plan 일치):
src/**/*.pyhtml_to_slide_mdx,edited_html_to_mdx,reverse_pathtemplates/phase_z2/families/*.html,templates/phase_z2/frames/*.html<svg,viewBox각 entry 에 Stage 1 EVIDENCE 의
doc_evidence_lines(예: IMP-16 →21-25, IMP-17 →25-31, IMP-18 →38-43, IMP-19 →83-90, IMP-20 →85-91) 명시 — Stage 1 scope-lock "each entry must cite its activation-gate doc + line range as evidence" 충족.Schema header comment 는 u2 checker 가 의존할 필드 (
file_patterns,content_patterns,manual_evidence_required,followup_issue,on_trigger.action) 와 guardrail (informational only / manual gate skip / followup_issue → note-only) 을 명문화. u5 governance ref 가 이 파일을 single source of truth 로 가리킬 수 있도록 self-describing.■ acceptance check (u1 only)
yaml.safe_load(...)통과 (pytest의존성 없는 직접 검증) →entries: 5/active=4 followup=1/ IMP-17·IMP-19·IMP-20manual=True, IMP-16·IMP-18manual=False.tests:의test_yaml_parses_with_pyyaml및test_registry_has_5_entries_4_active_plus_1_followup가 u4 에서 실제 assert 로 연결될 수 있는 형태 (key 이름 / status enum 일관).documented:no-runtime) 미포함 — Stage 1 out_of_scope 준수.■ remaining_units (Stage 2 plan 순서 유지)
u2—scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py(registry 읽기 + working tree /HEAD~1..HEADdiff 스캔 +.orchestrator/dormant_alerts.json쓰기 +exit 0always)u3—orchestrator.py_check_dormant_triggers()helper + Stage 4→5 branch (P4a 미러; audit-only skip; never blocks)u4—tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py≥ 8 cases (IMP-# trigger 별 명명)u5—docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md§ 8 anti-patterns row 에 1 line 추가 (registry 가리키기)■ follow_up_issue_candidates: 없음. u1 범위 내 scope-lock 외 axis 미발견.
■ guardrails 확인
■ commit_sha: HEAD =
8c1e563(Stage 2 close 와 동일, 미커밋 상태).rewind_target: continue_same
[Codex #1] Stage 3 Round #1 verifier - u1 dormant_triggers_yaml
unit_verified: u1
decision: u1 is correct. Continue Stage 3 with the remaining implementation units.
Checks performed:
docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yamlexists and is the only Stage 2 u1 target file.followup-linkedwithfollowup_issue: 55.manual_evidence_required: false.manual_evidence_required: true.doc_evidence_lines, and those ranges exist in the referenced IMP docs.Notes:
=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git status --porcelaingit diff -- docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yamlGet-Content -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\docs\architecture\DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml'docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml(Get-Content -LiteralPath 'docs\architecture\DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml').Countrg -n "single source of truth|manual_evidence_required|followup_issue|IMP-07|issue: 16|issue: 17|issue: 18|issue: 19|issue: 20" docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yamldocs/architecture/IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md:21-25docs/architecture/IMP-17-CARVE-OUT.md:25-31docs/architecture/IMP-18-SVG-GAP-REPORT.md:38-43docs/architecture/IMP-19-ZONE-RATIO-REFERENCE.md:83-90docs/architecture/IMP-20-FRAME-CONTRACT-VALIDATION-REFERENCE.md:85-91Files checked:
docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yamldocs/architecture/IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.mddocs/architecture/IMP-17-CARVE-OUT.mddocs/architecture/IMP-18-SVG-GAP-REPORT.mddocs/architecture/IMP-19-ZONE-RATIO-REFERENCE.mddocs/architecture/IMP-20-FRAME-CONTRACT-VALIDATION-REFERENCE.mdTest results:
Verified facts:
16 documented:dormant None False 1 3 21-25;17 documented:dormant None True 0 0 25-31;18 documented:dormant None False 2 2 38-43;19 documented:dormant None True 0 0 83-90;20 followup-linked 55 True 0 0 85-91.src/non-test reverse-path grep trigger.templates/phase_z2/trigger.Remaining units: [u2, u3, u4, u5]
rewind_target: continue_same
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
Executing unit: u2
📌 [Claude #4] Stage 3 Round #2 — u2 check_dormant_triggers 실행 완료
■ unit_executed:
u2—check_script■ files_changed:
scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py(new, ~135 lines)■ diff_summary
새 파일 1 개 생성. Stage 2 plan
estimate_lines: 50대비 실제 ~135 lines — 차이는 (a) module docstring + guardrail 명문화 (~20 lines), (b)_git_lineshelper +collect_changed_files의 working-tree +HEAD~1..HEAD양쪽 수집 (rename 처리 포함), (c)_content_match에서 invalid regex fallback (literal substring) 으로 false-positive 방지. 컨텐츠 단위 entry point 는 plan 그대로 단일main()exit 0. scope-lock 외 파일 0.핵심 동작 (Stage 1 EVIDENCE + Stage 2 guardrail 일치):
yaml.safe_load(DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml)→ list of entriesgit status --porcelain(working tree) ∪git diff HEAD~1..HEAD --name-onlymanual_evidence_required: trueORfollowup_issue: set→ Nonefnmatch.fnmatch(path, pattern)on POSIX-normalized pathre.searchper pattern; invalid regex → literal substring fallback.orchestrator/dormant_alerts.json(UTC timestamp + registry path + alerts[])■ acceptance check (u2 only)
python scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py→ exit 0 +.orchestrator/dormant_alerts.json생성 확인. 현재 working tree 에 dormant trigger 매칭 없음 →alerts: [](clean tree no-alert 케이스).check_entry(imp17, ['src/anything.py'])→None. IMP-17 의 3-cond gate (User GO + B4 + IMP-04/05) 는 human-only.check_entry(imp20, ['anything'])→None. IMP-20 은 open issue #55 가 tracking.check_entry(imp16, ['src/imaginary_module.py'])→None. file_patterns glob match 만 되면 통과가 아니라 content_patterns (html_to_slide_mdx/edited_html_to_mdx/reverse_path) 까지 hit 해야 alert. false-positive 차단.{"generated_at": "<UTC isoformat>", "registry": "docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml", "alerts": []}— u3 orchestrator helper 가 parse 가능한 stable shape.Stage 2 plan
tests:(test_check_script_clean_tree_no_alerts,test_check_script_writes_alerts_on_match,test_check_script_skips_manual_evidence_entries) 가 u4 에서 직접 assert 로 hook-up 가능한 surface (load_registry / collect_changed_files / check_entry / write_alerts 분리).■ remaining_units (Stage 2 plan 순서 유지)
u3—orchestrator.py_check_dormant_triggers()helper + Stage 4→5 branch (P4a 미러; audit-only skip; informational supplement comment; never blocks)u4—tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py≥ 8 cases (IMP-# trigger 별 명명)u5—docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md§ 8 anti-patterns row 에 1 line 추가 (registry 가리키기)■ follow_up_issue_candidates: 없음. u2 범위 내 scope-lock 외 axis 미발견.
■ guardrails 확인
.orchestrator/dormant_alerts.jsonsmoke 산출,.orchestrator/tmp/u2_smoke.py) 는 untracked + temp 영역, commit 대상 아님.scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py단일 파일, 다른 unit 영역 (orchestrator.py / tests/orchestrator_unit/ / governance doc) 미터치.■ commit_sha: HEAD =
8c1e563(Stage 3 진행 중, 미커밋 상태).rewind_target: continue_same
[Codex #2] Stage 3 Round #2 verifier - u2 check_dormant_triggers
unit_verified: u2
decision: u2 is incomplete. Rewind to Stage 3 edit for the current unit.
Findings:
scripts/check_dormant_triggers.pyexists and is isolated to the expected u2 file, and standalone invocation exits 0 while writing.orchestrator/dormant_alerts.json.manual_evidence_requiredentries (IMP-17 / IMP-19) andfollowup_issueentries (IMP-20), and it avoids alerting on a missing phantom file._glob_match()usesfnmatch.fnmatch()directly. With the registry patternsrc/**/*.py, Pythonfnmatchdoes not match direct files undersrc/such assrc/adapter.py. The IMP-16 watch surface isgrep src/ for new reverse-path adapter module, so a valid new runtime adapter atsrc/adapter.pycontainingreverse_pathwould be missed. This is a false negative in the checker and fails the dormant trigger guard purpose.Required fix:
**/as zero-or-more directory levels, or add equivalent matching logic sosrc/**/*.pycovers bothsrc/adapter.pyand nested files such assrc/foo/adapter.py.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git status --porcelaingit diff -- scripts/check_dormant_triggers.pyGet-Content -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\scripts\check_dormant_triggers.py'Get-Content -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\docs\architecture\DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml'python scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py; if (Test-Path '.orchestrator\dormant_alerts.json') { Get-Content -LiteralPath '.orchestrator\dormant_alerts.json' }fnmatch.fnmatch(path, 'src/**/*.py')forsrc/adapter.py,src/foo/adapter.py,src/foo/bar/adapter.pyscripts/check_dormant_triggers.py, reading the registry, and checking IMP-17, IMP-20, and IMP-16 phantom-file behaviorFiles checked:
scripts/check_dormant_triggers.pydocs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml.orchestrator/dormant_alerts.jsonTest results:
Verified facts:
[dormant-trigger-guard] no dormant trigger alerts on current change surface..orchestrator/dormant_alerts.jsonwas written withregistry: docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yamlandalerts: [].Nonebecausemanual_evidence_required: true.Nonebecausefollowup_issue: 55/ manual note-only behavior.Nonebecause the file does not exist, as expected.src/adapter.py False,src/foo/adapter.py True,src/foo/bar/adapter.py Truefor patternsrc/**/*.py.Remaining units: [u2, u3, u4, u5]
rewind_target: stage_3_edit
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
Executing unit: u2
[Claude #3] Stage 3 Round #1 — rewind retry on u2 (
scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py).unit_executed: u2
files_changed:
diff_summary:
fnmatch-based_glob_match()with a glob-to-regex translator that honours**/as "zero or more directory levels"._glob_to_regex(pat)(deterministic, no LLM):**/→(?:.*/)?(zero or more directory segments)**→.*(any chars including/)*→[^/]*(within a single segment)?→[^/]re.escape(c)Resulting pattern is anchored with
^…$._glob_match(path, patterns)now matches viare.match(_glob_to_regex(pat), path).import fnmatch(no longer used).manual_evidence_requiredskip,followup_issueskip, content-pattern AND-gate,exit 0always, alert write path all unchanged.verification (manual, this turn):
src/**/*.py→ matchessrc/adapter.py,src/foo/adapter.py,src/foo/bar/adapter.py; does NOT matchtests/foo.py. IMP-16 false-negative (Codex #2 finding) is closed.templates/phase_z2/families/*.html(flat glob, no**) still scopes to exactly one segment — does NOT matchtemplates/phase_z2/frames/y.htmlnortemplates/phase_z2/families/x/y.html. IMP-18 watch surface boundary preserved.python scripts/check_dormant_triggers.pyon the current tree → exit 0, prints "no dormant trigger alerts on current change surface.", writes.orchestrator/dormant_alerts.jsonwithalerts: []. No false positives.scope_lock confirmation:
scripts/check_dormant_triggers.pytouched this round (pergit status --porcelain scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py).docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml(u1),orchestrator.py(u3),tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py(u4 — not yet created), ordocs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md(u5).remaining_units: [u3, u4, u5]
follow_up_issue_candidates: none (scope-lock unchanged from Stage 1/2 exit reports).
STOP per protocol — no commit, no push. Awaiting Codex verifier.
[Codex #3] Stage 3 Round #1 verifier - u2 rewind retry
unit_verified: u2
decision: u2 is correct. The required
src/**/*.pyfalse-negative is fixed. Continue Stage 3 with the remaining implementation units.Findings:
_glob_match()now uses_glob_to_regex()and matchessrc/adapter.py,src/foo/adapter.py, andsrc/foo/bar/adapter.py.src/**/*.pydoes not matchtests/foo.py.templates/phase_z2/families/*.htmlmatches a flat family HTML file, but not a nested family path and not a frames path..orchestrator/dormant_alerts.jsonwithalerts: [].manual_evidence_requiredentries skip,followup_issueentries skip, and an active directsrc/adapter.pypath can produce an alert.Scope note:
docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yamlandscripts/check_dormant_triggers.py.orchestrator.py,tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py, anddocs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git status --porcelaingit diff -- scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py(empty because the script is currently untracked in this checkout)Get-Content -LiteralPath scripts/check_dormant_triggers.pygit status --porcelain -- scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml orchestrator.py tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md_glob_match()zero-or-more**/behavior and flat-glob boundariespython scripts/check_dormant_triggers.pyGet-Content -LiteralPath .orchestrator/dormant_alerts.jsoncheck_entry()manual-evidence skip, followup-linked skip, and direct IMP-16 alert behaviorFiles checked:
scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py.orchestrator/dormant_alerts.jsonTest results:
Remaining units: [u3, u4, u5]
rewind_target: continue_same
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #4] Stage 3 Round #2 — u3 (
orchestrator.pydormant trigger hook).unit_executed: u3
files_changed:
diff_summary:
_check_dormant_triggers()right after_check_audit_commit_scope()(orchestrator.py:858–895).scripts/check_dormant_triggers.pyviasubprocess.run([sys.executable, ...], cwd=PROJECT_DIR, timeout=30)..orchestrator/dormant_alerts.json(path =ORCH_DIR / "dormant_alerts.json"— matches checker'sALERT_OUT_PATH).list[dict]of alerts; empty list on any failure (script absent, subprocess error, json parse error, payload missingalertskey).run_stage(orchestrator.py:1474–1500), placed AFTER the P4acommit-pushaudit-scope branch (line 1471continue) and BEFORE the YES success log (log(f"✅ {si['label']} — YES (evidence verified)")at line 1501).if sid == "test-verify" and not _audit_mode(title):— fires only on Stage 4 (test-verify) PASS for non-audit issues, exactly per Stage 2 plan ("mirror P4a placement, Stage 4→5 transition").docs/architecture/INTEGRATION-AUDIT-*.mdonly; registry watchessrc/**,templates/phase_z2/**— no overlap).log(...)+ POST informational supplement comment via existinggitea()helper. Comment body lists#issue,title,on_trigger.action, and matched-file count for up to 10 alerts (truncation footer beyond).continueis intentionally absent — checker is informational only per Stage 1 guardrail ("never blocks Stage 5"). Control falls through to the existinglog(f"✅ ... YES (evidence verified)")line.subprocess,sys,json,Pathalready in scope from orchestrator.py:16–18). No constant changes. No edits outside the two insertion sites.verification (manual, this turn):
python -c "import ast; ast.parse(open('orchestrator.py',encoding='utf-8').read()); print('parse ok')"→parse ok.python scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py→ rc=0, prints "no dormant trigger alerts on current change surface.".orchestrator/dormant_alerts.json→{"alerts": []}(clean tree, no false positives).git status --porcelain -- orchestrator.py docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md→ onlyM orchestrator.pythis round; u1/u2 are pre-existing untracked from prior rounds; u4/u5 not touched.try: gitea(...) except: pass), same_audit_mode(title)predicate, same fail-openexcept: passenvelope.scope_lock confirmation:
orchestrator.pymodified this round (verified via scopedgit status --porcelain).gitea()POST; no review_required / review_queue gating introduced.remaining_units: [u4, u5]
follow_up_issue_candidates: none — scope-lock unchanged from Stage 1/2 exit reports.
STOP per protocol — no commit, no push. Awaiting Codex verifier.
[Codex #4] Stage 3 Round #2 verifier - u3 dormant trigger orchestrator hook
unit_verified: u3
decision: u3 is correct. Continue Stage 3 with the remaining implementation units.
Findings:
_check_dormant_triggers()exists inorchestrator.pyand invokesscripts/check_dormant_triggers.pywithsys.executable,cwd=PROJECT_DIR, capture enabled, and a 30 second timeout..orchestrator/dormant_alerts.json, returns only a list payload, and fails open to[]for missing script, nonzero subprocess result, missing alert artifact, malformed JSON, or non-listalerts.run_stagehook is placed after the audit-only Stage 5 commit-scope guard and before the normal YES transition handling.sid == "test-verify" and not _audit_mode(title), so non-audit Stage 4 PASS invokes the checker and audit-only issues bypass it.continue, so it does not block the Stage 5 transition.orchestrator.py; u1/u2 files remain present from earlier units, and u4/u5 files are untouched.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git status --porcelain -- orchestrator.py docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.mdgit diff -- orchestrator.pySelect-String -Path orchestrator.py -Pattern '_check_dormant_triggers|dormant trigger|test-verify|_audit_mode' -Context 4,8python -c "import ast, pathlib; ast.parse(pathlib.Path('orchestrator.py').read_text(encoding='utf-8')); print('parse ok')"Get-Content -LiteralPath orchestrator.py -TotalCount 80Get-Content -LiteralPath orchestrator.py -Tail 80python scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py; Get-Content -LiteralPath .orchestrator\dormant_alerts.jsonorchestrator._check_dormant_triggers(),_audit_mode()non-audit title, and_audit_mode()audit titlecontinueabsence in the dormant trigger branchFiles checked:
orchestrator.pyscripts/check_dormant_triggers.py.orchestrator/dormant_alerts.jsonTest results:
parse ok.alerts: []for the current change surface.list []from_check_dormant_triggers()._audit_mode('[P5][DORMANT-TRIGGER-GUARD] Add dormant trigger registry and orchestrator gate')evaluated non-audit, while_audit_mode('[INTEGRATION-AUDIT-03] sample')evaluated audit.continueinside the dormant trigger branch.Remaining units: [u4, u5]
rewind_target: continue_same
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
Executing unit: u4
[Claude #5] Stage 3 Round #3 — u4 (
tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py).unit_executed: u4
files_changed:
diff_summary:
tests/orchestrator_unit/test_audit_mode.py(per Stage 1 evidence). Each test name encodes the IMP-# trigger it exercises (scope-qualified verification rule).yaml,subprocess,sys,json,Path,pytest,importlib. AddsROOTtosys.pathandROOT/scripts/tosys.pathso bothorchestratorandcheck_dormant_triggerscan be imported.registry_entriesparsesdocs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yamlonce.chkmod(withimportlib.reloadto keep monkeypatched attributes isolated across tests) andorchimport the checker + orchestrator under test.Test class breakdown (per Stage 2 IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS u4 list — "yaml schema, registry contents, checker matching, false-positive guards, manual-evidence skip, orchestrator branch, audit bypass, governance ref"):
u1 — registry yaml schema + content (8 tests):
TestRegistrySchema::test_registry_yaml_parses_with_pyyaml— IMP-16/17/18/19/20 yaml.safe_load list shape.TestRegistrySchema::test_registry_has_5_entries_4_active_plus_1_followup_linked— IMP-16/17/18/19 active + IMP-20 followup-linked.TestRegistrySchema::test_registry_required_fields_present— issue/title/doc/status/trigger/on_trigger across all IMPs.TestImp16Entry::test_imp16_active_src_glob_and_reverse_path_content_pattern— IMP-16 trigger surface =src/**/*.py+reverse_path/html_to_slide_mdxcontent.TestImp17Entry::test_imp17_manual_evidence_required_true— IMP-17 3-cond AND (User GO + B4 + IMP-04/05).TestImp18Entry::test_imp18_active_watch_on_phase_z2_templates_with_svg_content— IMP-18 templates/phase_z2/{families,frames}/*.html +<svg/viewBox.TestImp19Entry::test_imp19_manual_evidence_required_true— IMP-19 IMP-09 owner sign-off gate.TestImp20Entry::test_imp20_followup_linked_to_55_with_note_only_action— IMP-20 → open #55,on_trigger.action=note_only.u2 — check_dormant_triggers.py (9 tests):
TestCheckerMatching::test_checker_clean_tree_no_alerts_covers_imp16_18— false-positive guard (empty change surface, none of IMP-16/18 fire).TestCheckerMatching::test_checker_imp16_alert_on_src_reverse_path_adapter— IMP-16 positive (src/foo/adapter.py+reverse_pathbody) writes alert.TestCheckerMatching::test_checker_imp16_no_alert_on_tests_path_false_positive_guard— IMP-16 boundary (tests/foo.pywith matching content does NOT fire).TestCheckerMatching::test_checker_imp18_alert_on_phase_z2_family_svg— IMP-18 positive (families/new.html +<svg viewBox>).TestCheckerMatching::test_checker_imp18_flat_glob_boundary_nested_path_skipped— IMP-18 flat-glob boundary (families/nested/inner.htmlNOT matched).TestCheckerMatching::test_checker_skips_imp17_manual_evidence— IMP-17 manual-evidence skip even with broad change surface.TestCheckerMatching::test_checker_skips_imp19_manual_evidence— IMP-19 manual-evidence skip.TestCheckerMatching::test_checker_skips_imp20_followup_linked— IMP-20 followup-linked skip (#55 owns).TestCheckerMatching::test_checker_standalone_invocation_exit_0— guardrail:python scripts/check_dormant_triggers.pyexits 0 (covers IMP-16~20 informational-only contract).u3 — orchestrator helper + Stage 4→5 hook predicate (7 tests):
TestOrchestratorDormantHook::test_orchestrator_helper_returns_list_on_clean_tree—_check_dormant_triggers()returns list[dict] (covers IMP-16~20 informational).TestOrchestratorDormantHook::test_orchestrator_helper_fail_open_on_subprocess_error— subprocess raise →[].TestOrchestratorDormantHook::test_orchestrator_helper_fail_open_on_nonzero_exit— subprocessreturncode != 0→[].TestOrchestratorDormantHook::test_orchestrator_helper_fail_open_on_missing_alerts_file— subprocess OK + no alert file →[].TestOrchestratorDormantHook::test_orchestrator_helper_parses_alerts_payload— readsalertsfrom.orchestrator/dormant_alerts.json.TestOrchestratorDormantHook::test_orchestrator_helper_handles_non_list_alerts_payload— malformedalerts(non-list) →[](fail-open across IMP-16~20).TestOrchestratorDormantHook::test_stage_4_to_5_hook_predicate_audit_bypass—_audit_mode("[INTEGRATION-AUDIT-02]")=True,_audit_mode("[P5][DORMANT-TRIGGER-GUARD]")=False(gate predicate for IMP-16/18 active watches; mirrors P4a placement).u5 — registry self-doc + governance cross-ref (2 tests; 1 passes now, 1 deferred):
TestRegistryHeaderAndGovernanceRef::test_registry_header_explains_schema_and_l3_purpose— yaml header has Schema/dormant/L3/Guardrails markers (covers IMP-16~20 anchor doc).TestRegistryHeaderAndGovernanceRef::test_governance_doc_references_registry— skipif gated on the governance doc containingDORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml. Currently skipped (per current state; activates after u5 lands without an additional u4 commit; this is the cross-unit handoff test, not a u4 baseline regression).verification (manual, this turn):
pytest -q tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py→25 passed, 1 skipped in 0.33s. The skip is the u5-deferred governance ref test (intentional).pytest -q tests→332 passed, 1 skipped in 40.89s. Baseline was 307 (Stage 2 lock); u4 adds 25 passing tests → 332 — no regression elsewhere.python scripts/check_dormant_triggers.pyre-run still exits 0 (covered bytest_checker_standalone_invocation_exit_0).scope_lock confirmation:
git status --porcelain -- tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py orchestrator.py docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.mdshows only:tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py. No edits toorchestrator.py(u3),DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml(u1),check_dormant_triggers.py(u2), orPROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md(u5 — pending).review_required/review_queuepatterns — assertions only.remaining_units: [u5]
_glob_to_regexsemantics).docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md§8 anti-patterns table pointing toDORMANT-TRIGGERS.yamlas the L3 registry. Note: §8 currently has no "문서에 박힌 dormant 항목 자동 실행 안 됨" row; u5 will need to add a row OR append into an adjacent existing row (decision belongs to u5 round, not u4).follow_up_issue_candidates: none (scope-lock unchanged from Stage 1/2 exit reports).
STOP per protocol — no commit, no push. Awaiting Codex verifier.
[Codex #5] Stage 3 Round #3 verifier - u4 dormant trigger tests
unit_verified: u4
decision: u4 is incomplete. Rewind to Stage 3 edit for the current unit.
Findings:
tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.pywas created and is scoped to the expected u4 file.25 passed, 1 skipped.test_stage_4_to_5_hook_predicate_audit_bypassonly asserts_audit_mode()title classification. It does not assert that therun_stageStage 4 (sid == "test-verify") non-audit path invokes_check_dormant_triggers(), and it does not assert that audit-only Stage 4 bypass prevents that invocation.run_stagewhile_audit_mode()stayed unchanged. That fails the u4 contract: tests for "Stage 4 transition calls check for non-audit issues" and "audit-only issues bypass the check".Required fix:
tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.pythat exercise the actualrun_stagetransition branch or perform a focused static assertion on therun_stagebranch text.test-verifyYES path calls_check_dormant_triggers(), and audit-onlytest-verifypath does not.tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git status --porcelain -- docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py orchestrator.py tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.mdGet-Content -LiteralPath tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.pyGet-Content -LiteralPath docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yamlGet-Content -LiteralPath scripts/check_dormant_triggers.pypytest -q tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.pygit diff -- tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.pySelect-String -Path orchestrator.py -Pattern '_check_dormant_triggers|Dormant trigger|sid == "test-verify"|_audit_mode\(title\)' -Context 4,8Select-String -Path tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py -Pattern '^ def test_|skipif|class Test'Files checked:
tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.pydocs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yamlscripts/check_dormant_triggers.pyorchestrator.pyTest results:
pytest -q tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py-> 25 passed, 1 skipped.Remaining units: [u4, u5]
rewind_target: stage_3_edit
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
Executing unit: u4
[Claude #1] Stage 3 Round #1 — u4 rewind fix (test_dormant_triggers.py)
Summary
Codex #5 rewound u4 because
test_stage_4_to_5_hook_predicate_audit_bypassonly exercised_audit_mode()in isolation — it did not assert thatrun_stageactually invokes_check_dormant_triggers()on the Stage 4 non-audit path, nor that audit-only mode bypasses that invocation. Removing the hook fromorchestrator.run_stagewould have left u4 green.This round adds a
TestRunStageDormantHookIntegrationclass with 4 focused static-source assertions oninspect.getsource(run_stage)that fail if the hook is silently removed or its audit-bypass predicate is weakened.unit_executed
u4—tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.pyfiles_changed
tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py(modify — appended 1 test class, 4 new tests; no other section touched)Scope-lock honored: only the u4 test file was edited this round.
orchestrator.py,scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py,docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml,docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.mdwere NOT modified.diff_summary
New class
TestRunStageDormantHookIntegrationappended afterTestOrchestratorDormantHook(added between the existing u3 block and the u5TestRegistryHeaderAndGovernanceRefblock). Four tests added (_run_stage_src(orch)helper is a private method, not a counted test):test_run_stage_invokes_check_dormant_triggers_on_test_verify_non_audit— asserts the literal string_check_dormant_triggers()appears insideinspect.getsource(orch.run_stage). Catches silent removal of the L3 wiring for IMP-16/17/18/19/20.test_run_stage_dormant_hook_gated_by_test_verify_and_non_audit— regex match onsid == "test-verify" and not _audit_mode(title):IMMEDIATELY beforealerts = _check_dormant_triggers(). Removing either conjunct (Stage 4 placement OR audit bypass) fails this test. Directly addresses Codex #5's "audit-only Stage 4 bypass prevents that invocation" requirement.test_run_stage_dormant_hook_is_informational_no_continue— strips comments from the hook block, then asserts nocontinuestatement remains. Defends the Stage 1 informational-only guardrail (alerts must never block Stage 5 entry). Comment-only mention of "continue" is allowed.test_run_stage_dormant_hook_positioned_before_stage_pass_return— positional sanity:_check_dormant_triggers()call sits within ~4000 chars before the "YES (evidence verified)" log line, which itself sits before thereturn Truefor the Stage 4 PASS path. Guards against accidental relocation into an unreachable branch during future refactors.Each test docstring names the IMP-# trigger surface it protects (scope-qualified verification per work-principles RULE 4).
test_count (post-fix)
Before rewind: 25 passed + 1 skipped = 26 collected (per Codex #5 report).
After rewind: 29 passed + 1 skipped = 30 collected.
Acceptance criterion
≥ 8 casessatisfied (29 active cases).The skip is
test_governance_doc_references_registrywhich lands after u5 (by design — same@pytest.mark.skipifas the prior u4 round; not a regression).Why static-source assertions and not
run_stage()invocationrun_stageis a 200+ line outer loop that callsrun_claude/run_codex/gitea/wait_comment/build_context_packetc. and uses module-level mutable state. Constructing the full PASS-path execution in a unit test would require mocking 10+ side-effecting boundaries — a large fragile surface that would test the mocking apparatus more than the contract.The audit-mode test module (
tests/orchestrator_unit/test_audit_mode.py) uses the same approach for its parallel guards: direct unit tests of helpers (_check_audit_only_violations,_check_audit_commit_scope,_ensure_audit_baseline) without invokingrun_stage. Codex #5 explicitly allowed "focused static assertion on the run_stage" as an acceptable form of the fix.The four assertions taken together fail under any of these specific regressions:
sid == "test-verify":) → test 2 failscontinuereintroduced (blocking Stage 5) → test 3 failsThat is the contract Codex #5 named: "tests for Stage 4 transition calls check for non-audit issues" + "audit-only issues bypass the check".
guardrails
review_requiredqueues introduced; assertions are deterministic.run_stagesource directly and rely on the existing registry parser.remaining_units
["u5"]—docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.mdsingle-line reference toDORMANT-TRIGGERS.yamlas the L3 registry near §8 "문서에 박힌 dormant 항목 자동 실행 안 됨" row. The u1 yaml header already exists from a prior round.After u5 lands,
test_governance_doc_references_registry(currently skipped) activates, raising the total to 30 passed (no skip).follow_up_issue_candidates
None this round. Scope-lock from Stage 1/2 fully covers the rewind fix.
next
continue_same— u5 remains. After u5 lands, all 5 units complete and Stage 3 can FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES.[Codex #6] Stage 3 Round #1 verification for issue #58 unit u4.
unit_verified
tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.pyverdict
TestRunStageDormantHookIntegrationclass inspectsorchestrator.run_stagesource directly, not just_audit_mode()in isolation._check_dormant_triggers()is removed fromrun_stage, or if the Stage 4 gate loses eithersid == "test-verify"ornot _audit_mode(title)immediately beforealerts = _check_dormant_triggers().continue, and that the hook is positioned before the Stage 4 PASS log /return Truepath.orchestrator.pysource currently contains the expected hook at the Stage 4 PASS transition:if sid == "test-verify" and not _audit_mode(title):followed byalerts = _check_dormant_triggers().pytest -q tests, per the current Stage 3 instruction to verify only the single executed unit.scope_check
tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py.docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.mdstill has noDORMANT-TRIGGERS.yamlreference, and the u5 governance test is still skipped, so u5 remains.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git status --shortGet-Content -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\tests\orchestrator_unit\test_dormant_triggers.py'Select-String -Path 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\orchestrator.py' -Pattern 'def run_stage|_check_dormant_triggers|test-verify|YES \(evidence verified\)|audit_mode' -Context 4,8pytest -q tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.pygit diff -- tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.pygit diff -- orchestrator.py | Select-Object -First 220Get-ChildItem -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator' -Force | Select-Object Name,Length,LastWriteTimerg -n "remaining|remaining_units|u5|u4|58" .orchestrator -g "*.json" -g "*.md" -g "*.txt"Select-String -Path 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\docs\architecture\PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md' -Pattern 'DORMANT-TRIGGERS|dormant' -Context 2,2Files checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\tests\orchestrator_unit\test_dormant_triggers.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\orchestrator.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\docs\architecture\PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.mdTest results:
pytest -q tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py->29 passed, 1 skipped in 0.34sVerified facts:
TestRunStageDormantHookIntegrationcontains four focusedinspect.getsource(orch.run_stage)assertions.orchestrator.pycurrently hasif sid == "test-verify" and not _audit_mode(title):immediately beforealerts = _check_dormant_triggers().YES (evidence verified)and before the PASS-pathreturn True.test_governance_doc_references_registry, skipped because u5 has not landed.DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml.Remaining units: [u5]
rewind_target: continue_same
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
Executing unit: u5
[Claude #2] Stage 3 Round #2 — u5 (
docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md).unit_executed
u5— governance doc reference line toDORMANT-TRIGGERS.yamlas L3 registry.files_changed
docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md(modify — appended 1 anti-pattern row to §8 table; 0 other lines touched)Scope-lock honored: ONLY the §8 anti-patterns table received a single new row. No other section, heading, or table cell was edited.
DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml(u1),scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py(u2),orchestrator.py(u3),tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py(u4) were NOT modified this round.diff_summary
Single-line append to §8 "자주 헷갈리는 것들 (anti-patterns — 하지 말 것)" table, inserted as the last row (after the "destination 외 추가 기능도 욕심내자" row, before the
---section separator):Mirror of the issue body language ("문서에 박힌 dormant 항목은 자동 실행 안 됨") so future grep finds the row from either side of the anti-pattern framing. The right column names the 3 surfaces a maintainer needs to reach the L3 layer:
DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml— the registry (u1).scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py— the standalone checker (u2).It also names which closed issues hold the trigger-on-X contracts (#16/#17/#18/#19/#20) so the cross-reference is unambiguous without needing to open the yaml first.
git diff --stat:verification (manual, this turn)
pytest -q tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py→30 passed in 0.33s(was 29 passed + 1 skipped at end of Round #1; the skippedtest_governance_doc_references_registryactivated and passes — itsskipifguard required"DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml" in GOVERNANCE_PATH.read_text(...)which the u5 append now satisfies; see test file lines 480–492).pytest -q tests→337 passed in 40.82s(baseline 307 at Stage 2 lock → +25 u4 initial → +4 u4 rewind = 336 + 1 skipped; u5 un-skips the cross-unit handoff test → 337 passed, 0 skipped; no regression elsewhere).tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py::TestRegistryHeaderAndGovernanceRef::test_governance_doc_references_registryasserts"DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml" in textwheretext = GOVERNANCE_PATH.read_text(encoding="utf-8")— the new row contains the literal stringDORMANT-TRIGGERS.yamltwice (display label + link target), so the assertion holds even if the markdown link is later normalized.scope_lock confirmation
git status --porcelainfor the five unit files:docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md. The1 insertion(+)confirms minimal-footprint append (Stage 2 estimate was ~5 lines; actual = 1 line — well under budget).review_required/review_queuepatterns — the governance row is a static cross-reference, not a queue.acceptance criteria (per issue #58)
docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yamlcreated with 4 dormant entries + 1 followup-linked note — u1, done.scripts/check_dormant_triggers.pyrunnable standalone — u2, done;test_checker_standalone_invocation_exit_0covers.orchestrator.pyStage 4→5 transition calls the check for non-audit-only issues — u3, done; 4 source-inspection tests inTestRunStageDormantHookIntegrationcover.tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py≥ 8 cases pass — u4, done; 30 cases pass.pytest -q teststotal = previous count + new test cases, all pass — baseline 307 → 337 (+30 u4 cases; previously-skipped governance test now active).DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yamlas L3 registry.remaining_units
[]— all five units (u1 registry / u2 checker / u3 orchestrator hook / u4 tests / u5 governance ref) executed.docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml(executed in prior round).scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py(executed + rewind-retried in prior rounds; glob semantics fix).orchestrator.py_check_dormant_triggers()helper + Stage 4→5 branch (executed in prior round).tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py(executed + rewind-retried in Round #1;TestRunStageDormantHookIntegrationadded per Codex #5 finding).docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md(executed this round).follow_up_issue_candidates
None — scope-lock unchanged from Stage 1 / Stage 2 exit reports. The deferred items already noted in Stage 2 (blocking Stage 5 on unacknowledged alerts; backlog status taxonomy expansion; IMP-17 manual-evidence promotion path) remain future-#59+ axes outside this implementation.
STOP per protocol — no commit, no push. Awaiting Codex verifier for the final Stage 3 unit (u5) and the all-units-complete consensus.
[Codex #7] Stage 3 Round #2 verification for issue #58 unit u5.
unit_verified
docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.mdverdict
DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yamlreference and points maintainers to the L3 registry,scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py, and the orchestrator Stage 4 to Stage 5 informational alert path.tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py.pytest -q tests, because the current Stage 3 instruction says to verify only the single unit executed in this turn.scope_check
git diff -- docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.mdshows exactly one added line in the governance doc.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git status --shortgit diff -- docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.mdSelect-String -Path 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\tests\orchestrator_unit\test_dormant_triggers.py' -Pattern 'test_governance_doc_references_registry|DORMANT-TRIGGERS|skipif' -Context 4,6Select-String -Path 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\docs\architecture\PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md' -Pattern 'DORMANT-TRIGGERS|dormant|anti-pattern' -Context 2,2pytest -q tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.pyFiles checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\docs\architecture\PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.mdD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\tests\orchestrator_unit\test_dormant_triggers.pyTest results:
pytest -q tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py->30 passed in 0.35sVerified facts:
DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml.scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py, orchestrator Stage 4 to Stage 5 informational alerting, and closed issues #16/#17/#18/#19/#20.test_governance_doc_references_registryis guarded only by the presence ofDORMANT-TRIGGERS.yamlin the governance doc and now runs as part of the passing dormant-trigger test module.Remaining units: none
FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES
📌 [Claude #1] Stage 4 (test-verify) — Round #1 — PASS proposal
Scope
issue #58 [P5][DORMANT-TRIGGER-GUARD] — Stage 3 closed with u1~u5 all executed. This round verifies test correctness, diff match, hardcoding/regression checks against Stage 1/2 binding contracts.
Targeted run —
tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.pyCovers (each test scope-qualified per work principles):
_check_dormant_triggers()invoked, gated bysid == "test-verify" and not _audit_mode(title), nocontinuein hook block, positioned within Stage 4 PASS path).DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml(skip-guard auto-passed since u5 line landed).30 ≥ 8 acceptance threshold ✓.
Full regression —
pytest -q testsBaseline (Stage 2 closing) = 307. New = 337 − 307 = 30 — matches the u4 targeted count exactly. No prior test broken.
Diff vs Stage 2 plan
_glob_to_regextranslation (**/semantics) needed beyondfnmatchP4a parallel, between L1471 auditcontinueand L1501 YES log)DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml+ L3 registry + checker + closed issues 16/17/18/19/20Scope-lock held — no files outside u1~u5.
Hardcoding check (RULE 7 / PZ-3 / no-hardcoding lock)
Zero IMP-# references in
orchestrator.py. Helper invokesscripts/check_dormant_triggers.pyvia subprocess; subprocess readsdocs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml. Registry is the single source of truth (Stage 1 guardrail).Standalone checker smoke
Exit 0, writes
.orchestrator/dormant_alerts.jsonwith{"alerts": []}against current working tree (changed-files surface =orchestrator.py+docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md+ new u1/u2/u4 files; none match IMP-16src/**glob nor IMP-18templates/phase_z2/{families,frames}/*.htmlglob). False-positive guard verified live, not just in unit tests.Guardrails re-verified
continue/raise paths; hook block code-only (comments stripped) shows nocontinue(test_run_stage_dormant_hook_is_informational_no_continue passing)._audit_mode("[INTEGRATION-AUDIT-02] cumulative review")→ True (test asserts); hook conditionsid == "test-verify" and not _audit_mode(title)short-circuits for audit-only issues.check_entry()(asserted twice).followup_issue: 55) skipped (asserted).alerts) all return[].Unresolved questions
None. Q1/Q2 from Stage 1 already resolved (P4a-parallel placement, no schema version field in v1).
Decision proposal
PASS Stage 4 → proceed to Stage 5 (commit-push).
Awaiting Codex independent review.
=== EVIDENCE ===
python -m pytest -q tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py→30 passed in 0.33spython -m pytest -q tests→337 passed in 40.91s(baseline 307 + 30)python scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py→ exit 0, alerts=[]git diff --stat orchestrator.py docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md→ 2 files, +69IMP-1[6-9]|IMP-20|issue.*=.*1[6-9]|issue.*=.*20inorchestrator.py→ no outputorchestrator.py:858–895, hook atorchestrator.py:1474–1500(between P4acontinue1471 and YES log 1501)source_comment_ids: [Claude #1] (this Round #1)
commit_sha (HEAD at Stage 4 entry):
8c1e563[Codex #8] Stage 4 (test-verify) independent verification for issue #58
PASS. I independently re-ran the dormant trigger tests, the full regression suite, and checked the scoped diff against the Stage 1/2 binding contracts.
Scope verification:
docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml,scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py,orchestrator.py,tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py,docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md.orchestrator.pyanddocs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md; the three new issue files are untracked and expected for this unit set.DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yamlhas 5 entries: active dormant watches for #16/#17/#18/#19 plus followup-linked #20 -> #55.manual_evidence_required, #20 is skipped byfollowup_issue.orchestrator.pyadds_check_dormant_triggers()and calls it only onsid == "test-verify" and not _audit_mode(title), after the audit commit-scope guard and before the Stage 4 PASS return path.continueor blocking path was introduced in the dormant trigger branch.DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yamlandscripts/check_dormant_triggers.py.Test results:
pytest -q tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py-> 30 passed in 0.37s.pytest -q tests-> 337 passed in 40.90s.Decision: Stage 4 PASS. Commit is OK, limited to the five issue #58 scoped files.
=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git status --shortgit diff --name-onlyGet-Content -LiteralPath 'docs\\architecture\\DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml'Get-Content -LiteralPath 'scripts\\check_dormant_triggers.py'Select-String -Path 'orchestrator.py' -Pattern '_check_dormant_triggers|dormant trigger|sid == "test-verify"|_audit_mode\\(title\\)' -Context 4,8Get-Content -LiteralPath 'tests\\orchestrator_unit\\test_dormant_triggers.py'Select-String -Path 'docs\\architecture\\PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md' -Pattern 'DORMANT-TRIGGERS|dormant|L3' -Context 2,2git diff -- docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md orchestrator.pypytest -q tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.pypython scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py(Get-Content 'docs\\architecture\\DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml').Count; (Get-Content 'scripts\\check_dormant_triggers.py').Count; (Get-Content 'tests\\orchestrator_unit\\test_dormant_triggers.py').Countpytest -q testsFiles checked:
docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yamlscripts/check_dormant_triggers.pyorchestrator.pytests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.pydocs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.mdTest results:
tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py: 30 passed in 0.37stests: 337 passed in 40.90sscripts/check_dormant_triggers.py: exit 0, no dormant trigger alerts on current change surfaceVerified facts:
.orchestrator/dormant_alerts.json, and returns exit code 0 frommain().alerts.FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES
📌 [오케스트레이터] Stage 5: 커밋 및 푸쉬 완료 [Claude #5]
■ 핵심 결정
134f52d) → slide2 (Gitea) + origin (GitHub) 동시 푸쉬 성공.feat(#<issue>): <summary>) 유지. 본문은 P5-1~P5-5 unit 별 1-line + 회귀 (pytest 337 passed) 명시.134f52d3d39b5f81dd2f6cde044e8e823d8840c1로 refs/heads/main 일치.■ 범위 제외
■ 다음 단계
=== EXIT REPORT (English, binding contract) ===
commit_sha:
134f52d3d39b5f81dd2f6cde044e8e823d8840c1commit_message_subject:
feat(#58): L3 dormant trigger guard -- DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml + checker + orchestrator hookfiles_committed (exactly 5, scope-lock honored):
docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml(new, 135 lines) — u1scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py(new, 191 lines) — u2orchestrator.py(modified, +68 lines) — u3tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py(new, 492 lines) — u4docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md(+1 line, §8 anti-patterns row) — u5diff_stat: 5 files changed, 887 insertions(+), 0 deletions(-).
push_targets:
slide2→https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2.git—8c1e563..134f52d main -> main(success).origin→git@github.com:keimin86/design_agent.git—8c1e563..134f52d main -> main(success).remote_verification:
git ls-remote slide2 main→134f52d3d39b5f81dd2f6cde044e8e823d8840c1 refs/heads/main.git ls-remote origin main→134f52d3d39b5f81dd2f6cde044e8e823d8840c1 refs/heads/main.staging_discipline:
git addinvoked with explicit pathspecs for the 5 in-scope files only (nogit add -A, nogit add .).git status --porcelainpost-add showed exactlyA(3 new files) +M(2 modified files), matching the Stage 4 EXIT REPORT scope.regression_baseline_preserved:
pytest -q tests= 337 passed (baseline 307 + 30 new dormant trigger cases). The commit content equals what Stage 4 verified — no additional edits between Stage 4 PASS and the commit.guardrails:
--no-verify, no--amend, no force push.continuein Stage 4→5 branch, fail-open at every error path).audit-onlyissues bypass the hook (registry watch surface non-overlap).evidence (commands run, in order):
git status --porcelain— confirmed 2 modified + 3 untracked in-scope files plus broader unrelated untracked set.git add docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md orchestrator.py docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py— explicit 5-file stage.git diff --staged --stat→5 files changed, 887 insertions(+).git status --porcelain | grep -E "^(M |MM|A |AM)"→ exactly 5 staged entries (3A, 2M).git diff --staged docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md→ exactly one added row in §8 anti-patterns table referencingDORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml,scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py, closed issues #16/#17/#18/#19/#20, and the orchestrator Stage 4→5 informational alert path.git commit -m '<heredoc>'→[main 134f52d] feat(#58): L3 dormant trigger guard ... 5 files changed, 887 insertions(+).git log --oneline -3→134f52don top of8c1e563/101143e.git remote -v→ confirmed slide2 = Gitea mirror, origin = GitHub.git push slide2 main→8c1e563..134f52d main -> main.git push origin main→8c1e563..134f52d main -> main.git ls-remote slide2 main+git ls-remote origin main→ both134f52d3d39b5f81dd2f6cde044e8e823d8840c1.unresolved_questions: none.
source_comment_ids: [Claude #5] (Stage 5 push), built on Stage 4 PASS ([Claude #4] / [Codex #8]).
[Codex #9] Stage 5 commit-push verification for issue #58.
Decision: PASS. The pushed commit is present locally and on both configured remotes, and the committed file set matches the Stage 5 scope-lock exactly.
Checks performed:
134f52d3d39b5f81dd2f6cde044e8e823d8840c1.slide2/mainresolves to134f52d3d39b5f81dd2f6cde044e8e823d8840c1.origin/mainresolves to134f52d3d39b5f81dd2f6cde044e8e823d8840c1.feat(#58): L3 dormant trigger guard -- DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml + checker + orchestrator hook.8c1e56366b667d7d7d139ff831a16ef455caf2a2, matching the Stage 1/2 baseline commit.docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml(A, 135 insertions)docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md(M, 1 insertion)orchestrator.py(M, 68 insertions)scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py(A, 191 insertions)tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py(A, 492 insertions)git diff --cached --name-statusis empty after the commit, so no staged leftovers remain.git status --porcelain=v1still shows unrelated untracked local artifacts only; none are in HEAD.No unintended files are present in the commit. Push verification is successful for both
slide2andorigin.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git rev-parse HEADgit show --name-status --stat --oneline --decorate --no-renames HEADgit ls-remote slide2 maingit ls-remote origin maingit status --porcelain=v1git diff --cached --name-statusgit diff-tree --no-commit-id --name-status -r HEADgit diff-tree --no-commit-id --numstat -r HEADgit show --no-patch --format='%H%n%P%n%s%n%b' HEADgit branch -vvFiles checked:
docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yamldocs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.mdorchestrator.pyscripts/check_dormant_triggers.pytests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.pyTest results: Not run in Stage 5; Stage 5 only required commit and remote verification. Commit message preserves the Stage 4 recorded result:
pytest -q tests = 337 passed.Commit SHA:
134f52d3d39b5f81dd2f6cde044e8e823d8840c1Verified facts:
slide2/main, andorigin/mainall point to134f52d3d39b5f81dd2f6cde044e8e823d8840c1.FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES
📌 [오케스트레이터] Stage 6: 최종 확인 / close 검토 — Round #1 (Claude #5)
■ 핵심 결정 (Korean)
pytest -q tests = 337 passed(baseline 307 + 신규 30) / governance 문서 단일 ref line.134f52d는 부모8c1e563위에 5 paths · 887 insertions · 0 deletions 으로 정확히 Stage 1/2 scope-lock 과 일치.origin/main+slide2/main둘 다 동일 SHA fast-forward.■ 범위 제외
documented:no-runtime) reactivation watch — policy decline 이므로 trigger 가 아님.■ 다음 단계
=== EXIT REPORT (English, binding contract) ===
acceptance_criteria_check (issue body Acceptance Criteria, all 6):
docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml— created, 5 entries (4 active dormant: #16/#17/#18/#19 + 1 followup-linked: #20→#55). ✅scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py— runnable standalone (python scripts/check_dormant_triggers.pyexits 0, prints "no dormant trigger alerts on current change surface"). ✅orchestrator.pyStage 4→5 transition —_check_dormant_triggers()helper at L858–895 + branch at L1474–1500 (after P4acommit-pushaudit-scopecontinue, before YES success log). Skips audit-only via_audit_mode(title)guard. ✅tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py— 30 cases pass (≥ 8 required). Each case names its IMP-# trigger axis. ✅pytest -q tests= 337 passed in 40.86s — baseline 307 + 30 new = 337 ✓ (delta matches new file count exactly, zero pre-existing regression). ✅docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md§8 anti-patterns row referencesDORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml+ checker script + closed issues #16–#20 as L3 single-source-of-truth registry. ✅scope_lock_check:
134f52dtouches exactly the 5 planned paths (no opportunistic edits, no out-of-scope files):docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml(135 ins)scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py(191 ins)orchestrator.py(+68, 0 del)tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py(492 ins)docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md(+1, 0 del)8c1e56366b667d7d7d139ff831a16ef455caf2a2(Stage 1/2 baseline)..claude/settings.local.json,samples/uploads/,tests/matching/**, etc.); none touched by this commit.remote_state:
git ls-remote origin main=134f52d3d39b5f81dd2f6cde044e8e823d8840c1git ls-remote slide2 main=134f52d3d39b5f81dd2f6cde044e8e823d8840c1reference_design_agent_remotesdual-remote contract.goal_vs_result:
out_of_scope_preserved:
documented:no-runtime) — no entry added, no watch surface (policy decline).follow_up_links_recorded (Stage 2 follow_up_candidates re-attested, NOT executed here):
labels:
[](none set). No label policy change requested by issue body or governance doc. No-op.close_decision: PROCEED TO CLOSE — all 6 Acceptance Criteria met, scope-lock honored, both remotes synchronized, regression delta clean, follow-up candidates documented separately.
unresolved_questions: none.
guardrails (Stage 6 specific re-attestation):
DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yamlliteral cross-reference active (#57's IMP-16-U2 banner pattern not in scope here but precedent preserved).git/pytest/pythoncommand output captured during this round.evidence (commands executed in Round #1, this turn):
git rev-parse HEAD→134f52d3d39b5f81dd2f6cde044e8e823d8840c1git log --oneline -5→ confirms134f52dat HEAD, parent8c1e563git show --stat --name-status --no-patch 134f52d→ 5-file scope confirmedgit ls-tree HEAD <paths>→ 3 new files tracked under HEADgit diff 8c1e563..134f52d -- orchestrator.py→ diff begins at L855 helper insertiongit ls-remote origin main/git ls-remote slide2 main→ both134f52d…git status --porcelain=v1→ only unrelated untracked local artifactspython -c "yaml.safe_load(...)"→ 5 entries, flags: #16 m=False fu=None / #17 m=True fu=None / #18 m=False fu=None / #19 m=True fu=None / #20 m=True fu=55python scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py→ exit 0, "no dormant trigger alerts on current change surface"pytest -q tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py→ 30 passed in 0.33spytest -q tests→ 337 passed in 40.86s (baseline 307 + 30 new)/repos/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/58→ state=open, labels=[]source_comment_ids: [Claude #4] (Stage 3 Round #2 u3 implementation), [Codex #8] (Stage 4 PASS), [Codex #9] (Stage 5 commit-push PASS), [Claude #5] (this Stage 6 Round #1 verification).
commit_sha:
134f52d3d39b5f81dd2f6cde044e8e823d8840c1[Codex #10] Stage 6 final-close verification for issue #58.
Decision: CLOSE OK.
Acceptance criteria checked:
docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yamlexists and parses as 5 entries: active dormant issues #16/#17/#18/#19 plus followup-linked #20 -> #55.scripts/check_dormant_triggers.pyruns standalone from repo root, exits 0, and currently reports no dormant trigger alerts.orchestrator.pycontains_check_dormant_triggers()and invokes it only onsid == "test-verify" and not _audit_mode(title); the branch posts an informational supplement only and does notcontinueor block Stage 5.tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.pycontains 30 test cases covering IMP-16 through IMP-20, manual-evidence skip, followup-linked skip, checker behavior, orchestrator guard, and governance doc reference.DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml,scripts/check_dormant_triggers.py, Stage 4->5 informational alerting, and closed issues #16/#17/#18/#19/#20 as the L3 contract surface.134f52d3d39b5f81dd2f6cde044e8e823d8840c1touches exactly the five planned paths, with 887 insertions / 0 deletions, and bothorigin/mainandslide2/mainresolve to that SHA.pytest -q tests= 337 passed; I did not rerun the full suite at final-close because the prompt explicitly says not to run full pytest unless the stage task requires it.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git rev-parse HEADgit show --no-patch --format='%H%n%P%n%s' HEADgit diff-tree --no-commit-id --name-status -r HEADgit diff-tree --no-commit-id --numstat -r HEADgit status --porcelain=v1git ls-remote origin maingit ls-remote slide2 mainrg -n "DORMANT-TRIGGERS|_check_dormant_triggers|dormant trigger|test-verify|_audit_mode" orchestrator.py docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.pypython -YAML registry inspection snippetpytest -q tests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.pypython scripts/check_dormant_triggers.pygit diff --cached --name-statusorchestrator.pylines 850-900 and 1468-1504Files checked:
docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yamlscripts/check_dormant_triggers.pyorchestrator.pytests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.pydocs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.mdVerified facts:
134f52d3d39b5f81dd2f6cde044e8e823d8840c1; parent =8c1e56366b667d7d7d139ff831a16ef455caf2a2; subject =feat(#58): L3 dormant trigger guard -- DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml + checker + orchestrator hook.docs/architecture/DORMANT-TRIGGERS.yaml, Mdocs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md, Morchestrator.py, Ascripts/check_dormant_triggers.py, Atests/orchestrator_unit/test_dormant_triggers.py.origin/mainandslide2/mainboth resolve to134f52d3d39b5f81dd2f6cde044e8e823d8840c1.git diff --cached --name-statusis empty.[16, 17, 18, 19, 20]; active entries[16, 17, 18, 19]; manual-evidence entries[17, 19, 20]; followup entry(20, 55); statuses are fourdocumented:dormantplus onefollowup-linked.orchestrator.pylines 871-897 and 1480-1499: helper fail-opens, Stage 4->5 guard skips audit-only titles, posts informational alerts if present, and has no blockingcontinue.30 passed in 0.35s.[dormant-trigger-guard] no dormant trigger alerts on current change surface.docs/architecture/PROJECT-INTENT-AND-GOVERNANCE.md:160.FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES