IMP-27 K5 — catalog 로드 + _get_block_by_id 중복 cleanup #27
Assignees
Kyeongmin (이경민)
Clear assignees
Kyeongmin (이경민)
No Assignees
Notifications
Due Date
No due date set.
Dependencies
No dependencies set.
Reference: Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2#27
Reference in New Issue
Block a user
related module: §2.8
renderer+ §2.10block_reference+block_selector(3 module)source: INSIGHT-MAP §5 K5
priority: ↓ low (future)
scope:
_get_block_by_id중복 제거 (3 module)guardrail / validation:
trigger axis: Phase R' cleanup 또는 Phase Z catalog 확장 axis 활성 시 (soft link: IMP-04)
milestone: B-4 §4 cleanup (3) [#92]
cross-ref:
review loop:
[Claude #1] Stage 1 problem-review — IMP-27 K5 (catalog 로드 +
_get_block_by_id중복 cleanup, 3 module)1. Root cause
Three Phase Q modules each grew their own catalog loader (and two of them grew their own
_get_block_by_id) during Phase Q evolution. INSIGHT-MAP §5 K5 (docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md:151) and PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md §2.10 K5 (docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md:1087) catch this as a cleanup-only 별 axis ("Phase R' cleanup 또는 Phase Z catalog 확장 axis 활성 시 중복 제거 별도 판단"). Verified factually per RULE 5 (value + path + upstream + unknown):1-a. Three loaders, not three duplicates — shapes differ
src/block_reference.py:110_load_catalog() -> list[dict]blockslistsrc/block_reference.py(5×: L260, L324, L462, L657, L666, L713),src/fit_verifier.py(4×: L131, L840, L985, L1004),src/space_allocator.py(3×: L34, L390, L786),src/pipeline.py:228src/block_selector.py:57load_catalog() -> dict{"blocks": [...], ...})src/block_selector.pyL109, L203src/renderer.py:32_load_catalog_map() -> dict[str, str]id → template_pathmapsrc/renderer.pyL77, L126, L135src/renderer.py:69_load_catalog_map_with_variants() -> dict[str, str]"id--variant" → template_pathmapsrc/renderer.pyL126The renderer pair returns a derived projection (id → template-path string), not the catalog list. Only
block_reference._load_catalogandblock_selector.load_catalogreturn the catalog itself, and even there the shape differs (list vs root dict). So "3-module duplication" is true at the file-read + mtime-cache layer only; the return contract duplication is 2-module.1-b. Two
_get_block_by_id, different signaturessrc/block_reference.py:124_get_block_by_id(block_id: str) -> dict | None_load_catalog()callsrc/block_selector.py:78_get_block_by_id(block_id: str, catalog: dict) -> dict | Nonesrc/renderer.pyhas no_get_block_by_id— it does template-path lookup against the derived map (_load_catalog_map) instead. So the issue body's "3 module" framing for_get_block_by_idis one module off: the actual duplication is 2 module (block_reference + block_selector), and renderer is co-listed only for the loader axis.1-c. Critical contextual fact —
templates/catalog.yamlwas deleted on 2026-05-08Commit
cc2f434("cleanup: legacy templates/blocks + figma_to_html_agent block-tests / 옛 docs 정리", 2026-05-08) deletedtemplates/catalog.yaml(3605 lines), with this rationale in the commit message:templates/catalog.yaml — 위 block library 의 catalog (의존성과 같이 폐기). ... Phase Z runtime / V4 catalog 영향 0 (의존성 grep 으로 사전 검증).Verified:
ls templates/catalog.yaml→ not found (current main HEAD =2896bb6).git log -- templates/catalog.yamlshows last touch =cc2f434(deletion).src/block_reference.py:112→path = TEMPLATES_DIR / "catalog.yaml"src/block_selector.py:22→CATALOG_PATH = Path("templates/catalog.yaml")src/renderer.py:23→CATALOG_PATH = TEMPLATES_DIR / "catalog.yaml"Failure-mode mismatch among the three loaders against the deleted file:
block_selector.load_catalog(L61–63):if not CATALOG_PATH.exists(): return {"blocks": []}— graceful empty.renderer._load_catalog_map(L39, L47, L60):if CATALOG_PATH.exists()guarded + warning log — graceful empty.block_reference._load_catalog(L113): unconditionalpath.stat().st_mtime— FileNotFoundError on first invocation. No.exists()guard.The third loader (block_reference) is the de-facto-shared utility (called by fit_verifier ×4, space_allocator ×3, pipeline ×1), so an actual runtime call against the dead path would raise. The cleanup commit's grep-verification (
Phase Z runtime / V4 catalog 영향 0) implies the lazy-import call sites underphase_z2_*runtime never fire in normal Phase Z path. That implication needs re-verification in Stage 2 plan; pending that, the cleanup framing must treat this as a dead-path consolidation, not a live-loader unification.1-d. Trigger-axis status (soft link IMP-04)
Issue trigger reads "Phase R' cleanup 또는 Phase Z catalog 확장 axis 활성 시 (soft link: IMP-04)". Verified:
docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md:48) = implemented. ✓ trigger #2 met on paper.frame_contracts.yaml+frame_partialsis schema-divergent from the deleted Phase Qcatalog.yaml(block id + variant) — established by IMP-24 (block_reference.py/block_selector.py간접 catalog 로딩 / block 검색 패턴 reference; Phase Q catalog (block id + variant) ≠ Phase Z catalog (frame contract + frame partial) schema; commitb1897c0). So IMP-04 activation does not auto-justify Phase Q catalog-loader cleanup; the schemas don't connect.documented (deferred)(docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md:68); activation gate (3-cond AND: User GO ∧ B4 frame_selection evidence ∧ IMP-04/05 live) is incomplete — B4 frame_selection evidence integration is pending (CLAUDE.md "B4 frame_selection evidence integration pending"). Phase R' is quiescent, not retired.→ Strict reading: neither activation gate is fully met. The closing rationale for IMP-27 in this round is the catalog-file-deleted ground reality (§1-c), not the IMP-04 / Phase R' cleanup gate. That ground reality recasts the scope from "dedup live loaders" to "consolidate / archive dead loaders + reconcile callers". This is a material change vs the issue body and must be acknowledged in Stage 2 plan.
1-e. Caller surface in / out of scope
In K5's 3-module scope but with cross-module caller links:
block_reference._load_catalogcallers — split between Phase R' surface (block_referencehigh-level entriesselect_reference_block/generate_design_reference/select_and_generate_references= Phase R' Archive per §2.10 K1,docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md:1079) and Phase Q residual-utility surface (fit_verifier._load_catalog4×,space_allocator._load_catalog3×,pipeline._match_by_tagsat L228). The second group is NOT Phase R' archive — it is active utility code that currently would fail-fast against the dead file if reached.block_selector.load_catalogcallers — internal toblock_selectoronly.block_selectoritself is unused in pipeline.py (Phase Q-2 legacy per §2.10 K3,docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md:1083); onlyformat_candidates_for_promptis consumed bysrc/kei_client.py:454(Kei flow integration, Archive per §2.10 K2).renderer._load_catalog_map/_load_catalog_map_with_variantscallers — internal torenderer.pyonly (called from_resolve_template_pathL108 → invoked byrender_slide_from_html, which is Phase R' Archive per §2.8 auditdocs/architecture/PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md:1345"AI 가 HTML 구조 직접 생성 금지").→ Asymmetric surface: cleanup of
renderer._load_catalog_map/block_selector.load_catalogtouches Archive surface only; cleanup ofblock_reference._load_catalogtouches an active utility used by fit_verifier / space_allocator / pipeline. These two halves need different treatment, not a single "unify loaders" pass.2. Scope-lock proposal (Stage 1 — to be tightened in Stage 2)
src/block_reference.py(loader + id-lookup blocks L107–129),src/block_selector.py(CATALOG_PATH + loader + id-lookup L22–84),src/renderer.py(CATALOG_PATH + 2 loaders L23–97)src/fit_verifier.py(4 import sites: L131, L840, L985, L1004),src/space_allocator.py(3 import sites: L34, L390, L786),src/pipeline.py:228,src/kei_client.py:454phase_z2_*modules (independent Phase Z catalog path:templates/phase_z2/catalog/frame_contracts.yaml)templates/catalog.yamlno longer exists sincecc2f434; "catalog 변경 0" applies only to live catalogs that the scope chooses to read from (e.g.,templates/catalog/blocks.yamlif and only if Stage 2 explicitly chooses that path — undecided)list[dict]vs root-dictvsid→template_path); align_get_block_by_idbetween block_reference + block_selectorOut of scope (must remain untouched):
templates/phase_z2/catalog/frame_contracts.yamland Phase Z partials (IMP-04 axis — different schema).templates/catalog/blocks.yaml(Phase Y/Q' block catalog read bysrc/catalog_blocks.py/src/pipeline_v2.py:89— different schema withsource_frame/recipe_compatslots vs Phase Qid + variant).select_reference_block/generate_design_reference/select_and_generate_references/format_candidates_for_prompt) — Archive markers K1 / K2, no cleanup posture.yaml.safe_load(catalog_path)sites inblock_assembler.py,design_director.py,block_matcher_tfidf.py,block_search.py— explicitly not in K5's "3 module" surface and would expand cleanup scope without §5 cover.tests/test_catalog_invariant.py:22has its own_load_catalog) — test-only fixture, not in K5's 3-module surface.3. Guardrails / validation
templates/catalog/blocks.yamlit materially changes the catalog source — that is a separate design decision flagged in §4 open questions, NOT an automatic move).fit_verifier/space_allocator/pipeline.py:228all iterate_load_catalog()aslist[dict]of block records (verified atsrc/fit_verifier.py:132,src/space_allocator.py:37,392,713,787,825,src/pipeline.py:228+). Any unified loader MUST preservelist[dict]return for the block_reference call sites (or migrate every call site to the new shape in the same commit unit).renderer._load_catalog_mapis consumed only by_resolve_template_path(Phase R' /render_slide_from_htmlArchive). Cleanup of renderer's loader must NOT pull Phase R' Archive entry points into the active Phase Z normal path (PZ-1: AI=0 normal). If the cleanup choice is "unify loaders into a shared module", that shared module must be importable without dragging Phase R' rendering symbols.block_selectorlegacy status preserved — §2.10 K3 (docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md:1083) typesblock_selectormain filtering (select_block_candidates/select_fallback_candidates) as Phase Q-2 legacy unused with dual-path risk. K5 cleanup must NOT silently reactivate that path (e.g., by routing block_reference callers throughblock_selector.load_catalog's dict-shape).templates/phase_z2/catalog/frame_contracts.yaml. Verified atdocs/architecture/PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md:99(post-IMP-24 commitb1897c0annotated form).templates/catalog/blocks.yaml— different schema, breaks Phase Qblock id + variantcontract), (c) keep loaders as no-op with empty-return guards (block_reference gains the.exists()guard that block_selector / renderer already have). Default Stage 1 proposal: leave the decision to Stage 2 plan; do NOT pre-commit to one option in Stage 1.templates/catalog.yamlabsent — verifiedls templates/catalog.yamlreturns no entry; onlytemplates/catalog/blocks.yamlandtemplates/phase_z2/catalog/frame_contracts.yamlexist (find templates -name "*.yaml").cc2f434(2026-05-08); commit message verified to state "Phase Z runtime / V4 catalog 영향 0 (의존성 grep 으로 사전 검증)"._get_block_by_id중복 (block_reference / block_selector / §2.8 renderer 3 module). Phase R' cleanup 또는 Phase Z catalog 확장 axis 활성 시 중복 제거 별도 판단." — verified atdocs/architecture/PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md:1087.docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md:151; backlog IMP-27 row atdocs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md:94(status=pending, priority=↓ low (future), soft link IMP-04).implementedverified atdocs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md:48.documented (deferred)verified atdocs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md:68; 3-cond AND gate with "B4 frame_selection evidence" pending (CLAUDE.md confirms "B4 frame_selection evidence integration pending").Grep _load_catalog\|load_catalog\|_get_block_by_idacrosssrc/(head_limit 0): block_reference_load_catalog6 internal + 4 external (fit_verifier) + 3 external (space_allocator) + 1 external (pipeline) = 14 invocations of the same symbol; block_selectorload_catalog2 internal + 0 external; renderer_load_catalog_map3 internal + 0 external.phase_z2_*.pylazy-importblock_reference._load_catalogindirectly viafit_verifier/space_allocatorreach a runtime call? cc2f434's commit-time grep claims no; Stage 2 plan should re-run that grep at HEAD2896bb6and produce trace evidence.templates/catalog/blocks.yamlschema fit — IF Stage 2 picks option (b) (migrate unified loader to Phase Y catalog), the new shape (source_frame,slots,recipe_compat) does not match Phase Q field expectations (min_height_px,height_cost,category,relation_types,variants) consumed by fit_verifier / space_allocator / pipeline / block_reference. Option (b) likely breaks active utility callers. Recommend Stage 2 default to option (a) or (c).4. Open questions for Stage 2 plan
templates/catalog/blocks.yamlwith adapter, or (c) no-op guards. Recommended default: option (a) + (c) hybrid — remove dead callers in fit_verifier / space_allocator / pipeline (option a) and add.exists()guard to block_reference._load_catalog for any residual lazy imports (option c). This preserves the issue guardrail "catalog 변경 0 — 로드 path 만 통합" by NOT introducing a new live catalog source._get_block_by_idconsolidation contract — if cleanup keeps a no-op block_reference loader,_get_block_by_idreduces to a trivial linear search on the empty list. Two options: drop the helper entirely (option a), or keep as no-op for caller-shape stability (option c). Tied to Q1.block_selectorretirement signal — issue body listsblock_selectorin K5 scope, butblock_selectormain filtering is Phase Q-2 legacy unused (§2.10 K3) and onlyformat_candidates_for_promptis consumed bykei_client.py:454(Kei flow integration Archive per K2). Stage 2 must decide: do we (i) removeblock_selector.load_catalog+_get_block_by_identirely and leave onlyformat_candidates_for_prompt(cleaner Phase R' archive), or (ii) consolidate into a shared loader to keep symmetry?renderer._load_catalog_mapis structurally different from the loader pair (returns id→template_path). Treating it as "duplication" in the same axis as block_reference/block_selector requires either redefining the duplication (file-read + mtime layer only) or splitting the renderer cleanup into a separate sub-axis. Stage 2 should pick one framing.tests/test_catalog_invariant.py:22defines its own local_load_catalog. If the cleanup removes / repoints the 3-module loaders, what test contract validates the consolidated state? Stage 2 plan must list expected test additions / migrations (or document rationale for none).5. Stage 2 plan preview (not executed in Stage 1)
2896bb6to confirm Phase Z normal path does not invoke any of the 3 loaders (close §3 unknown #1).src/or unit test additions).tests/test_catalog_consolidation_*.py.6. Review loop posture
FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES/NObefore proceeding to Stage 2 plan.rewind_targetcandidates:stage_1_review— if scope-lock / guardrails need factual or boundary refinement (e.g., add/remove a caller from the in-scope list; tighten Phase R' isolation language).[Codex #1] Stage 1 problem-review IMP-27
Verdict: scope-lock with correction.
I verified the root cause with grep/find against the current worktree. The IMP-27 cleanup target is real, but it must be worded precisely:
The scoped 3-module duplication is the catalog read/cache/projection layer, not identical return contracts.
src/block_reference.py:110defines_load_catalog() -> list[dict], readstemplates/catalog.yaml, caches by mtime, and returnsdata["blocks"].src/block_selector.py:57definesload_catalog() -> dict, readstemplates/catalog.yaml, caches by mtime, and returns the full root dict.src/renderer.py:32defines_load_catalog_map() -> dict[str, str], readstemplates/catalog.yaml, caches by mtime, and returns an id-to-template projection.src/renderer.py:69defines_load_catalog_map_with_variants() -> dict[str, str], reads the same catalog again for variant template projection after_load_catalog_map()refreshes the cache state._get_block_by_idduplication is 2-module only.src/block_reference.py:124defines_get_block_by_id(block_id: str) -> dict | Noneand calls its own_load_catalog().src/block_selector.py:78defines_get_block_by_id(block_id: str, catalog: dict) -> dict | Noneand searches a caller-supplied catalog.src/renderer.pyhas no_get_block_by_id; it resolves template paths through_load_catalog_map()and_load_catalog_map_with_variants().Direct consumers confirm blast radius is not limited to the three files if
_load_catalog()is changed.src/block_reference.pycalls_load_catalog()internally at lines 126, 260, 657, 666, and 713;_get_block_by_id()is used at lines 324 and 462.src/fit_verifier.pyimportssrc.block_reference._load_catalogat lines 131, 840, 985, and 1004.src/space_allocator.pyimportssrc.block_reference._load_catalogat lines 34, 390, and 786, with later same-function uses at lines 713 and 825.src/pipeline.py:228imports_match_by_tagsand_load_catalog, and calls_load_catalog()at line 280.Current catalog-path fact:
templates/catalog.yamlis missing in the current worktree.Test-Path templates/catalog.yamlreturnedFalse.git log --diff-filter=D --summary -- templates/catalog.yamlshows commitcc2f4340002242cba3ac2b16186b5c330d769816deletedtemplates/catalog.yamlon 2026-05-08, with commit rationale stating Phase Z runtime / V4 catalog impact 0.templates/catalog/blocks.yamlandtemplates/phase_z2/catalog, so any implementation plan must not silently recreate or re-centralize around the deleted legacytemplates/catalog.yamlunless the Stage 2 plan explicitly justifies that compatibility layer.Documentation cross-check matches the issue trigger, with the same wording caveat.
docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md:151lists K5 as catalog load plus_get_block_by_idduplication acrossblock_reference,block_selector, andrenderer, triggered only by Phase R' cleanup or Phase Z catalog extension.docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md:1087lists the same K5 cleanup axis.docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md:94lists IMP-27 as pending low-priority future cleanup, scoped to duplicate catalog loading acrossblock_reference,block_selector, andrenderer.Scope lock for Stage 2:
templates/catalog.yamlis deleted._get_block_by_idas a 2-module helper duplication, not a renderer concern.templates/catalog.yamlreaders found in other modules such asdesign_director.py,block_assembler.py,block_search.py, andblock_matcher_tfidf.py.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
rg -n "def _load_catalog|def load_catalog|def _load_catalog_map|def _load_catalog_map_with_variants|def _get_block_by_id|catalog\\.yaml|_load_catalog\\(|load_catalog\\(|_load_catalog_map\\(" src docs templatesTest-Path -LiteralPath 'templates\\catalog.yaml'; Get-ChildItem -LiteralPath 'templates' -Forcegit log --diff-filter=D --summary -- templates/catalog.yamlrg -n "from block_reference import|import block_reference|_load_catalog\\(|_get_block_by_id\\(|load_catalog\\(|_load_catalog_map\\(|_load_catalog_map_with_variants\\(" src/block_reference.py src/block_selector.py src/renderer.py src/fit_verifier.py src/space_allocator.py src/pipeline.pySelect-String -Path src/block_reference.py,src/block_selector.py,src/renderer.py -Pattern 'def _load_catalog|def load_catalog|def _get_block_by_id|def _load_catalog_map|def _load_catalog_map_with_variants|CATALOG_PATH|TEMPLATES_DIR' -Context 0,8rg -n "K5|_load_catalog|load_catalog|catalog schema|renderer|block_reference|block_selector|Phase R|Phase Z" docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.mdSelect-String -Path src/fit_verifier.py,src/space_allocator.py,src/pipeline.py -Pattern 'from block_reference import|import block_reference|_load_catalog|_match_by_tags' -Context 0,2rg -n "_get_block_by_id" src tests docs --glob '!docs/history/**'rg -n "def _load_catalog\\(|def load_catalog\\(|def _load_catalog_map\\(|def _load_catalog_map_with_variants\\(" src --glob '!docs/history/**'rg -n "templates/catalog.yaml|catalog.yaml" tests src --glob '!docs/history/**'Files checked:
src/block_reference.pysrc/block_selector.pysrc/renderer.pysrc/fit_verifier.pysrc/space_allocator.pysrc/pipeline.pydocs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.mddocs/architecture/PHASE-Q-AUDIT.mddocs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.mdtemplates/catalog/blocks.yamltemplates/phase_z2/catalogTest results: Not run; Stage 1 explicitly says NO pytest.
Verified facts:
templates/catalog.yamldoes not exist in the current worktree.cc2f4340002242cba3ac2b16186b5c330d769816deletedtemplates/catalog.yamlon 2026-05-08._get_block_by_id; renderer does not._load_catalog()fromblock_reference.pyhas external callers infit_verifier.py,space_allocator.py, andpipeline.py, so caller compatibility is a Stage 2 requirement.FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES
[Claude #2] Stage 2 simulation-plan — IMP-27 K5 (catalog 로드 + _get_block_by_id 중복 cleanup)
=== ISSUE-BODY AXIS COVERAGE ===
block_reference._load_catalog(list[dict])block_selector.load_catalog(root dict)renderer._load_catalog_map[_with_variants](derived)block_reference._get_block_by_id(no-arg)block_selector._get_block_by_id(catalog-injected)Coverage: every §scope axis maps to ≥1 unit. PASS.
=== KEY DECISIONS (Stage 1 Q1~Q3 resolved) ===
src/catalog.py(block_reference single-responsibility 유지, asymmetric ownership 회피).get_block_by_id(block_id, catalog=None)(catalog-injected 일반형; None 시 자동 load). 두 기존 form → 1-line wrapper.=== IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS ===
summary: Create src/catalog.py shared loader (load_root_catalog, load_blocks, get_block_by_id, get_catalog_mtime) with single mtime cache primitive.
files: [src/catalog.py]
tests: [tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py]
estimate_lines: 45
summary: Delegate block_reference._load_catalog and _get_block_by_id to src.catalog; remove module-level _catalog_cache.
files: [src/block_reference.py]
tests: [tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py]
estimate_lines: 18
summary: Delegate block_selector.load_catalog and _get_block_by_id to src.catalog; remove module-level _catalog_cache/_catalog_mtime.
files: [src/block_selector.py]
tests: [tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py]
estimate_lines: 22
summary: Refactor renderer._load_catalog_map and _load_catalog_map_with_variants to consume src.catalog.load_root_catalog; keep renderer-local projection cache keyed off shared mtime.
files: [src/renderer.py]
tests: [tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py]
estimate_lines: 35
=== PER-UNIT RATIONALE ===
u1 — Sole owner of file-read + mtime cache. API subsumes both existing contracts (list-of-blocks + root-dict + caller-injected get_block_by_id). Test = 5 cases: 4 functions + mtime invalidation.
u2 — block_reference loader/helper → 1-line wrappers. Internal sites L126/260/324/462/657/666/713 byte-identical. External callers fit_verifier 4 / space_allocator 5 / pipeline 1 untouched.
u3 — block_selector loader/helper → 1-line wrappers.
[Q-2] N개 블록info log moves into shared cache-miss path (logged once per file change — observably equivalent).u4 — Projections rebuild on shared-mtime change; cache renderer-side. Sites L77/L126/L135 byte-identical. CATALOG_PATH + projection cache names retained for minimal diff.
=== OUT-OF-SCOPE ===
=== ROLLBACK ===
1 unit = 1 atomic commit. Rollback =
git revert <sha>reverse u4→u3→u2→u1. Call-site contracts preserved → behavior fully restored on revert.=== EVIDENCE ===
src/: internal — block_reference._load_catalog (5), block_reference._get_block_by_id (2), block_selector.load_catalog (2), block_selector._get_block_by_id (2), renderer._load_catalog_map (3), renderer._load_catalog_map_with_variants (1). External — fit_verifier 4 / space_allocator 5 / pipeline 1 / scripts/test_phase_q.py 1._load_catalog(not src import) → no test impact. scripts/build_block_index.py has its ownload_catalog→ out of scope.grep catalog.yaml src/.D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\. NOT verified: concurrent-mtime equivalence (Stage 1 deferred); downstream test coverage breadth (Stage 4 pytest will surface regressions).FINAL_CONSENSUS: pending Codex review
[Codex #2] Stage 2 simulation-plan review IMP-27 K5
=== IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS ===
units:
summary: Create src/catalog.py as the sole file-read + mtime-cache owner with load_root_catalog, load_blocks, get_block_by_id, and get_catalog_mtime.
files: [src/catalog.py]
tests: [tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py]
estimate_lines: 45
summary: Delegate block_reference._load_catalog and block_reference._get_block_by_id to src.catalog while preserving list[dict] and no-catalog-argument contracts.
files: [src/block_reference.py]
tests: [tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py]
estimate_lines: 18
summary: Delegate block_selector.load_catalog and block_selector._get_block_by_id to src.catalog while preserving root-dict and catalog-injected contracts.
files: [src/block_selector.py]
tests: [tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py]
estimate_lines: 22
summary: Refactor renderer._load_catalog_map and _load_catalog_map_with_variants to consume the shared root catalog while keeping renderer-local projection caches.
files: [src/renderer.py]
tests: [tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py]
estimate_lines: 35
=== PER-UNIT RATIONALE ===
u1: Covers the issue's duplicated catalog-load axis by centralizing the only shared primitive: catalog.yaml read + mtime cache. Keeps schema and path unchanged. Unit is 1 file and under 50 estimated lines.
u2: Covers block_reference list-return loader and no-argument _get_block_by_id without touching fit_verifier, space_allocator, pipeline, or internal callers. Unit is 1 file and under 50 estimated lines.
u3: Covers block_selector root-dict loader and catalog-injected _get_block_by_id while preserving existing public signatures. Unit is 1 file and under 50 estimated lines.
u4: Covers renderer projection loaders as derived maps, not new root readers, preserving id->template and id--variant->template semantics. Unit is 1 file and under 50 estimated lines.
=== OUT-OF-SCOPE ===
=== ROLLBACK STRATEGY ===
Revert the Stage 3 commit that introduces src/catalog.py and the three delegating edits; no data migration or catalog content rollback is required.
=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
Files checked:
Test results:
Verified facts:
FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES
[Claude #3] Stage 3 code-edit Round #1 — IMP-27 K5
Executing unit: u1
■ unit_executed
src/catalog.pyas the sole file-read + mtime-cache owner withload_root_catalog,load_blocks,get_block_by_id,get_catalog_mtime.■ files_changed
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\catalog.py(76 lines)D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\tests\test_catalog_shared_loader.py(171 lines, 10 tests)■ diff_summary
src/catalog.py(new module):CATALOG_PATH = Path(__file__).parent.parent / "templates" / "catalog.yaml",_catalog_cache: dict | None = None,_catalog_mtime: float = 0.0.load_root_catalog() -> dict: file-read + mtime cache. Missing file → warns and returns{"blocks": []}(matches the pre-IMP-27 behavior ofblock_selector.load_catalogandrenderer._load_catalog_map).load_blocks() -> list[dict]: returnsload_root_catalog().get("blocks", [])— the contract thatblock_reference._load_catalogwill delegate to in u2.get_block_by_id(block_id, catalog=None) -> dict | None: canonical form per Q3.catalog=Noneauto-loads (block_reference form); caller-supplied dict honored (block_selector form).get_catalog_mtime() -> float: exposes cached mtime so the renderer projection caches in u4 can key off the shared invalidation signal.tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py(new test suite, 10 tests):tmp_pathfixture +monkeypatchofCATALOG_PATHto avoid coupling tests to the deletedtemplates/catalog.yaml(see follow-up below).get_block_by_idsignatures, unknown-id → None, single-file-read invariant on cold cache, mtime invalidation triggers reload,get_catalog_mtimesemantics, missing-file →{"blocks": []}.pytest tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py -q→ 10 passed.■ scope-lock verification
block_reference.py,block_selector.py,renderer.py,fit_verifier.py,space_allocator.py,pipeline.py(those are u2/u3/u4).git status --shortfor this unit: 2 untracked files (src/catalog.py,tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py). Existing tracked files unchanged.■ remaining_units
block_reference._load_catalogandblock_reference._get_block_by_idtosrc.catalog, preservinglist[dict]and no-catalog-argument contracts.block_selector.load_catalogandblock_selector._get_block_by_idtosrc.catalog, preserving root-dict and catalog-injected contracts.renderer._load_catalog_mapand_load_catalog_map_with_variantsto consume the shared root catalog while keeping renderer-local projection caches keyed offget_catalog_mtime().■ follow_up_issue_candidates
templates/catalog.yamlwas deleted in commitcc2f434("cleanup: legacy templates/blocks") on the legacy-cleanup axis. The three loaders enumerated in Stage 1 therefore operate on a permanently-absent file in current main. Two of them (block_selector.load_catalog,renderer._load_catalog_map) already handle this gracefully;block_reference._load_catalograisesFileNotFoundError. After u2, that wrapper will inherit the graceful contract — this is the strict cleanup intent of IMP-27 and stays within "behavior-preserving" since the Phase Z runtime never reaches the raising path (percc2f434commit message: "Phase Z runtime / V4 catalog 영향 0"). No follow-up issue required; calling this out for Codex Stage 4 cross-check.src/catalog_blocks.pyis a separate loader fortemplates/catalog/blocks.yaml(Phase Z block library), unrelated to the legacytemplates/catalog.yamlchain. K5 axis does not cover it. No action.=== EVIDENCE ===
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\catalog.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\tests\test_catalog_shared_loader.pypython -m pytest tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py -q→10 passed in 0.06sgit status --short src/ tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py→ only the two new??entries):src/block_reference.py,src/block_selector.py,src/renderer.py,src/fit_verifier.py,src/space_allocator.py,src/pipeline.pyload_root_catalog→dictwith"blocks"key (test_load_root_catalog_returns_root_dict)load_blocks→list[dict](test_load_blocks_returns_list_of_block_dicts)get_block_by_id(id)no-arg form (test_get_block_by_id_without_catalog_arg)get_block_by_id(id, catalog)injected form (test_get_block_by_id_with_catalog_arg_preserves_block_selector_contract)[Codex #3] Stage 3 code-edit review IMP-27 K5
Verdict: u1 is correct and scope-locked. Continue with the remaining implementation units.
Verified unit:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\catalog.pywithload_root_catalog,load_blocks,get_block_by_id, andget_catalog_mtime.load_root_catalog()owns the catalog file-read plus mtime cache and usesD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\templates\catalog.yamlas the unified path.load_blocks()preserves thelist[dict]projection needed by the futureblock_reference._load_catalogwrapper.get_block_by_id(block_id, catalog=None)supports both no-catalog auto-load and catalog-injected lookup forms.get_catalog_mtime()exposes the cached mtime for the future renderer projection cache refactor.None, singleyaml.safe_loadon warm cache, mtime invalidation, cached mtime semantics, and missing-file fallback.Scope qualification:
src\block_reference.py,src\block_selector.py, andsrc\renderer.pystill contain their old loaders; that is expected because u2, u3, and u4 remain.git status --shortclaim. This does not invalidate u1.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
Get-Content -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\catalog.py'Get-Content -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\tests\test_catalog_shared_loader.py'rg -n "def (_load_catalog|load_catalog|_load_catalog_map|_load_catalog_map_with_variants|_get_block_by_id)|_catalog_cache|_catalog_mtime|from src\.catalog|import catalog" src testsGet-Content -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\block_reference.py' -TotalCount 140Get-Content -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\block_selector.py' -TotalCount 100Get-Content -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\renderer.py' -TotalCount 110git ls-files --error-unmatch src/catalog.py tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.pypytest tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py -qgit diff --name-onlyTest-Path -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\templates\catalog.yaml'rg -n '^(CATALOG_PATH|def (load_root_catalog|load_blocks|get_block_by_id|get_catalog_mtime))|yaml\.safe_load|return \{"blocks": \[\]\}' src/catalog.py tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.pyFiles checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\catalog.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\tests\test_catalog_shared_loader.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\block_reference.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\block_selector.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\renderer.pyTest results:
pytest tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py -q=>10 passed in 0.06sVerified facts:
src/catalog.pyandtests/test_catalog_shared_loader.pyare not tracked yet, matching new-file u1 scope.git diff --name-onlyreturned no tracked modified files.templates/catalog.yamldoes not currently exist, and the new tests verify the missing-file empty catalog fallback.block_reference,block_selector, andrendererare unchanged and remain for u2-u4 delegation.Remaining units: [u2, u3, u4]
rewind_target: continue_same
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #4] Stage 3 code-edit Round #2 — IMP-27 K5
Executing unit: u2
■ unit_executed
block_reference._load_catalogandblock_reference._get_block_by_idtosrc.catalog, preservinglist[dict]and no-catalog-argument contracts. Drop the module-level_catalog_cachedict and the deadyamlimport.■ files_changed
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\block_reference.py(+7 / -20, 1 file, 27 lines net delta)D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\tests\test_catalog_shared_loader.py(+57, 4 new tests appended)■ diff_summary
src/block_reference.py:import yaml(no remaining yaml.* call site in this module).from src import catalog as _catalog_mod(single delegation entry point).TEMPLATES_DIR,Path,Anyretained (still used by Jinja env L38, raw template read L490, and ~10 type annotations).L129, now L104L116):_catalog_cache: dict[str, Any] = {"data": None, "mtime": 0}._load_catalog() -> list[dict]shrunk to 1-line wrapper:return _catalog_mod.load_blocks(). Preserves the exactlist[dict]return contract thatfit_verifier/space_allocator/pipelineimport as_load_catalog(8 lazy-import call sites total — see scope-lock evidence below)._get_block_by_id(block_id) -> dict | Noneshrunk to 1-line wrapper:return _catalog_mod.get_block_by_id(block_id). Preserves the no-catalog-argument signature consumed atblock_reference.py:324andblock_reference.py:462.카탈로그 로딩 (mtime 캐싱)→카탈로그 로딩 (IMP-27: src.catalog 공유 로더 위임)so future readers locate the delegation, not a now-empty cache layer.tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py(4 new tests appended after the u1 block):test_block_reference_load_catalog_returns_list_of_blocks— verifies thelist[dict]contract is preserved through the wrapper (matches fit_verifier / space_allocator / pipeline expectation).test_block_reference_get_block_by_id_no_arg_signature— verifies the no-catalog-arg form still resolves an id and returnsNonefor unknown ids.test_block_reference_shares_cache_with_shared_loader— usesmonkeypatchoncatalog_mod.yaml.safe_loadto count file reads; asserts thatblock_reference._load_catalog()+block_reference._get_block_by_id(...)+catalog.load_root_catalog()together produce exactly 1 file read. This is the regression guard for "no private _catalog_cache in block_reference".test_block_reference_has_no_private_catalog_cache— explicithasattrguard against_catalog_cachere-introduction.■ verification
python -m pytest tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py -q→ 14 passed in 0.09s (10 u1 tests + 4 u2 delegation tests).python -c "from src.block_reference import _load_catalog, _get_block_by_id"→ resolves; both callable.fit_verifier/space_allocator/pipelinepattern):from src.block_reference import _load_catalog; _load_catalog()→ returnslist(contract preserved). Note:templates/catalog.yamlis currently absent (deleted incc2f434), so the call returns[]via shared loader's missing-file fallback rather than the oldFileNotFoundError— see scope-qualified note below.■ scope-lock verification (Stage 1 contract)
_load_catalog: preserved (test_block_reference_load_catalog_returns_list_of_blocks)._get_block_by_id: preserved (test_block_reference_get_block_by_id_no_arg_signature).templates/catalog.yaml).src/block_reference.pyheader + loader section edited)._load_catalog()→ resolve to same shared loader; no signature change._get_block_by_id(block_id)→ no signature change.fit_verifier.py:131,840,985,1004,space_allocator.py:34,390,786,pipeline.py:228) all dofrom src.block_reference import _load_catalog; symbol still exists with identical signature → byte-identical at the call site.■ scope-qualified notes (not scope creep, flagged for transparency per RULE 5 factual-verification)
block_reference._load_catalograisedFileNotFoundErroron missingtemplates/catalog.yaml(no.exists()guard at the old L113, surfaced by Stage 1 problem-review). Post-u2, the shared loader returns{"blocks": []}and the wrapper returns[]. This unifies behavior withblock_selector.load_catalogandrenderer._load_catalog_mapwhich already returned empty on missing file. Stage 1 explicitly framed this as part of "file-read + mtime-cache layer 3 모듈 중복" consolidation; return contract (list[dict]) is unchanged. Sincetemplates/catalog.yamlis currently deleted (cc2f434), no active runtime path exercises the missing-file branch — all 8 external lazy importers are themselves dead-import surfaces already flagged in Stage 1.yamlimport removed from block_reference: confirmed unused after delegation viagrep -n "yaml" src/block_reference.py→ only "catalog.yaml" string in docstring/comments remain. No other module importsyamlfromblock_reference(only the loader used it).■ remaining_units
block_selector.load_catalogandblock_selector._get_block_by_idtosrc.catalog, preserving root-dict and catalog-injected contracts; drop module-level_catalog_cache/_catalog_mtime.renderer._load_catalog_mapand_load_catalog_map_with_variantsto consume the shared root catalog while keeping renderer-local projection caches keyed offget_catalog_mtime().■ follow_up_issue_candidates
templates/catalog.yamlitself is absent. All eight external lazy importers (fit_verifier4,space_allocator3,pipeline1) now resolve to alistreturning[]. Whether to (a) delete those dead imports, (b) repoint totemplates/catalog/blocks.yaml, or (c) keep the no-op guard is an axis already noted in Stage 1 unresolved-questions discussion. Out of u2 scope; flagged for follow-up issue if the project wants to remove the legacy callers entirely.unit_executed: u2
files_changed: src/block_reference.py, tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py
remaining_units: [u3, u4]
follow_up_issue_candidates: [F-1 (carry-over from u1 — legacy block_reference._load_catalog lazy importers in fit_verifier / space_allocator / pipeline now resolve to empty list[dict])]
[Codex #4] Stage 3 code-edit review IMP-27 K5
Verdict: u2 is correct and scope-locked. Continue with the remaining implementation units.
Verified unit:
src.block_reference._load_catalog()tosrc.catalog.load_blocks(), preserving the no-argumentlist[dict]contract used by existing callers.src.block_reference._get_block_by_id(block_id)tosrc.catalog.get_block_by_id(block_id), preserving the no-catalog-argument lookup contract.src.block_referenceno longer importsyamland no longer defines its own_catalog_cache.tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.pyand pass together with the u1 shared-loader tests.Scope qualification:
src/block_selector.pyandsrc/renderer.pyare still unchanged; that is expected because u3 and u4 remain.src/fit_verifier.py,src/space_allocator.py, andsrc/pipeline.pycall sites remain untouched and still call_load_catalog()with no arguments.templates/catalog.yamlcontent was changed.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git diff -- src/block_reference.py tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.pyrg -n "import yaml|from src import catalog|_catalog_cache|def _load_catalog|def _get_block_by_id|yaml\\." src/block_reference.py tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.pyGet-Content -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\block_reference.py' -TotalCount 150Get-Content -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\tests\test_catalog_shared_loader.py'python -m pytest tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py -qrg -n "_load_catalog\\(|_get_block_by_id\\(" src/block_reference.py src/fit_verifier.py src/space_allocator.py src/pipeline.pygit status --short -- src/catalog.py tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py src/block_reference.py src/block_selector.py src/renderer.py src/fit_verifier.py src/space_allocator.py src/pipeline.py templates/catalog.yamlpython -c "from src.block_reference import _load_catalog, _get_block_by_id; import inspect; print(inspect.signature(_load_catalog)); print(inspect.signature(_get_block_by_id))"Test-Path -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\drafts\27_stage_code-edit_codex_r2.md'Files checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\block_reference.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\tests\test_catalog_shared_loader.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\fit_verifier.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\space_allocator.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\pipeline.pyTest results:
python -m pytest tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py -q=>14 passed in 0.08sVerified facts:
src/block_reference.pyimportsfrom src import catalog as _catalog_mod.src/block_reference.pyhas noimport yaml, noyaml.*call, and no_catalog_cachedefinition.src/block_reference.pydefines_load_catalog() -> list[dict]as a wrapper around_catalog_mod.load_blocks().src/block_reference.pydefines_get_block_by_id(block_id: str) -> dict | Noneas a wrapper around_catalog_mod.get_block_by_id(block_id).() -> 'list[dict]'and(block_id: 'str') -> 'dict | None'.src/fit_verifier.py,src/space_allocator.py, andsrc/pipeline.pystill use no-argument_load_catalog()call sites.M src/block_reference.py,?? src/catalog.py, and?? tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py; no scoped changes are present forsrc/block_selector.py,src/renderer.py,src/fit_verifier.py,src/space_allocator.py,src/pipeline.py, ortemplates/catalog.yaml.Remaining units: [u3, u4]
rewind_target: continue_same
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #5] Stage 3 code-edit Round #3 — IMP-27 K5
Executing unit: u3
■ unit_executed
block_selector.load_catalogandblock_selector._get_block_by_idtosrc.catalog, preserving the root-dict and catalog-injected contracts. Drop module-levelCATALOG_PATH,_catalog_cache,_catalog_mtime, and the now-unusedyaml/pathlib.Pathimports.■ files_changed
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\block_selector.py(+7 / -32 net,git diff --statconfirms)D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\tests\test_catalog_shared_loader.py(+71, 4 new tests appended after the u2 block)■ diff_summary
src/block_selector.py:from pathlib import Path(only consumer was the deletedCATALOG_PATH).import yaml(only consumer was the deletedload_catalogbody).from src import catalog as _catalog_mod(single delegation entry point — mirrors the u2 wiring inblock_reference.py:30).from typing import Anyretained (still used bytopic: dict[str, Any]inselect_block_candidates).from src.space_allocator import ContainerSpec, HEIGHT_COST_ORDERretained.CATALOG_PATH = Path("templates/catalog.yaml")._catalog_cache: dict | None = None._catalog_mtime: float = 0.0.L83, now L51L58):load_catalog() -> dictshrunk to 1-line wrapper:return _catalog_mod.load_root_catalog(). Preserves the root-dict return contract consumed byselect_block_candidates(L83 → L86 of the new file),select_fallback_candidates(post-edit L177 region),scripts/test_phase_q.py:26(external importfrom src.block_selector import ... load_catalog), and theformat_candidates_for_promptcaller chain._get_block_by_id(block_id: str, catalog: dict) -> dict | Noneshrunk to 1-line wrapper:return _catalog_mod.get_block_by_id(block_id, catalog). Preserves the catalog-injected signature (positionalcatalogrequired by the existing definition; the canonicalsrc.catalog.get_block_by_idaccepts a positionalcatalogso the wrapper is byte-equivalent at call sites).catalog.yaml 로딩 (mtime 캐시)→catalog.yaml 로딩 (IMP-27: src.catalog 공유 로더 위임)so future readers locate the delegation, not a now-deleted local cache.tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py(4 new tests appended after the u2 block, lines 237~303):test_block_selector_load_catalog_returns_root_dict— verifies the root-dict contract (isinstance(root, dict),"blocks" in root,isinstance(root["blocks"], list)) is preserved through the wrapper. This is the contract thatselect_block_candidates(catalog=None)andscripts/test_phase_q.py:26rely on.test_block_selector_get_block_by_id_catalog_injected_signature— verifies the catalog-injected form still resolves an id from a caller-supplied dict and returnsNonefor unknown ids (assertsblock_selector._get_block_by_id(block_id, catalog_dict)still accepts positional catalog).test_block_selector_shares_cache_with_shared_loader— usesmonkeypatchoncatalog_mod.yaml.safe_loadto count file reads; asserts thatblock_selector.load_catalog()+block_selector._get_block_by_id(...)+catalog.load_root_catalog()together produce exactly 1 file read. This is the regression guard for "no private_catalog_cacheinblock_selector".test_block_selector_has_no_private_catalog_cache— explicithasattrguards against re-introduction of_catalog_cache,_catalog_mtime, orCATALOG_PATHon theblock_selectormodule.■ scope-lock verification
src/block_selector.py+ test file. No edits tosrc/renderer.py(u4) or any caller-side file (src/kei_client.py:454,scripts/test_phase_q.py:26).git diff --name-only -- src/ tests/lists onlysrc/block_reference.py(u2 carry-over from Round #2; unchanged this round) andsrc/block_selector.py.tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.pyandsrc/catalog.pyremain untracked (u1 carry-over). No spurious file in scope.src.catalog.CATALOG_PATHis the single source of truth and is unchanged.python -c "from src.block_selector import load_catalog, _get_block_by_id; import inspect; print(inspect.signature(load_catalog), inspect.signature(_get_block_by_id))"→() -> 'dict'and(block_id: 'str', catalog: 'dict') -> 'dict | None'— byte-identical to the pre-IMP-27 signatures.rg -n "block_selector\\.(CATALOG_PATH|_catalog_cache|_catalog_mtime)|from src\\.block_selector import.*(CATALOG_PATH|_catalog_cache|_catalog_mtime)" --include="*.py" .→ only the new u3 guard test lines (303). No other code in the repo depends on the removed symbols, so no caller-side update is required.■ verification
python -m pytest tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py -q→ 18 passed in 0.26s (10 u1 tests + 4 u2 tests + 4 u3 tests).python -c "from src.block_selector import load_catalog, _get_block_by_id, select_block_candidates, format_candidates_for_prompt"→ resolves; full public surface importable.git diff --stat -- src/block_selector.py→1 file changed, 7 insertions(+), 32 deletions(-). Net delta consistent with "delegate + drop local cache" — no scope creep.git status --short -- src/block_selector.py tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py src/catalog.py→M src/block_selector.py,?? tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py,?? src/catalog.py. Consistent with cumulative state across u1+u2+u3.■ remaining_units
renderer._load_catalog_mapand_load_catalog_map_with_variantsto consume the shared root catalog while keeping renderer-local projection caches keyed offsrc.catalog.get_catalog_mtime().■ follow_up_issue_candidates
templates/catalog.yamlwas deleted incc2f434during a legacy block library cleanup; the loader contract still exists for any remaining Phase Q call sites but no production catalog file is present) remains informational — outside IMP-27 K5 scope; surface separately if any Phase Q runtime path actually needs a populated catalog.scope-lock retained. Awaiting Codex u3 review before proceeding to u4.
[Codex #5] Stage 3 code-edit review IMP-27 K5
Verdict: u3 is correct and scope-locked. Continue with the remaining implementation unit.
Verified unit:
src.block_selector.load_catalog()tosrc.catalog.load_root_catalog(), preserving the no-argument root-dict contract used internally and byscripts/test_phase_q.py.src.block_selector._get_block_by_id(block_id, catalog)tosrc.catalog.get_block_by_id(block_id, catalog), preserving the catalog-injected signature.src.block_selectorno longer importsyamlorpathlib.Path, and no longer definesCATALOG_PATH,_catalog_cache, or_catalog_mtime.tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.pyand pass together with the existing u1 and u2 tests.Scope qualification:
src/renderer.pyis still unchanged; that is expected because u4 remains.src/fit_verifier.py,src/space_allocator.py, andsrc/pipeline.pycall sites remain untouched.templates/catalog.yamlcontent was changed.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git diff -- src/block_selector.py tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.pyrg -n "from pathlib import Path|import yaml|from src import catalog|CATALOG_PATH|_catalog_cache|_catalog_mtime|def load_catalog|def _get_block_by_id|yaml\." src/block_selector.py tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.pyGet-Content -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\block_selector.py' -TotalCount 120Get-Content -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\tests\test_catalog_shared_loader.py'python -m pytest tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py -qrg -n "load_catalog\(|_get_block_by_id\(" src/block_selector.py scripts tests src | sortpython -c "from src.block_selector import load_catalog, _get_block_by_id; import inspect; print(inspect.signature(load_catalog)); print(inspect.signature(_get_block_by_id))"git status --short -- src/catalog.py tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py src/block_reference.py src/block_selector.py src/renderer.py src/fit_verifier.py src/space_allocator.py src/pipeline.py templates/catalog.yamlrg -n "from src\.block_selector import|import .*block_selector|select_block_candidates|select_fallback_candidates|load_catalog" scripts/test_phase_q.py src/block_selector.pyrg -n "from pathlib import Path|import yaml|CATALOG_PATH|_catalog_cache|_catalog_mtime|yaml\." src/block_selector.pygit diff -- src/renderer.pyFiles checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\block_selector.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\tests\test_catalog_shared_loader.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\scripts\test_phase_q.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\renderer.pyTest results:
python -m pytest tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py -q=>18 passed in 0.08sVerified facts:
src/block_selector.pyimportsfrom src import catalog as _catalog_mod.load_catalog() -> dictreturns_catalog_mod.load_root_catalog()._get_block_by_id(block_id: str, catalog: dict) -> dict | Nonereturns_catalog_mod.get_block_by_id(block_id, catalog).src/block_selector.pyhas noyaml,Path,CATALOG_PATH,_catalog_cache, or_catalog_mtimematches.scripts/test_phase_q.pystill imports and callsload_catalog()with no arguments.src/renderer.pyhas no diff in this unit and remains for u4.Remaining units: [u4]
rewind_target: continue_same
FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO
[Claude #6] Stage 3 code-edit Round #4 — IMP-27 K5
Executing unit: u4
■ unit_executed
renderer._load_catalog_mapand_load_catalog_map_with_variantsto consume the shared root catalog viasrc.catalog.load_blocks(), keep renderer-local projection caches, and key projection invalidation offsrc.catalog.get_catalog_mtime(). Droprenderer.CATALOG_PATH, theyamlimport, and the legacy single_CATALOG_MTIMEmodule global; replace with per-projection keys_CATALOG_MAP_MTIME/_CATALOG_VARIANT_MAP_MTIME.■ files_changed
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\renderer.py(+39 / -49, net -10 lines pergit diff --stat)D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\tests\test_catalog_shared_loader.py(+109, fixture extended + 5 new u4 tests appended; file remains untracked from u1)■ diff_summary
src/renderer.py:import yaml(no remainingyaml.*call site in this module).from src import catalog as _catalog_mod(single delegation entry point — mirrors u2 wiring atblock_reference.py:30and u3 wiring atblock_selector.py).from collections import OrderedDict,from pathlib import Path,from typing import Any,from jinja2 import Environment, FileSystemLoader, andloggerretained (still used byTEMPLATES_DIRL21,STATIC_DIRL22,OrderedDictgroup grouping later in the file, Jinja env, and type hints).L30, L65L66 → now L20~L26):CATALOG_PATH = TEMPLATES_DIR / "catalog.yaml"(path lives insrc.catalog.CATALOG_PATHonly)._CATALOG_MTIME: float = 0.0(single legacy key — replaced by per-projection keys so the two projections invalidate independently and correctly underget_catalog_mtime()keying)._CATALOG_MAP_MTIME: float = 0.0and_CATALOG_VARIANT_MAP_MTIME: float = 0.0(renderer-local projection cache keys; values come from_catalog_mod.get_catalog_mtime())._CATALOG_MAP: dict[str, str] | None = Noneretained (projection cache)._CATALOG_VARIANT_MAP: dict[str, str] | None = Noneretained (projection cache); moved up next to its mtime key (formerly L65L66, now L25L26) so both projection caches sit together.catalog.yaml에서 id → template 경로 매핑 로드 (BF-10: mtime 체크로 자동 갱신)→id → template 경로 매핑 (IMP-27: src.catalog 공유 로더 위임, renderer-local projection cache)._load_catalog_map() -> dict[str, str](formerly L32L62, now L29L55):_catalog_mod.load_blocks()for raw data and_catalog_mod.get_catalog_mtime()for the cache key; projection map rebuild iterates the returnedlist[dict]and writesid → template.open(CATALOG_PATH, ...),yaml.safe_load, the missing-file warning, the exception swallowing) fully removed — those concerns now live insrc.catalog.load_root_catalog.dict[str, str]keyed by block id. Logging linecatalog.yaml 로드: {N}개 블록 매핑preserved (callers / log monitors unaffected)._load_catalog_map_with_variants() -> dict[str, str](formerly L69L97, now L58L80):_catalog_mod.load_blocks()directly. Removed the redundant_load_catalog_map()pre-call (the variant cache now keys offget_catalog_mtime()independently, so the side-effectful "force the other cache to refresh" trick is no longer needed).open(CATALOG_PATH, ...)+yaml.safe_loadblock — single shared file read enforced bysrc.catalog.dict[str, str]keyed by"block_id--variant_id", excludingdefaultvariants. Verified bytest_renderer_load_catalog_map_with_variants_returns_compound_key_dictbelow.tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py:fixture-block-bnow carriesvariantswith adefaultand acompactentry, enabling the variant projection test to exercise thedefault-exclusion rule (preserves pre-IMP-27 behavior inrenderer._load_catalog_map_with_variants)._reset_renderer_projection_cache()helper added (lines 47~53) and called from thefixture_catalog_pathfixture (line 65) so each test starts with both renderer-local projection caches cleared. Without this, the module-level state would leak across tests.test_renderer_load_catalog_map_returns_id_to_template_dict— verifiesid → templateprojection contract (matches existing callers_resolve_template_pathat L135 of the new renderer).test_renderer_load_catalog_map_with_variants_returns_compound_key_dict— verifies"id--variant" → templateprojection, with explicit assertion thatdefaultvariants are excluded.test_renderer_shares_cache_with_shared_loader— monkeypatchessrc.catalog.yaml.safe_loadto count file reads; asserts thatrenderer._load_catalog_map()+renderer._load_catalog_map_with_variants()+catalog.load_root_catalog()together produce exactly 1 file read. This is the regression guard for "renderer must not reopen the catalog file".test_renderer_projection_invalidates_when_shared_mtime_changes— rewrites the fixture file, bumps mtime, resetssrc.catalog._catalog_cache, and asserts thatrenderer._load_catalog_map()returns the new contents. Locks the contract "renderer projection cache keyed offsrc.catalog.get_catalog_mtime()".test_renderer_has_no_private_catalog_path_or_yaml— explicithasattrguards against re-introduction ofCATALOG_PATH,yaml, and the legacy_CATALOG_MTIMEsingle-key.■ verification (scope = u4 only)
python -m pytest tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py -q→ 23 passed in 0.14s (10 u1 + 4 u2 + 4 u3 + 5 u4).python -c "from src.renderer import _load_catalog_map, _load_catalog_map_with_variants; m=_load_catalog_map(); v=_load_catalog_map_with_variants()"→ resolves; both callable. Logged the expectedcatalog.yaml 미발견warning (current repo state:templates/catalog.yamldeleted incc2f434, same precondition as u1 fixture-mode tests).python -c "import src.renderer as r; for n in ('CATALOG_PATH','yaml','_CATALOG_MTIME','_CATALOG_MAP_MTIME','_CATALOG_VARIANT_MAP_MTIME'): print(n, hasattr(r,n))"→CATALOG_PATH False,yaml False,_CATALOG_MTIME False,_CATALOG_MAP_MTIME True,_CATALOG_VARIANT_MAP_MTIME True. Confirms scope-lock: legacy state gone, new per-projection mtime keys present.git diff --stat -- src/renderer.py→1 file changed, 39 insertions(+), 49 deletions(-).git status --shortfor this unit:M src/renderer.py,?? tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py(untracked since u1). No other tracked files modified.■ scope-lock verification
src/catalog.py,src/block_reference.py,src/block_selector.py,src/fit_verifier.py,src/space_allocator.py,src/pipeline.py._load_catalog_map(L77 → now L126 region inside_resolve_template_path) and_load_catalog_map_with_variants(L126 region) preserved as no-arg calls returningdict[str, str]— verified by re-grep_load_catalog_map\(insrc/renderer.py→ unchanged signatures at the call site.src.catalogintroduced in u1 is loader-only and pulls no Phase R' rendering symbols.■ remaining_units
■ follow_up_issue_candidates
templates/catalog.yamlwas deleted incc2f434("legacy block library cleanup"). All four loaders (src.catalog+ the three wrappers) gracefully return empty ({"blocks": []}/[]/{}); production behavior is unchanged because no live caller currently requires populated content from that path. Not in IMP-27 scope — IMP-04 (Phase R' / Phase Z catalog re-introduction axis) is the natural home for any re-population decision. Already filed as F-1 in r1.src/renderer.pystill has liveOrderedDict/Path/Any/ Jinja imports, but the legacy_CATALOG_MTIMErename to per-projection keys reveals that the renderer-local projection caches duplicate a pattern that could itself be hoisted intosrc.catalog(e.g. a genericprojection_cache(name, builder)helper). Not in IMP-27 scope — IMP-27 K5 axis is loader unification only; projection-cache helper extraction is a candidate for a follow-up cleanup axis ifsrc.rendererand any future projection consumer end up sharing >2 such caches. Filing for awareness only; do not open a new issue unless triggered.[Codex #6] Stage 3 code-edit review IMP-27 K5
Verdict: u4 is correct and scope-locked. All planned Stage 3 implementation units are now complete.
Verified unit:
src.renderer._load_catalog_map()andsrc.renderer._load_catalog_map_with_variants()to the shared catalog loader throughsrc.catalog.load_blocks().dict[id, template_path]anddict["id--variant", template_path].src.catalog.get_catalog_mtime().src.rendererno longer importsyaml, no longer definesCATALOG_PATH, and no longer uses the legacy single_CATALOG_MTIMEglobal.tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.pyand pass together with the u1, u2, and u3 tests.Scope qualification:
src/fit_verifier.py,src/space_allocator.py, andsrc/pipeline.pycall sites remain untouched.templates/catalog.yamlcontent was changed.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git diff -- src/renderer.py tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.pyrg -n "import yaml|from src import catalog|CATALOG_PATH|_CATALOG_MTIME|_CATALOG_MAP_MTIME|_CATALOG_VARIANT_MAP_MTIME|def _load_catalog_map|def _load_catalog_map_with_variants|yaml\.|load_blocks\(|get_catalog_mtime\(" src/renderer.py tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.pyGet-Content -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\renderer.py' -TotalCount 180Get-Content -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\tests\test_catalog_shared_loader.py'python -m pytest tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py -qpython -c "from src.renderer import _load_catalog_map, _load_catalog_map_with_variants; import inspect; print(inspect.signature(_load_catalog_map)); print(inspect.signature(_load_catalog_map_with_variants))"rg -n "_load_catalog_map\(|_load_catalog_map_with_variants\(" src/renderer.py src tests scriptsGet-Content -LiteralPath 'D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\catalog.py'git status --short -- src/catalog.py tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py src/block_reference.py src/block_selector.py src/renderer.py src/fit_verifier.py src/space_allocator.py src/pipeline.py templates/catalog.yamlsrc.catalog.CATALOG_PATHto a temp catalog, callrenderer._load_catalog_map(), rewrite the catalog with a newer mtime, callrenderer._load_catalog_map()again, and confirm the projection changes from{'a': 'blocks/a.html'}to{'b': 'blocks/b.html'}Files checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\renderer.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\tests\test_catalog_shared_loader.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\catalog.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\fit_verifier.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\space_allocator.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\pipeline.pyTest results:
python -m pytest tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py -q=>23 passed in 0.11sVerified facts:
src.rendererimportsfrom src import catalog as _catalog_mod._load_catalog_map() -> dict[str, str]calls_catalog_mod.load_blocks()and_catalog_mod.get_catalog_mtime()._load_catalog_map_with_variants() -> dict[str, str]calls_catalog_mod.load_blocks()and_catalog_mod.get_catalog_mtime().src.renderer.src.rendererhas noimport yaml, noyaml.*call, noCATALOG_PATH, and no_CATALOG_MTIME.git status --short -- ...reports only the expected IMP-27 files changed or untracked:src/catalog.py,tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py,src/block_reference.py,src/block_selector.py, andsrc/renderer.py.Remaining units: none
FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES
[Claude #7] Stage 4 test-verify — IMP-27 K5 catalog cleanup Round #1
검증 결과 요약 (Korean)
src/catalog.py) + 3 wrapper module + 23 unit case + 365 broader regression case 모두 GREEN.src/catalog.py(NEW, 77 lines),src/block_reference.py(-15 / +6, net -9),src/block_selector.py(-30 / +9, net -21),src/renderer.py(-49 / +39, net -10),tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py(NEW, 422 lines).src/catalog.py단독 소유 (block_search.py는 IMP-27 Stage 1 scope 외;phase_z2_*의 yaml import 는 다른 catalog 파일들 = frame_contracts / layouts / region_layouts / display_strategies, IMP-27 templates/catalog.yaml 과 별 데이터).=== EVIDENCE ===
1. Targeted test run
23 / 23 PASS. 분포:
id → templateprojection /id--variant → templateprojection / shared cache / projection invalidation on shared mtime change / private CATALOG_PATH+yaml+legacy _CATALOG_MTIME absence.2. Broader regression check (commit scope)
365 / 365 PASS (test 수집 시점).
tests/matching/**는 Stage 1 scope 외 (별 axis — V1~V4 매칭 시스템) — 의식적 제외.3. Signature preservation check
Stage 1 exit report의 6 wrapper contract 와 byte-identical.
4. Call-site enumeration (caller import 보존)
src/fit_verifier.pyL131, L840, L985, L1004)src/space_allocator.pyL34, L390, L786) + 추가 module-level grep 5src/pipeline.pyL228)(line 번호는 Stage 1 snapshot 시점과 동일 — caller 파일 unchanged.)
5. Hardcoding / RULE 7 check
templates/catalog.yaml경로 + mtime cache state grep:src/catalog.pysrc/block_reference.pysrc/block_selector.pyCATALOG_PATH)src/renderer.pyCATALOG_PATH)import yaml)_CATALOG_MTIME→ projection-local_CATALOG_MAP_MTIME/_CATALOG_VARIANT_MAP_MTIME)src/block_search.pysrc/phase_z2_composition.py/_mapper.py/_pipeline.pyRULE 7 (no hardcoding) PASS — 경로/cache 가 process-level 단일 owner 로 통합되었고 wrapper 는 1-line delegation.
6. Scope-lock guardrail (RULE 4)
src/catalog.py(NEW) +src/block_reference.py+src/block_selector.py+src/renderer.py+tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py(NEW). Stage 2 plan 의 5 path 와 정확 일치.7. Out-of-scope follow-up 후보 (Stage 3 exit report에 명시 — 본 verify에서 작업 X)
src/fit_verifier.py/src/space_allocator.py/src/pipeline.py는 본 issue Stage 1 의 scope_lock 에서 명시적 제외 — caller만, 자체 로딩 코드 없음.tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.pytracking 여부 = Stage 5 commit boundary 질문 (verify 단계 결정 사항 아님).판정
PASS — Stage 4 verify Round #1 통과.
다음 단계: Codex #7 재검증 → 통과 시 Stage 5 (commit + push).
[Codex #7] Stage 4 test-verify IMP-27 K5 Round #1
Decision: PASS; commit OK signal.
Scope-qualified verification completed for the IMP-27 commit scope. I found no blocking discrepancy in the implementation, signatures, call-site preservation, catalog path ownership, or tests. One non-blocking bookkeeping correction: the previous raw line-count claim for the two new files does not reproduce in this workspace (
src/catalog.py= 76 lines,tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py= 421 lines byGet-Content), so I am not using that count as a pass criterion.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git status --shortgit diff -- src/catalog.py src/block_reference.py src/block_selector.py src/renderer.py tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.pyrg -n "def _load_catalog|def load_catalog|def _load_catalog_map|def _load_catalog_map_with_variants|def _get_block_by_id|CATALOG_PATH|import yaml|_CATALOG_MTIME|_CATALOG_MAP_MTIME|_CATALOG_VARIANT_MAP_MTIME|load_blocks\(|get_catalog_mtime\(" src tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.pyGet-Content -LiteralPath 'src\catalog.py'rg -n "from src\.block_reference import _load_catalog|_load_catalog\(|load_catalog\(|_get_block_by_id\(|_load_catalog_map\(|_load_catalog_map_with_variants\(" src\fit_verifier.py src\space_allocator.py src\pipeline.py src\block_reference.py src\block_selector.py src\renderer.pygit diff -- src/fit_verifier.py src/space_allocator.py src/pipeline.pypython -m pytest tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py -vpython -m pytest tests/ -q --ignore=tests/matchingpython -signature inspection for the six public/private wrapper functionsgit diff --stat -- src/block_reference.py src/block_selector.py src/renderer.pyGet-Contentline counts forsrc\catalog.pyandtests\test_catalog_shared_loader.pygit diff -- templates/catalog.yaml src/fit_verifier.py src/space_allocator.py src/pipeline.pyFiles checked:
D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\catalog.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\block_reference.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\block_selector.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\renderer.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\tests\test_catalog_shared_loader.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\fit_verifier.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\space_allocator.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\pipeline.pyD:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\templates\catalog.yamlTest results:
python -m pytest tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py -v: 23 passed in 0.12s.python -m pytest tests/ -q --ignore=tests/matching: 365 passed in 37.80s.Verified facts:
src.catalogis the sharedtemplates/catalog.yamlfile-read + mtime-cache owner for the IMP-27 path, withload_root_catalog(),load_blocks(),get_block_by_id(), andget_catalog_mtime().src.block_reference._load_catalog()delegates tosrc.catalog.load_blocks()and preserves() -> list[dict].src.block_reference._get_block_by_id()delegates tosrc.catalog.get_block_by_id(block_id)and preserves(block_id: str) -> dict | None.src.block_selector.load_catalog()delegates tosrc.catalog.load_root_catalog()and preserves() -> dict.src.block_selector._get_block_by_id()delegates tosrc.catalog.get_block_by_id(block_id, catalog)and preserves(block_id: str, catalog: dict) -> dict | None.src.renderer._load_catalog_map()and_load_catalog_map_with_variants()consumesrc.catalog.load_blocks()and keep renderer-local projection caches keyed bysrc.catalog.get_catalog_mtime().src.rendererno longer ownsCATALOG_PATH,import yaml, or legacy_CATALOG_MTIME; it now owns_CATALOG_MAP_MTIMEand_CATALOG_VARIANT_MAP_MTIMEprojection keys.git diff -- templates/catalog.yaml src/fit_verifier.py src/space_allocator.py src/pipeline.pyis empty, so catalog data and the external call-site modules remain unchanged._load_catalog()callers infit_verifier.py,space_allocator.py,pipeline.py, internalblock_reference.py, internalblock_selector.py, and renderer projection callers; signatures are unchanged.block_search.pyandphase_z2_*catalog references found by grep are outside this IMP-27 binding scope and point to separate catalog concerns.FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES
[Claude #8] Stage 5 commit-push — IMP-27 K5 catalog cleanup Round #1
■ Commit
909bf75edc633111b325175a2d3e40639def62berefactor(#27): IMP-27 K5 catalog loader + _get_block_by_id cleanup2896bb6(docs(#26): IMP-26 J3 status pending->deferred + dual-precondition trigger)main■ Scope-locked files (5 — exactly per Stage 4 binding contract)
src/catalog.py(+76)src/block_reference.py(−21 / +6, net −15 —git diff --statshows 27 lines touched)src/block_selector.py(−30 / +9, net −21 — 39 lines touched)src/renderer.py(−49 / +39, net −10 — 88 lines touched)tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py(+421)git diff --staged --stattotals: 5 files / +550 / −101.■ Push
git push slide2 main→2896bb6..909bf75 main -> main(gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2.git)git push origin main→2896bb6..909bf75 main -> main(github.com:keimin86/design_agent.git)git ls-remote slide2 refs/heads/main→909bf75… refs/heads/main✅git ls-remote origin refs/heads/main→909bf75… refs/heads/main✅■ Out-of-scope files NOT staged (confirmed)
src/fit_verifier.py,src/space_allocator.py,src/pipeline.py,templates/catalog.yaml— untouched (post-commitgit statusshows noMfor these).tests/matching/**,samples/**,.orchestrator/**,chromedriver/**,templates/phase_z2/**,scripts/**, root-level orchestrator script — left untracked (carried over from prior working tree).■ Verification (pre-commit, carried over from Stage 4)
pytest tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py -v→ 23/23 PASS in 0.13s.pytest tests/ -q --ignore=tests/matching→ 365/365 PASS in 38.10s.■ Guardrails honored
git add -A/..git diffempty for those files).reference_design_agent_remotes: pushed to bothslide2(Gitea mirror = naming mismatchC.E.L_Slide_test2) andorigin(GitHub).gitearemote (=_Geulbeot, different project) intentionally NOT pushed.■ Stage 5 status
PASS. Commit
909bf75on both remotes; working tree returns to pre-commit untracked-only state (no scope file dirty).■ Next stage
Stage 6 final-close eligible.
rewind_target: n/a (no failure)
=== EVIDENCE ===
git log -1 --format="%H %s"→909bf75edc633111b325175a2d3e40639def62be refactor(#27): IMP-27 K5 catalog loader + _get_block_by_id cleanupgit diff --staged --stat(pre-commit) → 5 files / +550 / −101 / create modes forsrc/catalog.py+tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py.git push slide2 main→2896bb6..909bf75 main -> maingit push origin main→2896bb6..909bf75 main -> maingit ls-remote slide2 refs/heads/main→909bf75edc633111b325175a2d3e40639def62begit ls-remote origin refs/heads/main→909bf75edc633111b325175a2d3e40639def62begit status --short→ noM/Alines for scope files; untracked-only entries remain (out-of-scope).git remote -v→ slide2 =https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2.git; origin =git@github.com:keimin86/design_agent.git.FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES
[Codex #8] Stage 5 commit-push verification IMP-27 K5 Round #1
Stage 5 verification PASS.
Commit verified:
909bf75edc2896bb691cRemote verification:
909bf75edc909bf75edcScope verification:
Tests:
=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
Files checked:
Commit SHA:
909bf75edcVerified facts:
909bf75edcon branch main.2896bb691c.909bf75edc.909bf75edc.FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES
[Claude #9] Stage 6 final-close — IMP-27 K5 (catalog loader + _get_block_by_id cleanup) Round #1
Issue body re-read (binding goals)
_get_block_by_id중복 제거 (3 module — block_reference / block_selector / renderer).Origin verification
909bf75909bf75edc633111b325175a2d3e40639def62be2896bb6(IMP-26 J3)2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabcrefactor(#27): IMP-27 K5 catalog loader + _get_block_by_id cleanupkyeongmin/2026-05-20 19:31:26 +0900origin(GitHub)refs/heads/main909bf75…909bf75edc633111b325175a2d3e40639def62beslide2(Gitea mirror)refs/heads/main909bf75…909bf75edc633111b325175a2d3e40639def62be2896bb6..909bf75Goal vs result
909bf75)src/catalog.py(NEW, +76) sole file-read + mtime-cache owner;block_reference._load_catalog,block_selector.load_catalog,renderer._load_catalog_map[_with_variants]모두 위임_get_block_by_id중복 제거src/catalog.get_block_by_id(block_id, catalog=None);block_reference._get_block_by_id(no-arg) +block_selector._get_block_by_id(catalog-injected) → 1-line wrappersgit diff 909bf75 -- templates/catalog.yaml= emptygit diff 909bf75 -- src/fit_verifier.py src/space_allocator.py src/pipeline.py= emptyshortstat:
5 files changed, 550 insertions(+), 101 deletions(-)— matches Stage 5 binding contract.Review-loop checklist (issue body)
909bf75(Stage 3 + Stage 5)Follow-up links (out-of-scope, deferred)
yaml.safe_load(CATALOG_PATH)style reads:src/fit_verifier.py(4 import sites — L131, L840, L985, L1004)src/space_allocator.py(5 import sites — L34, L390, L713, L786, L825)src/pipeline.py:228src/block_search.pyyamlimport — separate axis (block search index, not catalog loader).phase_z2_*catalog imports — separate catalog data domain (frame_contracts / layouts / region_layouts / display_strategies), nottemplates/catalog.yaml.tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.pytracking — already committed at909bf75(no decision pending).These do not block IMP-27 K5 closure — issue scope was explicitly "3 module" (block_reference + block_selector + renderer). The above are candidates for a successor cleanup issue.
Labels / milestone
Close decision
READY TO CLOSE (issue close left to user per orchestrator convention).
Rationale:
_get_block_by_iddedup + catalog.yaml untouched + return contracts preserved + caller signatures byte-identical).909bf75present on both remotes (GitHuborigin+ Giteaslide2) atrefs/heads/main.=== EVIDENCE ===
commands:
git log -1 --format='%H%n%P%n%s%n%an%n%ai' 909bf75→909bf75edc633111b325175a2d3e40639def62be/ parent2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc/ titlerefactor(#27): IMP-27 K5 catalog loader + _get_block_by_id cleanup/kyeongmin/2026-05-20 19:31:26 +0900.git ls-remote origin refs/heads/main→909bf75edc633111b325175a2d3e40639def62be refs/heads/main.git ls-remote slide2 refs/heads/main→909bf75edc633111b325175a2d3e40639def62be refs/heads/main.git show --stat --format= 909bf75→ 5 files / +550 −101 (catalog.py +76 / block_reference.py 27 / block_selector.py 39 / renderer.py 88 / test_catalog_shared_loader.py +421).git diff 909bf75 -- src/fit_verifier.py src/space_allocator.py src/pipeline.py templates/catalog.yaml→ empty (out-of-scope guardrail).git log --oneline 2896bb6..909bf75→ exactly 1 commit909bf75.upstream docs:
docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md:151— §5 K5 cleanup axis.docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md:1087— §2.10 K5 row.binding contracts honored:
909bf75.[Codex #9] Stage 6 final-close verify IMP-27 K5 Round #1
Verdict: PASS. Close OK signal.
I independently verified the Stage 5 commit/push state and the Stage 6 closure criteria from the local repository and remotes. The implemented result matches the issue scope: shared catalog file-read + mtime-cache ownership is centralized in
src/catalog.py, the three target modules delegate to it,_get_block_by_idis canonicalized throughsrc.catalog.get_block_by_id, and the public wrapper signatures/return contracts remain preserved.Scope guard also holds:
templates/catalog.yaml,src/fit_verifier.py,src/space_allocator.py, andsrc/pipeline.pyhave no diff in the IMP-27 commit range. Bothoriginandslide2pointrefs/heads/mainat909bf75edc633111b325175a2d3e40639def62be, and the parent-to-HEAD range contains exactly one commit.=== EVIDENCE ===
Commands run:
git log -1 --format='%H%n%P%n%s%n%an%n%ai'git show --shortstat --format= HEADgit show --name-status --format= HEADgit rev-list --count 2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc..HEADgit ls-remote origin refs/heads/maingit ls-remote slide2 refs/heads/mainrg -n "def _load_catalog|def _get_block_by_id|from src import catalog|import yaml|CATALOG_PATH|_catalog_cache|_catalog_mtime" src\block_reference.py src\block_selector.pyrg -n "def _load_catalog_map|def _load_catalog_map_with_variants|from src import catalog|import yaml|CATALOG_PATH|_CATALOG_MTIME|_CATALOG_MAP_MTIME|_CATALOG_VARIANT_MAP_MTIME|load_blocks\(|get_catalog_mtime\(" src\renderer.pygit diff HEAD -- src\fit_verifier.py src\space_allocator.py src\pipeline.py templates\catalog.yamlgit diff HEAD^ HEAD -- templates\catalog.yaml src\fit_verifier.py src\space_allocator.py src\pipeline.pypython -c "import inspect; import src.block_reference as br; import src.block_selector as bs; import src.renderer as r; ..."python -m pytest tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.py -qFiles checked:
src/catalog.pysrc/block_reference.pysrc/block_selector.pysrc/renderer.pytests/test_catalog_shared_loader.pytemplates/catalog.yamlsrc/fit_verifier.pysrc/space_allocator.pysrc/pipeline.pyCommit SHA:
909bf75edc633111b325175a2d3e40639def62beVerified facts:
909bf75edc633111b325175a2d3e40639def62bewith parent2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc.refactor(#27): IMP-27 K5 catalog loader + _get_block_by_id cleanup.kyeongmin,2026-05-20 19:31:26 +0900.git show --name-statuslists exactlysrc/catalog.pyA,tests/test_catalog_shared_loader.pyA, and modifications tosrc/block_reference.py,src/block_selector.py,src/renderer.py.5 files changed, 550 insertions(+), 101 deletions(-).2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc..HEADcontains exactly 1 commit.origin refs/heads/mainandslide2 refs/heads/mainboth resolve to909bf75edc633111b325175a2d3e40639def62be.src/catalog.pydefines the sharedCATALOG_PATH,yaml.safe_load,_catalog_cache,_catalog_mtime,load_root_catalog,load_blocks,get_block_by_id, andget_catalog_mtimeownership.src/block_reference.pydelegates_load_catalog()to_catalog_mod.load_blocks()and_get_block_by_id(block_id)to_catalog_mod.get_block_by_id(block_id).src/block_selector.pydelegatesload_catalog()to_catalog_mod.load_root_catalog()and_get_block_by_id(block_id, catalog)to_catalog_mod.get_block_by_id(block_id, catalog).src/renderer.pydelegates projection inputs to_catalog_mod.load_blocks()and projection invalidation to_catalog_mod.get_catalog_mtime()while keeping renderer-local projection caches.block_reference._load_catalog(),block_reference._get_block_by_id(block_id),block_selector.load_catalog(),block_selector._get_block_by_id(block_id, catalog),renderer._load_catalog_map(),renderer._load_catalog_map_with_variants().templates/catalog.yaml,src/fit_verifier.py,src/space_allocator.py, andsrc/pipeline.pyare unchanged in the IMP-27 commit range.23 passed in 0.11s.365/365regression result.FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES