5-MDX presentation readiness review - gate vs human
Runs reviewed
Fresh final.html / preview.png outputs:
- presentation_review_20260604_01
- presentation_review_20260604_02
- presentation_…
Category B result - project-relative trace path fallback
Scope
Category B was the remaining path-handling bucket after Category A/C were closed. The failing integrations wrote run outputs…
Category A addendum - active no-leak assertion
Why this addendum
The Category A fix updated stale _fake_run test doubles to accept and capture the newer override axes:
- `override_text_ov…
Category A result - CLI fake-run mock drift fixed
Scope
After T28.5e point 6 was sealed, the next hygiene bucket was Category A: multiple CLI/reuse tests failed with the same error:
`TypeE…
T28.5e-1b result - full-pipeline status-laundering probe
Purpose
This seals the remaining half of T28.5e point 6(ii): a real source-text loss must not be laundered into PASS / presentation_…
T28.5e-1a result - helper guard for unrenderable position fallback
Purpose
This is a small acceptance-sealing test for T28.5e-1 point 6.
The original acceptance has two halves:
- No…
T28.5e-1 result - Emergency P3 fallback now preserves manual layout/section assignment
What changed
Implemented the scoped P3-only fix from the T28.5e-1 scope lock.
Emergency P3 fallback…
T28.5e-1 - scope lock: fix Emergency P3 fallback to preserve manual layout/section (keep invariant)
Root cause (T28.5e-0 verdict, code-confirmed)
The manual vertical-2 layout is NOT…
T28.5e-0 audit - override/layout invariant trigger path
Scope
Read-only audit of why the manual vertical-2 + left/right reproduction does not reach the T28.5d popup second pass.
No…
T28.5d-2 result - second popup pass with conditional promote
What changed
Implemented the T28.5d second popup pass as a deterministic bridge from T28.5c abort/no-recovery into the existing…
T28.5d-1 - scope lock: wire T28.5c abort/escalate into the existing popup chain (re-render)
Verdict: REUSE the existing popup/details chain
The popup chain already exists and is live: -…
T28.5d-0 audit - existing popup/details chain
Scope
Read-only audit before implementing T28.5d. No source files were changed in this slice.
Existing assets confirmed
- Router surface…
T28.5d-1 - scope lock: popup/details separation
Why this exists
T28.5c proved that some overflow cases cannot be solved by zone redistribution or frame/layout re-selection.
Latest smoke…
T28.5c-2 result - abort re-selection trace
Scope lock: Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2#98 (comment)
What changed
- Added a trace-only T28.5c re-selection…
T28.5c-1 - scope lock: abort -> frame/layout re-selection
Why this exists
T28.5b made the existing redistribution path manual-aware, but the latest runtime smoke exposed a different…
T28.5b cleanup verification - dead duplicate removed
What was removed
During T28.5b implementation a temporary duplicate of the zone-ratio planner was left in the uncommitted working…
T28.5b-2 result - manual-aware zone redistribution
Scope lock: Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2#98 (comment)
What changed
- Reused the existing `zone_ratio…
T28.5b-1 - scope lock: manual-aware zone redistribution (reuse, not rebuild)
Verdict: REUSE existing redistribution engine
Cross-checked by two independent audits. The zone/role redistribut…
T28.5 result - presentation-fit measurement + no-font-shrink guard
Scope comment: Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2#98 (comment)
What changed
- Added a…
T28.5 - Deterministic height-fit / presentation-layout policy (scope + acceptance)
Goal
T28.5 is NOT cosmetic polish. Its primary goal is a deterministic layout policy that never hides…