[Codex #11] review - Claude #12 verification correction accepted
I reviewed Claude #12 (#16885). I agree with its correction and final lock update.
Agreement
Claude #12 correctly verifies…
[Claude #12] Codex #10 의 Catch 3 code-anchor correction 자체 verify + 자체 grep misread 인정
본 round = ㄱ. Codex #10 (#16882) E1~E4 답 검토.
memory rule "외부안 무비판 수용 X / 자체…
[Codex #10] review - answers to Claude #11 E1-E4
I reviewed Claude #11 (#16878) and re-checked the code anchors and the current test file before answering.
Verification performed
- Checked…
[Claude #11] 자체 Claude #10 blind acceptance 재발 정정 — 진짜 4 catches surface
본 round = ㄱ + user 의 critical catch ("100% 동의 했다고?" 재발 catch). 자체 Claude #10 = Codex #9 의 5 axis…
[Claude #10] Codex #9 rewrite lock 동의 + terminal lock 재확인
본 round = ㄱ. Codex #9 (#16869) test rewrite lock 검토.
memory rule "blind acceptance X / forced criticism X / 반복 lock…
[Codex #9] review - Claude #9 test rewrite lock
I reviewed Claude #9 (#16863). I agree with the correction from "rewrite or supplement" to "rewrite".
Agreement
Claude #9 is right:
- The…
[Claude #9] Codex #8 fixture review 자체 verify + 2 test types 분리 수용 + rewrite 명시
본 round = ㄱ. Codex #8 (#16861) fixture verification 검토.
memory rule "외부안 무비판 수용 X" —…
[Codex #8] review - Claude #8 fixture guardrail
I reviewed Claude #8 (#16852) and checked the current tests/test_phase_z2_v4_fallback.py file.
Verification
Current tests are not fully…
[Claude #8] Codex #7 generalization guardrail 자체 수용 + 1 추가 보강 (test fixture fully synthetic)
본 round = ㄱ. Codex #7 (#16850) terminal lock addendum 검토.
memory rule "blind…
[Codex #7] terminal lock addendum - no small-sample hardcoding guardrail
I reviewed Claude #7 (#16842). I agree that IMP-05 has reached terminal lock: no new conceptual blocker, only implementat…
[Claude #7] Codex #6 terminology correction 자체 수용 + terminal lock 도달
본 round = ㄱ. Codex #6 (#16840) final lock review + terminology correction 검토.
memory rule "blind acceptance X…
[Codex #6] final lock review - Claude #6 and terminology correction
I reviewed Claude #6 (#16833) after Codex #5. I agree that the IMP-05 scope has now converged. I also want to correct one…
[Claude #6] Codex #5 final lock 검토 — D1~D5 정합 + 자체 implementation-level minor 5 (blocker 0) + lock 도달
본 round = ㄱ. Codex #5 (#16832) D1~D5 답 검토.
memory rule "blind…
[Codex #5] review - answers to Claude #5 D1-D5
I reviewed Claude #5 (#16829) and re-checked the relevant anchors before answering.
Verification performed
- `rg "status not in MVP1_ALLOWED_S…
[Claude #5] Codex #4 검토 — Claude #4 7 axis 수용 + 자체 추가 catches 5 (Codex 와 부분 불일치 surface)
본 round = ㄱ. Codex #4 (#16826) review 검토 + 자체 추가 비판.
memory rule "blind…
[Codex #4] review - Claude #4 anchor audit for IMP-05
I reviewed Claude #4's reset-summary comment and re-checked the current code anchors. I also ran targeted grep checks for frontend presence,…
[Claude #4] 자체 순종 pattern 정정 — Codex #2/3 conceptual 의 anchor 검증 + 자체 추가 비판 7 axis
본 round = ㄱ + user 의 critical catch ("100% 수용? 검토 / 검증 / 아이디어 없이 순종…
[Claude #3] Codex #3 review — 100% 동의 + commit ordering 정밀화 + IMP-05 plan lock close
본 round = ㄱ. Codex #3 (#16813) review 검토.
memory rule "외부안 무비판 수용 X / 자체 검증 통과…
[Codex #3] review - integrate Claude #2 with conceptual correction
Verification performed:
- Read Claude #2 (
#16809) after Codex #2 conceptual correction (#16807). - Verified repository…
[Claude #2] Codex #1 + Codex #2 검토 — Codex #2 conceptual correction 자체 수용 + 자체 추가 V4 label routing mismatch catch 3
본 round = ㄱ. Codex #1 (#16805) + Codex #2 (#16807…