Re-apply the W1 wording clarifications previously agreed in the comment
thread. The originally executed wording commit `6d33884` was reverted by
Codex via `c807b2c` after Codex acknowledged that `ㄱ` for both Claude and
Codex is comment-only review (no source/doc edit). Both sides 100%
agreement is restored via Claude rounds 16/17/19 and Codex rounds 15/18.
This Claude-applied commit is the agreed re-application path (option A).
Six fixes applied to docs/architecture/IMP-04-FRAME-SUITABILITY-MATRIX.md :
1. §2 ACTIVE 4 frames table : add resource status (A/T/I/F/S) column.
F13 has no `assets/` directory (marked `-`). State that ACTIVE means
catalog-registered / runtime-active, not necessarily A+T+I+F+S
resource-complete.
2. §4 Track B : strengthen wording. Track B = visual-resource-pending
inside the 32-frame scope, **NOT exclusion / discard / scope
reduction**. Visual-resource acquisition timing is the only difference.
3. §4 Track B option (b) : minimal CSS partial from analysis/texts only
is **main path X, explicit temporary placeholder only**. Avoids the
frame 1 (`three_persona_benefits` 556b448) quality failure pattern.
4. §4.1 Track A priority : **execution ordering only, NOT scope filter**.
All 16 reusable-now frames remain activation targets. V4-weak 11
frames stay in scope. Builder family grouping = secondary ordering
allowed after first refinement calibration.
5. §4.1 Codex review granularity explicit : first refinement, new builder
pattern, ambiguous mapping, shared catalog/builder logic = Codex
review mandatory. Low-risk repeated frames may be grouped only after
pattern is proven.
6. §4.1 calibration failure modes F1/F2/F3 (Claude round 14 catch + Codex
round 15 (a) accepted) :
- F1 small styling/wording issue -> same-frame follow-up commit +
Codex re-review.
- F2 approach-level problem -> pause Track A, approach re-lock round,
retry refinement.
- F3 scope/resource problem -> reopen scope/resource axis, possibly
IMP-04b, block bulk activation until resolved.
History trace : `fe766f1` (matrix base) -> `6d33884` (Codex W1 execute,
wrong workflow) -> `c807b2c` (Codex revert + workflow lock symmetric)
-> this commit (Claude re-apply under user execution signal, option A).
History noise retained as honest trace of the corrected ㄱ definition.
No source code changes. Documentation clarification only.
Refs Gitea #4 (IMP-04 — matrix wording re-application post-revert)
- Add active-frame resource status and clarify catalog-active versus resource-complete.\n- Clarify Track B as visual-resource-pending inside the 32-frame scope, not exclusion.\n- Clarify Track A priority as execution order, not scope filter.\n- Add Codex review granularity and calibration failure modes for the first refinement.\n- Mark minimal CSS from analysis/texts as temporary placeholder only.
- Classify pipeline.py as Archive-heavy with Salvage Candidate 0
- Record Phase Q/R'/T execution flow as outside Phase Z normal path
- Mark deterministic pipeline utilities as Reference Only
- Mark pipeline_context.py schema and lifecycle methods as Reference Only
- Surface §1 B-1 as indirect surface, not direct composition planner
- Add §5-1 dated entry for 2026-05-12
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
- Classify §2.10 as Mixed with Salvage Candidate 0
- Mark utilities / matching helpers / Phase Q-2 filtering as Reference Only
- Record block_reference high-level entries as Phase R' reference path Archive
- Record block_selector format_candidates_for_prompt as Kei prompt formatter Archive
- Surface §1 A-2 indirect, catalog duplication, block_selector legacy as separate axes
- Add §5-1 dated entry for 2026-05-12
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
- Classify html_generator.py as Archive-heavy with Salvage Candidate 0
- Record AI HTML generation path as Phase R' Archive Candidate
- Mark deterministic duplicate helpers as Reference Only
- Surface A-3/A-4 mapping mismatch as a factual note
- Add §5-1 dated entry for 2026-05-12
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
- Classify renderer.py as Mixed with Salvage Candidate 0
- Mark Jinja/catalog/template rendering helpers as Reference Only
- Record render_slide_from_html Phase R' path as Archive Candidate
- Clarify A-3 as indirect preview render surface
- Clarify A-4 as slide-base impact surface without conditional CSS implementation
- Add §5-1 dated entry for 2026-05-12
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
- Classify content_verifier.py as Mixed (Reference Only + Archive Candidate)
- Mark deterministic utilities (text extraction, Korean normalization, verification logic) as Reference Only — Phase Z normal path direct slot absent
- Mark Kei artifact detection (verify_no_forbidden_content + FORBIDDEN_KEI_MEMOS) and Kei AI generation retry loop (generate_with_retry) as Archive Candidate
- Clarify L4 Selenium / L5 Opus vision are header documentation only (no implementation in this file)
- Record no §3 Salvage application target (Salvage Candidate 0)
- Surface §1 B-2 mapping as indirect; H1-H3 reference axis candidates, H4-H5 Archive markers, H6 L4/L5 factual note
- Add §5-1 dated entry for 2026-05-12
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
- Classify content_editor.py as Archive Candidate at module level
- Document Kei AI direct slot-fill flow (fill_content / fill_candidates / EDITOR_PROMPT)
- Mark Kei API infrastructure (_call_kei_editor_with_retry / _parse_json) as outside Phase Z normal path
- Record no §3 Salvage Plan target for this module
- Surface §1 B-1/B-2 candidate-file mapping mismatch and AI repair fallback infrastructure as separate axes
- Add §5-1 dated entry for 2026-05-12
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
문서 역할 분담:
- README : 프로젝트 개요 + 큰 그림 (가끔 갱신)
- OVERVIEW : 22 단계 도면 (구조 잠금)
- STATUS-BOARD : 각 단계 정확한 상태 (자주 갱신)
- CHANGE-LOG : 결정 변경 이력
- ROADMAP (신규): 진행 계획 + 당장 할 일 + 세부 todo (자주 갱신)
내용:
1. 현재 위치 (MDX03 정상 경로 통과)
2. 지금까지 완료한 작업 6 가지 영역
3. 22 단계 진행 수준 (추정 % 표 + STATUS-BOARD 단일 출처 caveat)
4. 큰 로드맵 7 단계
5. 세부 todo (5.1 보고용 프로토타입 우선 / 5.2~5.8 단계별)
6. 당장 실행 순서 (보고용 프로토타입 → 22 단계 정리 복귀)
7. 문서 역할 분담 표
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
- consolidate evidence-based principles for Step 5/6/7 and B-axis matching layer
- record CompositionUnit, candidate-based composition, and 4-tier terminology
- defer bridge architecture and slot_payload evolution as scope-locked open items
- mark content object, internal region, and placement steps as partial
- record B1-B5 and trace-only runtime activation status
- refresh current missing items and bottleneck summary
- add Internal Region model to Phase Z architecture docs and specs
- add frame contract content type and Frame Slot declarations
- add dormant content object extractor and internal region planner
- 목표: MDX → BEPs 매칭 → 슬라이드 자동 생성
- 핵심 축: 표현 기준 통일, 블록 역할 재정의, direct-fit/recipe 2경로화
- 6단계 진행 계획: 토큰 → slide-base 분리 → 규칙 문서 → 폴더 정리 → 블록 전환 → 파이프라인 연결
- 역할 분리: figma_to_html_agent(원재료) / design_agent(조립 시스템)
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
- 루트의 IMPROVEMENT-PHASE-*.md, PHASE-*.md 등 45개 → docs/history/로 이동
- docs/block-tests/ 오래된 블록 테스트 HTML 삭제 (figma_to_html_agent로 대체)
- docs/figma-analysis/, docs/figma-assets/, docs/figma-screenshots/ 정리
- docs/test-*.html 등 초기 테스트 파일 정리
- 참고 페이지/ 스크린샷 정리
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
1단계 (실장):
- Kei API 연동 복구 (타임아웃 무제한, Kei persona 사고)
- 정보 구조 파악 단계 추가 (본문 흐름 vs 참조 분리)
- 각 꼭지에 role(flow/reference) 부여
- fallback: Anthropic 직접 호출 (info_structure + role 포함)
2단계 (팀장):
- info_structure + role 기반 배치 규칙 추가
- flow → 좌측/메인, reference → 우측/사이드
- detail_target → 본문 제외
- 중복 방지 규칙
파이프라인:
- pipeline.py import re 추가
Figma 관련 (다른 Claude Code 작업분):
- catalog.yaml, figma-screenshots, figma-analysis, 테스트 HTML
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
DA-12: 1단계 Kei 실장 — 꼭지 2~5개 추출 + 레이어/강조/배치/이미지/표/자세히보기 판단
DA-13: 2단계 디자인 팀장 — catalog 연동 + 블록 매핑 + 공간 배분 + 글자 수 가이드
DA-13b: 3단계 텍스트 편집자 — 글자 수 가이드 참고, 의미 우선 편집 + 자세히보기(요약+상세)
DA-14: 4단계 실무자(AI+코드) + 5단계 팀장 재검토 (균형 점검 → 2차 조정)
문서:
- CLAUDE.md: 5단계 프로세스 + 이미지/표/자세히보기 처리 원칙
- PLAN.md: DA-12~14 태스크 전면 재작성
- PROGRESS.md: 동기화
- FIGMA-COMPONENT-EXTRACTION-PLAN.md: 모드 독립 블록, 변환 규칙, image-block/details-block, MCP, 토큰 매핑
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
