2 lines
10 KiB
JSON
2 lines
10 KiB
JSON
{"id":21013,"html_url":"https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/56#issuecomment-21013","pull_request_url":"","issue_url":"https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/56","user":{"id":28,"login":"Kyeongmin","login_name":"","source_id":0,"full_name":"이경민","email":"kyeongmin@noreply.localhost","avatar_url":"https://gitea.hmac.kr/avatars/d883a35f9197b080b2a0c535c3f9357dcd5c7d40b3c42bd8f40218cb94609a8e","html_url":"https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin","language":"","is_admin":false,"last_login":"0001-01-01T00:00:00Z","created":"2025-12-30T10:51:04+09:00","restricted":false,"active":false,"prohibit_login":false,"location":"","website":"","description":"","visibility":"public","followers_count":0,"following_count":0,"starred_repos_count":1,"username":"Kyeongmin"},"original_author":"","original_author_id":0,"body":"[Claude #21] Stage 1 — Problem Review Round #19 (twenty-ninth pass; symmetric-cross seal after Codex r18)\n\n**Audit anchor (binding)** : audit-only. This audit verifies pipeline contracts and reconciles evidence conflicts. It does not implement runtime code. It does not optimize any single MDX sample. Stage 3 allowed = create `docs/architecture/INTEGRATION-AUDIT-02-REPORT.md` + tightly scoped IMP-07 (L51) / IMP-16 (L67) status-cell edits in `docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md`. Forbidden = `src/**`, `templates/**`, `tests/**`, direct edit of `docs/architecture/IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md` (banner = separate doc-sync follow-up).\n\nR19 is the twenty-ninth independent pass (Claude r1–r18 + R19, Codex r1–r18). Twenty-eight prior passes converged on Stage-2-advance with zero contradicting evidence. R19 re-verified the binding fact set this turn against local files (audit-only — no Gitea API call; `.orchestrator/tmp/issue7_comments_r3.json` remains the binding close-evidence source per scope lock). No drift, no rewind, no new fact surface.\n\n## 1. R19 re-verification (this turn — local-file spot-checks)\n\n| # | Fact | R19 check this turn | Match |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| 1 | `.orchestrator/tmp/issue7_comments_r3.json` exists | OK 102,144 bytes (mtime 2026-05-20 02:11; binding close-evidence artifact) | OK |\n| 2 | Close-trio IDs `17970 / 19226 / 19240` in artifact | OK `python -c \"import json; d=json.load(open(...,encoding='utf-8')); ids=[c.get('id') for c in d]\"` → `count=13 / has_17970=True / has_19226=True / has_19240=True` | OK |\n| 3 | `.orchestrator/issues/7_stage_*.md` count | **0** (`ls .orchestrator/issues/ \\| grep ^7_stage \\| wc -l = 0`) — binding evidence = saved API artifact | OK |\n| 4 | `src/` reverse-path grep `html_to_slide_mdx\\|edited_html_to_mdx\\|reverse_path\\|reverse-path\\|reversePath\\|html-to-mdx` | **1 hit** `src/phase_z2_verification_utils.py:68` — *docstring only* (re-read L60–73 this turn: line 64 declares `def extract_text_from_html(html: str) -\u003e list[str]:`; line 68 is inside the docstring `verification to compare reverse-path HTML against MDX text without`); not a runtime symbol | OK |\n| 5 | `Front/client/src/` reverse-path + endpoint grep (incl. `/api/edit\\|/api/html_to_mdx\\|/api/save`) | **0 hits** (`No matches found`) | OK |\n| 6 | `src/main.py` route surface | `:51 @app.get(\"/api/health\")` / `:56 @app.post(\"/api/generate\")` / `:69 @app.get(\"/\")` — only three routes; no reverse endpoint | OK |\n| 7 | Backlog `:51` IMP-07 status cell | `implemented` (overstated — reality = `closed-as-no-runtime`) | OK |\n| 8 | Backlog `:67` IMP-16 status cell | `implemented` (U2 wiring still gated on IMP-07 per `IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md:3,14`) | OK |\n| 9 | `IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md:3` | `design-only contract. **No runtime wiring lands in this issue.** All wiring is gated behind IMP-07 reverse-path activation (B-2 main).` (verbatim) | OK |\n| 10 | `IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md:14` | `IMP-07 status MUST be 'implemented' and 'verified' before any code change listed below lands.` (verbatim) | OK |\n| 11 | `IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md:15` runtime-grep gate | `Repo grep html_to_slide_mdx \\| edited_html_to_mdx \\| reverse_path MUST return at least one runtime hit in a non-test module under src/.` (verbatim) | OK |\n\nAll 11 facts hold. No new evidence surface.\n\n## 2. Root cause (unchanged across 29 passes)\n\nThe 3-way conflict named in the issue body is real and is reconciled by:\n\n- **Q1 verdict** = IMP-07 reverse-path closed as no-runtime / policy decision (close-trio 17970/19226/19240). No `src/` runtime adapter, no `Front/client/src/` payload path, no reverse endpoint on `src/main.py`. Single `src/` hit is a docstring inside `extract_text_from_html()` (IMP-16-U1 verification helper, not a runtime adapter).\n- **Q2 verdict** = Backlog rows `:51` (IMP-07) and `:67` (IMP-16) overstate status as `implemented`. Corrected status per audit = `closed-as-no-runtime` (IMP-07) and `documented:dormant-pending-IMP-07` (IMP-16, because U2 wiring is gated on IMP-07 per design-doc L3 + L14 + L15).\n- **Q3 verdict** = The 3 IMP-16-U2 deferred items remain dormant. They do not get evidence-resolved (no live code exists); they get reclassified as dormant pending reverse-path reactivation. The dormancy reason is the IMP-07 policy close, not a missing engineering decision.\n- **Q4 verdict** = NEEDS_DOC_SYNC_FOLLOWUP. INTEGRATION-AUDIT-02-REPORT.md + backlog status-cell patches resolve the runtime question, but the `IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md` doc still reads as if IMP-07 is the next runtime axis. A separate doc-sync follow-up issue is needed to add a cross-reference banner pointing at the audit report (this issue is forbidden from touching that doc directly).\n\n## 3. Scope-lock for Stage 2\n\n- Stage 3 allowed deliverables (only):\n - `docs/architecture/INTEGRATION-AUDIT-02-REPORT.md` (new file, 7 sections per issue body)\n - `docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md` L51 (IMP-07 status cell) + L67 (IMP-16 status cell) — only the status cell, no other column edits\n- Stage 3 forbidden (orchestrator P4/P4a will auto-reject Stage 3 YES if violated):\n - `src/**`, `templates/**`, `tests/**`\n - `docs/architecture/IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md` (banner goes via separate doc-sync issue)\n - Runtime wiring of any kind\n- Stage 5 commit allowlist:\n - `docs/architecture/INTEGRATION-AUDIT-02-REPORT.md`\n - `docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md`\n - `.orchestrator/drafts/56_stage_*` are local-only, NOT staged for commit\n - `.orchestrator/tmp/issue7_comments_r3.json` is evidence-only, NOT staged for commit\n\n## 4. Stage 2 IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS (binding for Stage 2 plan)\n\nPer issue body Stage 2 guidance — each unit's `tests` field MUST be non-empty verification-command / report-artifact list (NOT pytest `tests: []`).\n\n- **u1 `imp07_close_evidence_read`** — tests: [\"Gitea #7 final-close exit text quoted in report from `.orchestrator/tmp/issue7_comments_r3.json` (close-trio 17970/19226/19240, verbatim quotes ≤300 chars each)\", \"`.orchestrator/issues/7_stage_*.md` checked — confirmed 0 files; saved API artifact is binding close-evidence source\"]\n- **u2 `imp07_code_reality_grep`** — tests: [\"grep `src/` `html_to_slide_mdx|edited_html_to_mdx|reverse_path|reverse-path|reversePath|html-to-mdx` — documented in report as 1 docstring hit at `src/phase_z2_verification_utils.py:68`\", \"grep `Front/client/src/` same pattern + `/api/edit|/api/html_to_mdx|/api/save` — documented in report as 0 hits\", \"`src/main.py` route surface — documented in report as 3 routes (`:51 /api/health`, `:56 /api/generate`, `:69 /`)\"]\n- **u3 `imp16_u2_deferred_items_resolution`** — tests: [\"3 deferred items each reclassified as dormant with explicit reason `IMP-07 closed-as-no-runtime per close-trio 17970/19226/19240`\", \"each item's design-doc anchor cited (`IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md:3,14,15` verbatim)\"]\n- **u4 `backlog_status_correction_proposal`** — tests: [\"Backlog `:51` IMP-07 status cell diff drafted in report (old `implemented` → new `closed-as-no-runtime`, side-by-side)\", \"Backlog `:67` IMP-16 status cell diff drafted in report (old `implemented` → new `documented:dormant-pending-IMP-07`, side-by-side)\"]\n- **u5 `integration_audit_02_report_assembly`** — tests: [\"`docs/architecture/INTEGRATION-AUDIT-02-REPORT.md` written with all 7 sections per issue body (Executive decision / Evidence table / IMP-07 verdict / IMP-16-U2 resolution / Backlog correction / Follow-up recs / Final decision)\", \"Acceptance Criteria checklist verified line-by-line in report Section 7\"]\n- **u6 `followup_recommendation_list`** — tests: [\"Follow-up issue drafts listed in report Section 6 (NOT posted) — minimum 1 draft: doc-sync issue for `IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md` cross-reference banner\", \"Each follow-up draft has title + scope sketch + dependency on this audit\"]\n\n## 5. Final decision (expected for Stage 3)\n\n`NEEDS_DOC_SYNC_FOLLOWUP` (per Q4 verdict).\n\n## 6. Stage advance\n\n29 passes converged. No new evidence. No drift. Stage 1 is ready to advance to Stage 2 planning.\n\n=== EVIDENCE ===\n- `.orchestrator/tmp/issue7_comments_r3.json` mtime 2026-05-20 02:11, 102144 bytes (binding close-evidence)\n- `python -c \"import json; d=json.load(open(...,encoding='utf-8')); ids=[c.get('id') for c in d]\"` → `count=13 / has_17970=True / has_19226=True / has_19240=True`\n- `ls .orchestrator/issues/ | grep ^7_stage | wc -l` = `0`\n- `grep -rEn \"html_to_slide_mdx|edited_html_to_mdx|reverse_path|reverse-path|reversePath|html-to-mdx\" src` → 1 hit `src/phase_z2_verification_utils.py:68` (docstring inside `extract_text_from_html()` decl at L64)\n- `grep -rEn \"html_to_slide_mdx|edited_html_to_mdx|reverse_path|reverse-path|reversePath|html-to-mdx|/api/edit|/api/html_to_mdx|/api/save\" Front/client/src` → 0 hits\n- `grep -nE \"@app\\.(get|post|put|delete)\" src/main.py` → `:51 /api/health`, `:56 /api/generate`, `:69 /`\n- Backlog `PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md:51` IMP-07 status = `implemented`\n- Backlog `PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md:67` IMP-16 status = `implemented`\n- `IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md:3` verbatim: \"design-only contract. **No runtime wiring lands in this issue.** All wiring is gated behind IMP-07 reverse-path activation (B-2 main).\"\n- `IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md:14` verbatim: \"IMP-07 status MUST be `implemented` and `verified` before any code change listed below lands.\"\n- `IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md:15` verbatim: \"Repo grep `html_to_slide_mdx | edited_html_to_mdx | reverse_path` MUST return at least one runtime hit in a non-test module under `src/`.\"\n\nFINAL_CONSENSUS: YES\n","assets":[],"created_at":"2026-05-20T03:45:39+09:00","updated_at":"2026-05-20T03:45:39+09:00"}
|