1 line
12 KiB
JSON
1 line
12 KiB
JSON
{"body": "[Claude #2] Stage 1 \u2014 Problem Review Round #2 (INTEGRATION-AUDIT-02 reconcile \u2014 lock)\n\n**Audit anchor (binding)** : audit-only. No `src/**`, `templates/**`, `tests/**` change. Allowed = `docs/architecture/INTEGRATION-AUDIT-02-REPORT.md` (create) + `docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md` (IMP-07 / IMP-16 status cells only). Forbidden = direct edit of `IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md` (follow-up issue per \u00a7Follow-up recommendation lock).\n\nR2 re-verifies R1's evidence chain end-to-end (live re-read this turn) and locks Q1~Q4 + Stage 2 IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS. Gitea API verbatim quotes for #7 close text are carried from R1 (Gitea host TLS handshake failed in this env this turn \u2014 API re-verify will be done at Stage 3 before report draft). All other evidence re-grepped/re-read locally and matches R1.\n\n## 1. Q1~Q4 final lock (evidence rows)\n\n### Q1 \u2014 IMP-07 actual status = **`closed-as-no-runtime` (policy decision)**\n\n- **Gitea #7 close text** (per R1 verbatim quote \u2014 Stage 3 will re-fetch to confirm IDs)\n - id=17970 (user, 2026-05-15) : `<<\ud574\ub2f9 \uae30\ub2a5 \ud544\uc694 \uc5c6\uc74c>> (*) mdx -> html \ubcc0\ud658 \uc774\ud6c4 html \uc218\uae30 \uc218\uc815\ub41c \uac83\uc740 html\uc5d0\uc11c\ub9cc \uc801\uc6a9.`\n - id=19226 (\uacb0\uacfc\ubcf4\uace0\uc11c) \u00a74 : `\uc0ac\uc6a9\uc790 \uacb0\uc815\uc73c\ub85c ... edited HTML\uc744 \ub2e4\uc2dc MDX\ub85c \uc5ed\ubcc0\ud658\ud558\ub294 \uae30\ub2a5\uc740 \ud604\uc7ac Phase Z \ubcf8\ub958\uc5d0 \ud544\uc694\ud558\uc9c0 \uc54a\ub2e4\uace0 \ud310\uc815\ud588\ub2e4.`\n - id=19226 \u00a75 : `\ucf54\ub4dc \ubcc0\uacbd \uc5c6\uc774 close ... '\uae30\ub2a5 \ubd88\ud544\uc694 / \ud604 \uc815\ucc45\uc0c1 reverse path \ubbf8\uc9c4\ud589'`.\n - id=19240 v2 : `\ucf54\ub4dc \ubcc0\uacbd \uc5c6\uc774 \uc815\ucc45 \ud310\ub2e8\uc73c\ub85c close\ud588\ub2e4.`\n- **Local exit-report fallback** : `Glob .orchestrator/issues/7_stage_*.md` = **0 files**. R1's \"if present\" hedge confirmed empty \u2014 Q1 close-evidence is Gitea-side only.\n- **Live `src/` grep** `html_to_slide_mdx|edited_html_to_mdx|reverse_path|reverse-path` = **1 hit** : `src/phase_z2_verification_utils.py:68` *docstring only* (no runtime symbol / callsite \u2014 module is the IMP-16-U1 utility, not a reverse-path adapter).\n- **Live `Front/` grep** same pattern (+ `reversePath`) = **0 hits**.\n- **Forward-only payload path** :\n - `Front/client/src/services/designAgentApi.ts:279-294` \u2014 `runPipeline()` POSTs `/api/run` (MDX \u2192 pipeline). No reverse fetch / POST exists anywhere in this file.\n - `Front/vite.config.ts:228-409` \u2014 middleware = `/api/run` (forward MDX \u2192 spawn pipeline) + `/api/sample-mdx` (read fixture) + `/frame-preview/{n}` (read png) + `/data/runs/{run_id}/{path}` (read artifact). **No `/api/reverse`, `/api/html-to-mdx`, or any HTML\u2192MDX endpoint.**\n - `Front/server/index.ts` \u2014 static server only (not used as backend API host).\n - `src/main.py:51-72` \u2014 FastAPI endpoints = `/api/health`, `/api/generate` (forward SSE), `/`. **No reverse endpoint.**\n - `Front/client/src/components/SlideCanvas.tsx:255` author note : `\uae00\ubc97 \ud328\ud134 \ucc28\uc6a9 \u2014 designMode + contentEditable. backend \ubc18\uc601\uc740 \ubcc4 \uc791\uc5c5.` (= edit mode is frontend-only by author's own admission).\n - `Front/client/src/pages/Home.tsx:450-452` \u2014 `handleContentEdit = useCallback(() => { setHasPendingChanges(true); }, [])` \u2014 sets pending flag only; no fetch / POST / SSE.\n\n**Verdict** : `closed-as-no-runtime` (user policy close, no implementation lands).\n\n### Q2 \u2014 Backlog accuracy = **WRONG**, propose `documented:no-runtime`\n\n- Backlog `PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md:51` IMP-07 row status = `implemented` \u2717\n- AUDIT-01 \u00a76.2 row 6 (line 240) verdict = `implemented_live` was **based only on `Front/client/src/services/designAgentApi.ts` file existence + commit `0f0d3fa`** (Vite/React shell \u2014 forward-path scaffolding). AUDIT-01 did **not** grep for reverse-path symbols and did **not** read Gitea #7 close comments. The verdict is overstated.\n- **Proposed status** : `documented:no-runtime` \u2014 distinct from IMP-17's `documented (deferred)`. IMP-07 = **policy close** (close-as-not-needed); IMP-17 = **activation gate** (3-cond AND : User GO \u2227 B4 frame_selection evidence \u2227 IMP-04/05 live \u2014 full def at `IMP-17-CARVE-OUT.md`). Different lifecycle semantics \u2192 different status enum.\n- IMP-16 backlog `:67` row status `implemented` is **partial only** : U1 utility (`src/phase_z2_verification_utils.py`) is fully implemented; U2 wiring is design-only per `IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md:3` (\"**No runtime wiring lands in this issue.** All wiring is gated behind IMP-07 reverse-path activation\"). Proposed status : `implemented:u1-only` (or backlog row split \u2014 Stage 3 to decide).\n\n### Q3 \u2014 IMP-16-U2 deferred items = **all 3 RECLASSIFY AS DORMANT**\n\n`IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md:12-16` activation gate (3-cond AND):\n- (1) IMP-07 status MUST be `implemented` AND `verified` \u2014 \u2717 false (Q1).\n- (2) `src/` grep `html_to_slide_mdx | edited_html_to_mdx | reverse_path` MUST return \u22651 **runtime** hit in non-test module \u2014 \u2717 false (only docstring hit at line 68; not runtime symbol).\n- (3) Reverse-path entry MUST emit normalized re-entry MDX + upstream HTML \u2014 \u2717 false (no entry point exists).\n\n`IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md:69-75` 3 deferred items:\n- L71 (adapter module path) \u2192 cannot answer with live evidence \u2192 **dormant pending reverse-path reactivation**.\n- L72 (Step 2 per-section vs whole-MDX preservation variant) \u2192 answer depends on a non-existent emitter \u2192 **dormant**.\n- L73 (Step 14 invented-text per `area_name` vs global) \u2192 answer depends on non-existent area-tagged HTML \u2192 **dormant**.\n\n### Q4 \u2014 Follow-up needs (draft, NOT posted)\n\n- **(F1) Backlog patch** \u2014 issue body of this audit is itself the carrier; backlog cell-level edit lands inside this issue's Stage 5 commit (allowed-file glob).\n- **(F2) Doc-sync follow-up issue** \u2014 `IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md` keeps its design-only contract intact, but readers landing on it after a backlog correction need an explicit cross-reference banner pointing to `INTEGRATION-AUDIT-02-REPORT.md`. Draft title : `[DOC-SYNC] IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md cross-reference banner to INTEGRATION-AUDIT-02`. Scope = 1 banner block at top of doc, no contract change. **MUST be a separate issue** per audit-only mode constraint (`docs/architecture/IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md` is in this issue's forbidden glob).\n- **(F3) Runtime follow-up** \u2014 **NOT recommended**. User policy at Gitea #7 close = reverse path not needed. Until policy reversal, NEEDS_RUNTIME_FOLLOWUP is the wrong axis.\n\n## 2. Final decision lean = **NEEDS_DOC_SYNC_FOLLOWUP**\n\nBacklog patch alone (BACKLOG_PATCH_ONLY) is insufficient because `IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md` would remain visible-but-orphaned (design-only contract referencing an IMP-07 gate that the audit just classified `documented:no-runtime`). A reader hitting that doc needs the audit cross-reference banner. Banner edit is forbidden in this issue \u2192 separate issue. **Decision lean : `NEEDS_DOC_SYNC_FOLLOWUP`**.\n\n## 3. Scope-lock (binding for Stage 2~5)\n\n- **Allowed change** : `docs/architecture/INTEGRATION-AUDIT-02-REPORT.md` (create, 7 sections per issue body); `docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md` IMP-07 row status cell (L51) + IMP-16 row status cell (L67) only.\n- **Forbidden** : `src/**`, `templates/**`, `tests/**`, `docs/architecture/IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md` (any line).\n- **Out of scope** : posting follow-up issues \u2014 drafts go in \u00a76 of the report only.\n\n## 4. Stage 2 IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS guidance (audit subtasks \u2014 tests = verification artifacts, NOT pytest)\n\n- **u1 `imp07_close_evidence_read`** \u2014 tests: `[\"Gitea #7 close comment IDs 17970/19226/19240 verbatim quoted in INTEGRATION-AUDIT-02-REPORT.md \u00a72 with timestamps\", \".orchestrator/issues/7_stage_*.md absence noted in report \u00a72\"]`\n- **u2 `imp07_code_reality_grep`** \u2014 tests: `[\"src/ grep html_to_slide_mdx|edited_html_to_mdx|reverse_path result (1 docstring-only hit at src/phase_z2_verification_utils.py:68) quoted in report \u00a72\", \"Front/ grep same pattern (0 hits) quoted in report \u00a72\", \"AUDIT-01 \u00a76.2 row 6 file:line citation noted as overstated-verdict source\"]`\n- **u3 `imp16_u2_deferred_items_resolution`** \u2014 tests: `[\"Each of IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md L71/L72/L73 reclassified as dormant in report \u00a74 with explicit reason citing gate condition (2) or (3) failure\", \"Gate clauses at IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md:12-16 quoted\"]`\n- **u4 `backlog_status_correction_proposal`** \u2014 tests: `[\"Backlog L51 IMP-07 row diff old=implemented new=documented:no-runtime drafted in report \u00a75\", \"Backlog L67 IMP-16 row diff old=implemented new=implemented:u1-only OR row-split proposal drafted in \u00a75\", \"side-by-side table present\"]`\n- **u5 `integration_audit_02_report_assembly`** \u2014 tests: `[\"docs/architecture/INTEGRATION-AUDIT-02-REPORT.md created with all 7 sections per issue body (Executive / Evidence table / IMP-07 verdict / IMP-16-U2 resolution / Backlog correction / Follow-up drafts / Final decision)\", \"Acceptance Criteria checklist verified line-by-line in \u00a77\", \"Final decision = NEEDS_DOC_SYNC_FOLLOWUP per Q4 (F2)\"]`\n- **u6 `followup_recommendation_list`** \u2014 tests: `[\"Follow-up issue (F2) doc-sync draft title + scope sketch in report \u00a76\", \"Explicit NOT-recommended marker for runtime follow-up (F3) with policy-close justification\"]`\n\nStage 5 commit scope = report file (create) + backlog 2 row edits (cell-level). Pipeline run artifacts under `data/runs/` or `.orchestrator/` evidence-only, NOT staged.\n\n## 5. Risk / guardrails\n\n- **Gitea API re-verify pending** : R1's verbatim close-text quotes are the Q1 backbone. TLS handshake to `gitea.hmac.kr` failed this turn. Stage 3 u1 MUST re-fetch via API (or via Codex if persistent) before the report's \u00a72 table is sealed. If quotes differ, rewind to `stage_1_review`.\n- **Status enum hygiene** : `documented:no-runtime` is a new enum (not present in current backlog). Stage 3 u4 must justify the new enum in report \u00a75 (vs reusing `documented (deferred)` which is IMP-17's gate semantics).\n- **No double-write** : F2 (doc-sync) MUST be a separate Gitea issue post-stage-5 \u2014 not auto-posted from this audit (per issue body \u00a7Follow-up recommendation lock).\n\nDO NOT read all Gitea comments. Exit reports are binding contracts.\n\nrewind_target: stage_2_plan\nFINAL_CONSENSUS: NO\n\n=== EVIDENCE ===\nFiles re-read this turn :\n- `docs/architecture/IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md` (76L full \u2014 gate L12-16, deferred items L69-75 confirmed verbatim)\n- `docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md` L40-79 (IMP-07 L51 status=implemented, IMP-16 L67 status=implemented, IMP-17 L68 status=documented (deferred))\n- `docs/architecture/INTEGRATION-AUDIT-01-REPORT.md` lines 224, 240, 265, 272, 482-484 (row 6 verdict cites only designAgentApi.ts file existence + commit 0f0d3fa)\n- `src/phase_z2_verification_utils.py:68` (docstring-only hit \u2014 not runtime)\n- `src/main.py:51-72` (FastAPI = /api/health, /api/generate, / \u2014 no reverse)\n- `Front/client/src/services/designAgentApi.ts:279-294, 1-582` (runPipeline POST /api/run only; no reverse fetch in file)\n- `Front/client/src/components/SlideCanvas.tsx:255-268` (edit mode UI + author note \"backend \ubc18\uc601\uc740 \ubcc4 \uc791\uc5c5\")\n- `Front/client/src/pages/Home.tsx:440-475` (handleContentEdit sets pending flag only)\n- `Front/vite.config.ts:228-505` (middleware enumerated; no reverse endpoint)\n- `Front/server/index.ts` (static-only)\nGreps run this turn :\n- `Grep \"html_to_slide_mdx|edited_html_to_mdx|reverse_path|reverse-path\" src/` \u2192 1 hit (docstring at phase_z2_verification_utils.py:68)\n- `Grep \"html_to_slide_mdx|edited_html_to_mdx|reverse_path|reverse-path|reversePath\" Front/` \u2192 0 hits\n- `Grep \"IMP-07|implemented_live|reverse-path|reverse_path\" docs/architecture/INTEGRATION-AUDIT-01-REPORT.md` \u2192 confirms row 6 verdict reasoning (file existence + 0f0d3fa)\n- `Glob .orchestrator/issues/7_stage_*.md` \u2192 0 files\nNO = R2 confirms scope-lock + Stage 2 unit plan ready; Stage 2 must produce IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS per \u00a74 above with non-empty tests fields. Rewind target stage_2_plan = forward to plan stage (this is a Round-2 problem-review that finalizes the lock; the orchestrator moves to Stage 2 plan next).\n"} |