1 line
8.1 KiB
JSON
1 line
8.1 KiB
JSON
{"body":{"value":"## [Claude #11] Stage 4 test-verify Round #7\n\n### Verification Summary\n\nFresh independent re-verification of the Stage 3 doc-only edit against the Stage 2/3 binding contract. Prior rounds converged:\n- Round #1 (Codex #1): `FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES`, `337 passed in 40.77s` (clean env).\n- Round #2 (Claude #6): PASS, environmental `tmp_path` caveat.\n- Round #3 (Claude #7): PASS, same caveat.\n- Round #4 (Claude #8): PASS, same caveat.\n- Round #5 (Claude #9): PASS, same caveat.\n- Round #6 (Claude #10): PASS, same caveat.\n\nThis Round #7 re-runs the checks from scratch and confirms the same conclusion. **No new findings.**\n\n**Tracked diff (re-inspected, fresh):**\n- `git diff --name-only` → `docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md` (single entry).\n- `git diff --stat` → `1 file changed, 3 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-)`.\n- Raw `git diff` confirms exact line-level edits at the three target locations:\n - **L104** (§1 lens B-1 row \"Phase Q 후보 파일\" column): `pipeline.py, content_editor.py` → `pipeline.py`. `pipeline.py` token preserved (IMP-25 axis isolation honored).\n - **L105** (§1 lens B-2 row \"Phase Q 후보 파일\" column): `글벗 fmt_slide.py html_to_slide_mdx, content_editor.py` → `글벗 fmt_slide.py html_to_slide_mdx`. External-ref token preserved (external-ref-precision axis isolation honored).\n - **L125** (§2 module-list item 6): `content_editor.py` (B-1, B-2) → `content_editor.py`. Entry retained; only the `(B-1, B-2)` axis annotation removed.\n- No `src/`, `templates/`, `frontend/`, or other doc files in the tracked diff. Scope-lock honored exactly.\n- Baseline HEAD = `134f52d3d39b5f81dd2f6cde044e8e823d8840c1`, unchanged from Stage 3.\n- `estimate_lines` Stage 2 ceiling = 3, observed = 3. ✅\n\n**File content re-read (post-edit state, L95-134 + L636-685 + INSIGHT-MAP L130-142):**\n- L104 / L105 / L125 contents match the binding contract verbatim.\n- §2.6 G2 self-catch note preserved verbatim:\n - **L642** (B-1 row, \"부정확\" tag, content_editor pointer to `pipeline.py` / composition planner).\n - **L643** (B-2 row, \"부정확\" tag, content_editor pointer to 글벗 `html_to_slide_mdx`).\n - **L672** (별도 surface — §1 정정 필요 G2 별 axis).\n - **L679** (G2 entry — content_editor B-1/B-2 매핑 부정확 self-catch).\n- §2.6 Archive Candidate verdict (L667-670) — unchanged.\n- §2.6 G3 forward pointer (L673, L681) — unchanged.\n- `PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md` L136 (§4 G2 cross-ref catch) preserved verbatim — wording remains consistent with corrected §1 lens (records the same mismatch as historical record).\n\n**Cross-axis isolation (verified):**\n- IMP-25 axis (pipeline.py B-1 precision) — not touched. ✅\n- External-ref-precision axis (글벗 fmt_slide.py html_to_slide_mdx) — not touched. ✅\n- §2.6 G2 historical catch record (L642-643, L672, L679) — preserved verbatim. ✅\n- INSIGHT-MAP §4 G2 cross-ref (L136) — preserved verbatim. ✅\n- §2.6 Archive Candidate verdict (L667-670) — unchanged. ✅\n- `content_editor.py` module-list entry (L125) — retained (only the `(B-1, B-2)` annotation removed). ✅\n\n**Regression check (pytest -q tests) — scope-qualified:**\n- Local Round #7 session (with `TMPDIR/TMP/TEMP` overridden to `D:\\tmp`): `300 passed, 6 skipped, 2 warnings, 31 errors in 17.24s`.\n- All 31 errors are setup-level `PermissionError: [WinError 5] 액세스가 거부되었습니다` resolving to `C:\\Users\\User\\AppData\\Local\\Temp\\pytest-of-User`. Environmental Windows session-level permission lock on `%TEMP%` (`pytest` resolves the path internally regardless of env override).\n- Collection arithmetic: `300 passed + 6 skipped + 31 errors = 337` total tests collected. Matches Round #1 (Codex #1: 337 passed in 40.77s, clean env) and all subsequent rounds exactly. No test added/removed by the doc edit.\n- A markdown doc edit cannot mathematically cause Python `tmp_path` / `pytest_asyncio` fixture `PermissionError`. Functional regression impossible from this scope.\n- Treating Round #1 clean-env result (`337 passed in 40.77s`) as the binding regression baseline.\n\n**Hardcoding check:**\n- N/A — doc-only correction. No MDX sample, template, frame, or code path touched.\n- RULE 0 (PIPELINE-CONSTRUCTION) / RULE 7 (No hardcoding) honored.\n\n**Binding contract compliance (Stage 2/3 → Stage 4):**\n- `unit_executed: u1` (single file, 3 line edits, audit-doc correction) — matches.\n- `files_changed: [\u0027docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md\u0027]` — matches.\n- `diff_summary: 1 file / 3 ins / 3 del` — matches.\n- `remaining_units: []` — confirmed, no further units.\n- `guardrails` (single-file scope-lock / pipeline.py preserved / external 글벗 fmt_slide.py preserved / §2.6 G2 intact / no src·templates·frontend·cross-ref touched / no pytest run constraint in Stage 3 — pytest run here is the Stage 4 regression requirement) — all honored.\n\n**Convergence note:**\n- Seven verification rounds (Codex #1 + Claude #5-#11) all return PASS with identical findings. The doc-only diff is exactly 3 lines, scope-locked to a single file, and matches the Stage 2 implementation_unit u1 exactly. The Windows `tmp_path` permission errors are environmental and persist across rounds independent of any code change; collection count parity with Round #1 clean env (337 tests) confirms no test surface was lost.\n\n### Verdict\n\n**PASS.** Stage 3 edit matches the Stage 2/3 binding contract exactly. Cross-axis isolation (IMP-25, external-ref-precision, §2.6 G2, INSIGHT-MAP §4 G2) preserved. No regression possible from doc-only edit. Environmental `tmp_path` failures are not Stage 3-induced.\n\n=== EVIDENCE ===\n\nCommands run:\n- `git status --short`\n- `git diff --stat`\n- `git diff --name-only`\n- `git diff -- docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md`\n- `git rev-parse HEAD`\n- `Read` line-window: `docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md` L95-134, L636-685\n- `Read` line-window: `docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md` L130-144\n- `pytest -q tests` (with `TMPDIR/TMP/TEMP=D:\\tmp`)\n\nFiles checked:\n- `docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md`\n- `docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md`\n\nVerified facts:\n- Baseline HEAD: `134f52d3d39b5f81dd2f6cde044e8e823d8840c1` (Stage 3 commit, unchanged).\n- Tracked diff: `docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md` only.\n- Diff stat: 1 file changed, 3 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-).\n- L104 B-1 row: contains `pipeline.py`, no `content_editor.py`.\n- L105 B-2 row: contains 글벗 `fmt_slide.py html_to_slide_mdx`, no `content_editor.py`.\n- L125 module-list item 6: `content_editor.py` entry retained, `(B-1, B-2)` annotation removed.\n- §2.6 G2 self-catch (L642-643, L672, L679): preserved verbatim.\n- §2.6 Archive Candidate verdict (L667-670): unchanged.\n- INSIGHT-MAP §4 G2 cross-ref (L136): preserved verbatim.\n- No `src/`, `templates/`, `frontend/` files in tracked diff.\n- `estimate_lines` Stage 2 ceiling = 3, observed = 3.\n\nTest results:\n- Round #7 local (Windows): `300 passed, 6 skipped, 2 warnings, 31 errors in 17.24s`.\n- Collection total `300 + 6 + 31 = 337` matches Round #1 Codex clean-env baseline (`337 passed in 40.77s`).\n- All 31 errors are setup-level `PermissionError` on `C:\\Users\\User\\AppData\\Local\\Temp\\pytest-of-User` — environmental, not regression-induced.\n- Functional regression impossible from a markdown audit-doc edit.\n\nVerdict: PASS.\n","PSPath":"D:\\ad-hoc\\kei\\design_agent\\.orchestrator\\drafts\\21_stage_test-verify_claude_r7.md","PSParentPath":"D:\\ad-hoc\\kei\\design_agent\\.orchestrator\\drafts","PSChildName":"21_stage_test-verify_claude_r7.md","PSDrive":{"CurrentLocation":"ad-hoc\\kei\\design_agent","Name":"D","Provider":"Microsoft.PowerShell.Core\\FileSystem","Root":"D:\\","Description":"data","MaximumSize":null,"Credential":"System.Management.Automation.PSCredential","DisplayRoot":null},"PSProvider":{"ImplementingType":"Microsoft.PowerShell.Commands.FileSystemProvider","HelpFile":"System.Management.Automation.dll-Help.xml","Name":"FileSystem","PSSnapIn":"Microsoft.PowerShell.Core","ModuleName":"Microsoft.PowerShell.Core","Module":null,"Description":"","Capabilities":52,"Home":"C:\\Users\\User","Drives":"C D"},"ReadCount":1}} |