C.E.L_Slide_test2/.orchestrator/tmp/claude_r35_body.md

[Claude #27] Stage 5 R35 (relay #406) — state delta R34 → R35 = 0. code 0, plan 0, commit 0, push 0. 23rd identical close motion. Refusing further redundant relay per PZ-2 / RULE 0 / RULE 10.

1. R34 → R35 verified state (4 lines)

• git rev-parse HEAD origin/main = 8f6cffc2a7cbfbacb5f6bdeda5ac4d6eaccb22cb × 2; ahead/behind 0/0. 23 rounds identical SHA.
• git diff --name-only HEAD~4..HEAD = exactly the 6 IMP-08 files (D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\Front\client\src\pages\Home.tsx, D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\Front\client\src\services\designAgentApi.ts, D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\Front\vite.config.ts, D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_composition.py, D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\src\phase_z2_pipeline.py, D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\tests\test_phase_z2_subsection_schema.py).
• python -m pytest -q tests = 42 passed in 7.07s PASS (RULE 4 mandated runner).
• python -m unittest discover = Ran 0 tests in 0.000s / NO TESTS RAN exit 0 here (Python 3.13 sentinel) / Codex runtime reports exit 1 — same root: orchestrator template mismatch with RULE 4.

2. R35 action-0 justification (unchanged 23 rounds)

IMP-08 agreed plan ∩ not-yet-implemented = ∅. The seven exhaustively rejected paths from R5~R34 remain rejected:

1. New IMP-08 commit on speculative change → RULE 0 (no general-pipeline improvement available).
2. Self-edit .orchestrator/codex_prompt.txt:65 (unittest discover → pytest -q tests) → orchestrator-gate axis, separate decision unit per RULE 6; file untracked / user-owned.
3. --no-verify / hook bypass → explicitly forbidden by environment instructions.
4. Inject unittest.TestCase shim → RULE 7 (fix process, not result).
5. Clean dirty worktree → RULE 6/7 (other-axis WIP, not IMP-08 ownership).
6. Self-open new issue → shared-state action outside AI auth scope.
7. Flip to YES → RULE 10 symmetric violation (uncritical close = uncritical accept).

3. Codex acceptance restated (22 rounds running)

Codex #33 verbatim: "I accept the pushed IMP-08 commit at commit scope as a general Phase Z pipeline improvement, but I cannot give final consensus … because the required python -m unittest discover axis fails and the checkout still contains substantial out-of-scope dirty state." Codex #34 identical. Both AIs converged on IMP-08 commit-scope ACCEPT 22 rounds ago. The remaining NO is purely orchestrator-template axis + cross-axis dirty checkout — neither is IMP-08 scope.

4. Artifact status (RULE 3 + RULE 4)

• rendered [IMP-08 backend/schema axis]: not regenerated (commit-scope verification round).
• visual_check [IMP-08 backend/schema axis]: N/A.
• full_mdx_coverage [IMP-08 commit-range axis]: 29 rounds of static review found no MDX 03/04/05 / single-section-id / single-frame branch in HEAD~4..HEAD. RULE 0 prohibitions clear.

5. Termination paths (user-action only, unchanged 22 rounds)

• A. User ticks implemented + verified on issue body checklist and closes IMP-08 on commit-scope (already double-accepted by both AIs).
• B. User 1-line edit D:\ad-hoc\kei\design_agent\.orchestrator\codex_prompt.txt:65 python -m unittest discover → python -m pytest -q tests. Aligns orchestrator gate with RULE 4. Separate decision unit from IMP-08.
• C. User opens new issues for (1) orchestrator-gate template axis, (2) whole-checkout dirty cross-axis WIP, then closes IMP-08 on commit-scope.

6. Loop meta (factual, PZ-2)

• 23 consecutive Claude rounds (R13~R35) state delta 0 on IMP-08 commit-range axis.
• 22 consecutive Codex rounds (R13~R34) commit-scope ACCEPT + whole-checkout NO / unittest-gate NO split.
• Information gain per round since R12 = 0. AI-loop cannot self-converge without user-action on path A / B / C.

FINAL_CONSENSUS: NO