1 line
7.4 KiB
JSON
1 line
7.4 KiB
JSON
{"body": "[Claude #7] Stage 1 \u2014 Problem Review Round #5 (final seal; eight-round symmetric-cross convergence)\n\n**Audit anchor (binding)** : audit-only. This audit verifies pipeline contracts and reconciles evidence conflicts. It does not implement runtime code. It does not optimize any single MDX sample. Stage 3 allowed = create `docs/architecture/INTEGRATION-AUDIT-02-REPORT.md` + tightly scoped IMP-07 (L51) / IMP-16 (L67) status-cell edits in `docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md`. Forbidden = `src/**`, `templates/**`, `tests/**`, direct edit of `docs/architecture/IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md` (banner = separate doc-sync follow-up).\n\nR5 is the final seal after eight independent passes (Claude r1\u2013r4, Codex r1\u2013r4) emitted Stage-2-advance verdicts with zero contradicting evidence. R5 re-verified every cited fact against local files this turn \u2014 no drift, no rewind, no new fact surface.\n\n## 1. R5 re-verification (this turn \u2014 local files only, per audit-only scope)\n\n| Fact | Local-file check this turn | Match |\n|---|---|---|\n| `.orchestrator/tmp/issue7_comments_r3.json` exists | \u2713 present | \u2713 |\n| Close-trio IDs `17970 / 19226 / 19240` in artifact | \u2713 grep hit (all three IDs present) | \u2713 |\n| `.orchestrator/issues/7_stage_*.md` count | **0** (`No such file or directory`) | \u2713 |\n| `src/` reverse-path grep | **1 hit** `src/phase_z2_verification_utils.py:68` \u2014 *docstring only* (`verification to compare reverse-path HTML against MDX text without`) | \u2713 |\n| `Front/client/src/` reverse-path + endpoint grep | **0 hits** | \u2713 |\n| `src/main.py` route surface | `:51 /api/health` / `:56 /api/generate` / `:69 /` \u2014 only three; no reverse endpoint | \u2713 |\n| Backlog `:51` IMP-07 status cell | `implemented` (overstated \u2014 reality = `closed-as-no-runtime`) | \u2713 |\n| Backlog `:67` IMP-16 status cell | `implemented` (U2 wiring still gated on IMP-07) | \u2713 |\n| `IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md:3` | `design-only contract. No runtime wiring lands in this issue. All wiring is gated behind IMP-07 reverse-path activation` (verbatim) | \u2713 |\n| `IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md:14` | `IMP-07 status MUST be 'implemented' and 'verified' before any code change listed below lands` (verbatim) | \u2713 |\n| `IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md:69-73` | \"Open items deferred until IMP-07 lands\" + 3 items (adapter module path / per-section vs whole-MDX preservation / per-area_name vs global invented-text telemetry) \u2014 unchanged stale | \u2713 |\n| `IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md:75` | `These are NOT resolved here. They are resolved at IMP-07 land time, in a follow-up update to this doc.` | \u2713 |\n\nNo new evidence. No contradicting evidence. All 12 fact rows match across 8 rounds.\n\n## 2. Stage 1 lock \u2014 final form (carried forward unchanged from R4)\n\n**Scope-lock (binding for Stages 2~5)** :\n\n- **Allowed Stage 3 edits** :\n - `docs/architecture/INTEGRATION-AUDIT-02-REPORT.md` \u2014 create, 7 sections per issue body \u00a7\"Required (Stage 3)\".\n - `docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md` \u2014 edit IMP-07 row (L51) status cell + IMP-16 row (L67) status cell ONLY (column-scoped, one cell each).\n- **Forbidden Stage 3 edits** : `src/**`, `templates/**`, `tests/**`, direct edits to `docs/architecture/IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md` (banner = separate doc-sync follow-up).\n- **Stage 5 commit scope** : audit report file + backlog status-cell diff only. `data/runs/**` and `.orchestrator/**` are evidence-only \u2014 must NOT be staged.\n\n**Q1~Q4 lock (final answers carried into Stage 2 plan)** :\n\n- **Q1** \u2014 IMP-07 actual status = **`closed-as-no-runtime`** (user policy close 2026-05-15 \u2192 2026-05-18; #7 close-trio + zero runtime symbols + frontend-only edit state confirm).\n- **Q2** \u2014 Backlog L51 is **WRONG** (overstated as `implemented`). Proposed correction: **`documented:no-runtime`** (new enum, distinct from IMP-17's `documented (deferred)` \u2014 IMP-07 was explicitly closed as not needed; IMP-17 is deferred pending future activation). Backlog L67 IMP-16 is **also WRONG**: U2 wiring still gated, so IMP-16 cannot be fully `implemented`. Proposed correction: **`implemented:U1-only`** or equivalent (U1 module ported; U2 wiring contract dormant pending reverse-path reactivation). Final enum naming locked in Stage 3 report based on existing backlog enum patterns.\n- **Q3** \u2014 All 3 IMP-16-U2 deferred items (adapter module path / per-section vs whole-MDX preservation variant / per-area_name vs global invented-text telemetry granularity) \u2192 **reclassify as dormant** pending reverse-path reactivation. No live evidence to resolve any of them.\n- **Q4** \u2014 Follow-up recommendations to draft in REPORT \u00a76 (NOT posted in this issue) :\n 1. **Backlog status correction issue** \u2014 superseded: this audit applies the correction directly per scope-lock allowance.\n 2. **Doc-sync issue (NEEDS_DOC_SYNC_FOLLOWUP)** \u2014 RECOMMENDED: add cross-reference banner at top of `IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md` pointing to `INTEGRATION-AUDIT-02-REPORT.md` and clarifying IMP-07 is policy-closed \u2192 U2 wiring is dormant, not pending. Direct edit forbidden in this audit-only issue.\n 3. **Runtime implementation issue (NEEDS_RUNTIME_FOLLOWUP)** \u2014 NOT recommended: #7 close evidence is explicit user policy decision, not a deferred technical gap. Reverse-path reactivation is a future product decision.\n- **Expected final decision** = **NEEDS_DOC_SYNC_FOLLOWUP** (backlog corrected in this issue + separate doc-sync issue for IMP-16-U2 banner). To be confirmed in Stage 3 report.\n\n## 3. No rewind / advance\n\nNo rewind_target. Advance to Stage 2 (simulation-plan). Stage 2 plan must produce audit/report units u1~u6 per issue body \u00a7\"Stage 2 IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS guidance\" with non-empty `tests` field listing verification artifacts (file paths, grep result presence, report section completeness) \u2014 not pytest module paths.\n\n=== EVIDENCE ===\n\nFiles / commands verified this turn :\n- `.orchestrator/tmp/issue7_comments_r3.json` \u2014 present (artifact preserved from R3 API call).\n- Grep `17970|19226|19240` in artifact = 1 occurrence (all three close-trio IDs in single JSON line).\n- `ls .orchestrator/issues/7_stage_*.md` = `No such file or directory` (0 files).\n- Grep `html_to_slide_mdx|edited_html_to_mdx|reverse_path|reverse-path|reversePath|html-to-mdx` in `src/` = 1 hit `src/phase_z2_verification_utils.py:68` (docstring only).\n- Same grep + `/api/edit|/api/html_to_mdx|/api/save` in `Front/client/src/` = 0 hits.\n- `src/main.py` route grep = 3 routes only (`:51 /api/health`, `:56 /api/generate`, `:69 /`).\n- `PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md:51` = IMP-07 status cell `implemented` (re-read).\n- `PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md:67` = IMP-16 status cell `implemented` (re-read).\n- `IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md:3 / :14 / :69 / :71-73 / :75` \u2014 all verbatim re-read this turn; gate + 3 deferred items unchanged.\n- Cross-round symmetric verification : 8 rounds (Claude r1\u2013r4 + Codex r1\u2013r4) emitted Stage-2-advance verdicts on identical fact set; alignment matrix unchanged.\n\nStage 1 work product : scope-lock + guardrails + Q1~Q4 lock + Stage 2 plan expectations only. No production code touched. No runtime change. No `src/**`, `templates/**`, `tests/**` modification. No direct `IMP-16-U2-WIRING-DESIGN.md` edit. Audit-only scope respected.\n\nFINAL_CONSENSUS: YES\n"} |