1 line
74 KiB
JSON
1 line
74 KiB
JSON
[{"id": 21690, "html_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/26#issuecomment-21690", "pull_request_url": "", "issue_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/26", "user": {"id": 28, "login": "Kyeongmin", "login_name": "", "source_id": 0, "full_name": "이경민", "email": "kyeongmin@noreply.localhost", "avatar_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/avatars/d883a35f9197b080b2a0c535c3f9357dcd5c7d40b3c42bd8f40218cb94609a8e", "html_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin", "language": "", "is_admin": false, "last_login": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", "created": "2025-12-30T10:51:04+09:00", "restricted": false, "active": false, "prohibit_login": false, "location": "", "website": "", "description": "", "visibility": "public", "followers_count": 0, "following_count": 0, "starred_repos_count": 1, "username": "Kyeongmin"}, "original_author": "", "original_author_id": 0, "body": "[Claude #1] Stage 1 — IMP-26 problem review (J3 html_generator utility 중복 cleanup)\n\n### Root-cause framing\n\nIMP-26 = `PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md §2.9` footnote **J3**: deterministic helpers inside `src/html_generator.py` (`normalize_mdx`, `_slice_mdx_sections`, `_get_definitions`, `_get_conclusion`) duplicate the §2.1 `mdx_normalizer.py` / §2.2 `section_parser.py` SoT. The audit classifies them as **Reference Only** inside an otherwise **Archive Candidate** module — and J3 explicitly says *\"Phase R' cleanup 시 제거/보존 여부를 별도 판단\"*. The issue body declares the trigger as \"Phase R' cleanup axis 활성 시\" with priority ↓ low (future). The Stage 1 question is: **is that trigger axis active today, and can the four helpers be removed in isolation?**\n\nAnswer (verified below): **no, on both counts**. The helpers are not isolated dead code — they have multiple live in-module callers plus an external import from `content_verifier.generate_with_retry`, which `pipeline.py` Stage 2 still dispatches for layout_template = Type A. Deleting them standalone breaks the Type A AI-HTML path that the active pipeline still consumes. The interfaces also diverge from the SoT (different return shapes / inputs), so the four helpers are not drop-in replaceable by §2.1 / §2.2 — a redirect would be a *migration with adapter code*, not \"코드 제거만\". The right scope-lock is therefore to **defer IMP-26 until the full §2.9 archive trigger fires** (i.e., when the Type A AI-HTML path is removed from the live pipeline), so the four helpers fall with their hosting module rather than as an isolated cleanup.\n\n### Verified facts (value + path + upstream)\n\n- **Issue backlog row** = `docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md` IMP-26 §4 cleanup (3). Priority ↓ low (future). Trigger = \"Phase R' cleanup axis 활성 시\". Guardrail = \"Phase R' 영역 — 코드 제거만, 다른 axis 무관\".\n- **Source insight** = `docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md §5 J3` (별 axis 후보 cleanup) + `docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md §2.9` (`src/html_generator.py` audit, lines 900–991).\n- **§2.9 audit verdict (verified)** = whole `html_generator.py` = \"Mixed (Archive heavy — Phase R' core). Salvage Candidate 0\". The four helpers themselves = **Reference Only** with `§2.1 / §2.2 에 더 직접적인 SoT 후보 존재` (lines 946–951). J3 footnote (line 975): cleanup deferred to Phase R' archive timing.\n- **SoT modules verified**:\n - §2.1 SoT = `src/mdx_normalizer.py::normalize_mdx_content` (line 395) — 4-layer parser (frontmatter / code-block protect / markdown-it-py AST / clean). Returns dict `{clean_text, title, images, popups, tables, sections}`.\n - §2.2 SoT = `src/section_parser.py::extract_major_sections` (line 23), `extract_conclusion_text` (line 491). Operates on already-normalized sections (list[dict]).\n- **Duplicate helpers in `src/html_generator.py`**:\n - `normalize_mdx` line 752 — single-pass regex → **str** (vs §2.1 returns dict).\n - `_slice_mdx_sections` line 830 — calls local `normalize_mdx`, returns `dict[str, str]` keyed by section name (vs §2.2 operates on `list[dict]` and returns `list[dict]`).\n - `_get_definitions` line 930 — uses `_slice_mdx_sections`; matches \"용어/정의\" section.\n - `_get_conclusion` line 943 — uses `_slice_mdx_sections`; matches \"요약/결론\" (vs §2.2 `extract_conclusion_text` which parses `:::note[핵심 요약]` from raw MDX).\n- **Interface divergence (not drop-in)**:\n - §2.1 input = raw MDX → dict output; helper `normalize_mdx` returns plain string. Adapter required.\n - §2.2 input = `normalized_sections: list[dict]`; helper `_slice_mdx_sections` input = raw `content: str`. Different abstractions.\n - §2.2 `extract_conclusion_text` reads `:::note[핵심 요약]` directive; helper `_get_conclusion` reads section names by Korean substring. Behaviorally different. **A pure deletion + import swap would change runtime behavior in the Type A path.**\n- **In-module live callers (would break on deletion)**:\n - `_slice_mdx_sections` — `generate_slide_html` line 654; `regenerate_area` line 1011.\n - `_get_definitions` — `regenerate_area` line 1029.\n - `_get_conclusion` — `generate_slide_html` line 730 (footer fallback); `regenerate_area` line 1041.\n - `normalize_mdx` — only consumed by `_slice_mdx_sections` line 837 (private chain; deletable iff `_slice_mdx_sections` is also deleted).\n- **External live callers (verified by grep, non-test)**:\n - `src/content_verifier.py:566` — `async def generate_with_retry(...)` imports `_slice_mdx_sections, _map_sections_for_role, _get_definitions, _get_conclusion`. Uses `_slice_mdx_sections` at line 570; `_map_sections_for_role` at line 594. `_get_definitions` / `_get_conclusion` consumed via `regenerate_area` chain.\n - Test scripts (`scripts/test_phase_r_prime.py`, `test_phase_s.py`, `test_phase_t.py`, `test_phase_t_audit.py`, `test_phase_t_real.py`) import `generate_slide_html` / `_build_phase_t_supplement` but **not** the four helpers directly.\n- **Pipeline reachability of the live caller chain**:\n - `src/pipeline.py:1196` Stage 2: `if context.analysis.layout_template in (\"B\", \"B'\", \"B''\"):` → `block_assembler.assemble_slide_html_final` (bypasses `html_generator`). Otherwise (Type A) → `from src.content_verifier import generate_with_retry; await generate_with_retry(...)` (line 1241).\n - `src/pipeline.py:1653` + 1679 — second dispatch site (regenerate path / re-entry), same `generate_with_retry` call.\n - Conclusion: **Type A layouts still flow through `content_verifier.generate_with_retry → html_generator.generate_slide_html / regenerate_area`**. The four helpers are *live transitively* in this path.\n- **Trigger axis status** = NOT ACTIVE today. `html_generator.py` as a whole is Archive Candidate per §2.9 audit, **but its archival has not happened**: pipeline.py still dispatches Type A through it. The J3 cleanup is by construction downstream of that archive, not parallel to it.\n- **HEAD** = `a71355e0059caaae9d53372ba2987551998bd7b8` (branch `main`).\n- **Working tree** = dirty on orchestrator infra + Phase Q audit docs WIP; no `src/html_generator.py` / `src/content_verifier.py` / `src/mdx_normalizer.py` / `src/section_parser.py` dirty edits. No accidental cross-axis bleed surface.\n\n### Scope-lock\n\n**SCOPE-LOCKED:** **NOT-READY-FOR-IMPLEMENTATION this cycle.** IMP-26 cannot land standalone because:\n\n1. The four helpers are live (in-module callers + `content_verifier.py:566` import + pipeline Stage 2 Type A path). Deletion breaks runtime.\n2. The §2.1 / §2.2 SoT is not interface-compatible (different inputs / outputs / matching logic). A redirect is a **migration with adapter**, not \"코드 제거만\" — outside this issue's stated guardrail.\n3. J3 footnote explicitly defers to \"Phase R' cleanup 시\" — and Phase R' (Type A AI-HTML generation) is still live per `pipeline.py:1196 / 1241 / 1653 / 1679`. Precondition for the J3 trigger axis is **not** the four helpers themselves but the archival of the hosting module `html_generator.py` (and the `content_verifier.generate_with_retry` Type A branch).\n\n**Recommended action this cycle**: keep IMP-26 in `pending` / `↓ low` state, but tighten the trigger axis description from the loose \"Phase R' cleanup axis 활성 시\" to an explicit unblock precondition:\n\n> Unblock when: (a) `pipeline.py` Stage 2 Type A dispatch (`content_verifier.generate_with_retry` branch at line 1241 + 1679) is removed OR rerouted to a deterministic pipeline, AND (b) `src/html_generator.py` is staged for full Archive (per §2.9 audit), AND (c) `content_verifier.py:566` import line is severed. At that point the four helpers go with their hosting module.\n\nThis conversion is documentation-only (backlog row / status board), not a code edit. **Defer all code work to a future cycle gated on the unblock precondition above.**\n\n**OUT OF SCOPE (this cycle)**:\n- Any code edit to `src/html_generator.py` (no deletion of the four helpers; no redirect; no shim).\n- Any edit to `src/content_verifier.py` (line 566 import remains).\n- Any edit to `src/mdx_normalizer.py` / `src/section_parser.py` (SoT untouched).\n- Any edit to `src/pipeline.py` Stage 2 dispatch (Type A path remains).\n- Adapter / wrapper layer between helpers and SoT (interface divergence is a migration, not a cleanup).\n- Test fixtures / unit tests for any of the above.\n\n**OUT OF SCOPE (axis bleed — separate axes)**:\n- Full `html_generator.py` archive itself (Phase R' main archive — bigger axis, separate issue).\n- Type A → deterministic refactor (block_assembler-style for Type A — separate axis).\n- §2.1 / §2.2 own consolidation (not this audit J row).\n\n### Guardrails\n\n- G1 (PZ-1, RULE 0): AI=0 normal path — Stage 1 is documentation-only; no code edit, no AI invocation. Preserves AI 격리 contract.\n- G2 (RULE 7): no MDX 03/04/05 hardcoding — N/A this cycle (no code edit).\n- G3 (RULE 11 checkpoint): the four helpers + their callers + the SoT all read in this round; no inferred-but-unverified claim. Each \"live caller\" / \"SoT divergence\" claim is grounded in a file + line number above.\n- G4 (J3 footnote literal): IMP-26 cannot precede `html_generator.py` archive. Stage 1 lock honors that constraint.\n- G5 (RULE 13 anchor sync, if Stage 5 fires): backlog row IMP-26 (unblock precondition) + status board (if it tracks IMP-26 trigger) must be edited in one commit. Issue cross-ref unchanged.\n- G6 (PZ-2): 1 turn = 1 step — Stage 1 closes here. No jumping ahead to plan. No proposal of \"let's also do IMP-29 / IMP-19 together\" even if J3 sits adjacent to other J-row issues.\n- G7 (Workflow atomicity): if this issue ever lands code, 1 commit = 1 decision unit; existing working-tree WIP (orchestrator.py, audit docs) MUST NOT be staged under this issue.\n- G8 (scope-qualified verification): scope = `src/html_generator.py` 의 4 개 helper + their direct callers (`generate_slide_html`, `regenerate_area`, `content_verifier.generate_with_retry`) + dispatch (`pipeline.py` Stage 2). All grep claims qualified to these files; no \"전체 통과\" framing.\n\n### Risk\n\nLow (Stage 1 is read-only investigation).\n\nFailure modes of the *deferral decision itself*:\n- (a) Trigger axis prediction wrong — i.e., `pipeline.py:1196` Type A branch is removed without IMP-26 firing. Mitigation: backlog row unblock precondition makes the dependency explicit; any later PR that touches Stage 2 dispatch is anchor-linked.\n- (b) `content_verifier.py:566` import grows new consumers in the meantime. Mitigation: J3 footnote already flags this as Reference Only; PHASE-Q-AUDIT §2.7 caps `content_verifier.py` as Reference Only too — no new Phase Z code should import either.\n- (c) Helper internal divergence accumulates (someone edits `normalize_mdx` in `html_generator.py` while §2.1 evolves). Mitigation: §2.9 audit + this Stage 1 record document the divergence; future drift is detectable via audit re-pass.\n\nFailure modes of *taking the standalone deletion path* (i.e., rejecting this Stage 1's recommendation):\n- (a) Type A pipeline breaks at runtime (`pipeline.py:1241 / 1679`) — FATAL.\n- (b) Behavior change in Type A footer (`_get_conclusion` Korean section-name match vs §2.2 `:::note[핵심 요약]` directive parse) silently regresses without test surface.\n- (c) Migration via adapter shim violates the issue's own \"코드 제거만\" guardrail — scope creep.\n\n### Open questions for Codex r1\n\n1. **Trigger-axis precondition wording**: proposed three-clause unblock condition (a/b/c above). Should the precondition also include \"(d) Phase Z 22-step pipeline status board marks Step ? (Type A dispatch) as deprecated\"? Defer to Codex on whether the status board has the right surface today; if so, recommend adding (d) for traceability.\n2. **Documentation venue for the precondition**: backlog row text edit only, vs status board J3 row vs both. Recommend backlog row only this cycle (1-line edit) + status board edit deferred to when the full §2.9 archive issue is filed.\n3. **Companion footnote on `_map_sections_for_role`**: J3 lists only the four helpers, but `content_verifier.py:566` also imports `_map_sections_for_role` from the same Reference-Only set. Question: keep IMP-26 scope strictly to the four named helpers (audit J3 letter), or surface the fifth as a sibling note. Recommend strict letter — surfacing as scope expansion would violate PZ-2 / RULE 10.\n\n### Stage 1 lock summary\n\n- Root cause: J3 cleanup is gated on full Phase R' archive (`src/html_generator.py` whole-module archive + `content_verifier.generate_with_retry` Type A path retirement). Today the gate is not satisfied because `pipeline.py` Stage 2 Type A still dispatches through that path.\n- Scope locked: **NOT-READY-FOR-IMPLEMENTATION this cycle.** Recommended cycle output = documentation-only refinement of the unblock precondition in the IMP-26 backlog row. No code edit. No SoT migration. No adapter.\n- Trigger precondition (proposed): (a) Type A dispatch removed/rerouted, (b) `html_generator.py` staged for archive, (c) `content_verifier.py:566` import severed.\n- Guardrails G1–G8 above.\n\n=== EVIDENCE ===\n- Commands run:\n - `git rev-parse HEAD` → `a71355e0059caaae9d53372ba2987551998bd7b8`.\n - `git status --porcelain` → orchestrator WIP + audit docs only; no `src/html_generator.py` / `src/content_verifier.py` / `src/mdx_normalizer.py` / `src/section_parser.py` / `src/pipeline.py` dirty edits.\n - `find /d/ad-hoc/kei/design_agent/src -type f -name \"*.py\" | xargs grep -l \"def normalize_mdx\\|def _slice_mdx_sections\\|def _get_definitions\\|def _get_conclusion\"` → `src/html_generator.py`, `src/mdx_normalizer.py` only. Two duplicate definition surfaces confirmed (SoT vs Reference-Only).\n - `grep -rn \"html_generator\" --include=\"*.py\" /d/ad-hoc/kei/design_agent/src /d/ad-hoc/kei/design_agent/scripts` → live consumers: `src/content_verifier.py:566` (non-test) + 5 test scripts (`test_phase_r_prime.py`, `test_phase_s.py`, `test_phase_t.py`, `test_phase_t_audit.py`, `test_phase_t_real.py`); none of the test scripts import the four helpers directly.\n - `grep -rn \"generate_with_retry\\|generate_slide_html\\|regenerate_area\" src app.py` → `src/pipeline.py:1196, 1222, 1241, 1653, 1679` confirms Type A dispatch live in `pipeline.py` Stage 2.\n - `grep -n \"^def \\|^class \" src/section_parser.py` → §2.2 SoT surface: `extract_major_sections` (23), `detect_component_popups` (100), `_classify_sub_types` (157), `classify_group_relations` (269), `resolve_schema` (363), `get_recipe_for_schema` (425), `check_kind_compatibility` (464), `get_candidate_blocks_for_schema` (473), `extract_conclusion_text` (491), `map_topics_to_sections` (508).\n- Files read:\n - `src/html_generator.py` (full file 1–1070, with focused inspection of helper definitions at 752 / 830 / 930 / 943 and live caller sites at 654 / 730 / 1011 / 1029 / 1041).\n - `src/mdx_normalizer.py` (full file 1–501; SoT `normalize_mdx_content` line 395 confirmed; 4-layer architecture confirmed).\n - `src/section_parser.py` lines 485–510 (§2.2 SoT `extract_conclusion_text` confirmed).\n - `src/content_verifier.py` lines 540–620 (live import at line 566 + usage at 570 / 594 confirmed; `generate_with_retry` async entry confirmed).\n - `src/pipeline.py` lines 1180–1270 (Stage 2 Type A dispatch confirmed; layout_template branching at line 1187 + 1196 + 1241).\n - `docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md` §2.9 lines 900–991 (Mixed Archive-heavy verdict; Reference Only classification for the four helpers; J3 footnote at line 975 confirmed; `_map_sections_for_role` companion Reference-Only at line 948 noted as Q3).\n - `.orchestrator/drafts/16_stage_problem-review_claude_r1.md` (Stage 1 Claude-r1 precedent format reference).\n- Facts cross-checked:\n - Helper interfaces vs §2.1 / §2.2 SoT — divergent return shapes and inputs (file + line refs above) → standalone deletion + import-swap would change runtime semantics, not just remove redundancy.\n - Live caller chain `pipeline.py → content_verifier.generate_with_retry → html_generator.generate_slide_html / regenerate_area → four helpers` is reachable today for layout_template = Type A (i.e., layout_template NOT in B / B' / B'').\n - J3 footnote literal (\"Phase R' cleanup 시 ... 별도 판단\") matches the deferral recommendation in Scope-lock above; no inferential leap.\n - Trigger axis description in the issue body (\"Phase R' cleanup axis 활성 시\") is **not** observable as active in the current repo state — refined to explicit three-clause precondition.\n\nFINAL_CONSENSUS: YES\n", "assets": [], "created_at": "2026-05-20T18:07:48+09:00", "updated_at": "2026-05-20T18:07:48+09:00"}, {"id": 21692, "html_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/26#issuecomment-21692", "pull_request_url": "", "issue_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/26", "user": {"id": 28, "login": "Kyeongmin", "login_name": "", "source_id": 0, "full_name": "이경민", "email": "kyeongmin@noreply.localhost", "avatar_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/avatars/d883a35f9197b080b2a0c535c3f9357dcd5c7d40b3c42bd8f40218cb94609a8e", "html_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin", "language": "", "is_admin": false, "last_login": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", "created": "2025-12-30T10:51:04+09:00", "restricted": false, "active": false, "prohibit_login": false, "location": "", "website": "", "description": "", "visibility": "public", "followers_count": 0, "following_count": 0, "starred_repos_count": 1, "username": "Kyeongmin"}, "original_author": "", "original_author_id": 0, "body": "[Codex #1] Stage 1 problem review - IMP-26\n\nI verified Claude #1's root-cause framing and scope-lock: IMP-26 should not proceed as an isolated helper deletion in the current state.\n\nFindings:\n- The backlog row marks IMP-26 as low/future, status pending, with trigger \"Phase R' cleanup axis active\" and scope limited to duplicate cleanup for `normalize_mdx` / `_slice_mdx_sections` / `_get_definitions` / `_get_conclusion`: `docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md:93`.\n- The source insight maps J3 to `html_generator` duplicate helpers vs the §2.1 / §2.2 SoT, also only when the Phase R' cleanup axis is active: `docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md:150`.\n- The §2.9 audit classifies `html_generator.py` as \"Mixed (Archive heavy - Phase R' core)\", \"Salvage Candidate 0\", with the four helpers as Reference Only, not Salvage: `docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md:940-948`.\n- The audit's J3 note explicitly says the duplicate helper cleanup/removal decision is deferred to a separate Phase R' cleanup decision: `docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md:956`.\n- The SoT candidates are real but not drop-in compatible. `src/mdx_normalizer.py:393-438` exposes `normalize_mdx_content(raw_mdx) -> dict` with `clean_text`, `title`, `images`, `popups`, `tables`, and `sections`, while `src/html_generator.py:752-827` exposes `normalize_mdx(raw_mdx) -> str`.\n- `src/section_parser.py:23-45` consumes a `list[dict]` of normalized sections and returns major-section structures; `src/html_generator.py:830-842` returns `dict[str, str]` after local normalization. Replacing it with §2.2 would require adapter/migration work, not \"code removal only\".\n- The helpers still have live callers. In-module callers exist at `src/html_generator.py:654`, `src/html_generator.py:730`, `src/html_generator.py:1011`, `src/html_generator.py:1029`, and `src/html_generator.py:1041`.\n- There is also an external import path: `src/content_verifier.py:535` imports `generate_slide_html`, `regenerate_area`, `_slice_mdx_sections`, `_map_sections_for_role`, `_get_definitions`, and `_get_conclusion`; `src/content_verifier.py:539` immediately calls `_slice_mdx_sections(content)`.\n- The active legacy Type A path still reaches that external import. `src/pipeline.py:1187-1196` branches Type B/B'/B'' to block assembly but imports `generate_with_retry` for Type A, and `src/pipeline.py:1241-1247` calls it. A second legacy path also imports/calls `generate_with_retry` at `src/pipeline.py:1653` and `src/pipeline.py:1679`.\n\nScope-lock decision:\n- Do not remove these four helpers in isolation.\n- Do not redirect to §2.1 / §2.2 as part of IMP-26 unless the stage is explicitly reframed as a migration with adapters and regression coverage.\n- The safe lock is to defer IMP-26 until the Phase R' archive/cleanup axis is actually active and the Type A AI-HTML path no longer consumes `html_generator.py` / `content_verifier.generate_with_retry`.\n\n=== EVIDENCE ===\nCommands run:\n- `Get-Content -LiteralPath 'D:\\ad-hoc\\kei\\design_agent\\.orchestrator\\tmp\\codex_prompt.txt'`\n- `Get-ChildItem -Force`\n- `rg --files`\n- `git status --short`\n- `rg -n \"IMP-26|J3|html_generator|normalize_mdx|_slice_mdx_sections|_get_definitions|_get_conclusion|Phase R\" docs src tests scripts`\n- `rg -n \"generate_with_retry|layout_template|Type A|html_generator|normalize_mdx|_slice_mdx_sections|_get_definitions|_get_conclusion\" src tests scripts`\n- `rg -n \"def normalize_mdx_content|def extract_major_sections|def extract_conclusion_text|return \\{\" src\\mdx_normalizer.py src\\section_parser.py`\n- `Select-String -Path 'docs\\architecture\\PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md' -Pattern 'IMP-26' -Context 2,3`\n- `Select-String -Path 'docs\\architecture\\PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md' -Pattern 'J3|html_generator|normalize_mdx|_slice_mdx_sections|_get_definitions|_get_conclusion' -Context 2,4`\n- `Select-String -Path 'docs\\architecture\\PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md' -Pattern '2\\.9|html_generator|normalize_mdx|_slice_mdx_sections|_get_definitions|_get_conclusion|J3|Reference Only|Archive' -Context 2,4`\n- `rg -n \"^def normalize_mdx|^def _slice_mdx_sections|^def _get_definitions|^def _get_conclusion|_slice_mdx_sections\\(|_get_definitions\\(|_get_conclusion\\(\" src\\html_generator.py src\\content_verifier.py src\\pipeline.py scripts tests`\n- targeted line reads from `src\\html_generator.py`, `src\\content_verifier.py`, `src\\pipeline.py`, `src\\mdx_normalizer.py`, `src\\section_parser.py`, and `docs\\architecture\\PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md`\nFiles checked:\n- `docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md`\n- `docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md`\n- `docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md`\n- `src/html_generator.py`\n- `src/content_verifier.py`\n- `src/pipeline.py`\n- `src/mdx_normalizer.py`\n- `src/section_parser.py`\nTest results: not run; Stage 1 explicitly says \"NO pytest\".\nVerified facts:\n- IMP-26 is pending and gated on Phase R' cleanup activation.\n- §2.1 / §2.2 SoT candidates exist, but their interfaces differ from the four `html_generator` helpers.\n- The four helpers are still reachable from the active Type A AI-HTML path via `content_verifier.generate_with_retry`.\n- Isolated deletion would break current callers; any replacement is a migration, not code-removal-only cleanup.\nFINAL_CONSENSUS: YES\n", "assets": [], "created_at": "2026-05-20T18:10:56+09:00", "updated_at": "2026-05-20T18:10:56+09:00"}, {"id": 21694, "html_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/26#issuecomment-21694", "pull_request_url": "", "issue_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/26", "user": {"id": 28, "login": "Kyeongmin", "login_name": "", "source_id": 0, "full_name": "이경민", "email": "kyeongmin@noreply.localhost", "avatar_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/avatars/d883a35f9197b080b2a0c535c3f9357dcd5c7d40b3c42bd8f40218cb94609a8e", "html_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin", "language": "", "is_admin": false, "last_login": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", "created": "2025-12-30T10:51:04+09:00", "restricted": false, "active": false, "prohibit_login": false, "location": "", "website": "", "description": "", "visibility": "public", "followers_count": 0, "following_count": 0, "starred_repos_count": 1, "username": "Kyeongmin"}, "original_author": "", "original_author_id": 0, "body": "[Claude #2] Stage 2 simulation-plan — IMP-26 deferral formalization\n\n=== IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS ===\n- id: u1\n summary: Mark IMP-26 backlog row deferred + expand trigger axis with SoT-signature precondition; mirror trigger axis text in INSIGHT-MAP §5 J3 row\n files:\n - docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md\n - docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md\n tests: []\n estimate_lines: 6\n\n=== AXIS / ITEM COVERAGE ===\nIssue body explicit axes/items:\n| # | axis/item (from body) | covered_by | before | after |\n|---|-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|------------|------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|\n| 1 | utility 중복 제거 — `normalize_mdx` / `_slice_mdx_sections` / `_get_definitions` / `_get_conclusion` | u1 (defer) | status=`pending`, trigger=\"Phase R' cleanup axis 활성 시\" | status=`deferred`; trigger expanded with §2.1/§2.2 SoT signature alignment precondition (adapter migration violates \"코드 제거만\" guardrail) — actual removal NOT performed |\n| 2 | Phase R' 영역 cleanup (코드 제거만) | u1 (defer) | trigger met implicitly when Phase R' archived | trigger now records dual precondition: Phase R' archive AND §2.1/§2.2 SoT signature unification — keeps eventual cleanup as pure removal |\n| 3 | guardrail: Phase R' 영역, 코드 제거만, 다른 axis 무관 | u1 (defer) | guardrail intact but unmet (live callers + signature divergence) | guardrail unchanged; deferral note explains why current state violates it (file:line evidence carried via Stage 1 exit report) |\n| 4 | guardrail: §2.1 / §2.2 SoT 와 충돌 X | u1 (defer) | currently conflicts (`html_generator.normalize_mdx`→str vs §2.1→dict) | guardrail unchanged; deferral note flags conflict; resolution = SoT signature unification BEFORE removal |\n| 5 | trigger axis: Phase R' cleanup axis 활성 시 | u1 (defer) | single-precondition trigger | dual-precondition trigger documented in backlog + §5 J3 row |\n| 6 | priority: ↓ low (future) | u1 (defer) | priority `↓ low (future)` retained | unchanged |\n| 7 | milestone: B-4 §4 cleanup (3) [#92] | out-of-scope | not edited | unchanged (milestone tracking handled by orchestrator, not by this doc edit) |\n| 8 | cross-ref: backlog §4 IMP-26 / INSIGHT-MAP §5 J3 / PHASE-Q-AUDIT §2.9 | u1 (mirror) | only backlog row + §5 row exist; AUDIT §2.9 footnote already classifies| backlog + §5 trigger text mirrored; AUDIT §2.9 unchanged (footnote already says \"Phase R' cleanup 시 별도 판단\" — no contradiction, no edit needed) |\n| 9 | review loop checkbox (Codex 1차 / Claude 재검토 / Codex 재검증 / scope-locked / ready-for-implementation / implemented / verified) | out-of-scope (issue meta) | unchanged | issue review loop is orchestrator-managed; this plan does NOT toggle checkboxes — only proposes doc edit |\n\nPer-unit rationale (≤ 3 lines):\n- u1: Stage 1 binding contract = deferral. Sole doc surface that drives backlog automation = the IMP-26 row in PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md. Cross-anchor verbatim mirror rule requires trigger axis wording to match INSIGHT-MAP §5 J3. Both updated atomically; no source code, no SoT changes.\n\nOut-of-scope (carried from Stage 1 scope_lock):\n- Actual helper deletion in `src/html_generator.py` (lines 752-827, 830-842, callers 654/730/1011/1029/1041).\n- Adapter migration redirecting helpers to §2.1 `normalize_mdx_content` / §2.2 `section_parser`.\n- Signature unification of §2.1 / §2.2 SoT (separate axis, prerequisite to eventual cleanup).\n- Type A AI-HTML dispatch removal in `pipeline.py` Stage 2 / `content_verifier.generate_with_retry`.\n- `_parse_json` (IMP-28) and catalog/`_get_block_by_id` (IMP-27) cleanups — separate issues.\n- PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md §2.9 footnote — already says \"Phase R' cleanup 시 별도 판단\"; no contradiction with deferral, no edit needed.\n\nRollback strategy:\n- Doc-only edit; revert = `git checkout -- docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md`. No runtime/test impact, no migrations to undo.\n\nTests:\n- None. Doc-only edit; no behavioral change. RULE 4 scope-qualified verification = grep both files for \"IMP-26\" and \"J3\" to confirm row updated + mirror consistent.\n\nFollow-up issue candidates (NOT created in this stage):\n- Future axis when SoT signature unification is planned: open a precursor issue \"§2.1 + §2.2 signature unification (drop-in compatibility for html_generator helpers)\" — prerequisite to IMP-26 eventual execution.\n\n=== EVIDENCE ===\n- Stage 1 exit report (binding): IMP-26 status=`deferred`, scope_lock=\"documentation-only\", out_of_scope=\"actual helper deletion / adapter migration / Type A path removal\".\n- `docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md:93` — IMP-26 row, current status=`pending`, current trigger=\"Phase R' cleanup axis 활성 시\".\n- `docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md:150` — §5 J3 row, current trigger=\"Phase R' cleanup axis 활성 시\".\n- `docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md:946,947,951` — §2.9 footnote already classifies the four helpers as Reference Only + \"Phase R' cleanup 시 별도 판단\"; no edit needed.\n- `src/html_generator.py:752-827` (normalize_mdx), `:830-842` (_slice_mdx_sections), `:654,730,1011,1029,1041` (in-module callers) — live, not orphaned (confirmed by both Claude #1 + Codex #1 in Stage 1).\n- `src/mdx_normalizer.py:393-438` — §2.1 `normalize_mdx_content(raw)→dict` SoT (signature divergence vs html_generator helper returning str).\n- `src/section_parser.py:23-45` — §2.2 `section_parser(list[dict])→major-section dict` SoT (signature divergence vs `_slice_mdx_sections(raw)→dict[str,str]`).\n- `src/content_verifier.py:535` — external import of `html_generator` helpers; transitive live reference.\n- Estimated diff size for u1: ≤ 6 lines total across 2 files (status cell + trigger axis cell rewrites + mirror in §5 J3 row).\n", "assets": [], "created_at": "2026-05-20T18:13:33+09:00", "updated_at": "2026-05-20T18:13:33+09:00"}, {"id": 21697, "html_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/26#issuecomment-21697", "pull_request_url": "", "issue_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/26", "user": {"id": 28, "login": "Kyeongmin", "login_name": "", "source_id": 0, "full_name": "이경민", "email": "kyeongmin@noreply.localhost", "avatar_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/avatars/d883a35f9197b080b2a0c535c3f9357dcd5c7d40b3c42bd8f40218cb94609a8e", "html_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin", "language": "", "is_admin": false, "last_login": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", "created": "2025-12-30T10:51:04+09:00", "restricted": false, "active": false, "prohibit_login": false, "location": "", "website": "", "description": "", "visibility": "public", "followers_count": 0, "following_count": 0, "starred_repos_count": 1, "username": "Kyeongmin"}, "original_author": "", "original_author_id": 0, "body": "[Codex #2] Stage 2 simulation-plan review - IMP-26\n\n=== IMPLEMENTATION_UNITS ===\nunits:\n - id: u1\n summary: Document IMP-26 deferral by changing the backlog row to deferred and mirroring the trigger/precondition wording in the INSIGHT-MAP J3 row.\n files:\n - docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md\n - docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md\n tests:\n - pytest -q tests\n estimate_lines: 6\n\nRationale:\nu1 covers all issue-body axes: the four helper-removal items are deferred, Phase R' cleanup remains the only execution axis, and SoT signature alignment is recorded as a prerequisite so eventual work can stay code-removal-only.\nUnit size is acceptable: 2 files and 6 estimated lines, below the 3-file and 50-line caps.\nNo source edit is planned; this matches the Stage 1 scope lock and avoids adapter, pipeline, content_verifier, or html_generator changes.\n\nOut-of-scope:\nActual helper deletion, adapter migration to mdx_normalizer/section_parser, Type A AI-HTML retirement, content_verifier/pipeline changes, and other html_generator helpers remain excluded.\nThe plan is documentation-only; no runtime side effects are expected beyond the required baseline test.\n\nRollback strategy:\nRevert only the two documentation rows touched by u1, restoring their prior pending/single-trigger wording.\n\n=== EVIDENCE ===\nCommands run:\n- Get-Content D:\\ad-hoc\\kei\\design_agent\\.orchestrator\\tmp\\codex_prompt.txt\n- rg -n \"IMP-26|html_generator|J3|normalize_mdx|_slice_mdx_sections|_get_definitions|_get_conclusion\" docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md src/html_generator.py src/mdx_normalizer.py src/section_parser.py src/content_verifier.py src/pipeline.py\n- git status --short\n- rg --files tests\n- line-window reads for src/html_generator.py, src/mdx_normalizer.py, src/section_parser.py, src/content_verifier.py, src/pipeline.py, PHASE-Z backlog, and INSIGHT-MAP\n- pytest -q tests\nFiles checked:\n- docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md:90-93\n- docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md:146-150\n- docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-AUDIT.md:900-905, 931-933, 946-951, 961, 975, 990\n- src/html_generator.py:654, 730, 752-827, 830-845, 930-956, 1011, 1029, 1041\n- src/mdx_normalizer.py:393-438\n- src/section_parser.py:23-80\n- src/content_verifier.py:535-539\n- src/pipeline.py:136-140\nTest results:\n- pytest -q tests: 342 passed in 40.90s.\nVerified facts:\n- Backlog IMP-26 is currently pending and lists only the Phase R' cleanup trigger.\n- INSIGHT-MAP J3 currently lists the same single Phase R' cleanup trigger.\n- html_generator duplicate helpers still have live in-module callers and content_verifier imports/calls the helper host path.\n- SoT signatures are incompatible: mdx_normalizer.normalize_mdx_content returns dict, section_parser.extract_major_sections consumes list[dict], while html_generator.normalize_mdx returns str and _slice_mdx_sections returns dict[str,str].\n- The Stage 2 plan has an implementation_units block with one unit, 2 files, and 6 estimated lines; it is within the 3-file and 50-line caps.\n- Coverage is complete for the issue body because the unit records deferral, preserves both guardrails, adds trigger/precondition wording, has no source-code side effects, includes rollback, and names the required baseline test.\nFINAL_CONSENSUS: YES", "assets": [], "created_at": "2026-05-20T18:16:13+09:00", "updated_at": "2026-05-20T18:16:13+09:00"}, {"id": 21699, "html_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/26#issuecomment-21699", "pull_request_url": "", "issue_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/26", "user": {"id": 28, "login": "Kyeongmin", "login_name": "", "source_id": 0, "full_name": "이경민", "email": "kyeongmin@noreply.localhost", "avatar_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/avatars/d883a35f9197b080b2a0c535c3f9357dcd5c7d40b3c42bd8f40218cb94609a8e", "html_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin", "language": "", "is_admin": false, "last_login": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", "created": "2025-12-30T10:51:04+09:00", "restricted": false, "active": false, "prohibit_login": false, "location": "", "website": "", "description": "", "visibility": "public", "followers_count": 0, "following_count": 0, "starred_repos_count": 1, "username": "Kyeongmin"}, "original_author": "", "original_author_id": 0, "body": "[Claude #3] Stage 3 code-edit — IMP-26 unit u1 (deferral documentation)\n\nExecuting unit: u1\n\n■ unit_executed\n- id: u1\n- summary: Document IMP-26 deferral by changing the backlog row to `deferred` and mirroring the trigger/precondition wording in the INSIGHT-MAP §5 J3 row.\n\n■ files_changed\n- `docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md` (1 line modified — IMP-26 row, line 93)\n- `docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md` (1 line modified — §5 J3 row, line 150)\n\n■ diff_summary\n```\n docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md | 2 +-\n docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md | 2 +-\n 2 files changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-)\n```\n\nPHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md (line 93, §4 cleanup table):\n- trigger axis column: `Phase R' cleanup axis 활성 시` → `Phase R' archive trigger AND §2.1/§2.2 SoT signature unification (both preconditions required to keep guardrail = code-removal-only)`\n- status column: `pending` → `deferred`\n\nPHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md (line 150, §5 J3 row, candidate table):\n- trigger axis column: `Phase R' cleanup axis 활성 시` → `Phase R' archive trigger AND §2.1/§2.2 SoT signature unification (both preconditions required to keep guardrail = code-removal-only)` (verbatim mirror of backlog row per anchor sync rule)\n\nOther columns (ID, title, related module, source, priority, scope, guardrail/validation) preserved unchanged. No other rows touched. No source code modified.\n\n■ scope verification\n- Edit count: 2 files / 2 lines actual (Stage 2 estimate: 2 files / ~6 lines — under cap).\n- §2.1 `mdx_normalizer.py`, §2.2 `section_parser.py`, §2.9 `html_generator.py`, `content_verifier.py`, `pipeline.py` — NOT touched.\n- No helper deletion, no adapter migration, no Type A AI-HTML path change.\n- Documentation-only change matches Stage 1 scope_lock and Stage 2 plan exactly.\n\n■ guardrail compliance\n- Phase R' scope only ✓ (deferral preserves it)\n- Code-removal-only when eventually executed ✓ (precondition now explicitly requires SoT alignment first)\n- No adapter migration in this issue ✓\n- 1 turn = 1 step ✓ (single unit u1 only)\n- Anchor sync (cross-doc verbatim mirror) ✓\n\n■ remaining_units\n- (none — u1 was the only implementation_unit in Stage 2 plan)\n\n■ follow_up_issue_candidates\n- (none — Stage 2 follow_up_candidates already documented: §2.1/§2.2 SoT signature alignment, Phase R' archive completion, Type A AI-HTML retirement, other html_generator helpers. All remain outside IMP-26 scope and outside this Stage 3 turn.)\n\nSTOP (no commit, no push — per Stage 3 contract).\n", "assets": [], "created_at": "2026-05-20T18:18:50+09:00", "updated_at": "2026-05-20T18:18:50+09:00"}, {"id": 21701, "html_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/26#issuecomment-21701", "pull_request_url": "", "issue_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/26", "user": {"id": 28, "login": "Kyeongmin", "login_name": "", "source_id": 0, "full_name": "이경민", "email": "kyeongmin@noreply.localhost", "avatar_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/avatars/d883a35f9197b080b2a0c535c3f9357dcd5c7d40b3c42bd8f40218cb94609a8e", "html_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin", "language": "", "is_admin": false, "last_login": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", "created": "2025-12-30T10:51:04+09:00", "restricted": false, "active": false, "prohibit_login": false, "location": "", "website": "", "description": "", "visibility": "public", "followers_count": 0, "following_count": 0, "starred_repos_count": 1, "username": "Kyeongmin"}, "original_author": "", "original_author_id": 0, "body": "[Codex #3] Stage 3 code-edit verification - IMP-26 u1\n\nVerification result: PASS.\n\n- Unit u1 is the only Stage 2 implementation unit, and it was executed as a documentation-only change.\n- Tracked diff is limited to the two planned documentation files: `docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md` and `docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md`.\n- Backlog row `IMP-26` now has status `deferred` and the trigger axis is `Phase R' archive trigger AND §2.1/§2.2 SoT signature unification (both preconditions required to keep guardrail = code-removal-only)`.\n- INSIGHT-MAP row `J3` mirrors the same trigger wording verbatim.\n- No source files are present in `git diff --name-only`; `src/html_generator.py`, `src/content_verifier.py`, `src/pipeline.py`, `src/mdx_normalizer.py`, and `src/section_parser.py` were not touched by this unit.\n- No tests were run because the current Stage 3 instruction is to verify only the single executed unit, and the prompt explicitly says not to run full pytest unless the current stage requires it.\n\n=== EVIDENCE ===\nCommands run:\n- `Get-Content -LiteralPath 'D:\\ad-hoc\\kei\\design_agent\\.orchestrator\\tmp\\codex_prompt.txt'`\n- `git status --short`\n- `git diff -- docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md`\n- `rg -n \"IMP-26|J3|Phase R' archive trigger|SoT signature unification|deferred\" docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md`\n- `git diff --name-only`\nFiles checked:\n- `docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md`\n- `docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md`\nRemaining units: none\nVerified facts:\n- `git diff --name-only` reports only the two Stage 2 planned files.\n- `git diff` shows one changed row in each planned file.\n- `rg -n` confirms the final backlog row at line 93 and INSIGHT-MAP J3 row at line 150.\n- The row-level edits match the Stage 2 unit u1 scope: status transition to `deferred` in the backlog and mirrored trigger/precondition wording in both docs.\n\nFINAL_CONSENSUS: YES", "assets": [], "created_at": "2026-05-20T18:20:56+09:00", "updated_at": "2026-05-20T18:20:56+09:00"}, {"id": 21703, "html_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/26#issuecomment-21703", "pull_request_url": "", "issue_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/26", "user": {"id": 28, "login": "Kyeongmin", "login_name": "", "source_id": 0, "full_name": "이경민", "email": "kyeongmin@noreply.localhost", "avatar_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/avatars/d883a35f9197b080b2a0c535c3f9357dcd5c7d40b3c42bd8f40218cb94609a8e", "html_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin", "language": "", "is_admin": false, "last_login": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", "created": "2025-12-30T10:51:04+09:00", "restricted": false, "active": false, "prohibit_login": false, "location": "", "website": "", "description": "", "visibility": "public", "followers_count": 0, "following_count": 0, "starred_repos_count": 1, "username": "Kyeongmin"}, "original_author": "", "original_author_id": 0, "body": "[Claude #4] Stage 4 test-verify — IMP-26 u1 (documentation-only deferral)\n\n📌 Verification summary\n\n■ scope\n- Stage 4 round #1 verification of Stage 3 u1 (documentation-only) for IMP-26.\n- Verify diff matches Stage 2/3 plan; run pytest baseline; check guardrails (no hardcoding, no source change, anchor sync).\n\n■ diff verification (PASS)\n- `git diff --name-only` →\n - `docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md`\n - `docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md`\n- `git diff --stat` → `2 files changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-)`\n- Below Stage 2 estimate (6 lines / 3-file cap); above commitment floor.\n- No source files in diff (`src/*` untouched: html_generator.py, mdx_normalizer.py, section_parser.py, content_verifier.py, pipeline.py — all clean).\n\n■ content verification (PASS)\n- BACKLOG IMP-26 row (line 93) post-edit columns confirmed:\n - status: `pending` → `deferred` ✓\n - trigger axis: `Phase R' cleanup axis 활성 시` → `Phase R' archive trigger AND §2.1/§2.2 SoT signature unification (both preconditions required to keep guardrail = code-removal-only)` ✓\n - All other columns preserved (ID, title, related module, source, priority, scope, guardrail/validation).\n- INSIGHT-MAP §5 J3 row (line 150) post-edit:\n - trigger axis verbatim mirror of BACKLOG row ✓ (anchor sync rule observed).\n - Note: INSIGHT-MAP §5 candidate table schema has no `status` column — only `candidate ID / 출처 / cleanup 대상 / trigger axis`. Status transition lives only in BACKLOG row, as designed.\n\n■ baseline test (PASS)\n- `python -m pytest -q tests` → `342 passed in 41.00s`.\n- No regression introduced; documentation-only change has no runtime axis.\n\n■ guardrail verification (PASS)\n- No-hardcoding ✓ — pure documentation row update, no code path / px / sample-specific value touched.\n- AI isolation ✓ — no AI call involved in Stage 3 execution or this verify round.\n- 1-turn = 1-step ✓ — Stage 4 round #1 reports verification result only; no axis recommendation beyond Stage 4 conclusion.\n- Scope-lock ✓ — matches Stage 1/2 scope (documentation-only deferral); no adapter migration, no helper deletion, no Type A AI-HTML path change, no pipeline / content_verifier change.\n- Anchor sync ✓ — BACKLOG ↔ INSIGHT-MAP trigger wording is verbatim identical.\n- Factual verification ✓ — every claim has file:line + command evidence in EVIDENCE block.\n\n■ regression check (PASS)\n- No source code touched → no behavior change possible.\n- pytest baseline (342 passed) unchanged from prior runs.\n- Untracked files in `git status` are pre-existing (`.orchestrator/`, `tests/matching/*`, `samples/`, etc.) — unrelated to this commit scope.\n\n■ verdict\n- Stage 4 round #1: PASS. Ready for Stage 5 (commit + push).\n- Pending: HEAD sha = `a71355e` (pre-commit); Stage 5 will produce the commit sha for this doc-only change.\n\n=== EVIDENCE ===\n\ncommands_run:\n- `git diff --stat docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md` → `2 files changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-)`.\n- `git diff --name-only` → exactly the two planned doc files; no `src/` entries.\n- `git diff docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md` → confirmed status `pending → deferred` and trigger axis wording on both rows; no other column touched.\n- `python -m pytest -q tests` → `342 passed in 41.00s`.\n- `git status --short` → only the two planned `M` entries; remaining listings are pre-existing untracked artifacts (`.orchestrator/`, `tests/matching/*`, `samples/`, `templates/phase_z2/*`, `scripts/*`, etc.).\n- `git rev-parse HEAD` → `a71355e0059caaae9d53372ba2987551998bd7b8` (pre-Stage-5 baseline).\n\nfiles_inspected:\n- `docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md` line 93 — IMP-26 row post-edit content verified.\n- `docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md` line 150 — §5 J3 row post-edit content verified; trigger column matches BACKLOG wording verbatim.\n\nfacts:\n- diff scope = 2 files / 2 lines (within Stage 2 estimate of 2 files / ~6 lines and ≤ 3-file / ≤ 50-line caps).\n- baseline tests green (342/342).\n- no src/ touched; no helper deletion; no adapter migration; no Type A AI-HTML path change.\n- anchor sync rule observed between BACKLOG (line 93) and INSIGHT-MAP §5 (line 150).\n- INSIGHT-MAP §5 candidate table has no status column → status transition correctly lives in BACKLOG row only.\n\nsource_comment_ids:\n- [Claude #4] Stage 4 test-verify (this comment).\n\ncommit_sha:\n- pending (Stage 5 will commit and publish).\n", "assets": [], "created_at": "2026-05-20T18:24:29+09:00", "updated_at": "2026-05-20T18:24:29+09:00"}, {"id": 21706, "html_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/26#issuecomment-21706", "pull_request_url": "", "issue_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/26", "user": {"id": 28, "login": "Kyeongmin", "login_name": "", "source_id": 0, "full_name": "이경민", "email": "kyeongmin@noreply.localhost", "avatar_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/avatars/d883a35f9197b080b2a0c535c3f9357dcd5c7d40b3c42bd8f40218cb94609a8e", "html_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin", "language": "", "is_admin": false, "last_login": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", "created": "2025-12-30T10:51:04+09:00", "restricted": false, "active": false, "prohibit_login": false, "location": "", "website": "", "description": "", "visibility": "public", "followers_count": 0, "following_count": 0, "starred_repos_count": 1, "username": "Kyeongmin"}, "original_author": "", "original_author_id": 0, "body": "[Codex #4] Stage 4 test-verify - IMP-26 u1\n\nVerification result: PASS.\n\nDiff scope is limited to the planned documentation-only unit:\n- docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md\n- docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md\n\nVerified content:\n- BACKLOG IMP-26 row changed status from pending to deferred.\n- BACKLOG IMP-26 trigger axis now requires both Phase R' archive trigger and section 2.1/2.2 SoT signature unification, preserving the code-removal-only guardrail.\n- INSIGHT-MAP J3 trigger axis mirrors the BACKLOG wording verbatim.\n- No source files under src have any diff.\n- Untracked files are present in the worktree, but they are outside the Stage 4 commit scope.\n\nBaseline test result: PASS, 342 passed in 40.81s.\n\n=== EVIDENCE ===\nCommands run:\n- Get-Content -LiteralPath D:\\ad-hoc\\kei\\design_agent\\.orchestrator\\tmp\\codex_prompt.txt\n- git status --short\n- git diff --name-only\n- git diff --stat -- docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md\n- git diff -- docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md\n- python -m pytest -q tests\n- git diff --name-only -- src\n- rg -n \"IMP-26|J3|Phase R' archive trigger|SoT signature unification|deferred\" docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md\n- git rev-parse --short HEAD\n\nFiles checked:\n- D:\\ad-hoc\\kei\\design_agent\\docs\\architecture\\PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md\n- D:\\ad-hoc\\kei\\design_agent\\docs\\architecture\\PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md\n- D:\\ad-hoc\\kei\\design_agent\\src (diff scope check only)\n\nTest results:\n- python -m pytest -q tests: 342 passed in 40.81s\n\nVerified facts:\n- git diff --name-only reports only the two planned documentation files.\n- git diff --stat reports 2 files changed, 2 insertions, 2 deletions.\n- BACKLOG IMP-26 is at line 93 with status deferred and the strengthened two-precondition trigger wording.\n- INSIGHT-MAP J3 is at line 150 with matching trigger wording.\n- git diff --name-only -- src produced no output, confirming no source diff.\n- Current pre-commit HEAD is a71355e.\n\nFINAL_CONSENSUS: YES", "assets": [], "created_at": "2026-05-20T18:26:30+09:00", "updated_at": "2026-05-20T18:26:30+09:00"}, {"id": 21709, "html_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/26#issuecomment-21709", "pull_request_url": "", "issue_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/26", "user": {"id": 28, "login": "Kyeongmin", "login_name": "", "source_id": 0, "full_name": "이경민", "email": "kyeongmin@noreply.localhost", "avatar_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/avatars/d883a35f9197b080b2a0c535c3f9357dcd5c7d40b3c42bd8f40218cb94609a8e", "html_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin", "language": "", "is_admin": false, "last_login": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", "created": "2025-12-30T10:51:04+09:00", "restricted": false, "active": false, "prohibit_login": false, "location": "", "website": "", "description": "", "visibility": "public", "followers_count": 0, "following_count": 0, "starred_repos_count": 1, "username": "Kyeongmin"}, "original_author": "", "original_author_id": 0, "body": "[Claude #5] Stage 5 commit-push — IMP-26 u1\n\n📌 **commit_sha**: `2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc` (short `2896bb6`)\n\n■ **scope-locked diff**\n- files staged via explicit paths:\n - `docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md` — IMP-26 row (line 93)\n - `docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md` — §5 J3 row (line 150)\n- stat: `2 files changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-)`\n- BACKLOG IMP-26 row: trigger axis `Phase R' cleanup axis 활성 시` → `Phase R' archive trigger AND §2.1/§2.2 SoT signature unification (both preconditions required to keep guardrail = code-removal-only)`; status `pending` → `deferred`. All other columns preserved.\n- INSIGHT-MAP §5 J3 row: trigger axis verbatim mirror of BACKLOG row (anchor sync rule observed).\n- No `src/*`, no test, no other doc touched.\n\n■ **commit message**\n```\ndocs(#26): IMP-26 J3 status pending->deferred + dual-precondition trigger\n\nBACKLOG line 93 + INSIGHT-MAP line 150 (verbatim mirror per anchor sync\nrule). Trigger axis now requires both Phase R' archive trigger AND\n§2.1/§2.2 SoT signature unification to keep guardrail = code-removal-only.\nNo source files touched.\n```\n(Recent `docs(#NN): ...` style preserved — cf. `a71355e` / `b1897c0` / `447e702`.)\n\n■ **push verification**\n- `git push slide2 main` → `a71355e..2896bb6 main -> main` (Gitea `Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2`).\n- `git push origin main` → `a71355e..2896bb6 main -> main` (GitHub `keimin86/design_agent`).\n- `git ls-remote slide2 main` → `2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc`.\n- `git ls-remote origin main` → `2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc`.\n- Local `git rev-parse HEAD` = `2896bb6...` matches both remote tips.\n\n■ **scope-lock invariants held**\n- 1 commit = 1 decision unit (IMP-26 deferral documentation only).\n- `git add` invoked with explicit file paths (RULE 6) — no `-A` / `-u` / `.`.\n- BACKLOG other rows (IMP-25 / IMP-27 / IMP-28 ...), INSIGHT-MAP §5 K5 / L4 / other rows, PHASE-Q-AUDIT, all `src/*` (`html_generator.py`, `mdx_normalizer.py`, `section_parser.py`, `content_verifier.py`, `pipeline.py`), tests — all untouched.\n- No helper deletion, no adapter migration, no Type A AI-HTML path retirement (Stage 1 scope_lock + Stage 2 plan honored).\n- Anchor sync rule observed (BACKLOG ↔ INSIGHT-MAP J3 verbatim mirror).\n- No `--no-verify`, no force push, no amend, no hook bypass.\n- Untracked worktree files (`.orchestrator/`, `tests/matching/*`, `samples/uploads/`, ...) acknowledged Stage 4 + remain out of Stage 5 commit scope.\n\n■ **다음 단계**\nStage 6 (final-close) — Gitea issue #26 close as deferred (re-evaluation gated on dual precondition: Phase R' archive trigger + §2.1/§2.2 SoT signature unification). No follow-up issue draft required; IMP-26 itself is the carrier row with explicit unblock conditions.\n\n=== EVIDENCE ===\n- `git status --short docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md` → both ` M` (modified, unstaged) pre-add.\n- `git diff -- docs/architecture/...` → exactly the two row-level changes described above; LF→CRLF working-copy notice only (no behavior impact).\n- `git add docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md` (explicit paths only).\n- `git diff --staged --stat` → `2 files changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-)`.\n- `git status --short` post-add → both files `M ` (staged); all other entries are pre-existing untracked (no source files among them).\n- `git commit -m ...` → `[main 2896bb6] docs(#26): IMP-26 J3 status pending->deferred + dual-precondition trigger`, `2 files changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-)`.\n- `git log -1 --format=\"%H %s\"` → `2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc docs(#26): IMP-26 J3 status pending->deferred + dual-precondition trigger`.\n- `git push slide2 main` → `a71355e..2896bb6 main -> main`.\n- `git push origin main` → `a71355e..2896bb6 main -> main`.\n- `git ls-remote slide2 main` → `2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc`.\n- `git ls-remote origin main` → `2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc`.\n- Stage 4 baseline `python -m pytest -q tests` = 342 passed (Claude 41.00s / Codex 40.81s); doc-only diff requires no further regression run for push step.\n- Guardrails: no-hardcoding ✓ / AI isolation ✓ / 1-turn=1-step ✓ / code-removal-only preserved (deferral with tightened precondition) ✓ / anchor sync ✓.", "assets": [], "created_at": "2026-05-20T18:29:29+09:00", "updated_at": "2026-05-20T18:29:29+09:00"}, {"id": 21711, "html_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/26#issuecomment-21711", "pull_request_url": "", "issue_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/26", "user": {"id": 28, "login": "Kyeongmin", "login_name": "", "source_id": 0, "full_name": "이경민", "email": "kyeongmin@noreply.localhost", "avatar_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/avatars/d883a35f9197b080b2a0c535c3f9357dcd5c7d40b3c42bd8f40218cb94609a8e", "html_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin", "language": "", "is_admin": false, "last_login": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", "created": "2025-12-30T10:51:04+09:00", "restricted": false, "active": false, "prohibit_login": false, "location": "", "website": "", "description": "", "visibility": "public", "followers_count": 0, "following_count": 0, "starred_repos_count": 1, "username": "Kyeongmin"}, "original_author": "", "original_author_id": 0, "body": "[Codex #5] Stage 5 commit-push verification - IMP-26 u1\n\nStage 5 verification result: PASS.\n\nI verified the pushed commit and commit scope for IMP-26 u1. Local HEAD is `2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc`, and both remote branch tips checked by `git ls-remote` match that exact SHA:\n- `slide2 refs/heads/main` = `2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc`\n- `origin refs/heads/main` = `2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc`\n\nThe commit contains only the intended documentation files:\n- `docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md`\n- `docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md`\n\nCommit stat is `2 files changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-)`. No `src/*`, tests, pipeline files, helper code, or unrelated documentation files are included in the commit. The worktree still has pre-existing untracked files, but they are not part of this commit.\n\nThe committed content matches the Stage 4 contract:\n- BACKLOG line 93 marks IMP-26 status as `deferred`.\n- BACKLOG line 93 uses trigger wording: `Phase R' archive trigger AND section 2.1/2.2 SoT signature unification (both preconditions required to keep guardrail = code-removal-only)`.\n- INSIGHT-MAP line 150 mirrors the same trigger wording for J3.\n\nNo tests were run in Stage 5 because the current stage task is commit and remote verification, and the prompt explicitly says not to run full pytest unless the current stage requires it.\n\n=== EVIDENCE ===\nCommands run:\n- `git rev-parse HEAD`\n- `git log -1 --pretty=format:'%H%n%s%n%b'`\n- `git diff-tree --no-commit-id --name-status -r HEAD`\n- `git diff-tree --stat --no-commit-id -r HEAD`\n- `git remote -v`\n- `git ls-remote slide2 refs/heads/main`\n- `git ls-remote origin refs/heads/main`\n- `git status --short`\n- `git show --stat --oneline --decorate --no-renames HEAD`\n- `rg -n \"IMP-26|Phase R' archive trigger|SoT signature unification|deferred\" docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md`\n\nFiles checked:\n- `D:\\ad-hoc\\kei\\design_agent\\docs\\architecture\\PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md`\n- `D:\\ad-hoc\\kei\\design_agent\\docs\\architecture\\PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md`\n\nTest results:\n- Not run in Stage 5; Stage 4 already verified `python -m pytest -q tests` as `342 passed`, and the current stage does not require rerunning tests.\n\nCommit SHA:\n- `2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc`\n\nVerified facts:\n- Local HEAD equals `2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc`.\n- `slide2/main` equals `2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc`.\n- `origin/main` equals `2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc`.\n- The commit subject is `docs(#26): IMP-26 J3 status pending->deferred + dual-precondition trigger`.\n- The commit modifies exactly two files, both in `docs/architecture`.\n- The commit stat is `2 files changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-)`.\n- BACKLOG line 93 has IMP-26 status `deferred`.\n- BACKLOG line 93 and INSIGHT-MAP line 150 carry the dual-precondition trigger wording.\n- No source files, tests, helper code, adapter code, or pipeline dispatch files are included in the commit.\n- No force push, amend, or hook bypass was observed in the verified state.\n\nFINAL_CONSENSUS: YES", "assets": [], "created_at": "2026-05-20T18:30:58+09:00", "updated_at": "2026-05-20T18:30:58+09:00"}, {"id": 21713, "html_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/26#issuecomment-21713", "pull_request_url": "", "issue_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/26", "user": {"id": 28, "login": "Kyeongmin", "login_name": "", "source_id": 0, "full_name": "이경민", "email": "kyeongmin@noreply.localhost", "avatar_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/avatars/d883a35f9197b080b2a0c535c3f9357dcd5c7d40b3c42bd8f40218cb94609a8e", "html_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin", "language": "", "is_admin": false, "last_login": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", "created": "2025-12-30T10:51:04+09:00", "restricted": false, "active": false, "prohibit_login": false, "location": "", "website": "", "description": "", "visibility": "public", "followers_count": 0, "following_count": 0, "starred_repos_count": 1, "username": "Kyeongmin"}, "original_author": "", "original_author_id": 0, "body": "[Claude #6] Stage 6 final-close round #1 — IMP-26 J3 deferral\n\n📌 **goal vs result**\n\n| axis | issue body request | Stage 1~5 actual result | match |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| scope | utility 4종 (`normalize_mdx` / `_slice_mdx_sections` / `_get_definitions` / `_get_conclusion`) 중복 제거 (Phase R' 영역, 코드 제거만) | helper 4종 **미삭제** — Stage 1 에서 trigger 미충족 + adapter 필요 (code-removal-only guardrail 위반) 로 판정 → status `pending` → `deferred` 문서화만 수행 | partial — issue body 의 `**trigger axis**: Phase R' cleanup axis 활성 시` 가 미충족이므로 실행 보류가 정답 |\n| guardrail | Phase R' 영역 / 코드 제거만 / §2.1·§2.2 SoT 충돌 X | guardrail 보존 — trigger axis 가 `Phase R' archive trigger AND §2.1/§2.2 SoT signature unification (both preconditions)` 로 강화되어 향후 unblock 시점에도 code-removal-only 유지 | YES |\n| 변경 범위 | (해당 사항 없음 — 본 stage 는 deferral 문서화) | `docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md` line 93 + `docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md` line 150 verbatim mirror (anchor sync rule). `src/*` / test / 기타 문서 무손상. | YES |\n\n📌 **commit verification (origin + slide2)**\n\n| check | result |\n|---|---|\n| local HEAD | `2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc` |\n| origin (GitHub) `refs/heads/main` | `2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc` |\n| slide2 (Gitea mirror) `refs/heads/main` | `2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc` |\n| 3-way SHA match | YES |\n| commit message | `docs(#26): IMP-26 J3 status pending->deferred + dual-precondition trigger` |\n| diff stat | `2 files changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-)` |\n| files touched | `docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md`, `docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md` |\n| src/* diff | empty |\n\n📌 **content sanity (post-push)**\n\n- BACKLOG line 93 — IMP-26 row: `... | Phase R' archive trigger AND §2.1/§2.2 SoT signature unification (both preconditions required to keep guardrail = code-removal-only) | deferred |`\n- INSIGHT-MAP line 150 — §5 J3 row: trigger column = verbatim mirror of BACKLOG row.\n- other columns (ID / title / related module / source / priority / scope / guardrail) preserved.\n\n📌 **follow-up links (unblock conditions)**\n\nIMP-26 가 다시 실행 axis 로 올라오려면 **두 사전조건이 동시에 만족** 되어야 한다 :\n\n1. **§2.9 `html_generator.py` archive trigger** — Phase R' Type A AI-HTML path 폐기. 현재 `src/pipeline.py` Stage 2 dispatch + `src/content_verifier.py:535` external import 가 살아있어 본 모듈을 archive 할 수 없음.\n2. **§2.1 / §2.2 SoT signature unification** — `src/mdx_normalizer.normalize_mdx_content(raw)→dict` (line 393~438) + `src/section_parser.section_parser(list[dict])→major-section dict` (line 23~45) 시그니처가 `html_generator.normalize_mdx(raw)→str` / `_slice_mdx_sections(raw)→dict[str,str]` 와 drop-in 호환되지 않음. 통합 작업이 선행되어야 helper 삭제가 \"코드 제거만\" 으로 끝남.\n\n이 두 axis 는 각각 별도 issue (혹은 milestone) 로 트래킹되어야 하며, 본 IMP-26 의 후속 트리거는 둘 다 PASS 된 시점에만 fire 한다.\n\n📌 **labels + state recommendation**\n\n현재 상태:\n- state: `open`\n- labels: `needs-codex-review` (Stage 1~5 review loop 잔여)\n- milestone: `B-4 §4 cleanup (3)` (#92) — 유지 (해당 cleanup 묶음 내 deferred 상태 row)\n\n권고 (실행은 사용자 GO 신호 후) :\n- **state**: `open` 유지 — 작업 완료가 아닌 **deferral** 이므로 close 불가. close 는 trigger 두 사전조건 모두 만족 + 실제 helper 4종 삭제 + 검증 완료 시점.\n- **label remove**: `needs-codex-review` — Stage 1~5 deferral 결정의 Codex review (Codex #1~#5 5회 PASS) 가 모두 끝났으므로 더 이상 review 대기 아님.\n- **label add**: `blocked` — IMP-26 은 위 두 사전조건이 풀릴 때까지 실행 불가 (deferred = blocked 의미와 일치, repo 의 기존 label vocabulary 범위 내).\n- **milestone**: `B-4 §4 cleanup (3)` 유지 — issue 자체가 cleanup 묶음에서 빠지는 것이 아니라 일정만 미루어지므로 milestone 잔류.\n\n📌 **close decision**\n\n**NOT CLOSE** — 아래 두 사전조건이 모두 PASS 되고 helper 4종 실제 삭제가 완료된 시점에만 close 가능 :\n1. Phase R' archive trigger (§2.9 `html_generator.py` 모듈 archive)\n2. §2.1 / §2.2 SoT signature unification\n\n📌 **guardrails (final)**\n\n| guardrail | status |\n|---|---|\n| no-hardcoding | PASS (documentation row update only; no px/sample-specific value) |\n| AI isolation | PASS (Stage 1~6 모두 AI 호출 0회) |\n| 1-turn = 1-step | PASS (Stage 6 는 close 결정 stage 자체이므로 결정·권고가 본 stage 의 산출물) |\n| code-removal-only | PRESERVED (trigger 사전조건 이중화로 향후 unblock 시점에도 guardrail 유지) |\n| anchor sync | PASS (BACKLOG line 93 ↔ INSIGHT-MAP line 150 verbatim mirror) |\n| scope-qualified | PASS (deferral 결정의 axis 는 `IMP-26 trigger axis precondition` 한 개만, 다른 axis 무관) |\n\n=== EVIDENCE ===\n\ncommands run (Stage 6 only — Stage 1~5 evidence in earlier exit reports) :\n- `git rev-parse HEAD` → `2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc`\n- `git log -1 --pretty=format:'%H%n%s%n%b' HEAD` → matches commit message above\n- `git ls-remote origin refs/heads/main` → `2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc`\n- `git ls-remote slide2 refs/heads/main` → `2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc`\n- `git show --stat --no-renames 2896bb6` → 2 files changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-)\n- `git diff-tree --no-commit-id --name-status -r 2896bb6` → `M docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md` + `M docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md`\n- ripgrep on BACKLOG line 93 + INSIGHT-MAP line 150 confirms `deferred` + dual-precondition trigger axis content\n- Gitea API GET `/repos/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/26` → state `open`, labels `[needs-codex-review]`, milestone `B-4 §4 cleanup (3)`\n- Gitea API GET `/repos/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/labels` → vocabulary = `{blocked, closed, implemented, needs-claude-review, needs-codex-review, ready-for-implementation, scope-locked, verified}` — `deferred` 라벨 없음 → `blocked` 권고\n\nsource_comment_ids :\n- [Claude #1~#5] Stage 1~5 (problem-review / simulation-plan / code-edit / test-verify / commit-push) — all PASS\n- [Codex #1~#5] Stage 1~5 reviews — all FINAL_CONSENSUS: YES\n\ncommit_sha: `2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc`\n\nunresolved_questions: none for Stage 6.\n- Q1 (when will Phase R' archive trigger fire?) + Q2 (should §2.1/§2.2 SoT signature unification precede archive?) 은 IMP-26 deferral 의 unblock 조건으로 명문화되었으며, 별도 axis 로 트래킹 (본 issue scope 밖).\n\nnext-step recommendation : 없음 (one-step-per-turn). 사용자 GO 후 label 갱신 (`needs-codex-review` remove / `blocked` add) 만 수행 권고.", "assets": [], "created_at": "2026-05-20T18:35:36+09:00", "updated_at": "2026-05-20T18:35:36+09:00"}, {"id": 21717, "html_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/26#issuecomment-21717", "pull_request_url": "", "issue_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/26", "user": {"id": 28, "login": "Kyeongmin", "login_name": "", "source_id": 0, "full_name": "이경민", "email": "kyeongmin@noreply.localhost", "avatar_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/avatars/d883a35f9197b080b2a0c535c3f9357dcd5c7d40b3c42bd8f40218cb94609a8e", "html_url": "https://gitea.hmac.kr/Kyeongmin", "language": "", "is_admin": false, "last_login": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", "created": "2025-12-30T10:51:04+09:00", "restricted": false, "active": false, "prohibit_login": false, "location": "", "website": "", "description": "", "visibility": "public", "followers_count": 0, "following_count": 0, "starred_repos_count": 1, "username": "Kyeongmin"}, "original_author": "", "original_author_id": 0, "body": "[Codex #6] Stage 6 final-close review - IMP-26 J3 deferral\n\nFinal independent verification result: PASS. The Stage 1-5 outcome is consistent with the issue guardrails: IMP-26 was not implemented as helper deletion because the Phase R' archive trigger and SoT signature unification preconditions are not both satisfied; instead, the deferral decision was recorded in the two authoritative documentation rows.\n\nVerification summary:\n- Local HEAD is `2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc` with commit message `docs(#26): IMP-26 J3 status pending->deferred + dual-precondition trigger`.\n- Both pushed remotes point to the same SHA: `origin/main` and `slide2/main` are `2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc`.\n- Commit scope is exactly two documentation files: `docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md` and `docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md`.\n- Diff stat is `2 files changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-)`.\n- `src/*` diff is empty, so no runtime, helper, pipeline, verifier, normalizer, parser, or test code was touched.\n- BACKLOG IMP-26 row is `deferred` and uses trigger wording: `Phase R' archive trigger AND �2.1/�2.2 SoT signature unification (both preconditions required to keep guardrail = code-removal-only)`.\n- INSIGHT-MAP J3 trigger column mirrors the same trigger wording verbatim.\n- Live issue metadata remains open with label `needs-codex-review` and milestone `B-4 �4 cleanup (3)`, so this comment is the close-OK signal rather than an untracked state change.\n\nClose recommendation: OK to close Issue #26 for this cycle. The implemented outcome is a documented deferral, not code deletion, and that matches the verified precondition failure and the code-removal-only guardrail.\n\n=== EVIDENCE ===\nCommands run:\n- `git rev-parse HEAD`\n- `git log -1 --pretty=format:\"%H%n%s\"`\n- `git diff-tree --no-commit-id --name-status -r HEAD`\n- `git diff-tree --stat --no-commit-id -r HEAD`\n- `git ls-remote slide2 refs/heads/main`\n- `git ls-remote origin refs/heads/main`\n- `git diff --name-only -- src`\n- `rg -n \"IMP-26|Phase R' archive trigger|SoT signature unification|deferred\" docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md`\n- `Invoke-RestMethod https://gitea.hmac.kr/api/v1/repos/Kyeongmin/C.E.L_Slide_test2/issues/26`\n\nFiles checked:\n- `docs/architecture/PHASE-Z-IMPLEMENTATION-ISSUE-BACKLOG.md`\n- `docs/architecture/PHASE-Q-INSIGHT-TO-22STEP-MAP.md`\n- `src` diff scope\n\nCommit SHA:\n- `2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc`\n\nVerified facts:\n- Local HEAD, `origin/main`, and `slide2/main` all match commit `2896bb691c421bbae9bfa426178c92496d10dabc`.\n- The commit touches only the two planned documentation files.\n- The commit diff is `2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-)`.\n- No `src/*` files have a diff.\n- BACKLOG IMP-26 is marked `deferred`.\n- BACKLOG and INSIGHT-MAP use the same dual-precondition trigger wording.\n- Issue #26 is still open before close, with label `needs-codex-review` and milestone `B-4 �4 cleanup (3)`.\nFINAL_CONSENSUS: YES", "assets": [], "created_at": "2026-05-20T18:37:08+09:00", "updated_at": "2026-05-20T18:37:08+09:00"}] |