Structure Intent Diagnostic — 점수 통합 전 검수

목적: structure_intent 추론이 사람 직관과 맞는지 확인. 맞으면 Phase 24/25 점수에 통합 진입.

범위: 11 문제 frame 에만 intent 태깅. 나머지 21 frames 은 neutral 0.5 처리.

대상 11 frames: 13, 14, 17, 18, 20, 23, 24, 28, 29, 30, 31

정의된 intent 종류 (10): category_comparison, concept_comparison, industry_comparison, multi_attribute_comparison, persona_benefit, problem_diagnosis, process_product_split, requirement_list, requirement_or_pillar, transformation_story

MDX01-2 — BIM vs DX 다면 비교

정답 Frame: 18
MDX detected_intents: ['concept_comparison', 'multi_attribute_comparison']
MDX item_count: 2
MDX relation_type: compare

순위	sid	template_id	frame_intents	compat	비고
1	18	bim_dx_comparison_table	concept_comparison, multi_attribute_comparison	1.00	🎯 정답
2	23	app_sw_package_vs_solution	concept_comparison, multi_attribute_comparison	1.00
3	24	engn_sw_three_types	category_comparison, multi_attribute_comparison	1.00
4	30	industry_current_status_three_	industry_comparison, multi_attribute_comparison	1.00
5	31	industry_characteristics_three	industry_comparison, multi_attribute_comparison	1.00
6	21	solution_engn_split_diagram	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50
7	25	commercial_sw_four_categories	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50
8	26	sw_dependency_four_problems	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50
9	19	design_method_distortion_three	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50
10	27	bim_adoption_central_split	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50
11	12	construction_goals_three_circl	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50
12	15	policy_goals_plus_execution_re	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50

하위 5개 (intent 불일치 확인용):

순위	sid	template_id	frame_intents	compat
28	13	three_parallel_requirements	requirement_list	0.30
29	20	dx_sw_necessity_three_perspect	requirement_or_pillar	0.30
30	28	sw_reality_three_emphasis	problem_diagnosis	0.25
31	17	bim_current_problems_paired	problem_diagnosis	0.25
32	29	process_product_two_way	process_product_split, transformation_story	0.20

🔎 문제 후보 진단:

Frame 29 process_product_two_way: intent=[process_product_split, transformation_story], compat=0.20 ✓ 낮음 (정상)

MDX02 — 주체별 기대효과

정답 Frame: 14
MDX detected_intents: ['persona_benefit']
MDX item_count: 3
MDX relation_type: parallel

순위	sid	template_id	frame_intents	compat	비고
1	14	three_persona_benefits	persona_benefit	1.00	🎯 정답
2	21	solution_engn_split_diagram	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50
3	25	commercial_sw_four_categories	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50
4	26	sw_dependency_four_problems	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50
5	19	design_method_distortion_three	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50
6	27	bim_adoption_central_split	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50
7	12	construction_goals_three_circl	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50
8	15	policy_goals_plus_execution_re	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50
9	32	policy_achievement_five_goals	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50
10	01	sw_development_cycle_six_nodes	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50
11	04	domestic_bim_actor_relations	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50
12	06	compensation_complaint_map	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50

하위 5개 (intent 불일치 확인용):

순위	sid	template_id	frame_intents	compat
28	31	industry_characteristics_three	industry_comparison, multi_attribute_comparison	0.40
29	13	three_parallel_requirements	requirement_list	0.30
30	29	process_product_two_way	process_product_split, transformation_story	0.30
31	28	sw_reality_three_emphasis	problem_diagnosis	0.20
32	17	bim_current_problems_paired	problem_diagnosis	0.20

🔎 문제 후보 진단:

Frame 21 solution_engn_split_diagram: intent=[(미태깅)], compat=0.50 ⚠️ 높음 (문제)

MDX03-1 — DX 필수요건 3요소

정답 Frame: 13
MDX detected_intents: ['requirement_list']
MDX item_count: 3
MDX relation_type: parallel

순위	sid	template_id	frame_intents	compat	비고
1	13	three_parallel_requirements	requirement_list	1.00	🎯 정답
2	20	dx_sw_necessity_three_perspect	requirement_or_pillar	0.70
3	21	solution_engn_split_diagram	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50
4	25	commercial_sw_four_categories	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50
5	26	sw_dependency_four_problems	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50
6	19	design_method_distortion_three	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50
7	27	bim_adoption_central_split	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50
8	12	construction_goals_three_circl	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50
9	15	policy_goals_plus_execution_re	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50
10	32	policy_achievement_five_goals	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50
11	01	sw_development_cycle_six_nodes	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50
12	04	domestic_bim_actor_relations	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50

하위 5개 (intent 불일치 확인용):

순위	sid	template_id	frame_intents	compat
28	30	industry_current_status_three_	industry_comparison, multi_attribute_comparison	0.30
29	31	industry_characteristics_three	industry_comparison, multi_attribute_comparison	0.30
30	29	process_product_two_way	process_product_split, transformation_story	0.20
31	28	sw_reality_three_emphasis	problem_diagnosis	0.15
32	17	bim_current_problems_paired	problem_diagnosis	0.15

🔎 문제 후보 진단:

Frame 28 sw_reality_three_emphasis: intent=[problem_diagnosis], compat=0.15 ✓ 낮음 (정상)

MDX03-2 — 과정/결과 혁신

정답 Frame: 29
MDX detected_intents: ['process_product_split', 'transformation_story']
MDX item_count: 2
MDX relation_type: compare

순위	sid	template_id	frame_intents	compat	비고
1	29	process_product_two_way	process_product_split, transformation_story	1.00	🎯 정답
2	21	solution_engn_split_diagram	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50
3	25	commercial_sw_four_categories	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50
4	26	sw_dependency_four_problems	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50
5	19	design_method_distortion_three	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50
6	27	bim_adoption_central_split	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50
7	12	construction_goals_three_circl	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50
8	15	policy_goals_plus_execution_re	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50
9	32	policy_achievement_five_goals	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50
10	01	sw_development_cycle_six_nodes	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50
11	04	domestic_bim_actor_relations	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50
12	06	compensation_complaint_map	(미태깅, neutral)	0.50

하위 5개 (intent 불일치 확인용):

순위	sid	template_id	frame_intents	compat
28	13	three_parallel_requirements	requirement_list	0.20
29	18	bim_dx_comparison_table	concept_comparison, multi_attribute_comparison	0.20
30	23	app_sw_package_vs_solution	concept_comparison, multi_attribute_comparison	0.20
31	28	sw_reality_three_emphasis	problem_diagnosis	0.15
32	17	bim_current_problems_paired	problem_diagnosis	0.15

🔎 문제 후보 진단:

Frame 18 bim_dx_comparison_table: intent=[concept_comparison, multi_attribute_comparison], compat=0.20 ✓ 낮음 (정상)

검수 가이드

정답 Frame 이 상위에 있는가 — compat ≥ 0.8 예상
문제 후보 (MDX01-2×29, MDX03-1×28, MDX03-2×18) 가 0.4 이하인가 — 낮으면 의도대로 intent 가 걸러냄
MDX detected_intents 가 자연스러운가 — AI 추론 결과 검토
미태깅 frame (neutral 0.5) 이 정답보다 위에 오는가 — 있으면 부분 적용 한계 = 추가 태깅 필요

모두 통과하면 → Phase 24/25 점수 통합 진입.