# Phase 6 — 4개 유닛 × 7개 방법 통합표

**콘텐츠 4개:**
- 1. (MDX 1) 팝업 — DX와 BIM의 구분 (정답 Frame **18**)
- 2. (MDX 2) 2.2 DX 시행 주체별 기대효과 (정답 Frame **14**)
- 3. (MDX 03) 1. DX 시행을 위한 필수요건 — 기술·사람·자연 (정답 Frame **13**)
- 4. (MDX 03) 2. Process 혁신과 Product 변화 (정답 Frame **29**)

**방법 7개**: 키워드 3 + 구조 1 + 의미 3 (청킹+sbert / 청킹+E5 / Cross)

정답 프레임은 ⭐ 표시

| 콘텐츠 | TF-IDF | Char 3-gram | Kiwi+BM25 | 구조 메타 | 청킹+sbert | 청킹+E5 | Cross |
|------|------|------|------|------|------|------|------|
| **1. (MDX 1) 팝업 — DX와 BIM의 구분**<br>정답 = Frame **18** |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |
| **1순위** | ⭐ ![18](../../data/figma_previews/18.png)<br>**18** (91%)<br>BIM과 DX의 이해 | ⭐ ![18](../../data/figma_previews/18.png)<br>**18** (47%)<br>BIM과 DX의 이해 | ⭐ ![18](../../data/figma_previews/18.png)<br>**18** (128.9)<br>BIM과 DX의 이해 | ![17](../../data/figma_previews/17.png)<br>**17** (80%)<br>현황 및 문제점 | ⭐ ![18](../../data/figma_previews/18.png)<br>**18** (83%)<br>BIM과 DX의 이해 | ⭐ ![18](../../data/figma_previews/18.png)<br>**18** (90%)<br>BIM과 DX의 이해 | ![24](../../data/figma_previews/24.png)<br>**24** (50%)<br>Engn. S/W의 구성 과… |
| **2순위** | ![16](../../data/figma_previews/16.png)<br>**16** (14%)<br> | ![22](../../data/figma_previews/22.png)<br>**22** (6%)<br>Model에 특화된 Engn… | ![16](../../data/figma_previews/16.png)<br>**16** (44.0)<br> | ![01](../../data/figma_previews/01.png)<br>**01** (65%)<br> | ![09](../../data/figma_previews/09.png)<br>**09** (76%)<br>시공 전 모델 기반 시공상세… | ![16](../../data/figma_previews/16.png)<br>**16** (89%)<br> | ![07](../../data/figma_previews/07.png)<br>**07** (50%)<br> |
| **3순위** | ![24](../../data/figma_previews/24.png)<br>**24** (12%)<br>Engn. S/W의 구성 과… | ![30](../../data/figma_previews/30.png)<br>**30** (5%)<br>산업별 현황 | ![17](../../data/figma_previews/17.png)<br>**17** (33.3)<br>현황 및 문제점 | ![05](../../data/figma_previews/05.png)<br>**05** (60%)<br>보상현황·민원 관리 | ![25](../../data/figma_previews/25.png)<br>**25** (76%)<br>3rd Party | ![07](../../data/figma_previews/07.png)<br>**07** (89%)<br> | ![10](../../data/figma_previews/10.png)<br>**10** (50%)<br>현장 실효성 증대 위한 **… |
| **2. (MDX 2) 2.2 DX 시행 주체별 기대효과**<br>정답 = Frame **14** |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |
| **1순위** | ⭐ ![14](../../data/figma_previews/14.png)<br>**14** (61%)<br> | ⭐ ![14](../../data/figma_previews/14.png)<br>**14** (20%)<br> | ⭐ ![14](../../data/figma_previews/14.png)<br>**14** (114.8)<br> | ![17](../../data/figma_previews/17.png)<br>**17** (80%)<br>현황 및 문제점 | ![07](../../data/figma_previews/07.png)<br>**07** (84%)<br> | ![07](../../data/figma_previews/07.png)<br>**07** (88%)<br> | ⭐ ![14](../../data/figma_previews/14.png)<br>**14** (61%)<br> |
| **2순위** | ![12](../../data/figma_previews/12.png)<br>**12** (37%)<br>건설산업의 목표 (BIM의 … | ![12](../../data/figma_previews/12.png)<br>**12** (7%)<br>건설산업의 목표 (BIM의 … | ![12](../../data/figma_previews/12.png)<br>**12** (67.8)<br>건설산업의 목표 (BIM의 … | ![01](../../data/figma_previews/01.png)<br>**01** (65%)<br> | ![18](../../data/figma_previews/18.png)<br>**18** (74%)<br>BIM과 DX의 이해 | ![18](../../data/figma_previews/18.png)<br>**18** (88%)<br>BIM과 DX의 이해 | ![23](../../data/figma_previews/23.png)<br>**23** (53%)<br>Application S/W… |
| **3순위** | ![29](../../data/figma_previews/29.png)<br>**29** (19%)<br>좌측 배너 과정 (Proce… | ![29](../../data/figma_previews/29.png)<br>**29** (6%)<br>좌측 배너 과정 (Proce… | ![29](../../data/figma_previews/29.png)<br>**29** (59.3)<br>좌측 배너 과정 (Proce… | ![05](../../data/figma_previews/05.png)<br>**05** (60%)<br>보상현황·민원 관리 | ![09](../../data/figma_previews/09.png)<br>**09** (73%)<br>시공 전 모델 기반 시공상세… | ![11](../../data/figma_previews/11.png)<br>**11** (87%)<br>시공단계 BIM 모델과 정보… | ![18](../../data/figma_previews/18.png)<br>**18** (53%)<br>BIM과 DX의 이해 |
| **3. (MDX 03) 1. DX 시행을 위한 필수요건 — 기술·사람·자연**<br>정답 = Frame **13** |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |
| **1순위** | ![15](../../data/figma_previews/15.png)<br>**15** (56%)<br>정책목표 | ![15](../../data/figma_previews/15.png)<br>**15** (21%)<br>정책목표 | ![15](../../data/figma_previews/15.png)<br>**15** (87.2)<br>정책목표 | ![02](../../data/figma_previews/02.png)<br>**02** (17%)<br>Engineering S/W… | ![15](../../data/figma_previews/15.png)<br>**15** (76%)<br>정책목표 | ![15](../../data/figma_previews/15.png)<br>**15** (89%)<br>정책목표 | ⭐ ![13](../../data/figma_previews/13.png)<br>**13** (51%)<br>필수조건 |
| **2순위** | ⭐ ![13](../../data/figma_previews/13.png)<br>**13** (30%)<br>필수조건 | ⭐ ![13](../../data/figma_previews/13.png)<br>**13** (9%)<br>필수조건 | ⭐ ![13](../../data/figma_previews/13.png)<br>**13** (43.2)<br>필수조건 | ![04](../../data/figma_previews/04.png)<br>**04** (16%)<br>국내 | ⭐ ![13](../../data/figma_previews/13.png)<br>**13** (72%)<br>필수조건 | ⭐ ![13](../../data/figma_previews/13.png)<br>**13** (87%)<br>필수조건 | ![15](../../data/figma_previews/15.png)<br>**15** (50%)<br>정책목표 |
| **3순위** | ![20](../../data/figma_previews/20.png)<br>**20** (16%)<br>디지털 전환(DX)은 S/W… | ![29](../../data/figma_previews/29.png)<br>**29** (5%)<br>좌측 배너 과정 (Proce… | ![16](../../data/figma_previews/16.png)<br>**16** (29.0)<br> | ![08](../../data/figma_previews/08.png)<br>**08** (16%)<br>효율적인 정보의 관리와 활용 | ![20](../../data/figma_previews/20.png)<br>**20** (60%)<br>디지털 전환(DX)은 S/W… | ![12](../../data/figma_previews/12.png)<br>**12** (86%)<br>건설산업의 목표 (BIM의 … | ![17](../../data/figma_previews/17.png)<br>**17** (50%)<br>현황 및 문제점 |
| **4. (MDX 03) 2. Process 혁신과 Product 변화**<br>정답 = Frame **29** |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |
| **1순위** | ⭐ ![29](../../data/figma_previews/29.png)<br>**29** (66%)<br>좌측 배너 과정 (Proce… | ⭐ ![29](../../data/figma_previews/29.png)<br>**29** (30%)<br>좌측 배너 과정 (Proce… | ⭐ ![29](../../data/figma_previews/29.png)<br>**29** (101.6)<br>좌측 배너 과정 (Proce… | ![25](../../data/figma_previews/25.png)<br>**25** (50%)<br>3rd Party | ⭐ ![29](../../data/figma_previews/29.png)<br>**29** (81%)<br>좌측 배너 과정 (Proce… | ⭐ ![29](../../data/figma_previews/29.png)<br>**29** (90%)<br>좌측 배너 과정 (Proce… | ![16](../../data/figma_previews/16.png)<br>**16** (59%)<br> |
| **2순위** | ![12](../../data/figma_previews/12.png)<br>**12** (19%)<br>건설산업의 목표 (BIM의 … | ![12](../../data/figma_previews/12.png)<br>**12** (8%)<br>건설산업의 목표 (BIM의 … | ![12](../../data/figma_previews/12.png)<br>**12** (38.5)<br>건설산업의 목표 (BIM의 … | ![26](../../data/figma_previews/26.png)<br>**26** (50%)<br> | ![12](../../data/figma_previews/12.png)<br>**12** (61%)<br>건설산업의 목표 (BIM의 … | ![12](../../data/figma_previews/12.png)<br>**12** (86%)<br>건설산업의 목표 (BIM의 … | ⭐ ![29](../../data/figma_previews/29.png)<br>**29** (55%)<br>좌측 배너 과정 (Proce… |
| **3순위** | ![09](../../data/figma_previews/09.png)<br>**09** (15%)<br>시공 전 모델 기반 시공상세… | ![15](../../data/figma_previews/15.png)<br>**15** (5%)<br>정책목표 | ![07](../../data/figma_previews/07.png)<br>**07** (33.4)<br> | ![02](../../data/figma_previews/02.png)<br>**02** (46%)<br>Engineering S/W… | ![30](../../data/figma_previews/30.png)<br>**30** (59%)<br>산업별 현황 | ![14](../../data/figma_previews/14.png)<br>**14** (86%)<br> | ![12](../../data/figma_previews/12.png)<br>**12** (52%)<br>건설산업의 목표 (BIM의 … |

---

## 방법별 1순위 정답 집계

| 방법 | MDX1 팝업(18) | MDX2 2.2(14) | MDX03-1(13) | MDX03-2(29) | 정답 합계 |
|------|---------------|--------------|-------------|-------------|----------|
| TF-IDF | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ | ✓ | **3/4** |
| Char 3-gram | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ | ✓ | **3/4** |
| Kiwi+BM25 | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ | ✓ | **3/4** |
| 구조 메타 | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | **0/4** |
| 청킹+sbert | ✓ | ✗ | ✗ | ✓ | **2/4** |
| 청킹+E5 | ✓ | ✗ | ✗ | ✓ | **2/4** |
| Cross | ✗ | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ | **2/4** |