# Priority 5 프레임 검토 리포트 (C.2-b r2)

r1 버그 수정 후 재라벨링. 각 프레임마다 **r1 → r2 변화** 를 함께 표시.

## Frame 03 — 국외 BIM 수행 현황

- layout: `list-numbered-4` (original: `list-numbered`)
- relation_type / cardinality.ideal: `parallel` / 4

### r1 → r2 변화 요약

| 축 | r1 primary | r2 primary | 변경 |
|---|---|---|---|
| content_affinity | `process_steps` | **`stakeholder_roles`** | ✓ |
| structure_intent | `sequence` | **`multi_parallel`** | ✓ |

### r2 content_affinity
- primary: **`stakeholder_roles`**
- secondary: `policy_requirements`
- evidence:
    - `primary` (keyword_match) — kw=['수행', '수행'] / rule='수행' 등 키워드가 stakeholder_roles 를 가리킴 / conf=0.7
    - `secondary_1` (keyword_match) — kw=['국외', '국외'] / conf=0.65
    - `blocked_by_not_suits` — process_steps(['단계', '순서']), concept_comparison(['비교']), capability_requirements(['필수', '요건'])

### r2 structure_intent
- primary: **`multi_parallel`**
- evidence:
    - `primary` (content_or_structure) — rule=4개 병렬 / conf=0.75
    - `blocked_by_not_suits` — persona_mapping(['주체별']), binary_compare(['2개 비교']), sequence(['단계', '순서'])

### alternative_patterns
| 대안 | confidence | source | reason |
|---|---:|---|---|
| `bullet-cards` | 1.0 | derived_from_COMPAT | _COMPAT 공통 호환 mdx_layout 집합 기반 파생 (정규화 1.0) |
| `list-stacked` | 1.0 | derived_from_COMPAT | _COMPAT 공통 호환 mdx_layout 집합 기반 파생 (정규화 1.0) |
| `side-card` | 0.88 | derived_from_COMPAT | _COMPAT 공통 호환 mdx_layout 집합 기반 파생 (정규화 0.88) |
| `definition-list` | 0.82 | derived_from_COMPAT | _COMPAT 공통 호환 mdx_layout 집합 기반 파생 (정규화 0.82) |

---

## Frame 11 — 시공단계 BIM 모델·정보 활용 구분

- layout: `cards-3-category` (original: `3-category`)
- relation_type / cardinality.ideal: `parallel` / 3

### r1 → r2 변화 요약

| 축 | r1 primary | r2 primary | 변경 |
|---|---|---|---|
| content_affinity | `persona_benefit` | **`concept_definition`** | ✓ |
| structure_intent | `sequence` | **`multi_parallel`** | ✓ |

### r2 content_affinity
- primary: **`concept_definition`**
- secondary: `comparative_matrix`
- evidence:
    - `primary` (keyword_match) — kw=['분류', '구분', '분류'] / rule='분류' 등 키워드가 concept_definition 를 가리킴 / conf=0.8
    - `secondary_1` (keyword_match) — kw=['다면'] / conf=0.65
    - `blocked_by_not_suits` — persona_benefit(['발주자', '설계자', '시공자']), concept_comparison(['비교', '대조', 'vs']), process_steps(['순서']), capability_requirements(['필수', '요건'])

### r2 structure_intent
- primary: **`multi_parallel`**
- secondary: `matrix_coverage`
- evidence:
    - `primary` (content_or_structure) — rule=카드 3열 / conf=0.75
    - `secondary_1` (keyword_match) — rule=— / conf=0.55
    - `blocked_by_not_suits` — persona_mapping(['주체별']), sequence(['순서'])

### alternative_patterns
| 대안 | confidence | source | reason |
|---|---:|---|---|
| `3-section` | 1.0 | derived_from_COMPAT | _COMPAT 공통 호환 mdx_layout 집합 기반 파생 (정규화 1.0) |
| `3-emphasis` | 0.85 | derived_from_COMPAT | _COMPAT 공통 호환 mdx_layout 집합 기반 파생 (정규화 0.85) |
| `3col-parallel` | 0.72 | derived_from_COMPAT | _COMPAT 공통 호환 mdx_layout 집합 기반 파생 (정규화 0.72) |
| `3col-cards` | 0.65 | derived_from_COMPAT | _COMPAT 공통 호환 mdx_layout 집합 기반 파생 (정규화 0.65) |
| `3col-compare` | 0.65 | derived_from_COMPAT | _COMPAT 공통 호환 mdx_layout 집합 기반 파생 (정규화 0.65) |

---

## Frame 12 — 건설산업의 목표 (BIM의 목적)

- layout: `cycle-3way-intersection` (original: `cycle-3way`)
- relation_type / cardinality.ideal: `parallel` / 3

### r1 → r2 변화 요약

| 축 | r1 primary | r2 primary | 변경 |
|---|---|---|---|
| content_affinity | `interrelation` | **`interrelation`** | — |
| structure_intent | `cycle_interrelation` | **`cycle_interrelation`** | — |

### r2 content_affinity
- primary: **`interrelation`**
- secondary: `goal_axes`
- evidence:
    - `primary` (keyword_match) — kw=['조화', '교차', '수렴', '3원', '교차', '수렴', '3원'] / rule='조화' 등 키워드가 interrelation 를 가리킴 / conf=0.95
    - `secondary_1` (keyword_match) — kw=['목표', '궁극적', '목표', '궁극적'] / conf=0.65
    - `blocked_by_not_suits` — persona_benefit(['발주자', '설계자', '시공자']), process_steps(['순서']), capability_requirements(['필수', '요건'])

### r2 structure_intent
- primary: **`cycle_interrelation`**
- secondary: `hierarchy`, `multi_parallel`
- evidence:
    - `primary` (content_or_structure) — rule=조화 / conf=0.95
    - `secondary_1` (keyword_match) — rule=— / conf=0.55
    - `secondary_2` (layout_default) — rule=— / conf=0.55
    - `blocked_by_not_suits` — persona_mapping(['주체별']), sequence(['순서']), singleton_emphasis(['문제', '진단', '약점'])

### alternative_patterns
| 대안 | confidence | source | reason |
|---|---:|---|---|
| `3col-parallel` | 0.7 | manual_seed | 3개 요소를 순환 대신 평면 병렬 나열로 표현하는 대안 |
| `circular-nodes` | 0.6 | manual_seed | N개 요소를 radial 로 배치하는 대안 |

---

## Frame 20 — 디지털 전환(DX)은 S/W가 필수다

- layout: `cards-3-header` (original: `3col-cards`)
- relation_type / cardinality.ideal: `parallel` / 3

### r1 → r2 변화 요약

| 축 | r1 primary | r2 primary | 변경 |
|---|---|---|---|
| content_affinity | `concept_comparison` | **`capability_requirements`** | ✓ |
| structure_intent | `binary_compare` | **`multi_parallel`** | ✓ |

### r2 content_affinity
- primary: **`capability_requirements`**
- secondary: `before_after_change`
- evidence:
    - `primary` (keyword_match) — kw=['필수', 'S/W', '필수', 'S/W'] / rule='필수' 등 키워드가 capability_requirements 를 가리킴 / conf=0.85
    - `secondary_1` (keyword_match) — kw=['전환'] / conf=0.65
    - `blocked_by_not_suits` — comparative_matrix(['다면']), process_steps(['순서']), concept_comparison(['비교', '대조', 'vs']), concept_definition(['개념'])

### r2 structure_intent
- primary: **`multi_parallel`**
- secondary: `state_transition`
- evidence:
    - `primary` (content_or_structure) — rule=3관점 / conf=0.8
    - `secondary_1` (keyword_match) — rule=— / conf=0.55
    - `blocked_by_not_suits` — matrix_coverage(['다면']), binary_compare(['2개 개념', '대조']), sequence(['순서'])

### alternative_patterns
| 대안 | confidence | source | reason |
|---|---:|---|---|
| `persona-3col` | 1.0 | derived_from_COMPAT | _COMPAT 공통 호환 mdx_layout 집합 기반 파생 (정규화 1.0) |
| `3col-parallel` | 0.78 | derived_from_COMPAT | _COMPAT 공통 호환 mdx_layout 집합 기반 파생 (정규화 0.78) |
| `3col-compare` | 0.69 | derived_from_COMPAT | _COMPAT 공통 호환 mdx_layout 집합 기반 파생 (정규화 0.69) |
| `table-3col` | 0.62 | derived_from_COMPAT | _COMPAT 공통 호환 mdx_layout 집합 기반 파생 (정규화 0.62) |
| `compare-rows` | 0.24 | derived_from_COMPAT | _COMPAT 공통 호환 mdx_layout 집합 기반 파생 (정규화 0.24) |

---

## Frame 29 — Process/Product 혁신

- layout: `banner-top-2col-bottom` (original: `compare-2banner-top-2col-bottom`)
- relation_type / cardinality.ideal: `compare` / 2

### r1 → r2 변화 요약

| 축 | r1 primary | r2 primary | 변경 |
|---|---|---|---|
| content_affinity | `before_after_change` | **`before_after_change`** | — |
| structure_intent | `state_transition` | **`state_transition`** | — |

### r2 content_affinity
- primary: **`before_after_change`**
- secondary: `concept_comparison`, `comparative_matrix`
- evidence:
    - `primary` (keyword_match) — kw=['AS-IS', 'TO-BE', '혁신', '이중 변환', '과정', 'AS-IS', 'TO-BE', '혁신'] / rule='AS-IS' 등 키워드가 before_after_change 를 가리킴 / conf=0.95
    - `secondary_1` (keyword_match) — kw=['대조', 'vs', 'vs'] / conf=0.65
    - `secondary_2` (keyword_match) — kw=['축', '축'] / conf=0.65
    - `blocked_by_not_suits` — process_steps(['단계', '순서'])

### r2 structure_intent
- primary: **`state_transition`**
- secondary: `binary_compare`
- evidence:
    - `primary` (content_or_structure) — rule=AS-IS / conf=0.95
    - `secondary_1` (layout_default) — rule=— / conf=0.55
    - `blocked_by_not_suits` — sequence(['단계', '순서'])

### alternative_patterns
| 대안 | confidence | source | reason |
|---|---:|---|---|
| `compare-2col` | 1.0 | derived_from_COMPAT | _COMPAT 공통 호환 mdx_layout 집합 기반 파생 (정규화 1.0) |
| `table-2col` | 0.98 | derived_from_COMPAT | _COMPAT 공통 호환 mdx_layout 집합 기반 파생 (정규화 0.98) |
| `2col-paired` | 0.86 | derived_from_COMPAT | _COMPAT 공통 호환 mdx_layout 집합 기반 파생 (정규화 0.86) |
| `2-boxes` | 0.54 | derived_from_COMPAT | _COMPAT 공통 호환 mdx_layout 집합 기반 파생 (정규화 0.54) |
| `central-split` | 0.52 | derived_from_COMPAT | _COMPAT 공통 호환 mdx_layout 집합 기반 파생 (정규화 0.52) |

---